I'll answer you, but first, do people on the other sites you've played/spectated on usually claim role info early? Honors system because my spanish is quite rusty so I can't check anyway.
I'll answer you, but first, do people on the other sites you've played/spectated on usually claim role info early? Honors system because my spanish is quite rusty so I can't check anyway.
usually we claim on day 1 or day 2 if the role is not bad to claim .
town has less information so generally is better to push for more claiming .
I'll answer you, but first, do people on the other sites you've played/spectated on usually claim role info early? Honors system because my spanish is quite rusty so I can't check anyway.
usually we claim on day 1 or day 2 if the role is not bad to claim .
town has less information so generally is better to push for more claiming .
:thinking:
TWTBAW stands for Too Wolfy To Be A Wolf; basically, Vaimes thinks it's very wolfy to ask for claims but thinks that, if you were a wolf, you might know that it's wolfy and therefore not ask for roleclaims (rolefishing).
Since early claims are part of your usual meta I'm gonna go with "not an alignment tell either way". Maybe slightly +town.
@KoolKoal: Welcome back! We've drifted a bit in terminology due to crossover from other sites, I think "scummy" is a bit more popular than "wolfy" on the whole though.
@KoolKoal: Welcome back! We've drifted a bit in terminology due to crossover from other sites, I think "scummy" is a bit more popular than "wolfy" on the whole though.
Favorite alignment?
Thanks for the welcome
Favorite alignment is definitely scum. I love the feeling I get when someone wrongly declares me town, or says "scum would never do that." I'm pretty good at shaking people's expectations of what a scum would do. And when I get caught I tend to flail horribly, which is at least humorous to look back on
I also used to have a garbage town game, but was getting reasonably proficient when I stopped playing. I hope I haven't regressed back to garbage, and that more years of life experience actually made me better at reading people, but we'll see.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I'll bet you wish you had a non-unglued/unhinged card that shared your first name.
KoolKoal: Feel free to take this with a grain of salt since self meta isn't particularly helpful, but I think I get scumread mostly for style over substance, but also for a certain lack of substance over style. It's not so much what I AM posting most of the time (though sometimes that can seem bad) but what I'm NOT posting. I've been told I come to non-obvious conclusions a lot, so when I post, quite a bit of the time there's jumps in logic that people can't follow and they think that's scummy. I get that accusation about a lot of questions I ask specifically. People call them "busy work" when the questions are legit etc.
As far as things to ignore, I can't think of anything. I would suggest you focus less on what I'm doing and more on how I'm doing it. That's probably more likely to be accurate. Like I've just said, what I do tends to come off a little weird, but if you look for how I do it, mindset comes into play and maybe you figure out something useful.
I'll answer you, but first, do people on the other sites you've played/spectated on usually claim role info early? Honors system because my spanish is quite rusty so I can't check anyway.
usually we claim on day 1 or day 2 if the role is not bad to claim .
town has less information so generally is better to push for more claiming .
I'll answer you, but first, do people on the other sites you've played/spectated on usually claim role info early? Honors system because my spanish is quite rusty so I can't check anyway.
usually we claim on day 1 or day 2 if the role is not bad to claim .
town has less information so generally is better to push for more claiming .
hi,
to clarify this, are you claiming roles for any particular reason or just everybody is mass claiming early in the game
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Can we have Megiddo removed from the forum forever please?
i'm pretty sure i can find your ***** online within 3 minutes
I'll answer you, but first, do people on the other sites you've played/spectated on usually claim role info early? Honors system because my spanish is quite rusty so I can't check anyway.
usually we claim on day 1 or day 2 if the role is not bad to claim .
town has less information so generally is better to push for more claiming .
hi,
to clarify this, are you claiming roles for any particular reason or just everybody is mass claiming early in the game
generally all players claim before the end of day 3 .
I just started a cruise on a stretch I’ve never done before, so I’ll be low activity the next 2 weeks.
Which is sad. I was just home for 3 weeks without a game to play
True enough, KCC, I forgot you were already voting Vaimes.
I kind of think he's a villager, though. Could you walk me through the read like I've never played Mafia before? Or is it literally just, you think he was trying to avoid RVS?
I kind of think he's a villager, though. Could you walk me through the read like I've never played Mafia before? Or is it literally just, you think he was trying to avoid RVS?
It's more that he thought he had cover to skip RVS and tried taking advantage of it.
Like, I had a reason for my post, vaimes had an excuse
1) I have Not Voted in RVS several times before.
2) I thought the "contentless post" was funny, if a bit drier.
3) I promise to really, really think about your alignment. Not Silver's though!
Kind of think it's just not wolfy, though.
Meh.
KJ/Emiko probably not knowingly aligned though, yeah.
what TWTBAW mean?
Why are we talking about wolves? I thought I signed up for mafia not werewolf. I mentioned it to our general server and I thought you were online at the time, so its actually your fault for not noticing. Yeah, when I realized I hadn't played in 4 or 5 years O.o
That doesn't make it okay. -And I wasn't avoiding RVS, I was being hilarious.
Also, what are the odds here that Emiko is scum, and was told to just go after KJ
It's also funny that we're both back from 5 year breaks at pretty much the same time
MTGS mafia resurgence? Let's get some new-old life in here.
usually we claim on day 1 or day 2 if the role is not bad to claim .
town has less information so generally is better to push for more claiming .
i do not listen to teammates that try to order me around .
TWTBAW stands for Too Wolfy To Be A Wolf; basically, Vaimes thinks it's very wolfy to ask for claims but thinks that, if you were a wolf, you might know that it's wolfy and therefore not ask for roleclaims (rolefishing).
Since early claims are part of your usual meta I'm gonna go with "not an alignment tell either way". Maybe slightly +town.
@KoolKoal: Welcome back! We've drifted a bit in terminology due to crossover from other sites, I think "scummy" is a bit more popular than "wolfy" on the whole though.
Favorite alignment?
Favorite alignment is definitely scum. I love the feeling I get when someone wrongly declares me town, or says "scum would never do that." I'm pretty good at shaking people's expectations of what a scum would do. And when I get caught I tend to flail horribly, which is at least humorous to look back on
I also used to have a garbage town game, but was getting reasonably proficient when I stopped playing. I hope I haven't regressed back to garbage, and that more years of life experience actually made me better at reading people, but we'll see.
vote shadow for being a wolf.
I'm excited to play with KK again.
Thanks to DNC at Heroes of the plane studios for this awesome sig and SGT_Chubbz for the awesome avy.
Check out the Shop Thread
Not to say this is the wolfy version its pretty neutral. But
Lack of townpoint
No claiming please
@everyone
to clarify this, are you claiming roles for any particular reason or just everybody is mass claiming early in the game
generally all players claim before the end of day 3 .
are you uncertain ?
Which is sad. I was just home for 3 weeks without a game to play
Why are you asking only tom about this?
Thanks to DNC at Heroes of the plane studios for this awesome sig and SGT_Chubbz for the awesome avy.
Check out the Shop Thread
Don't think he's won a wolf game against me yet.
When did you start playing Mafia? I don't remember ever playing with you
Might be the wolfy version.
Vaimes/silver team would not surprise me
That's what I'd tell new scum. But probably not based on the reaction
I only have one vote, Silver
Of course you are
How confident would you say you are in being able to read me?
Have you played with KoolKoal?
I kind of think he's a villager, though. Could you walk me through the read like I've never played Mafia before? Or is it literally just, you think he was trying to avoid RVS?
Okay. I'm a little wary on the idea of a townYou being willing to snapread me, given your limited track record there
It's more that he thought he had cover to skip RVS and tried taking advantage of it.
Like, I had a reason for my post, vaimes had an excuse
2) I thought the "contentless post" was funny, if a bit drier.
3) I promise to really, really think about your alignment. Not Silver's though!
Given that this statement is complete nonsense.
I'm pretty confident that if you are town, I will figure that out
I did think your RVS vote + confirming it as real was a little red flag-y. Just looked like how scum would vote, no real words about it beyond that.
Maybe me putting my thoughts about your more concretely will make you less cranky.
:angryeyes:
Vote Tom