Polendino: Segovia Hellkite. I'm already dropping four mana on a 2/2 flier with firebreathing. But punishing me for having it in play? I'll pass.
Small Child: Morab's Disciple. Drawing cards is all fine and dandy, but isn't it kinda counterproductive for a blue deck to reveal all of their counterspells along with the maybe one or two fatties in their hand?
Arcel: Pinpeak Dragon. Hooooolyyyyyyy craaaaaap. A 4/2 flier that requires my opponent to remove an additional flier from my other blocking creatures is just retarded. I can think of ways to abuse this.
Savia: Abydos Scrapwielder. I was gonna stop at three and then I saw this. Jegus this is crazy. Yeah I'll faithless looting all of my Batterskulls/War+Peace's and reanimate them like a pro.
Big_Cal: These guys are awesome and have some really cool synergy. I’m a bit skeptical about their flavor with correlation to their p/t, since they seem a tad high on the red one. At the end of the day though, that doesn’t matter and the card’s elegance outweighs.
Arcel: I think that Pinpeak Dragon ought be a rare, and in addition to that, the effect seems like it would be better suited on a differently flavored dragon. The sphinx has a decidedly white effect, though I do enjoy how they pair up.
Ninja Caterpie: Again, the dragon is really cute, though an odd fit for an uncommon. I enjoy the mirroring effect here and I think that both effects very much fit a dragon in a highly positive way. Very cool design and one I would love to play with.
Polendino, Socrates, CrustaceanCrusader, Small Child, and Cythare are still in imminent danger of being on probation. You guys all need to get a top 3 (of the people you're assigned to critique) in within the next couple of hours.
Dudes... it's 3 critiques per person... Other CCLs you have to judge 8 people in average. If you have time to make a post saying how much a bother it is, invest a single minute more and do the critiques.
I really do predict this to be our worst rare in set award winner. I'd be happier opening a jar of eyeballs, so I think anything worse is highly unlikely. This card wont just have zero constructed potential, but not be significantly better than a mass of ghouls in a draft.