Quote from shadowlancerx »Anyone have anything else?
Tom, you’re 100% on Cantrip? Even with that role?
Quote from Azrael »Updated:
Dkingsland - numerous strong townie attitude posts.
Killjoy – strong tonally
Vez - genuine attempt to counter-claim, strong tone.
Cantripmancer – post 38: consistently focused on logic-based tells, unfair seeming attacks.
Sir chris – would have been super easy to let me die. Hopefully not pocketing me.
beeboy – certain type of self-awareness, wants freedom to lynch arbitrarily, unvote based on role reasons. More analysis necessary, says time for competing wagons – why?
fuwa - self-deprecating frequently, fence sits on both sides of shadow and sir chris, no reasoning for sir chris vote. Inconsistent in characterizing her own attacks, seems to suggest her attacks subjective and might be valid only in her own eyes. Very light-hearted/carefree in tone, which is somewhat unusual for inexperienced scum .
Axelrod – weak push vs KJ, weak jump off. 189. Weirdly states suspicions heightened at same time he extricates.
Syrenz/LW - entertains two diametrically opposed ideas using strong language for each, wavers, then picks one. Not organic read.
Shadow– snipes reasonlessly at KJ, tries to pick on KJ for not counter-voting in his analysis post.
Vaimes – too preoccupied with protecting his own self-image, non-committed and poor explanations for votes on Cantrip and I, good explanation for vote on Tom (buddy?), but won’t follow through, too-easy clear on shadow (buddy?), multiple extremely poor voting reasons for me (activity, lack of counter-wagon, cheap points, not reading posts fully), not fairly evaluating.
Quote from Grapefruit21 »KJ, Cantrip, and KCC all feel townie to me.
Chris is scum.
Wisp, tom, and Shadow are the three players I'm having the hardest time pegging. Wisp is there on tone and energy level but he's lacking the tunnel vision he normally has. Tom is tom. But he was really scummy D1 but he's been solid toDay. And scum!tom probably doesn't shoot that early. Shadow on the other hand just feels all kind of wrong but his votes yesterday are so pure.
Vez and Vaimes are meh townish.
Axel, Osie, and Meg are meh scum-ish.
Quote from Grapefruit21 »And I'm permanently paranoid about getting pocketed. Our fearless moderator has a lot to do with that...
Quote from Killjoy »So now the problem is I don't wanna vote on either of the leading wagons <azrael/fuwa. I would cfd to Last. I'm kinda distrusting KCC but not so hard that I'm willing to vote on that right now.
Quote from Killjoy »Quote from Cantripmancer »Fair enough.
No other thoughts? Who's scum, KJ? Or are they both scum? Maybe V/V? Which? C'mon, guy I attacked and then backed off of because I liked your persistence and conviction in responses! Weigh in!One of you/Axel, one of Tom/Shadow, probably last. Maybe Vaimes?
I'm town reading Rhand. I feel good about beeboy.
Quote from Cantripmancer »Fair enough.
No other thoughts? Who's scum, KJ? Or are they both scum? Maybe V/V? Which? C'mon, guy I attacked and then backed off of because I liked your persistence and conviction in responses! Weigh in!
Quote from Killjoy »My current grouping for possible scum is in [tom/Vaimes/KCC/Last]. I would vote tom but I think there's 4 votes on him now? and we're not done talking yet.
Quote from Lastwhisper »Wisp
Lesser Town Leans
(only because I can barely remember a post of their's off the top of my head, and I've been ignoring them)
The really don't wanna touch today category:
might be some inconsistencies, who knows, this is off the top of my head
dont @ me
looks like I missed Vez, ill just /barn Shadow for now
Quote from Sir Chris »So let me build out a world and see how it goes.
Vaimes is town due to reaction to Az's claim
Vezok is trown due to reaction to Az's claim
KCC has displayed earnest which I tend to lean to town
Wagonomics make me think Shadow/AZ are town
Psychology of posting makes me think beeboy is town as well
It's my list so I get to be town too
4-5 scum in
Of these 9, 5 were off the two main wagons (GF, Axel, Tom, Fuwa, LW)
3 were on Az (Cantripmancer, Rhand, dkings)
and 1 was on Shadow (Killjoy)
I don't think Az' wagon was pure, but I have severe doubts three scum hopped onto him if all my assumptions above are correct so 1-2 scum in Mancer/Rhand/DK, with me leaning towards one.
Killjoy is probably just scum if I am right about all of my town reads.
Which leaves 2-3 in the "we don't care who dies among the town members, so we'll just stay on our random wagons."
Quote from tomsloger »Cantrip/vez
Quote from tomsloger »After everything im at
Shooting in that bottom 4 for sure. Prolly iso all 4 tomorrow
Quote from Bateleur »Ambush Krotiq makes me laugh so much. I keep rereading the card and it keeps not having Flash. In what sense is this an ambush again? I just have visions of this huge Krotiq poorly concealed in some bushes, feeling slightly sad that his carefully planned ambushes never seem to work.
Quote from shadowlancerx »@Axel: I hear you, I think I live in the world where if we do lynch KJ and he’s town, few things would even be speedbumps to a Tom lynch tomorrow.
Quote from shadowlancerx »Certainly some A for effort material from Tom here considering I’d basically said I was going to hammer.
Tempted to just tralalala hammer KJ but I’ve got plenty of time to piddle around and pretend like I know what I’m doing.
Quote from shadowlancerx »Coloring votes and names, as you well know cause I believe you did it a couple days ago, is not nothing. And I commented on you doing it as well.
But contextually, Tom put in that time when I basically declared intent to hammer, which does count for something. If it’s Hail Mary scum play, it is solid.
It’s nice that you keep shading me though, do you really think scum!me waits around in a scenario where I’m buddies with Tom and can guarantee your lynch instead? I’m legit asking.
Quote from shadowlancerx »“See if my wagon becomes viable”
Dude, I could literally hammer you right now, your wagon is viable. If you’re town, show me some critical thinking on this.
Quote from Killjoy »So. I'd like to point a few things out here:
1) Tom's 'effort' posts are primarily info, and less analysis.
2) The analysis isn't actually super connected to all the vote posts.
3) Tom's effort posts don't actually require a lot of effort, which is only relevent if shadow is scum with him. Quote from shadowlancerx »Certainly some A for effort material from Tom here considering I’d basically said I was going to hammer.
Tempted to just tralalala hammer KJ but I’ve got plenty of time to piddle around and pretend like I know what I’m doing.Shadow is impressed by the firstof the self preservation info posts. It's literally just tom ISO'd a bunch of people, and colored the votes to his t/s list. It's not that impressive. Yet, shadow takes that as yet another excuse to try to stay on me instead of tom.
4) Tom (I don't thnik) EVER considered scum!Cantrip following cantrip claiming that tom was lying. This is something I just realized and if true, I think it means his thoughts aren't natural. Town tom would have considered scum cantrip. I havene't verified this yet and tom has a lot of posts. I'm not sure I'd find it if I tried since i'm looking for a negative.
I know my reads have been terrible this game. Az, I figured if he was scum, he wouldnt be caught d1, He's Az. He's pretty good at the game. And Grape I just trusted for stupid reasons. Don't let that get in the way of lynching tom, who is now proven scum.
Quote from Killjoy »Good job waiting for a response.
I'm surprised I lasted that long given Az and Grapefruit. At least that will be more info for analysis later.
Quote from shadowlancerx »Darn
Quote from Proph »Killjoy (4): tomsloger, Sir Chris, Lastwhisper, vezokpiraka
tomsloger (3): Axelrod, Cantripmancer, Killjoy