Anak - Seems very comfortable coming back. I like his confidence and hope it lasts.
D_V - Mindmelding here on Vaimes. While he's not taking things super seriously, he's not over-relaxed. Slight town feels for now.
Null:
Grapefruit - Need to see more, especially explanation of his vote choice.
Kamikaze - Easy choice of vote, need to see more.
Lastwhisper - Need to see more. OMGUS is NAI or slight town for him.
Vezok - Again, need to see more. Kvetching about something offtopic is NAI. Choice of Rodemy could also go either way.
Absent:
Fuwa
Ganderin_dan
Tubba Fett
Scumlean:
GJ - I need to see more here, but so far he's just cozying up to people… Ehh.
kpaca - This has every possibility of going up or down, but so far kpaca feels stilted, and I'm not getting any of that fire between the lines from him.
Tom - Assume Tom is scum until he does something to make him town.
Wuffles - The Darth Vader gimmick doesn't do much… His vote and buddying up to Vaimes both look strange.
Light Scumread:
Vaimes - For being the highest poster, not very useful posts. Almost overly friendly, kinda try-hard.
Osie making a serious rainbow wall less that 60 posts in is??? It's not really scummy or townie. It's just weird. Town!Osie could want to move the game out of RVS and be seeing real things but ummm that would be a serious level of overreading in some cases (like me).
And there are so many thing scum!Osie could be going for. Trying to look solvey, trying to form a narrative, trying to specifically appear eager as a town tell.
@Osie why go in depth on your neutral reads so early?
@Osie why go in depth on your neutral reads so early?
I suppose I've just had a goal to see how early in a game I can solve it. Doesn't hurt that I've played with every player on this list except for Wuffles, and I've seen some of Wuffles' play too, as a host or spectator.
@Osie why go in depth on your neutral reads so early?
I suppose I've just had a goal to see how early in a game I can solve it. Doesn't hurt that I've played with every player on this list except for Wuffles, and I've seen some of Wuffles' play too, as a host or spectator.
Nvm the earlier question then. We're played together? Forum?
@Osie why go in depth on your neutral reads so early?
I suppose I've just had a goal to see how early in a game I can solve it. Doesn't hurt that I've played with every player on this list except for Wuffles, and I've seen some of Wuffles' play too, as a host or spectator.
Nvm the earlier question then. We're played together? Forum?
@Osie why go in depth on your neutral reads so early?
I suppose I've just had a goal to see how early in a game I can solve it. Doesn't hurt that I've played with every player on this list except for Wuffles, and I've seen some of Wuffles' play too, as a host or spectator.
Nvm the earlier question then. We're played together? Forum?
osie, none of your points make me scum. They’re either town-indicative for me or NAI. Why do my posts need to be useful during RVS?
You observed F&E so I have a pretty hard time believing your light scumread.
-
DV, where did you pull that dichotomy from?
That's fair. You were scummy as town in F&E too. It's still early. We'll see. I guess I just don't trust you right now. Like, I suppose it's not quite fair to say that you're not posting useful posts. I think my point would be expressed clearer as "At the moment, I think your posts have an air of being intentionally over-friendly and useless."
I never understand why those things are off-putting to people, but given it’s not just you, all I can say is it’s a personality trait.
I think it has to do with looking for subtle tells, and since those can often be tells for people, it's a concern. I was called out for similar in Two Takes It when I really was scum.
Stilted means you sound off from your usual happy, friendly self. Could just be coming back after a while of not playing.
Yeah I’ve also grown up a lot in the last two years. Tbh im planning on trying to get my footing in this game. It’s why I was glad to see a normal sign up available so quickly into me returning.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Official Moderator of The [Gutter]
Think the MtgStaff is just swell? Join today! You too can be involved in an 8 year grudge and delete nearly 9000 of kpaca's posts!
Yeah, I'm gonna say you are scum and that at least one other person in the townblock is scum.
vote tomsloger
Statistically, the first person to suggest a townblock is scum. I'm restricted to phone posting this week so I can't provide examples, but I'll try when I have the time.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Thanks to DNC at Heroes of the plane studios for this awesome sig and SGT_Chubbz for the awesome avy. Check out the Shop Thread
Anak - Seems very comfortable coming back. I like his confidence and hope it lasts.
D_V - Mindmelding here on Vaimes. While he's not taking things super seriously, he's not over-relaxed. Slight town feels for now.
Null:
Grapefruit - Need to see more, especially explanation of his vote choice.
Kamikaze - Easy choice of vote, need to see more.
Lastwhisper - Need to see more. OMGUS is NAI or slight town for him.
Vezok - Again, need to see more. Kvetching about something offtopic is NAI. Choice of Rodemy could also go either way.
Absent:
Fuwa
Ganderin_dan
Tubba Fett
Scumlean:
GJ - I need to see more here, but so far he's just cozying up to people… Ehh.
kpaca - This has every possibility of going up or down, but so far kpaca feels stilted, and I'm not getting any of that fire between the lines from him.
Tom - Assume Tom is scum until he does something to make him town.
Wuffles - The Darth Vader gimmick doesn't do much… His vote and buddying up to Vaimes both look strange.
Light Scumread:
Vaimes - For being the highest poster, not very useful posts. Almost overly friendly, kinda try-hard.
Anak - Seems very comfortable coming back. I like his confidence and hope it lasts.
D_V - Mindmelding here on Vaimes. While he's not taking things super seriously, he's not over-relaxed. Slight town feels for now.
Null:
Grapefruit - Need to see more, especially explanation of his vote choice.
Kamikaze - Easy choice of vote, need to see more.
Lastwhisper - Need to see more. OMGUS is NAI or slight town for him.
Vezok - Again, need to see more. Kvetching about something offtopic is NAI. Choice of Rodemy could also go either way.
Absent:
Fuwa
Ganderin_dan
Tubba Fett
Scumlean:
GJ - I need to see more here, but so far he's just cozying up to people… Ehh.
kpaca - This has every possibility of going up or down, but so far kpaca feels stilted, and I'm not getting any of that fire between the lines from him.
Tom - Assume Tom is scum until he does something to make him town.
Wuffles - The Darth Vader gimmick doesn't do much… His vote and buddying up to Vaimes both look strange.
Light Scumread:
Vaimes - For being the highest poster, not very useful posts. Almost overly friendly, kinda try-hard.
Strong Scumread:
Vote: Vaimes
This is wolfy.
I'm just going to come directly at this one how?
Also can we all stop with this dumb posting style of making attacks but not explaining them at all? This isn't MU.
Tom/GJ have already done this this game. You don't get to make vague statements that other people can then fill in their own thoughts to support. Its a bastard way of arguing and playing this game.
osie, none of your points make me scum. They’re either town-indicative for me or NAI. Why do my posts need to be useful during RVS?
You observed F&E so I have a pretty hard time believing your light scumread.
-
DV, where did you pull that dichotomy from?
That's fair. You were scummy as town in F&E too. It's still early. We'll see. I guess I just don't trust you right now. Like, I suppose it's not quite fair to say that you're not posting useful posts. I think my point would be expressed clearer as "At the moment, I think your posts have an air of being intentionally over-friendly and useless."
You don't trust him right now? Who, pray tell, do you trust right now? I get the trying to get ready early, from you at least, but saying you don't trust him is weird.
Tom why does it feel like you aren't having any fun right now? I don't recall you being this serious this early in a game before.
@Vezok Where do these statistics come from exactly?
if you keep expecting, legit answers from Tom, you will be solely disappointed...
Osie has a good strat for tom, "Scum read him until proven otherwise."
also I agree on GJ...
Vez, GJ, and Vaimes, seem like good focuses for now
DV Tom/GJ have already done this this game. You don't get to make vague statements that other people can then fill in their own thoughts to support. Its a bastard way of arguing and playing this game.
I agree, but I also tend to do this a lot as well, but thats mostly because im always afraid to push my leads
DV Tom/GJ have already done this this game. You don't get to make vague statements that other people can then fill in their own thoughts to support. Its a bastard way of arguing and playing this game.
I agree, but I also tend to do this a lot as well, but thats mostly because im always afraid to push my leads
Ehh
But things like what I quoted, or the "Osie is flailing" comment. Are attacks made on people with no actual backing. There is nothing explaining why they think that way and now they are expecting me to fill in the the blanks. Apparently asking for a sentence or two more of explanation is too much for the MU folks. Or we get golden posts like
Which literally say nothing at all while attempting to say something. Also I think Tom manged to pick three people who I either have neutral or slight scum reads on for the moment. So, I'm confused why he picked these three players. Nothing Kpaca has said so far seems to have any indication of his alignment. Vaimes is actually flailing, with the way he is attempting to defend himself. Tubba has one post? Sick "Town core" read.
if you keep expecting, legit answers from Tom, you will be solely disappointed...
Osie has a good strat for tom, "Scum read him until proven otherwise."
also I agree on GJ...
Vez, GJ, and Vaimes, seem like good focuses for now
Oh I'll also explain this now.
Both Osie and Vaimes tried to townie point/townie read me page one with the way I was posting.
Anak - Seems very comfortable coming back. I like his confidence and hope it lasts.
D_V - Mindmelding here on Vaimes. While he's not taking things super seriously, he's not over-relaxed. Slight town feels for now.
Null:
Grapefruit - Need to see more, especially explanation of his vote choice.
Kamikaze - Easy choice of vote, need to see more.
Lastwhisper - Need to see more. OMGUS is NAI or slight town for him.
Vezok - Again, need to see more. Kvetching about something offtopic is NAI. Choice of Rodemy could also go either way.
Absent:
Fuwa
Ganderin_dan
Tubba Fett
Scumlean:
GJ - I need to see more here, but so far he's just cozying up to people… Ehh.
kpaca - This has every possibility of going up or down, but so far kpaca feels stilted, and I'm not getting any of that fire between the lines from him.
Tom - Assume Tom is scum until he does something to make him town.
Wuffles - The Darth Vader gimmick doesn't do much… His vote and buddying up to Vaimes both look strange.
Light Scumread:
Vaimes - For being the highest poster, not very useful posts. Almost overly friendly, kinda try-hard.
Strong Scumread:
Vote: Vaimes
This is wolfy.
I'm just going to come directly at this one how?
Also can we all stop with this dumb posting style of making attacks but not explaining them at all? This isn't MU.
Tom/GJ have already done this this game. You don't get to make vague statements that other people can then fill in their own thoughts to support. Its a bastard way of arguing and playing this game.
My reads are tone based, because that's all you got 100 posts in.
As far as why I don't like osie, I don't believe his list in genuine. 54 posts in with more than half of them being ***** posts, and he is trying to seriously get a read on that? It reads like busy work trying to look like he is town doing some hunting. 4 nulls out of 15? I have like 8, and the rest of you with a straight face, tell me otherwise.
As far as my style, lynch me if you don't like it. I went 9+ months without playing, another few months won't kill me. Fleshed out reads come after day 1, because tone is the only ******* thing you have to go with on day 1 because you don't know T/W interactions.
Am I the only dark lord looking forward to seeing the famous Osie flailing this game?
*exhales loudly*
You're probabally not because either he or Vaimes are scum.
Vote: Vaimes
Nice start to the flail
You're a flail.
How is that flail?
@tom: Is that vote serious?
Also osie seems town here. Vaimes is yet to make a solid impression on me. kpaca is giving me some weird vibes.
Thanks to DNC at Heroes of the plane studios for this awesome sig and SGT_Chubbz for the awesome avy.
Check out the Shop Thread
And there are so many thing scum!Osie could be going for. Trying to look solvey, trying to form a narrative, trying to specifically appear eager as a town tell.
@Osie why go in depth on your neutral reads so early?
And for the record my vote explains itself.
Thanks to DNC at Heroes of the plane studios for this awesome sig and SGT_Chubbz for the awesome avy.
Check out the Shop Thread
"Hmm. The force is strong with this one. Said nobody ever.
*heavy breathing intensifies*
I've never played with Osie before. I literally only have his sig quotes to give me clues how he plays.
Hey that's not true, I got him in Megiddos Biceps mafia! Otherwise yeah this is true...
Osie I know that's a thing you do as town, but it still irks me to see a reads list that early.
Meesa been tinking yousa should bow to the true dark lord!
Can I just vote on the only person I like here atm?
Vote Grapefruit
I suppose I've just had a goal to see how early in a game I can solve it. Doesn't hurt that I've played with every player on this list except for Wuffles, and I've seen some of Wuffles' play too, as a host or spectator.
@Anak/Vezok but who's counting?
Vote: Osieorb
You don't have to abstain from RVS if you end it yourself
Megiddo's Biceps Mafia was a fantastic game.
Also...
Aww... That's not very nice.
Can we get some reasons or are you just going to throw that out there and try to Roll Safe on by like nobody is going to question you on it?
- He swears he's town, and I like him, so I'll believe him.
- Oww he votes for D_V, how cute.
- Can I keep you as a pet?
Osie is famous?
D_V
- I just like him personally
Lastwhisper
- Even if he's town, I want to lynch him.
- Why does Osie get a green name?
Vaimes
- sounds pockety
- also sounds shady in #24
Grapefruit
- If you're not Grape, I don't like you anymore. John Henry sounds like a mean person.
- Also I have a feeling you don't remember me.
I want to know too @Osie
Vezok
What kind of weird vibes?
.. also is there a rule on double posting here?
3 posts in a row maximum.
EBWODP: Oh, and nah, just on Live.
See #67. I tend to look for tells as soon as possible.
You observed F&E so I have a pretty hard time believing your light scumread.
-
DV, where did you pull that dichotomy from?
That's fair. You were scummy as town in F&E too. It's still early. We'll see. I guess I just don't trust you right now. Like, I suppose it's not quite fair to say that you're not posting useful posts. I think my point would be expressed clearer as "At the moment, I think your posts have an air of being intentionally over-friendly and useless."
I just went mobile so I’ll go into detail in a few hours.
Overly-friendly and try-hard, specifically.
I never understand why those things are off-putting to people, but given it’s not just you, all I can say is it’s a personality trait.
Do you feel that makes me scum or just wrong?
I think it has to do with looking for subtle tells, and since those can often be tells for people, it's a concern. I was called out for similar in Two Takes It when I really was scum.
Is this what you were looking for?
Stilted means you sound off from your usual happy, friendly self. Could just be coming back after a while of not playing.
Oh god I hope we don't lose entertaining kpaca.
Yeah, I'm gonna say you are scum and that at least one other person in the townblock is scum.
vote tomsloger
Statistically, the first person to suggest a townblock is scum. I'm restricted to phone posting this week so I can't provide examples, but I'll try when I have the time.
Thanks to DNC at Heroes of the plane studios for this awesome sig and SGT_Chubbz for the awesome avy.
Check out the Shop Thread
This is wolfy.
The GJ way path to no lynching:
The GJ way path to no lynching:
The GJ way path to no lynching:
Tom I expect a legitimate answer.
GJ is rubbing me the wrong way with that wolfy post now. Osie basically just manged to echo my entire thoughts in the game.
Vaimes not understanding the dichotomy is off putting.
I'm just going to come directly at this one how?
Also can we all stop with this dumb posting style of making attacks but not explaining them at all? This isn't MU.
Tom/GJ have already done this this game. You don't get to make vague statements that other people can then fill in their own thoughts to support. Its a bastard way of arguing and playing this game.
You don't trust him right now? Who, pray tell, do you trust right now? I get the trying to get ready early, from you at least, but saying you don't trust him is weird.
Tom why does it feel like you aren't having any fun right now? I don't recall you being this serious this early in a game before.
@Vezok Where do these statistics come from exactly?
what dichotomy?
if you keep expecting, legit answers from Tom, you will be solely disappointed...
Osie has a good strat for tom, "Scum read him until proven otherwise."
also I agree on GJ...
Vez, GJ, and Vaimes, seem like good focuses for now
Tom/GJ have already done this this game. You don't get to make vague statements that other people can then fill in their own thoughts to support. Its a bastard way of arguing and playing this game.
I agree, but I also tend to do this a lot as well, but thats mostly because im always afraid to push my leads
Ehh
But things like what I quoted, or the "Osie is flailing" comment. Are attacks made on people with no actual backing. There is nothing explaining why they think that way and now they are expecting me to fill in the the blanks. Apparently asking for a sentence or two more of explanation is too much for the MU folks. Or we get golden posts like
Which literally say nothing at all while attempting to say something. Also I think Tom manged to pick three people who I either have neutral or slight scum reads on for the moment. So, I'm confused why he picked these three players. Nothing Kpaca has said so far seems to have any indication of his alignment. Vaimes is actually flailing, with the way he is attempting to defend himself. Tubba has one post? Sick "Town core" read.
Oh I'll also explain this now.
Both Osie and Vaimes tried to townie point/townie read me page one with the way I was posting.
A lot of what you just said looks completely made up.
My reads are tone based, because that's all you got 100 posts in.
As far as why I don't like osie, I don't believe his list in genuine. 54 posts in with more than half of them being ***** posts, and he is trying to seriously get a read on that? It reads like busy work trying to look like he is town doing some hunting. 4 nulls out of 15? I have like 8, and the rest of you with a straight face, tell me otherwise.
As far as my style, lynch me if you don't like it. I went 9+ months without playing, another few months won't kill me. Fleshed out reads come after day 1, because tone is the only ******* thing you have to go with on day 1 because you don't know T/W interactions.
The GJ way path to no lynching: