You asked me a question and I cheekily answered it with my answer in question form. I'm not sure how that's WIFOM but you are more than welcome to clear it up for me.
But it's so simple. All I have to do is divine from what I know of you: Are you the sort of man who would put the poison into his... wait, hang on, just gonna drink that wine instead. By all means keep answering questions with stupid questions. I'm very thirsty, after all.
No, it was stupid because it was stupid. But sure, fish for town reasons I'll swallow (protip go for the white and salty ones). *****, I think I got the iocane powder drinking that wine, didn't I?
- Teia
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"This isn't the power of a Queen Succubus. It's just... mere violence."
There was once a hydra named homaridhoney
The Family did not think they were funny
"Please make it stop
or we'll give you the chop!"
But that argument is really quite crummy!
Horriblehumour, or whatever you are calling yourself this hour, I want you to answer me one thing.
Who is showing signs of being in the Mafia team and what are those signs?
Your flamingo clan was terrible in the last clan Mafia. I had to single handedly drag them across the finish line. If you are scum now I pity your team mate. Perhaps that's why they are standing out so easily to us, resignation and panic.
There was once a hydra named homaridhoney
The Family did not think they were funny
"Please make it stop
or we'll give you the chop!"
But that argument is really quite crummy!
Man, it sure is liberating posting under a hydra account.
Pretty sure Seppel is never scum. Vote Iso/Rhand/Generic because Generic is always scum.
Why did you make these three statements? Why is it liberating to post under a hydra account?
I really dislike PG's opening. Lots of bookkeeping, and has a nervous twinge regarding "who should I vote?"
Like Teia for following up on it and voting PG. Banter between Teia and Iso is whatever.
Yeah Wheat's posts here are not good. He reads as panicked when he votes Iso, and the stuff about the sig/avatar feels.. artificial? Like, he's mad over something that should be a non-issue.
Quote from Wheat »
@Iso: I mean, maybe it's because I'm his clanmate and I'm biased to know that he's town but PG's entrance felt genuine to me. He's got a few old games (as in, years old) that you could check out if you want to see how PG normally plays. If you're curious I can ask him since I don't remember which games they all were...Hayate maybe?
This all feels like unnecessary justification to me. I mean, you know that you're town - why do you need to look over your clanmates's posts and say "it's genuine"?
My biggest problem with Crafters at this point is that they're not really scumhunting - just a bunch of banter. The "let me show you all of PG's posts" thing is also indicative of a nervous scum mindset - I remember catching dan in Pleasantville Mafia for this.
----
Right now I want more people to post - there's only like four people playing. My only reads so far are that Crafters are scum, and that Teia's town. Unsure on Family thus far, and everyone else has made like 10 posts combined.
Unvote ; Vote: Crafters
Wheat/PG:
1. Who do you think is scum and why?
2. PG: If you think I'm scum, then why are you unvoting to prevent quickhammers?
3. Why did you want a claim at L-2, when this game is a smaller game?
I've decided to turn over main control of the hydra to PG
Before I go, I'll answer Proph's questions to me
1. Family, because they are reacting to this game as though it's already solved. In reality, I think they have down what they their townsona would believe and are ready to move forward. I also felt HH was scum due to, well, everything. I would be going with Family to start since I'd want to see if you were really scum or if HH was just really stupid and purposely trying to lose for his clan for some reason
3. Technically I wanted a claim at L-1 since I put intent to vote on HH, but even so I don't think game size affects claim time in general.
Wahaha... Well, if the game is in my hands, I have a good feeling that we're going to die because yeah... I like backseat piloting mafia in a hydra, but I actually hate playing and replaced out of my last game because of it. I would say that I do enjoy running games tho. THat was fun.
@Proph: Only 3 pages in, so I am not sure who can be scum because like you said there's only like half of the people posting. If I had to go with one read, I'd have to say I have a feeling Family is scum because this feels like scum Iso. And whenever I can be helpful, I am because I feel that everyone should follow the rules and adhere to how the game is played, which is what I think you mean by bookkeeping. And there wasn't a nervous twinge of 'who should I vote' it was a Vote Iso that I wanted to clarify could be interpreted as a Vote for Family if need be. For question 2, I don't think you're scum. I think Wheat was just really annoyed with HH as was most of the people voting for him. As for claiming at L-2, as far as I know claims are at L-2. If that's not standard for smaller games, then I'll keep that in mind for the future.
@Iso: You were saying that my entrance was awkward, but didn't really explain it as more than a gut feeling. So in my post with all my first posts I was demonstrating that all my entrances have been somewhat awkward and include Voting you whether you are actually playing or not. Looking back, it was Flamingo who was saying that Limited and Crafters look like scumbuddies, but was giving no reason (or any reasons for any of his actions), so I assumed the reason was that we both voted you and I reminded Limited to sign his post. Well, we all forget to sign our posts sometimes, so I was trying to put out a reminder to do so since it was still the first page (and my first post). Hell, last page both Jr and Figurative forgot to bold their votes, which you had to remind them of. So I don't know what the big deal is with being helpful.
And to respond to Iso's question after the unvote...
Nope. Just backseat mafia-ing with what I think should be standard mafia playing procedures. For more details from someone that actually likes playing mafia, please see Wheat. And yes, I am pretty angry about being saddled with this. I guess fair warning: I'm currently taking 3 summer school classes to graduate at the end of summer, so I may not be able to be the most active continuing forward as the workload picks up.
I guess apologies to Wheat for mucking up the game. I never intended to take over, so I kept my original post helpful and as you say irrelevant. What would you post in your first post that's relevant anyway?
I'm sure Wheat came in after my first post trying to clean up for me by explaining my actions which he couldn't because they weren't his actions. As for mindset, my mindset there was to come in, Vote Iso, then let Wheat take over. That didn't work too well.
As for scumIso, this feels like Unseen University vs Steins;Gate. Like you, I'm attributing it to gut feeling for now. I also didn't like your statement about following the current wagon. (Teia caught that) That sounds like scum mindset. For your analysis of Flamingo, considering HH was literally trolling us the whole time, I'd like to give Proph a chance since he actually knows what he's doing.
As for us peeing on ourselves, pretty much sums it up since there is dissonance within our hydra. Anyway, off to work, may not be back for some time cuz hw...
You made a really deep cut
And baby, now we've got bad blood, hey!
homaridhoney
Cool story, bro.
New!Flamingo is trying hard. Maybe being a tryhard. Thankfully I like watching men at work so with some time I can tell if you're, like, honest and ***** or not.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"This isn't the power of a Queen Succubus. It's just... mere violence."
Puddlejumper, Seppel, talk to me. You two have been playing Mafia longer than the three of us. What are you seeing, here? Flamingos + Crafters scumteam? Or are we missing something subtle?
Also, Puddlejumper, are you still not gonna tell us who you are?
~Iso
I'm not seeing how there's any case on Flamingo. I mean, he's annoying, but as far as mindset goes I think he's more on the ball than you are. I think it's more likely you're seeing him as lynchbait.
1. Family, because they are reacting to this game as though it's already solved. In reality, I think they have down what they their townsona would believe and are ready to move forward.
What does this actually all actually mean? The "reacting to this game as though its already been solved" isn't a scumtell and you have to give me specific evidence for the second part.
Quote from PG »
@Proph: Only 3 pages in, so I am not sure who can be scum because like you said there's only like half of the people posting. If I had to go with one read, I'd have to say I have a feeling Family is scum because this feels like scum Iso.
Can you substantiate that with anything more than gut?
Quote from Limited »
I'm not seeing how there's any case on Flamingo. I mean, he's annoying, but as far as mindset goes I think he's more on the ball than you are. I think it's more likely you're seeing him as lynchbait.
Can you answer my questions?
-proph (basically assume that every single post from now on is by me)
I'm not seeing how there's any case on Flamingo. I mean, he's annoying, but as far as mindset goes I think he's more on the ball than you are. I think it's more likely you're seeing him as lynchbait.
-Puddlejumper
I appreciate the many reasons you gave for this. It's wonderful to see such in-depth content in a game of Mafia.
- Teia
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"This isn't the power of a Queen Succubus. It's just... mere violence."
Trying to lynch people because they "aren't playing real mafia" is *the* textbook example of the lynchbait excuse. It's not really the sort of thing I need to go in depth on.
-Puddlejumper
I confirm the information Iso has presented. I'm aware we were playing in the game with a dishonest mindset, and I'm fine being lynched for it. I promise nothing of the sort will happen again, though (this incident is apparently escalating to the higher-ups, would rather have them not deal with more headaches).
Quote from Iso »
Given that information, Proph, I'm curious - why was there such dissonance within where to put your clan's vote?
I was the only one playing the game (pushing Crafters/Limited). Meg just copy and pasted "vote brigade" and made the infracting post. CC just trolled and did nothing. We had an agreement where I would ignore everything else and just play the game with those two hindering it.
Quote from Iso »
Additionally, can you explain your previous posts' views?
My posts were 13, 25, 39, 59, 77 and 81. If you look at my previous posts they are all consistent. Meg and CC were just trolling.
Quote from Iso »
Did you guys discuss this at all in your QT? Why did you all pretend to be HH and then pretend you hadn't been posting before (that one's specifically at you, Proph)?
We pretended to be HH to troll, and I pretended that I hadn't posted before because I didn't think OOG info would be brought into the thread and I wanted to start from a clean state.
Apologies to everyone for my clan being such a hassle. I did not expect it to blow up like this.
---
Hey, Limited, can you answer my question? Thanks!
Quote from CF »
Why did you make these three statements? (in your first post) Why is it liberating to post under a hydra account?
Puddlejumper, Seppel, talk to me. You two have been playing Mafia longer than the three of us. What are you seeing, here? Flamingos + Crafters scumteam? Or are we missing something subtle?
Also, Puddlejumper, are you still not gonna tell us who you are?
~Iso
The rope comment and the ensuing breakdown felt like town in retrospect.
Oops. He HAS played though
I'm not? I think Juliet sounds a little different but that's about all I'm thinking about with Juliet.
-WG
-WG
Unvote, Vote: Family
Your next line is, "OMGUS!"
-WG
Going where the momentum is, eh? That's certainly town-motivated behaviour if I ever saw it.
But it's so simple. All I have to do is divine from what I know of you: Are you the sort of man who would put the poison into his... wait, hang on, just gonna drink that wine instead. By all means keep answering questions with stupid questions. I'm very thirsty, after all.
lol
- Teia
"This isn't the power of a Queen Succubus. It's just... mere violence."
- Teia
"This isn't the power of a Queen Succubus. It's just... mere violence."
Vote Crafters
Lets get Biblical!!!!
Exodus 22:18 "A
witchWheat thou dost not keep alive"-Sepi
"This isn't the power of a Queen Succubus. It's just... mere violence."
I was wrooooooong!
-WG
First Post Unseen University.
First Post Steins; Gate
First Post Super Robot Battle Royale
First Post How To Train Your Dragon
-WG
more fake than limited
homatidhoney
i recommend you all barn me
-homanoidhomey
unvote vote crafters
homasidheoi'
That was my point
-WG
-
View User Profile
-
View Posts
-
Send Message
Non-Staff Quasi-ModAs of post #82
(5 to Lynch)
The Family (2) – Limited (7), Crafters (65)
Crafters (2) - MTGS Brigade (71), Clan Flamingo (81)
Clan Flamingo (1) - The Family (37)
Limited (1) - Gaymers (60)
Not Voting: Ronin, EDH, Masterless
EDH and Ronin have been prodded.
~ Jr
Modern
UBR Grixis Control
U Merfolk
Pauper
U Mono U Delver
Ancestral Visions is freed
The Family did not think they were funny
"Please make it stop
or we'll give you the chop!"
But that argument is really quite crummy!
-
View User Profile
-
View Posts
-
Send Message
Non-Staff Quasi-ModPlease bold your votes when voting.
And Figurative, please use the hydra-account provided to you.
PG always sounds awkward. I think it has to do with the ellipses and the Wahahas.
(I still love you, PG)
so uh, you planning on doing anything?
You're at L-2, otherwise I'd snap vote you.
Claim now.
And baby, now we've got bad blood, hey!
homaridhoney
I recommend you all barn me.
homaridhombre
I can count the number of times I've felt the need to nominate someone for the mafia blacklist on one finger. That finger is pointed at you.
Send a different representative next year.
-WG
I'm Aino, Town Vanilla. My flavor says that I was reborn as a fish - due to this I have no knowledge of magic.
Reading the game now, will be back with reads soon.
Prophylaxis
-PG
Why did you make these three statements? Why is it liberating to post under a hydra account?
I really dislike PG's opening. Lots of bookkeeping, and has a nervous twinge regarding "who should I vote?"
Like Teia for following up on it and voting PG. Banter between Teia and Iso is whatever.
Yeah Wheat's posts here are not good. He reads as panicked when he votes Iso, and the stuff about the sig/avatar feels.. artificial? Like, he's mad over something that should be a non-issue.
This all feels like unnecessary justification to me. I mean, you know that you're town - why do you need to look over your clanmates's posts and say "it's genuine"?
My biggest problem with Crafters at this point is that they're not really scumhunting - just a bunch of banter. The "let me show you all of PG's posts" thing is also indicative of a nervous scum mindset - I remember catching dan in Pleasantville Mafia for this.
----
Right now I want more people to post - there's only like four people playing. My only reads so far are that Crafters are scum, and that Teia's town. Unsure on Family thus far, and everyone else has made like 10 posts combined.
Unvote ; Vote: Crafters
Wheat/PG:
1. Who do you think is scum and why?
2. PG: If you think I'm scum, then why are you unvoting to prevent quickhammers?
3. Why did you want a claim at L-2, when this game is a smaller game?
Before I go, I'll answer Proph's questions to me
1. Family, because they are reacting to this game as though it's already solved. In reality, I think they have down what they their townsona would believe and are ready to move forward. I also felt HH was scum due to, well, everything. I would be going with Family to start since I'd want to see if you were really scum or if HH was just really stupid and purposely trying to lose for his clan for some reason
3. Technically I wanted a claim at L-1 since I put intent to vote on HH, but even so I don't think game size affects claim time in general.
-Wheat
I like Proph.
-
View User Profile
-
View Posts
-
Send Message
Non-Staff Quasi-ModAs of post #107
(5 to Lynch)
The Family (1) – Limited (7)
Crafters (3) - MTGS Brigade (71), Clan Flamingo (105), Masterless (107)
Clan Flamingo (1) - The Family (37)
Limited (1) - Gaymers (60)
Not Voting: Ronin, EDH, Crafters
As a reminder: Votes that aren't bolded are will be ignored.
@Proph: Only 3 pages in, so I am not sure who can be scum because like you said there's only like half of the people posting. If I had to go with one read, I'd have to say I have a feeling Family is scum because this feels like scum Iso. And whenever I can be helpful, I am because I feel that everyone should follow the rules and adhere to how the game is played, which is what I think you mean by bookkeeping. And there wasn't a nervous twinge of 'who should I vote' it was a Vote Iso that I wanted to clarify could be interpreted as a Vote for Family if need be. For question 2, I don't think you're scum. I think Wheat was just really annoyed with HH as was most of the people voting for him. As for claiming at L-2, as far as I know claims are at L-2. If that's not standard for smaller games, then I'll keep that in mind for the future.
@Iso: You were saying that my entrance was awkward, but didn't really explain it as more than a gut feeling. So in my post with all my first posts I was demonstrating that all my entrances have been somewhat awkward and include Voting you whether you are actually playing or not. Looking back, it was Flamingo who was saying that Limited and Crafters look like scumbuddies, but was giving no reason (or any reasons for any of his actions), so I assumed the reason was that we both voted you and I reminded Limited to sign his post. Well, we all forget to sign our posts sometimes, so I was trying to put out a reminder to do so since it was still the first page (and my first post). Hell, last page both Jr and Figurative forgot to bold their votes, which you had to remind them of. So I don't know what the big deal is with being helpful.
And to respond to Iso's question after the unvote...
Nope. Just backseat mafia-ing with what I think should be standard mafia playing procedures. For more details from someone that actually likes playing mafia, please see Wheat. And yes, I am pretty angry about being saddled with this. I guess fair warning: I'm currently taking 3 summer school classes to graduate at the end of summer, so I may not be able to be the most active continuing forward as the workload picks up.
-PG
I've already had enough of fighting through game after game of my own mistakes, I'm not about to fight through someone else's.
-WG
I'm sure Wheat came in after my first post trying to clean up for me by explaining my actions which he couldn't because they weren't his actions. As for mindset, my mindset there was to come in, Vote Iso, then let Wheat take over. That didn't work too well.
As for scumIso, this feels like Unseen University vs Steins;Gate. Like you, I'm attributing it to gut feeling for now. I also didn't like your statement about following the current wagon. (Teia caught that) That sounds like scum mindset. For your analysis of Flamingo, considering HH was literally trolling us the whole time, I'd like to give Proph a chance since he actually knows what he's doing.
As for us peeing on ourselves, pretty much sums it up since there is dissonance within our hydra. Anyway, off to work, may not be back for some time cuz hw...
-PG
Ms. Frizzle, is that you?
Cool story, bro.
New!Flamingo is trying hard. Maybe being a tryhard. Thankfully I like watching men at work so with some time I can tell if you're, like, honest and ***** or not.
"This isn't the power of a Queen Succubus. It's just... mere violence."
"This isn't the power of a Queen Succubus. It's just... mere violence."
-Sepi~desu!
"This isn't the power of a Queen Succubus. It's just... mere violence."
I'm not seeing how there's any case on Flamingo. I mean, he's annoying, but as far as mindset goes I think he's more on the ball than you are. I think it's more likely you're seeing him as lynchbait.
-Puddlejumper
Can you substantiate that with anything more than gut?
Can you answer my questions?
-proph (basically assume that every single post from now on is by me)
I appreciate the many reasons you gave for this. It's wonderful to see such in-depth content in a game of Mafia.
- Teia
"This isn't the power of a Queen Succubus. It's just... mere violence."
-Puddlejumper
-Puddlejumper
I was the only one playing the game (pushing Crafters/Limited). Meg just copy and pasted "vote brigade" and made the infracting post. CC just trolled and did nothing. We had an agreement where I would ignore everything else and just play the game with those two hindering it.
My posts were 13, 25, 39, 59, 77 and 81. If you look at my previous posts they are all consistent. Meg and CC were just trolling.
We pretended to be HH to troll, and I pretended that I hadn't posted before because I didn't think OOG info would be brought into the thread and I wanted to start from a clean state.
Apologies to everyone for my clan being such a hassle. I did not expect it to blow up like this.
---
Hey, Limited, can you answer my question? Thanks!
-proph
The rope comment and the ensuing breakdown felt like town in retrospect.
Iso(Family) says Brigade is town.
Flamingo and Family are not scum together.
If those are all town (just assuming), then that leaves Gaymers, Crafters, Limited, Spirit, and Ronin.
And that's almost autowin.
Maybe I should read some.