And I like Kanji's opening as well. I saw that Tom implied that it's openwolfing but waltzing into the thread and proposing a chain lynch in order to psyche out a scumread most definitely doesn't seem like a typical scum move.
Tom has said he doesn't really have a read at all.
His read on Manasi isn't a town read or a scum read. Its a They could be "connected" read? Based off of RVS.
If Tom continues on his madness of ranking people based on Nacho a player he has said he isn't going to read, I swear to god I'm going to scream. Its nonsense.
X could equal Y + 1 and also Z + 2, but I'm never going to define X so it is all just pointless fluff that I'm saying.
Speaking of confirmation bias, this feels fake.
My knowledge of MTGS is kinda thin, but DV is someone who's played more than few games with tom, right? Like, on the "how much do I want to strangle tom" scale between "1 - roleplaying as Voxx" and "10 - roleplaying as a spider," this is like, a very tepid 3 or 4.
Idk what you'll do with this information but DV defaults to like an 8 with me, except that one game where we were both town and realized it early and rekt a scumteam together
Not gonna bother doing pbp analysis for this ***** but I feel the tone isn't 'free' enough for what i normally expect from her villa game. I'm no manasi.reading expert but it just feels like doing for the sake of it
You can probably explain it better than me
Yeah I feel that. Going through the motions a bit, sure. Idk that I can explain it better than that, but that's the general vibe I got from her early posts. I think the "intentional effort to Play Nice" probably mitigates that read /some/ but not completely.
going through the motions, yeah that's a good way of putting it. Honestly was hoping to bait her into doing something by throwing down a naked vote on her but she didn't really bite
And yeah that's a fair point on the play nice thing
What do you think of Tom in general so far
I think it's a bit early for a going through the motions type read. And we should maybe talk about this later.
Remind me maybe
Meh on DV scumread.
Was talking to some friends about it while him and i were arguing and I'm not gonna go find the post but there was a moment where I basically kited him into nacho that really looked like town DV
But also my opinion of him is kinda shaken by the mafia theory opinions he's expressed here.
Thought i knew him better after 3 years or whatever.
It's like finding out your cool if a little weird cousin thinks the earth is flat
So idk
no it's an actual question. You said it and it's whatever but shin agreed so I'm curious.
Like, I didn't care at the time. Didn't respond to it really. Didn't think about it again until shin brought it up so, like, what could y'all possibly be misconstruing as me overreacting I literally isoed myself (no easy feat on mobile) and can't even hazard a guess
Tom asked someone else a question, then I asked him a question to his question, and he responded to me defensively trying to be like "well I'm responding to you but shin agreed"
hell no dawg LMAO
I deliberately pressured you and you caved in. Give up like the wolf that you are.
no it's an actual question. You said it and it's whatever but shin agreed so I'm curious.
^ This quote is an extreme mafia tell to the absolute max.
It's like "I wanna come at you, but someone else said, so I don't wanna be too straightforward but let me do something to do something because I feel the heat"
Not gonna bother doing pbp analysis for this ***** but I feel the tone isn't 'free' enough for what i normally expect from her villa game. I'm no manasi.reading expert but it just feels like doing for the sake of it
You can probably explain it better than me
Yeah I feel that. Going through the motions a bit, sure. Idk that I can explain it better than that, but that's the general vibe I got from her early posts. I think the "intentional effort to Play Nice" probably mitigates that read /some/ but not completely.
going through the motions, yeah that's a good way of putting it. Honestly was hoping to bait her into doing something by throwing down a naked vote on her but she didn't really bite
And yeah that's a fair point on the play nice thing
What do you think of Tom in general so far
I think it's a bit early for a going through the motions type read. And we should maybe talk about this later.
Remind me maybe
#197 | #198 @Kanji Vote: Kanji Your welcome, also that entrance was fascinating thats why. The real question is why are you trying to avoid that entrance like it was meaningless? Oh this is your first game and your stuck with someone as experienced as tom XD. Sure someone already explained to you what a pocket it, but for future reference doing it aint always scummy but scum are more inclinded to do it while town are more likely to fall for it.
#189 @Mana I don't agree that Tom's weird read is NAI, there was meaning behind it regardless if you refuse to look at it like that. It's good that it created debate but i am sure that either you | Tom | Nacho atleast 1 in those 3 is scum based on all these interactions going on. Your welcome to scum read me but my alignent would not have changed how i treated tom's post.
#191 @Mana I get town read alot for similar reasons, i like to beat at a dead horse until people break >:D
#186 | 187 @RandWolf Why the vote? Also you care to give examples of what is making you think anak is wolfy? Same goes for Newcomb
#170 #172 @Nacho It counts as a read on you because he aint saying your seperate alignments he's saying you have a chance to be the same alignment which means while sure he said mana is town that also refers to a read on you. Sure you can be of seperate alignments but that wasnt what town was insinuating. He's not directly giving an opinion on you but he is implying you as a person are connected to manasi, so if he thinks said person is town that means he also thinks your town. You see how that works?
#179 @Nacho I mean i aint stupid enough to argue that I didn't say something that i clearly did, am smart enough to own up to a mistake because denying that mistake is the equivalent to saying "Hey i am scum". I get confused easily but that happens in every game, only different is that this is your first time playing with me.
#165 @D_V I feel like thats quite a stretch, but at the same time thats a big group of people in a 9 player game so guess doesnt change much, also isn't this list missing the person you suspect i am confused
#164 @tomsloger Why would you want to get someone mislynched also why start a random train on a person who clearly said they wouldnt have been here till friday.
#162 @cantripmancer Setting up dichotomies serves what purposes tho?
Yeah I dunno, been changing up my gameplay a bunch with each new game I'm in so figured I'd take it all the way especially if the playerbase isn't a group very familiar with me. I've gotten a lot more attention this game than I've anticipated which is pretty exciting. I'm glad your team took ya off the if I'm not *****posting etc meta read. It's been dead for a while (like what Visor said).
Man I really hate how Kanji is just like... making up what he's reacting to. He keeps saying that tom's biting and freaking out about it but like, nothing of that sort is even happening. The only problem is I don't understand how he's playing so I can't even call him a wolf for it. I really liked Newcomb's initial thoughts BESIDES the stuff about me, heh. I'm not killing Visor either so hard yikes on figuring out who to lynch.
Meh on DV scumread.
Was talking to some friends about it while him and i were arguing and I'm not gonna go find the post but there was a moment where I basically kited him into nacho that really looked like town DV
But also my opinion of him is kinda shaken by the mafia theory opinions he's expressed here.
Thought i knew him better after 3 years or whatever.
It's like finding out your cool if a little weird cousin thinks the earth is flat
So idk
You should stop. Like now.
You're just wrong and the fact that you continue to shade me over this without saying anything other than "I disagree" with zero thoughts behind it is pathetic. If I wanted to have a discussion about human Psychology from someone that I assume doesn't have nearly the same education that I do, I'd walk out on the street. I don't do that because its a waste of time. So, if you're not going to say anything other than "I disagree" then shut up, because that's not an argument and you haven't remotely explained why I'm wrong.
Anyways, I'm out be back later. Need to take a break so I don't get force ably replaced and I'm really unsure what Newcomb is even posting about. Looks pretty LOL though.
Man I really hate how Kanji is just like... making up what he's reacting to. He keeps saying that tom's biting and freaking out about it but like, nothing of that sort is even happening. The only problem is I don't understand how he's playing so I can't even call him a wolf for it. I really liked Newcomb's initial thoughts BESIDES the stuff about me, heh. I'm not killing Visor either so hard yikes on figuring out who to lynch.
Stop spitting nonsense, you're just mad I outed two wolves on day 1.
I'm MVP. You can piss on my grave after you nightkill me it's gucci.
#197 | #198 @Kanji Vote: Kanji Your welcome, also that entrance was fascinating thats why. The real question is why are you trying to avoid that entrance like it was meaningless? Oh this is your first game and your stuck with someone as experienced as tom XD. Sure someone already explained to you what a pocket it, but for future reference doing it aint always scummy but scum are more inclinded to do it while town are more likely to fall for it.
It's cool fam. Most people wanna hit on me the first time they meet me.
TOM CAN YOU SHARE WHY YOU ARE SCUM READING CANTRIP?
I know typing out any sort of justification is really hard for you, but I believe in your ability to do so, old sport.
hi I am waiting for him to show back up and react bro you know full well I'll explain what and when I want to and asking me directly makes it moderately less likely you'll get an answer
And no I'm not gonna argue with you anymore about it or dickmeasure how many degrees we both have it doesn't matter I'm taking it as that's your actual opinion and working from there. Yes, it's shaken a lot of my suppositions wrt you as a player but it's not like I had a solid way to read you anyway so it might actually end up a benefit.
It's just... such a foreign thought to me and it will take me a bit.
Also I think the actual percentage is probably somewhere in the middle and we're both just arguing extremes so whatever.
hi I am waiting for him to show back up and react bro you know full well I'll explain what and when I want to and asking me directly makes it moderately less likely you'll get an answer
And no I'm not gonna argue with you anymore about it or dickmeasure how many degrees we both have it doesn't matter I'm taking it as that's your actual opinion and working from there. Yes, it's shaken a lot of my suppositions wrt you as a player but it's not like I had a solid way to read you anyway so it might actually end up a benefit.
It's just... such a foreign thought to me and it will take me a bit.
Also I think the actual percentage is probably somewhere in the middle and we're both just arguing extremes so whatever.
^ LMAO why is your post so towny here. Dang bro you finally cracked. OK I'm cool with you. Who you wanna vote for real?
tom only has one vote on him (me) yet he's completely stopped solving the game and only responds to offensive jabs at him
This is not ***** town does
I've been scumread for a lot of reasons but I think this is a first.
Like, I usually get "Tom doesn't care" to my knowledge I've never even heard the word overreacting wrt me. In mafia or real life. Like, I'm an emotionless husk that smokes too much weed I don't even care about winning this game really much less about one vote on me that no one competent will listen to
hi I am waiting for him to show back up and react bro you know full well I'll explain what and when I want to and asking me directly makes it moderately less likely you'll get an answer
And no I'm not gonna argue with you anymore about it or dickmeasure how many degrees we both have it doesn't matter I'm taking it as that's your actual opinion and working from there. Yes, it's shaken a lot of my suppositions wrt you as a player but it's not like I had a solid way to read you anyway so it might actually end up a benefit.
It's just... such a foreign thought to me and it will take me a bit.
Also I think the actual percentage is probably somewhere in the middle and we're both just arguing extremes so whatever.
^ LMAO why is your post so towny here. Dang bro you finally cracked. OK I'm cool with you. Who you wanna vote for real?
nah that's not a townie post that's clearly my NAI opinion there with some fence sitting thrown in
What's telling about it?
Et tu, Nacho?
Vote: DV
shinchi v, Nacho maaaaaybe v. I want visor to be a villager. Probably just gonna hop in his pocket and hope my team drags me out if needed.
Anak kinda mislych bait-y.
Agree w/ visor on manasi for the most part, think that's one that can firm up or not pretty easily with a Day or so.
Everyone else kind of a blur.
Idr which game but it was here and megiddo was my partner. We both used it
Remind me maybe
Was talking to some friends about it while him and i were arguing and I'm not gonna go find the post but there was a moment where I basically kited him into nacho that really looked like town DV
But also my opinion of him is kinda shaken by the mafia theory opinions he's expressed here.
Thought i knew him better after 3 years or whatever.
It's like finding out your cool if a little weird cousin thinks the earth is flat
So idk
^ this post itself admits it ya *****
Smash Tom.
GG EZ game.
If you don't trust me you're wrong
do something cool ASAP
Like, I didn't care at the time. Didn't respond to it really. Didn't think about it again until shin brought it up so, like, what could y'all possibly be misconstruing as me overreacting I literally isoed myself (no easy feat on mobile) and can't even hazard a guess
Rest in pieces.
I'd much rather hear shins answer anyway.
Tom asked someone else a question, then I asked him a question to his question, and he responded to me defensively trying to be like "well I'm responding to you but shin agreed"
hell no dawg LMAO
I deliberately pressured you and you caved in. Give up like the wolf that you are.
GG EZ GAME
everyone follow me ASAP on my vote please.
Vote: tomsloger
^ This quote is an extreme mafia tell to the absolute max.
It's like "I wanna come at you, but someone else said, so I don't wanna be too straightforward but let me do something to do something because I feel the heat"
Get owned boy
wassup tom
I will say I like newcomb tho.
Piece of advice: don't F with my homeboys or ya'll finna get styled on.
Cheers
see you guys in two days I guess
I found him thoroughly whelming
I actually also want to see the reasons you believed that Kanji.
Thanks to DNC at Heroes of the plane studios for this awesome sig and SGT_Chubbz for the awesome avy.
Check out the Shop Thread
Why were you inclined to say this??
What so you think of tom
#189 @Mana I don't agree that Tom's weird read is NAI, there was meaning behind it regardless if you refuse to look at it like that. It's good that it created debate but i am sure that either you | Tom | Nacho atleast 1 in those 3 is scum based on all these interactions going on. Your welcome to scum read me but my alignent would not have changed how i treated tom's post.
#191 @Mana I get town read alot for similar reasons, i like to beat at a dead horse until people break >:D
#186 | 187 @RandWolf Why the vote? Also you care to give examples of what is making you think anak is wolfy? Same goes for Newcomb
#170 #172 @Nacho It counts as a read on you because he aint saying your seperate alignments he's saying you have a chance to be the same alignment which means while sure he said mana is town that also refers to a read on you. Sure you can be of seperate alignments but that wasnt what town was insinuating. He's not directly giving an opinion on you but he is implying you as a person are connected to manasi, so if he thinks said person is town that means he also thinks your town. You see how that works?
#179 @Nacho I mean i aint stupid enough to argue that I didn't say something that i clearly did, am smart enough to own up to a mistake because denying that mistake is the equivalent to saying "Hey i am scum". I get confused easily but that happens in every game, only different is that this is your first time playing with me.
#165 @D_V I feel like thats quite a stretch, but at the same time thats a big group of people in a 9 player game so guess doesnt change much, also isn't this list missing the person you suspect i am confused
#164 @tomsloger Why would you want to get someone mislynched also why start a random train on a person who clearly said they wouldnt have been here till friday.
#162 @cantripmancer Setting up dichotomies serves what purposes tho?
Ill reply to page 5 and 6 the next chance i get.
If he can fake that I'd be impressed
How would you describe your town and wolf gameplay
What alignment do you think you are best at
Do you think you are a good wolf?
Yeah I dunno, been changing up my gameplay a bunch with each new game I'm in so figured I'd take it all the way especially if the playerbase isn't a group very familiar with me. I've gotten a lot more attention this game than I've anticipated which is pretty exciting. I'm glad your team took ya off the if I'm not *****posting etc meta read. It's been dead for a while (like what Visor said).
Man I really hate how Kanji is just like... making up what he's reacting to. He keeps saying that tom's biting and freaking out about it but like, nothing of that sort is even happening. The only problem is I don't understand how he's playing so I can't even call him a wolf for it. I really liked Newcomb's initial thoughts BESIDES the stuff about me, heh. I'm not killing Visor either so hard yikes on figuring out who to lynch.
You should stop. Like now.
You're just wrong and the fact that you continue to shade me over this without saying anything other than "I disagree" with zero thoughts behind it is pathetic. If I wanted to have a discussion about human Psychology from someone that I assume doesn't have nearly the same education that I do, I'd walk out on the street. I don't do that because its a waste of time. So, if you're not going to say anything other than "I disagree" then shut up, because that's not an argument and you haven't remotely explained why I'm wrong.
Anyways, I'm out be back later. Need to take a break so I don't get force ably replaced and I'm really unsure what Newcomb is even posting about. Looks pretty LOL though.
TOM CAN YOU SHARE WHY YOU ARE SCUM READING CANTRIP?
I know typing out any sort of justification is really hard for you, but I believe in your ability to do so, old sport.
You don't even know. LOL
When we raving?
Stop spitting nonsense, you're just mad I outed two wolves on day 1.
I'm MVP. You can piss on my grave after you nightkill me it's gucci.
I dunno he keeps trying to explain stuff. I could dig up quotes but we still have like a week so maybe I'll do it sometime later.
Also reacts instantly to my *****posts instead of ignoring them like most normal people would do right now.
That's my game dawg. Pressure people verbally til they slip up.
tom seems like he's trying too hard not to slip.
the fact that no one is following me on the vote (as opposed to the nacho thing) is also very interesting and duly mofkn noted.
tom only has one vote on him (me) yet he's completely stopped solving the game and only responds to offensive jabs at him
This is not ***** town does
Ok
Hey shin how was I overreacting?
It's cool fam. Most people wanna hit on me the first time they meet me.
And no I'm not gonna argue with you anymore about it or dickmeasure how many degrees we both have it doesn't matter I'm taking it as that's your actual opinion and working from there. Yes, it's shaken a lot of my suppositions wrt you as a player but it's not like I had a solid way to read you anyway so it might actually end up a benefit.
It's just... such a foreign thought to me and it will take me a bit.
Also I think the actual percentage is probably somewhere in the middle and we're both just arguing extremes so whatever.
^ LMAO why is your post so towny here. Dang bro you finally cracked. OK I'm cool with you. Who you wanna vote for real?
Like, I usually get "Tom doesn't care" to my knowledge I've never even heard the word overreacting wrt me. In mafia or real life. Like, I'm an emotionless husk that smokes too much weed I don't even care about winning this game really much less about one vote on me that no one competent will listen to
I get that a lot yeah. LOL
Just curious.
tom confirmed town