I need a substitute host for my mafia game (Camp Tacronic). If interested, PM me. I'm sort of in a bind here.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Mafia MVP Harry Potter Mafia!
Logical Reasoning is dead; Long Live Stupidity
Quote from Seppel »
I love Joboman, Poggy, Niv, and Vezok, because, while they may not be the best players, they still try to win. Having fun is the most important thing to a game, but I've learned that if you don't try to win, then you're ruining everyone else's fun.
Sorry Eco, but you didn't put up the game so I felt compelled to.
This is Day 1. I've cut out some posts from other players that weren't that important so that there wouldn't be so much flying around. Also during these posts there was a whole seperate wagon against another player before it got resolved and people returned to this issue I've got out those posts as well since they have no relevance to the game. Even so it runs a bit long but hopefully it's not too much.
Players to anaylze are: Bob, Frank, Jeremy, John and also Alex and Matt if you can.
Quote from Bob »
The wagon on Jake seemed to grow a little fast, but Alex's unvote makes me feel a bit better. I really dislike the part where Jake tries to condemn Matt based off a game in progress. Barring something else happening, post-vote count I am willing to vote him.
Tom's vote against Alex was bad but at least he admitted that it was bad and from following posts (such as the one where he says that scum would just go for no-lynch day) it is evident that he is newbie so his bad vote doesn't mean much.
Matt's "serious" vote against Alex was helpful and brought us into discussion. I disagree with Jeremy's point about discussing random game strategy instead since I don't think anything can really be gleaned from there (other than if the player is a good player or bad.
Quote from Frank »
@Bob, why would you wait for a post vote count to vote? Do you feel more confident in voting him if he's not close to lynching? So if he is at L-1 will you not vote? I don't like how this is coming across, sounds like your fence sitting. Trying to place your vote where you'll not get notice and called out on it. If you feel he's scum, vote.
Quote from Bob »
No, because I do not want him to be lynched without claiming...
Several non-essential posts cut out.
Quote from Jeremy »
Vote Frank
Please explain yourself. Why is it scummy for Bob to NOT want to lynch someone who has yet to fully defend them self, much less claim? This post absolutely REEKS of scum trying to goad a townie into causing a mislynch.
You sir, just hurled yourself to the top of my scum-list.
Quote from Jeremy »
At Everyone. What is your read on Frank? Specifically, what do you feel about his post [links to Frank's post]? I would like to hear a few answers on this question, especially from some of you who haven't been posting much.
Quote from John »
It honestly sounds to me like he really wanted to get a lynch vote through on Jake before anybody had a chance to ask for a claim. I'm not sure if its neccessarily a scummy play, but it sure seems suspicious. I won't vote until I hear what he has to say about it, but FoS: Frank is definitely warranted...
Oh, and Unvote: Jake
Quote from Bob »
I don't like it. I'm still waiting for him to answer why he thinks it would be a good move to vote without claiming at L-1.
Quote from Bob »
EBWODP: Unvote
Just looked over Frank and he only has 2 content posts, one the one that was mentioned and the other makes that look even worse.
Originally Posted by Frank I agree. Doing some reading and looking to get some tells, but I'd have to think that any other votes would look bad unless there backed by strong points.
He says any other votes would look bad and a couple of posts later he wants to me to vote Jake.
Vote Frank
Quote from Frank »
Wrong, I never said I wanted you to vote him. I ask why you would wait for a count when you feel someone is scum.
John-
It honestly sounds to me like he really wanted to get a lynch vote through on Jake before anybody had a chance to ask for a claim
Wrong too, I did not even have a vote on him. I also believed the wagon should slow down(which now seems to be me, funny how that wagon changed.)
Quote from John »
Yeah, and it is the reason you didn't have a vote on him that I now believe you are scum. You were goading Bob into voting by putting him in the very difficult of scenario of being L-1 and being the lynch-casting vote, and basically asking him if he could do it. And that was all without you casting a single vote, so when Jake gets lynched and it turns out he's a town, there is no suspicion on you because you can just come back and say "I didn't even vote for the guy". Ok, this, along with everything else I've read has turned what I thought could've been just a couple bad plays on your part into a slip-up of the scummy kind.
Vote Frank
Quote from Frank »
As to riding Bob, If after my post he moved and placed his vote that would have told me wonders as to what side he is on.
Quote from Frank »
My claim. [claims vanilla]
Now for the record I don't like where this is going. We should look at who is jumping on the wagons. To me this is a way for scum to weed out the power roles to make it easier on themselves. Now if we have a scum false-claim I do not encourage a counterclaim as that would make it that much easier for scum. Unless the doc is still hidden and can protect.
Quote from Matt »
Originally Posted by Frank Wrong, I never said I wanted you to vote him. I ask why you would wait for a count when you feel someone is scum.
This Is a lie.
Originally Posted by Frank I don't like how this is coming across, sounds like your fence sitting. Trying to place your vote where you'll not get notice and called out on it. If you feel he's scum, vote.
You also never explained the above post to us. You just kinda changed the subject to whether or not your fence sitting.
Then this.
Originally Posted by Frank As to riding Bob, If after my post he moved and placed his vote that would have told me wonders as to what side he is on.
So you saying that to Bob was a way to get his alignment? Really? That's your reasoning?
vote: Frank
Quote from Alex »
Frank's play is most certainly bad. He is quick to point fingers at "fence sitters" or "waggoners" but has no commitment of any opinion of his own. He matches logic with side skirting and avoidance, and can't seem to answer any real questions.
Since his vote count is so high, I'm going to FoS: Frank with intent to vote, unless he seriously gives us some real answers. Soon too.
I believe there's also another normal starting up soon. I think it was delayed due to many games starting at the same time as well as the other normal having difficulty filling up.
Bob - Skander = Scum
Frank - Archmage Eternal = Town
Jeremy - HKKID = Town
Alex - CDM = Scum
Matt - kpaca =Neutral survivor
John - greymon =Scum
The main thing I was interested in seeing is how people saw Frank/AE. In the actual game the town pretty much steamrolled over him with not a single dissenter to his lynch. But over here some of you got that he was town.
And further revaltions have given away that Seppel lives an hour away from me. I will be investing in that safehouse.
And some anti-personnel land mines, a mile of barbed wire, an RPG launcher and so forth.
Also: Not sure I can get another Godfather game up soon, since I am to be spending the next few days looking at places to live next year, which promises to be a soul-destroying and expensive exercise. Thus, if anyone else wants to step in, go ahead.
Greetings from San Fran. I'd like to thank all of you who said they'd be able to help me, but i had to leave it to CPE due to my early flight.
Thanks a lot!
I'll be back again on my computer Sunday Night/Monday Morning.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Mafia MVP Harry Potter Mafia!
Logical Reasoning is dead; Long Live Stupidity
Quote from Seppel »
I love Joboman, Poggy, Niv, and Vezok, because, while they may not be the best players, they still try to win. Having fun is the most important thing to a game, but I've learned that if you don't try to win, then you're ruining everyone else's fun.
Also: Not sure I can get another Godfather game up soon, since I am to be spending the next few days looking at places to live next year, which promises to be a soul-destroying and expensive exercise. Thus, if anyone else wants to step in, go ahead.
Bob - Skander = Scum
Frank - Archmage Eternal = Town
Jeremy - HKKID = Town
Alex - CDM = Scum
Matt - kpaca =Neutral survivor
John - greymon =Scum
The main thing I was interested in seeing is how people saw Frank/AE. In the actual game the town pretty much steamrolled over him with not a single dissenter to his lynch. But over here some of you got that he was town.
Worst mafia game ever.
I'm surprised I managed to stay out of this version of the godfather game. I reconized it immediately.
Yeah, uh, this setup had some balance issues. Skander sent in a kill on both masons, and I thought, "Huh? What is he talking about?" Went back and checked his PM:
And I just went :o.
The mafia janitor's information denial, the neutral survivor, and the potential for double-kills should the mafia be killed in the wrong order, made this setup very, very difficult for the town to win.
Nice. I got that one too. Although I would feel more accomplished if these were all solid analysis as opposed to mostly gut.
Salvation Mafia Clan
Mafia Stats
last updated 03/23/11
Logical Reasoning is dead; Long Live Stupidity
PM me the details.
This is Day 1. I've cut out some posts from other players that weren't that important so that there wouldn't be so much flying around. Also during these posts there was a whole seperate wagon against another player before it got resolved and people returned to this issue I've got out those posts as well since they have no relevance to the game. Even so it runs a bit long but hopefully it's not too much.
Players to anaylze are: Bob, Frank, Jeremy, John and also Alex and Matt if you can.
Several non-essential posts cut out.
Yeah, good job. I got occupied by RL. :/
Frank - Scum
Jeremy - Was leaning scum, but now Town. Possibly neutral.
Alex - Town
Matt - Town
John - Scum
Salvation Mafia Clan
Mafia Stats
last updated 03/23/11
Vacation is awesome, but the return sucks.. Esp when you come up dead >< lol.
Hope everyone else had a great week.
Think a host was looking for a replacement for Janus Mafia, which only just started.
Maybe start there?
Salvation Mafia Clan
Mafia Stats
last updated 03/23/11
It was taken from Youkai Mafia
Bob - Skander = Scum
Frank - Archmage Eternal = Town
Jeremy - HKKID = Town
Alex - CDM = Scum
Matt - kpaca =Neutral survivor
John - greymon =Scum
The main thing I was interested in seeing is how people saw Frank/AE. In the actual game the town pretty much steamrolled over him with not a single dissenter to his lynch. But over here some of you got that he was town.
Of course, not expecting 4 non-town vs 2 town probably threw me off a bit, but still terrible.
Salvation Mafia Clan
Mafia Stats
last updated 03/23/11
Yeah I knew it was skewed because I had to cut out the posts that were off topic - which were mainly townie posts.
ZDS: You need to go post in the Clan council about this Scavenger hunt thing for the next clan contest.
Damn, that was sneaky. I swear that post wasn't there earlier.
HELLLLLP MEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
EDIT: Also, this is my 2000th post. I'm giving myself a cookie.:cookie:
Many thanks to Sgt. Chubbz of Damnation studios.
V/LA: 3/21-3/24 & 3/27-3/29
And further revaltions have given away that Seppel lives an hour away from me. I will be investing in that safehouse.
Many thanks to Sgt. Chubbz of Damnation studios.
And some anti-personnel land mines, a mile of barbed wire, an RPG launcher and so forth.
Also: Not sure I can get another Godfather game up soon, since I am to be spending the next few days looking at places to live next year, which promises to be a soul-destroying and expensive exercise. Thus, if anyone else wants to step in, go ahead.
Thanks a lot!
I'll be back again on my computer Sunday Night/Monday Morning.
Logical Reasoning is dead; Long Live Stupidity
I'll do it. I'll have it up tommorrow night.
Many thanks to Sgt. Chubbz of Damnation studios.
Worst mafia game ever.
I'm surprised I managed to stay out of this version of the godfather game. I reconized it immediately.
Oh! Youkai!
That's the game where I replaced in as scum janitor, and we won through a ridiculously overpowered two-shot last-standing scum.
Good times.
That game was screwed up in so many ways. I rloved Arimnaes' reaction when I sent in the double kill: