i have sloth maybe thinly v off tonal/comfrot *****
wisp claim seems >rand true but based on how wisp played joat in champs it's probably not out of his wolfrange to fps it
lagoon claim is caked in multiple layers of wifom and i don't feel like unpacking that on its own
Sloth has this sort of tone and comfort as scum and town based off the one scum game I saw him play,
On Wisp he has a pretty wide wolf range when it comes to random claims start of day one. I would like to think that he has learned to stop doing that, because itnormally bites him eventually. He will become clear in time though I'm sure.
I'm largely going to ignore setup assumptions this game, since Osie tends to mess me up a lot lately by just throwing random stuff in that makes no sense to me. So going to try and do this the old fashioned way which I suck at and will likely get scumread for in due time.
I'm largely going to ignore setup assumptions this game, since Osie tends to mess me up a lot lately by just throwing random stuff in that makes no sense to me. So going to try and do this the old fashioned way which I suck at and will likely get scumread for in due time.
That's the defeatist starting attitude I like to see!
Mafia sucks, none of us should be playing this anyway, where is Vaimes, etc.
Actually, back to this: What's the hurry of getting this out so quickly. Day is almost 2 weeks long and you started this as a discussion proposal.
Then you skipped the discussion and just tossed this in there without waiting for people to comment on it. I mean, 3/4s of the players haven't even posted yet.
Well, I figure people are going to be cagey about their roles, and are pretty much going to do whatever they want/think is best. I wanted to get my thing out now rather than later so it wouldn't get lost in a sea of drama or derail any scumhunting.
I don't really want comments on my claim. I just wanted the claim out there.
I think Sloth had a good point here. I don't see claiming any role info without some sort of discussion happening whether you intended it or not, especially this soon.
I think it's like a weird WIFOMy situation now that you have brought attention to it. I don't think you increased the chances of going ignored. While I don't agree with the play, I can understand why with the unique timing of the beginning.
i don't... really wanna waste brainpower processing how i wanna deal with lagoon's claim rn, but i'm gonna
assuming it's some kind of role that needs to be not targeted in order to work properly or something like that, it's probably NAI to claim it... but probably also kinda dumb to do as a villager, unless you're that sure you're gonna get randed? so that's something
idk. that part of it at least can probably be taken at face value, unless it's the world's wonkiest "don't peek me" cover. probably would recommend not ******* with it unless we think lagoon's wolfy independently
i miss mountainous
The random odds are a good observation too, but who knows what kind of setup we're playing. I'd suggest we rely on assumptions as little as possible when it comes to roles and interactions, if the setup info is any indication.
actually wisp why the hell even claim that to begin with? if you're town it's literally not relevant information unless you're on the chopping block and/or planning on getting nightkilled
i don't like... see what we're supposed to do with that information rn. i don't see what sharing it's supposed to accomplish
bleh so now i think BOTH claims itt are ill advised lmao
i don't doubt that you're telling the truth about your alignment not revealing on death. i just don't see the town motivation for sharing that information
if you're scum, it's an attempt to wifom us out of any associative reads on your slot should you wind up being voted out, combined with like... attempting to earn towncred for honesty?
if you're town, it's just pointless, especially this early on
I only read the first 100 posts and i already like Amy by tone and vibe, and noticed who knows who.
I am glad to recognise Lagoon and Awa from Mafia Colosseum.
Kind of like Tom for his gif posting too.
I didn't wake up yet so i will come back later to catch up. Busy weekend is included in rl schedule.
Something I want to ask and get out of the way as soon as possible so we don't drown in this topic later: should people with antitown roles/abilities come forward and clarify, whether it's through hints or outright, or should we all just keep quiet and work it out later? I'm considering making a partial claim.
11 seems relevant here.
lol took me forever to realize you meant rule 11. I was like "player 11? Is that code?" and the "11 to eliminate! What does it mean?!" "Wait she posted the 11th post."
100%, I was going to use “confused blond lady math equation overlay” meme, but Pepe Silvia is on point as well.
I don’t think revealing roles that are “anti-town” would be very beneficial. It’d just pour wine all over the table.
Don't worry about past humiliations, I just got done with a game here where font and Azrael ran circles around me. It was fun!
Because you don't listen.
Can someone tell me the **** tom's latest gif is?
Umm... it’s high culture, Philistine!
(It’s a different magic themed show and frankly I’m loving it and hope with my heart of hearts that he continues to do so. Also, also, I don’t think they mean anything, ever.)
i don't doubt that you're telling the truth about your alignment not revealing on death. i just don't see the town motivation for sharing that information
if you're scum, it's an attempt to wifom us out of any associative reads on your slot should you wind up being voted out, combined with like... attempting to earn towncred for honesty?
if you're town, it's just pointless, especially this early on
don't like it.
But see, this is exactly what I was talking about re: coming forward with role quirks like this. If Wisp had just died without a flip, then we'd immediately assume Janitor (or maybe not, because setup-gaming won't work here). I think it's nice to know, without it necessarily moving the needle on his alignment.
I only read the first 100 posts and i already like Amy by tone and vibe, and noticed who knows who.
I am glad to recognise Lagoon and Awa from Mafia Colosseum.
Kind of like Tom for his gif posting too.
I didn't wake up yet so i will come back later to catch up. Busy weekend is included in rl schedule.
Bienvenue à MTGS!
ZDS is French, you two must already know each other.
Oh Lord, do not do this. Like the gifs, sure, but do not like this poster because of the gifs.
I think gooLagoon's claim is more town-indicative than LW's. It feels more like the kind of think a Town would spew into the thread early. LW might as well, but he is also very capable of just claiming random stuff to mess with people.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from Bateleur »
Ambush Krotiq makes me laugh so much. I keep rereading the card and it keeps not having Flash. In what sense is this an ambush again? I just have visions of this huge Krotiq poorly concealed in some bushes, feeling slightly sad that his carefully planned ambushes never seem to work.
There's also the fact that my role won't be revealed on death either. And how many of those do we expect in this game?
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from Bateleur »
Ambush Krotiq makes me laugh so much. I keep rereading the card and it keeps not having Flash. In what sense is this an ambush again? I just have visions of this huge Krotiq poorly concealed in some bushes, feeling slightly sad that his carefully planned ambushes never seem to work.
Ambush Krotiq makes me laugh so much. I keep rereading the card and it keeps not having Flash. In what sense is this an ambush again? I just have visions of this huge Krotiq poorly concealed in some bushes, feeling slightly sad that his carefully planned ambushes never seem to work.
I didn't really think about the possible implication of a janitor
I saw my role pm, and I was like, this is probably something better to claim now, rather than later
I think it looks good regardless of my alignment
Noted on brevity.
We'll have to put that to the test, I'm sure.
20 players - I suspect 5 scum tops?
Alright, sleep time.
Night all!
Probably believe you.
my sleep schedule is... interesting
wisp claim seems >rand true but based on how wisp played joat in champs it's probably not out of his wolfrange to fps it
lagoon claim is caked in multiple layers of wifom and i don't feel like unpacking that on its own
What sort of game is this if you don't show up on death, got no reason to distrust it, and not interested in lynching you day one to test this out.
Sloth has this sort of tone and comfort as scum and town based off the one scum game I saw him play,
On Wisp he has a pretty wide wolf range when it comes to random claims start of day one. I would like to think that he has learned to stop doing that, because itnormally bites him eventually. He will become clear in time though I'm sure.
Only wolves spellchecki thetief postsdh
That's the defeatist starting attitude I like to see!
Mafia sucks, none of us should be playing this anyway, where is Vaimes, etc.
I mean, it's better than naked mem, but wtf.
tomsloger (2) - Axelrod, Ampharos
Ampharos (1) - gooLagoon
Slothful (1) - Fuwa
Zionite (1) - Slothful
No Elim (1) - tomsloger
Not voting: Everyone else.
Vote History:
Slothful - Zionite
Axelrod - tomsloger
TerRaine - Slothful > Unvote
Ampharos - tomsloger
tomsloger - No Lynch
Fuwa - Slothful
Fulcrum is V/LA.
Fuwa is V/LA.
It takes 11 to elim, and Day 1 Deadline is the 29th at 1930 PST.
Please no. Not this again.
I think Sloth had a good point here. I don't see claiming any role info without some sort of discussion happening whether you intended it or not, especially this soon.
I think it's like a weird WIFOMy situation now that you have brought attention to it. I don't think you increased the chances of going ignored. While I don't agree with the play, I can understand why with the unique timing of the beginning.
The random odds are a good observation too, but who knows what kind of setup we're playing. I'd suggest we rely on assumptions as little as possible when it comes to roles and interactions, if the setup info is any indication.
Definitely an anti-town role. Flips are everything. Possibly other ways to deal with this? Forgive me for not taking your word for it.
Adblock plus works. Much cleaner site once you scrape off the burnt parts!
i don't like... see what we're supposed to do with that information rn. i don't see what sharing it's supposed to accomplish
bleh so now i think BOTH claims itt are ill advised lmao
i don't doubt that you're telling the truth about your alignment not revealing on death. i just don't see the town motivation for sharing that information
if you're scum, it's an attempt to wifom us out of any associative reads on your slot should you wind up being voted out, combined with like... attempting to earn towncred for honesty?
if you're town, it's just pointless, especially this early on
don't like it.
Hello and have a good game!
I only read the first 100 posts and i already like Amy by tone and vibe, and noticed who knows who.
I am glad to recognise Lagoon and Awa from Mafia Colosseum.
Kind of like Tom for his gif posting too.
I didn't wake up yet so i will come back later to catch up. Busy weekend is included in rl schedule.
prolly out until sometime in the afternoon/evening (US time)
Off to work. *dead*
100%, I was going to use “confused blond lady math equation overlay” meme, but Pepe Silvia is on point as well.
I don’t think revealing roles that are “anti-town” would be very beneficial. It’d just pour wine all over the table.
Umm... it’s high culture, Philistine!
(It’s a different magic themed show and frankly I’m loving it and hope with my heart of hearts that he continues to do so. Also, also, I don’t think they mean anything, ever.)
You can call me WMU or Wake and don't think i will sleep all the DP
I would try a vote to encourage activity
##Vote Killjoy top playerlist, not yet posting
-
Bienvenue à MTGS!
ZDS is French, you two must already know each other.
Not necessarily true
I think gooLagoon's claim is more town-indicative than LW's. It feels more like the kind of think a Town would spew into the thread early. LW might as well, but he is also very capable of just claiming random stuff to mess with people.
tom's gifs are a little weak for my tastes.
Hard to say, but if a significant number of us don't flip, then discussing it matters even less, I suppose.
Kek
You sure? Mine are very cozy. Velvet lined. Come in suspicious cloak form.
I saw my role pm, and I was like, this is probably something better to claim now, rather than later
I think it looks good regardless of my alignment
Why do you assume there'd be no flip at all?