I read everything usually
I skimmed a lot of page 2
I attack Rodemy because his posts felt fake, not because of some mechanical talk, which I didn't even know about
because I haven't read the OP yet
I like Lagoon, don’t like last, but adjusting for how I never like last hes probably neutral right now.
Would still lynch anyone who’s alignment won’t show up.
@Axelrod: wanna trade roles
If anyone can grand the dark mark, I would be very grateful
Also Jesus Christ 140 posts in 12 hours. Can we not lol?
I agree. I’ll catch up on a few hours but holy *****, calm down people.
That first post WAS fake sir. I've admitted that.
That last one you gotta be kidding me. I can't have any opinions in this game can i?
First I get attacked for saying i don't like toms gimmick and now because i think the game is going too fast? Have you LOOKED at this? The game started TODAY and we are almost 500 posts in. How does my frustration feel fake? Please how can i feel the same way as one person (kpaca) and I am the one who gets painted as scum? Yes, my scum game is to complain about things that everyone naturally is upset about. Such a scum game i play. -.-
Kpaca and Rodemy not both wolves, lock it in.
oh, ya think? God this is frustrating right now. Can we get some actual ******* reads please?
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Thank you for choosing
Rodemy Pizza
It’s not the best choice, but it’s a choice nonetheless
Tubba
Their entrance is the exact opposite of how I saw them in the wolf game with me, maybe I am being a little pre-mature, but I am going to treat them as town, unless I find reason otherwise
Lagoon
claim more likely to come from town, depends on his consistency and if he just decides to ride that claim, which he isn’t doing so far
posts are also ok
Ter
has been more proactive with her vote then in the previous game I played with, which is good? Nice mixture of scum hunting and question asking. The worst thing from this slot is probably their post on Fonti being unlikely to be a wolf, because she rolled it last game? Sure I can see town making that post, even if it sucks
Rodemy –
posts are fine, gambit is probably unlikely to come from wolf!rod, and he will usually volume clear himself, so I am liking this slot
ZDS
this is entrance is more likely to from his town self, cause from his one wolf game that I witnessed, he was quite calculated with his votes
Killjoy
Currently, his posts are fine
Tom
People are saying there is a story in his gifs? Haven’t actually iso’d him to see if this is true, and even if it is, it still is relatively NAI atm.
Sloth
in between memeing and serious thoughts
Jack?
Though I am always against this lynch day 1
Fuwa
I can't read this slot
Amp?
Probably volume-clears herself? But she will probably say read doesn’t work anymore
Wake?
I think they have one post?
Shadow?
Nothing, that I remember without rereading
Kpaca –
feels like he is scum hunting? But its not like something he couldn’t do as mafia, if I had to place him, I would say low-leaning town, but I am keeping him at null
Poison?
Actively choosing to do nothing, feels more like a forced scum entrance, but that isnt enough to vote
Axel –
his mechnical post comes off as opportunistic
Terry –
Opportunistic push on me, that he may still actually believe? but that kinda gets thrown in the dumpster when he decides to shade me, without actually voting me
Zion –
His wall feels like the typical wolf asking questions that do nothing, and responding to posts with or without thoughts that bring nothing to progress the game
this looks like garbage but w/e, I hate doing read lists, especially this early, but this is probably the best way to get my thoughts out, without spamming the thread
Does not one else care that Lastwhisper isn’t taking a firm stance on anything, isn’t paying attention, and is spending most of his time posting fluff that means nothing?
Does not one else care that Lastwhisper isn’t taking a firm stance on anything, isn’t paying attention, and is spending most of his time posting fluff that means nothing?
I care Kpaca.
To expand. I want flips day one, if there is even a chance that someone won't flip, I don't want to them dead this early. They can still get scum reads and we can lynch them later. The fact that Axelrod also claimed non-flipper is worrisome.
Are you going to read my posts? You say, starting now? Good. Now that's out of the way and we can move on...
I don't think we should lynch a non-flipper today, so I'll have to settle for just pointing out what I think are scum tells.
I've read your posts from the start. They leave me wanting.
You start the game off with a weak as hell case on Last which screams opportunistic and disingenuous. Defense Defense Defense over it.
Throw a very brittle and barren bone of "I don't want to lynch people we don't get info from" which...is obvious and is talking for the sake of talking if you don't bother hunting anyone else.
More defense!
Slightest of twitches back to Last...
and then complain at me for calling you out on your lack of scum hunting.
Do something. Even if Rod's derpgambit of dark mark pull wasn't good at least it was something
Are you going to read my posts? You say, starting now? Good. Now that's out of the way and we can move on...
I don't think we should lynch a non-flipper today, so I'll have to settle for just pointing out what I think are scum tells.
I've read your posts from the start. They leave me wanting.
You start the game off with a weak as hell case on Last which screams opportunistic and disingenuous. Defense Defense Defense over it.
Throw a very brittle and barren bone of "I don't want to lynch people we don't get info from" which...is obvious and is talking for the sake of talking if you don't bother hunting anyone else.
More defense!
Slightest of twitches back to Last...
and then complain at me for calling you out on your lack of scum hunting.
Do something. Even if Rod's derpgambit of dark mark pull wasn't good at least it was something
playing devil's advocate for a moment: at what point does a wolf with any level of self-awareness temper their bullheadedness and adopt a bit more reasonable of a thread stance
admittedly i've never played with joe before so i have no way of knowing if he's any different as a wolf, but it seems like at some point you'd realize that your push is weak and that you're drawing an inordinate amount of attention to yourself
but it seems like at some point you'd realize that your push is weak and that you're drawing an inordinate amount of attention to yourself
Hence why I am still reading his posts and telling him to convince me I'm wrong. I'm more than willing to admit when I have a bad tunnel going but I need to see something to show that other than alleged twtbaw
Are you going to read my posts? You say, starting now? Good. Now that's out of the way and we can move on...
I don't think we should lynch a non-flipper today, so I'll have to settle for just pointing out what I think are scum tells.
I've read your posts from the start. They leave me wanting.
You start the game off with a weak as hell case on Last which screams opportunistic and disingenuous. Defense Defense Defense over it.
Throw a very brittle and barren bone of "I don't want to lynch people we don't get info from" which...is obvious and is talking for the sake of talking if you don't bother hunting anyone else.
More defense!
Slightest of twitches back to Last...
and then complain at me for calling you out on your lack of scum hunting.
Do something. Even if Rod's derpgambit of dark mark pull wasn't good at least it was something
playing devil's advocate for a moment: at what point does a wolf with any level of self-awareness temper their bullheadedness and adopt a bit more reasonable of a thread stance
admittedly i've never played with joe before so i have no way of knowing if he's any different as a wolf, but it seems like at some point you'd realize that your push is weak and that you're drawing an inordinate amount of attention to yourself
i guess the tl;dr is "kinda feels twtbaw"
Why would a town player care about drawing an inordinate amount of attention to themselves?
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Official Moderator of The [Gutter]
Think the MtgStaff is just swell? Join today! You too can be involved in an 8 year grudge and delete nearly 9000 of kpaca's posts!
honestly is it even wolfy for joe to make that push in the first place
like don't get me wrong it's definitely a bad push and if wisp is mafia it's 100% "right for the wrong reasons" type stuff
but at the same time like... if you're scum, you'd know that wisp didn't mean anything insidious by the comment, and would have to actively think of that fake angle to push. you'd either have to be feigning oblivious about the concept of people having different names on other sites, or you could legitimately not know what wisp means, but either way you'd have to come up with an angle that i don't think naturally pops into a wolf's brain
if you're town, on the other hand, it's a legitimately obtuse push to make, but comes from a brain that's like... actively sniffing for weird ***** in people's posts and trying to figure out what could be behind it
i don't think it's a super clearing towncase or anything but i think this comes from villagers more than it comes from wolves.
Are you going to read my posts? You say, starting now? Good. Now that's out of the way and we can move on...
I don't think we should lynch a non-flipper today, so I'll have to settle for just pointing out what I think are scum tells.
I've read your posts from the start. They leave me wanting.
You start the game off with a weak as hell case on Last which screams opportunistic and disingenuous. Defense Defense Defense over it.
Throw a very brittle and barren bone of "I don't want to lynch people we don't get info from" which...is obvious and is talking for the sake of talking if you don't bother hunting anyone else.
More defense!
Slightest of twitches back to Last...
and then complain at me for calling you out on your lack of scum hunting.
Do something. Even if Rod's derpgambit of dark mark pull wasn't good at least it was something
playing devil's advocate for a moment: at what point does a wolf with any level of self-awareness temper their bullheadedness and adopt a bit more reasonable of a thread stance
admittedly i've never played with joe before so i have no way of knowing if he's any different as a wolf, but it seems like at some point you'd realize that your push is weak and that you're drawing an inordinate amount of attention to yourself
i guess the tl;dr is "kinda feels twtbaw"
Why would a town player care about drawing an inordinate amount of attention to themselves?
i... never said a town player would?
i'm saying that if joe's a wolf you'd think he would at some point realize how wolfy he looks
honestly is it even wolfy for joe to make that push in the first place
like don't get me wrong it's definitely a bad push and if wisp is mafia it's 100% "right for the wrong reasons" type stuff
but at the same time like... if you're scum, you'd know that wisp didn't mean anything insidious by the comment, and would have to actively think of that fake angle to push. you'd either have to be feigning oblivious about the concept of people having different names on other sites, or you could legitimately not know what wisp means, but either way you'd have to come up with an angle that i don't think naturally pops into a wolf's brain
if you're town, on the other hand, it's a legitimately obtuse push to make, but comes from a brain that's like... actively sniffing for weird ***** in people's posts and trying to figure out what could be behind it
i don't think it's a super clearing towncase or anything but i think this comes from villagers more than it comes from wolves.
Yeah this is pretty astute and you and Joe are pretty much both town.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Official Moderator of The [Gutter]
Think the MtgStaff is just swell? Join today! You too can be involved in an 8 year grudge and delete nearly 9000 of kpaca's posts!
The accountant in me really doesn't feel like it's super probable Fonti draws scum two games in a row with me
This is an inquisitive, almost playful Fulcrum, whereas last game my gut feeling from her was predatory. Unless they’ve drastically changed it up, they’re town. I don’t like how Goo pushed claims in so early as a matter of principle, but I don’t see much that makes me think it was scum motivated.
@Rod
Explain why you’re so wrong and your best case scenario for an outcome of your DarkMarky Mark Gambit.
My partial claim: I strongly prefer not to be targeted by anybody for any reason; it will interfere with my role. This is your only warning, and I'm claiming this because it's important. Please take my words at face value if you're a villager. Mafia, I can't stop you from killing/blocking/redirecting/etc. me but I'm not that interesting, promise.
Are you claiming miller, yes or no.
Actually, back to this: What's the hurry of getting this out so quickly. Day is almost 2 weeks long and you started this as a discussion proposal.
Then you skipped the discussion and just tossed this in there without waiting for people to comment on it. I mean, 3/4s of the players haven't even posted yet.
I agree with this tbh, if it was meant for no further discussion why bring it up at SOD?
@Amy
you can iso, by going back a page, click the post count near the topic, and click the post count for the player
also you want me to evaluate your vote on me?
I guess overall its pretty fair?
I dont think its malicious at least
honestly is it even wolfy for joe to make that push in the first place
like don't get me wrong it's definitely a bad push and if wisp is mafia it's 100% "right for the wrong reasons" type stuff
but at the same time like... if you're scum, you'd know that wisp didn't mean anything insidious by the comment, and would have to actively think of that fake angle to push. you'd either have to be feigning oblivious about the concept of people having different names on other sites, or you could legitimately not know what wisp means, but either way you'd have to come up with an angle that i don't think naturally pops into a wolf's brain
if you're town, on the other hand, it's a legitimately obtuse push to make, but comes from a brain that's like... actively sniffing for weird ***** in people's posts and trying to figure out what could be behind it
i don't think it's a super clearing towncase or anything but i think this comes from villagers more than it comes from wolves.
fair, it probably is more like for wolves to sheep that read then build in themselves
My partial claim: I strongly prefer not to be targeted by anybody for any reason; it will interfere with my role. This is your only warning, and I'm claiming this because it's important. Please take my words at face value if you're a villager. Mafia, I can't stop you from killing/blocking/redirecting/etc. me but I'm not that interesting, promise.
Are you claiming miller, yes or no.
Actually, back to this: What's the hurry of getting this out so quickly. Day is almost 2 weeks long and you started this as a discussion proposal.
Then you skipped the discussion and just tossed this in there without waiting for people to comment on it. I mean, 3/4s of the players haven't even posted yet.
I agree with this tbh, if it was meant for no further discussion why bring it up at SOD?
see the problem I have with this post is, is that you are able to bounce thoughts off of Sloth's post, which not necessarily wolfy overall, its just an easy comment to make, because its hard to prove these thoughts are your own because he already answered his own question, and then you answered it again
Does not one else care that Lastwhisper isn’t taking a firm stance on anything, isn’t paying attention, and is spending most of his time posting fluff that means nothing?
I care Kpaca.
To expand. I want flips day one, if there is even a chance that someone won't flip, I don't want to them dead this early. They can still get scum reads and we can lynch them later. The fact that Axelrod also claimed non-flipper is worrisome.
worrisome how? I believe u might be jumping the gun a little too hard, but the pressure is nice. I think his earlier posts are more nai, what bothers me more is his shade while not voting me. I guess I could say, I think town!Terry would probably stand his ground a little harder, rather than back off because others told it was dumb?
Yup! Site won't let me register under aa-dono iirc so I went with my second username.... though I played here before... badly, and embarrassingly made me not want to play again, but Sloth pulled me back here so here I am
Woah Aa-dono, I remember scum reading you mostly because of your semi-inactivity, so I think I would be having a sliiiiight meta on you. Happy to play with you again.
Okay, so I read upto p-3, tom posts only in GIF's, pretty null. Although if he does that during EoD, I would like to poison him.
I like Amy, I'm town leaning her.
Don't know what to make out of the three claims?
-Two no role reveals (trusting both of them atm, although not sure of the alignment)
-weird lagoon claim at EoD is not something I would scum read him for tbh, but well I'll see if he turns out to be wolfy.
#255
In regards to this post, I’d probably say the same thing I said in regards to Terry. I’d expect town!Sloth to stand his ground on his own opinion, rather than back off because others think its something that Terry could do as town
Page 1 of his iso is combinations of playfulness, and poking at Terry, also he votes Jack because ???
Calls out Rodemy as being possible scum? But he hasn’t said anything really about Jack, so IDK why his vote ended up there?
So Sloth can be a wolf I guess? His content on a macro level isn’t townie enough to volume clear him yet thats for sure
My partial claim: I strongly prefer not to be targeted by anybody for any reason; it will interfere with my role. This is your only warning, and I'm claiming this because it's important. Please take my words at face value if you're a villager. Mafia, I can't stop you from killing/blocking/redirecting/etc. me but I'm not that interesting, promise.
Are you claiming miller, yes or no.
Actually, back to this: What's the hurry of getting this out so quickly. Day is almost 2 weeks long and you started this as a discussion proposal.
Then you skipped the discussion and just tossed this in there without waiting for people to comment on it. I mean, 3/4s of the players haven't even posted yet.
I agree with this tbh, if it was meant for no further discussion why bring it up at SOD?
see the problem I have with this post is, is that you are able to bounce thoughts off of Sloth's post, which not necessarily wolfy overall, its just an easy comment to make, because its hard to prove these thoughts are your own because he already answered his own question, and then you answered it again
Ohh, sorry, I always comment while catching up, so I replied before going to the next page.
What treatment? People voting for you? Seriously? This is your response? "people are mean to me"? WHAT
well you people want me to force stuff, and then you call it *****
when of course its gonna be *****, when this is not how I play mafia
I choose to walk away cause its better for my sanity, and the thread
TBH I should expect this, because wagoning me early on his literally a meme at this point
because my entrances are usually garbage
What treatment? People voting for you? Seriously? This is your response? "people are mean to me"? WHAT
well you people want me to force stuff, and then you call it *****
when of course its gonna be *****, when this is not how I play mafia
I choose to walk away cause its better for my sanity, and the thread
TBH I should expect this, because wagoning me early on his literally a meme at this point
because my entrances are usually garbage
I’d like to hear other people way in on this sort of behavior at this point.
oh, ya think? God this is frustrating right now. Can we get some actual ******* reads please?
caveat being i'm super weak to AtE but whatever
**** yes.
We can bring in Rodemy as an unpaid intern.
this looks like garbage but w/e, I hate doing read lists, especially this early, but this is probably the best way to get my thoughts out, without spamming the thread
vote: Zionite
I don't think we should lynch a non-flipper today, so I'll have to settle for just pointing out what I think are scum tells.
😡
bingo
lazy read denied, try harder
idk what u guys want from me at this point
leave me alone, jesus
what is there to read
you haven't done *****
you are literally in my nulls
talk to me about sloth
no, I'll come back tomorrow
I am not in the mood for this kind of treatment
I am just trying to enjoy a game of mafia without blowing up the thread
I've read your posts from the start. They leave me wanting.
You start the game off with a weak as hell case on Last which screams opportunistic and disingenuous. Defense Defense Defense over it.
Throw a very brittle and barren bone of "I don't want to lynch people we don't get info from" which...is obvious and is talking for the sake of talking if you don't bother hunting anyone else.
More defense!
Slightest of twitches back to Last...
and then complain at me for calling you out on your lack of scum hunting.
Do something. Even if Rod's derpgambit of dark mark pull wasn't good at least it was something
curious to hear if you have any sort of read of my vote on you when you get back
admittedly i've never played with joe before so i have no way of knowing if he's any different as a wolf, but it seems like at some point you'd realize that your push is weak and that you're drawing an inordinate amount of attention to yourself
i guess the tl;dr is "kinda feels twtbaw"
Lastwhisper (2) - Ampharos, kpaca
TheRealStinkyJoeTerry (2) - tomsloger, TerRaine
tomsloger (2) - Axelrod, ZeDorkSlipeur
Zionite (2) - fulcrum, Lastwhisper
gooLagoon (1) - Rodemy
Jackrito (1) - Slothful
Killjoy (1) - xX_WakeMeUp1337_Xx
Rodemy (1) - gooLagoon
Slothful (1) - Fuwa
xX_WakeMeUp1337_Xx (1) - Zionite
Not voting: Jackrito, Killjoy, Poison Chan, shadowlancerx, TheRealStinkyJoeTerry, Tubba Fett
Vote History:
Slothful - Zionite > Jackrito
Axelrod - tomsloger
TerRaine - Slothful > Unvote > TheRealStinkyJoeTerry
Ampharos - tomsloger > Lastwhisper
tomsloger - No Elim > Axelrod > TheRealStinkyJoeTerry
Fuwa - Slothful
Zionite - xX_WakeMeUp1337_Xx
Rodemy - tomsloger > TheRealStinkyJoeTerry > gooLagoon
xX_WakeMeUp1337_Xx - Killjoy
TheRealStinkyJoeTerry - Ampharos > Lastwhisper > Unvote
fulcrum - Lastwhisper > Zionite
ZeDorkSlipeur - tomsloger
kpaca - Lastwhisper
Lastwhisper - Zionite
Fulcrum is V/LA.
Fuwa is V/LA.
It takes 11 to elim, and Day 1 Deadline is the 29th at 1930 PST.
I want for you to have votes on you. That is what I want from you. And you are crumbling like a house of cards made out of crumbly things.
What treatment? People voting for you? Seriously? This is your response? "people are mean to me"? WHAT
Hence why I am still reading his posts and telling him to convince me I'm wrong. I'm more than willing to admit when I have a bad tunnel going but I need to see something to show that other than alleged twtbaw
Vote TheRealStinkyJoeTerry
Why would a town player care about drawing an inordinate amount of attention to themselves?
like don't get me wrong it's definitely a bad push and if wisp is mafia it's 100% "right for the wrong reasons" type stuff
but at the same time like... if you're scum, you'd know that wisp didn't mean anything insidious by the comment, and would have to actively think of that fake angle to push. you'd either have to be feigning oblivious about the concept of people having different names on other sites, or you could legitimately not know what wisp means, but either way you'd have to come up with an angle that i don't think naturally pops into a wolf's brain
if you're town, on the other hand, it's a legitimately obtuse push to make, but comes from a brain that's like... actively sniffing for weird ***** in people's posts and trying to figure out what could be behind it
i don't think it's a super clearing towncase or anything but i think this comes from villagers more than it comes from wolves.
i'm saying that if joe's a wolf you'd think he would at some point realize how wolfy he looks
Well that makes sense.
Yeah this is pretty astute and you and Joe are pretty much both town.
This is an inquisitive, almost playful Fulcrum, whereas last game my gut feeling from her was predatory. Unless they’ve drastically changed it up, they’re town. I don’t like how Goo pushed claims in so early as a matter of principle, but I don’t see much that makes me think it was scum motivated.
@Rod
Explain why you’re so wrong and your best case scenario for an outcome of your DarkMarky Mark Gambit.
I said the push was weak...didn't say it was a scumfirm for Joe.
Most D1 cases...especially early on aren't super strong. They need to build and have momentum. They change and shift and grow.
What I don't like is the lack of anything that comes after. All we have is defense of a stalled weak case.
do whatever you want, i guess
For better or worse I usually do
I agree with this tbh, if it was meant for no further discussion why bring it up at SOD?
you can iso, by going back a page, click the post count near the topic, and click the post count for the player
also you want me to evaluate your vote on me?
I guess overall its pretty fair?
I dont think its malicious at least
still bothered by his shade though so /shrug
The ultimate truth.
Woah Aa-dono, I remember scum reading you mostly because of your semi-inactivity, so I think I would be having a sliiiiight meta on you. Happy to play with you again.
"oh so town"
Okay, so I read upto p-3, tom posts only in GIF's, pretty null. Although if he does that during EoD, I would like to poison him.
I like Amy, I'm town leaning her.
Don't know what to make out of the three claims?
-Two no role reveals (trusting both of them atm, although not sure of the alignment)
-weird lagoon claim at EoD is not something I would scum read him for tbh, but well I'll see if he turns out to be wolfy.
Sloth and Ter is pretty Null till now.
WMU should stab osie for that name.
In regards to this post, I’d probably say the same thing I said in regards to Terry. I’d expect town!Sloth to stand his ground on his own opinion, rather than back off because others think its something that Terry could do as town
Page 1 of his iso is combinations of playfulness, and poking at Terry, also he votes Jack because ???
Calls out Rodemy as being possible scum? But he hasn’t said anything really about Jack, so IDK why his vote ended up there?
So Sloth can be a wolf I guess? His content on a macro level isn’t townie enough to volume clear him yet thats for sure
Ohh, sorry, I always comment while catching up, so I replied before going to the next page.
well you people want me to force stuff, and then you call it *****
when of course its gonna be *****, when this is not how I play mafia
I choose to walk away cause its better for my sanity, and the thread
TBH I should expect this, because wagoning me early on his literally a meme at this point
because my entrances are usually garbage
I am currently happy with my reads and my vote
Take a breath, hun.
Things will be ok.