Where's my bowtie? I was wearing a bowtie, right? And what happened to my hands? They were here just a second ago... are these hooves? How am I supposed to pick up anything with hooves?
AND WHY IS THE ONLY THING TO EAT AROUND HERE PEARS!? I HATE PEARS!
I am starting to believe this being Battlestar Galactica Mafia was just an elaborate hoax to get all the doctors together in one place. Nyxu are you The Master?
Joke posts. ScumGuardman likes to open with joke posts.
Seppel gets a gold star (and +1 Caexpoint) for coming to the exact same conclusion I did about Guardman.
I read pretty much all of Guardman's games. When he's scum he tends to open with multiple jokes. When he's town, he doesn't post for a while then comments on the current situation with a srspost. The more jokes, the more likely Guardman is to be scum.
Everything scares me... kitties scare me... squirrels scare me... corpses....corpses bring forth a pletora of confusing feeling which i prefer not to dwell on...:p
Where's my bowtie? I was wearing a bowtie, right? And what happened to my hands? They were here just a second ago... are these hooves? How am I supposed to pick up anything with hooves?
AND WHY IS THE ONLY THING TO EAT AROUND HERE PEARS!? I HATE PEARS!
I am starting to believe this being Battlestar Galactica Mafia was just an elaborate hoax to get all the doctors together in one place. Nyxu are you The Master?
Joke posts. ScumGuardman likes to open with joke posts.
EBWODP: @LnGrrrR: OGI stands for Ongoing Game Info.
Guardman incorrectly defines OGI. But this is where we start connecting the dots of the multiverse.
1) Seppel says there's "OGI" going on in the thread. Lists two townreads and a scumread.
2) Guardman sees the post, and becomes only concerned about himself as the scumread.
3) Guardman thinks that I'm pulling info from an ongoing game to explain why he's scum????
The leap of logic here is ridiculous! It's obvious that he's coming from a guilty mindset. He's creating reasons for his guilt and trying to defend against them!
It sounds like you are twisting facts to your favor actually...
Then by all means, please explain Guardman's logic to me and tell me that it's a town mindset.
It's just weird how you and Generic suddenly attacked him for nothing other than some offhand comments that you are suddenly trying to psycoanalyze into "HE'S MAFIA!" Sounds like you are just trying to throw the town towards lynching their own. WHICH IS WHY YOU ARE ON MY WATCH LIST.
Also the fact you point out that he incorrectly defined OGI makes no sense. Why does that even matter? You use it as an argument, but it has nothing to do with anything. Just seems like you are using it to lure people in. it's like saying, 'THAT MAN DOESN'T LOVE CHOCOLATE ICE CREAM" to a bunch of chocolate ice cream lovers.
Your arguments don't seem too valid.
Your reasoning for a Scum gaurdsmen is the fact his first post was a joke. What about other people? they all posted jokes too.. but you single out Gaurdsmen from the bat because ONE person had some doubt. Seems to me like you are trying to play on that doubt and side with generic because you two are on the same team.
I find it funny you didn't try and argue for why i am voting against you. I also find it funny that you are more focused on pinning Gaurdsmen than you are saving your own ass... which by the way is on the line still..
Nope. Stickin with you and goin with Generic as scum as well
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Thank you for choosing
Rodemy Pizza
It’s not the best choice, but it’s a choice nonetheless
Where's my bowtie? I was wearing a bowtie, right? And what happened to my hands? They were here just a second ago... are these hooves? How am I supposed to pick up anything with hooves?
AND WHY IS THE ONLY THING TO EAT AROUND HERE PEARS!? I HATE PEARS!
I am starting to believe this being Battlestar Galactica Mafia was just an elaborate hoax to get all the doctors together in one place. Nyxu are you The Master?
Joke posts. ScumGuardman likes to open with joke posts.
EBWODP: @LnGrrrR: OGI stands for Ongoing Game Info.
Guardman incorrectly defines OGI. But this is where we start connecting the dots of the multiverse.
1) Seppel says there's "OGI" going on in the thread. Lists two townreads and a scumread.
2) Guardman sees the post, and becomes only concerned about himself as the scumread.
3) Guardman thinks that I'm pulling info from an ongoing game to explain why he's scum????
The leap of logic here is ridiculous! It's obvious that he's coming from a guilty mindset. He's creating reasons for his guilt and trying to defend against them!
It sounds like you are twisting facts to your favor actually...
Then by all means, please explain Guardman's logic to me and tell me that it's a town mindset.
It's just weird how you and Generic suddenly attacked him for nothing other than some offhand comments that you are suddenly trying to psycoanalyze into "HE'S MAFIA!" Sounds like you are just trying to throw the town towards lynching their own. WHICH IS WHY YOU ARE ON MY WATCH LIST.
Also the fact you point out that he incorrectly defined OGI makes no sense. Why does that even matter? You use it as an argument, but it has nothing to do with anything. Just seems like you are using it to lure people in. it's like saying, 'THAT MAN DOESN'T LOVE CHOCOLATE ICE CREAM" to a bunch of chocolate ice cream lovers.
Your arguments don't seem too valid.
Your reasoning for a Scum gaurdsmen is the fact his first post was a joke. What about other people? they all posted jokes too.. but you single out Gaurdsmen from the bat because ONE person had some doubt. Seems to me like you are trying to play on that doubt and side with generic because you two are on the same team.
I find it funny you didn't try and argue for why i am voting against you. I also find it funny that you are more focused on pinning Gaurdsmen than you are saving your own ass... which by the way is on the line still..
Nope. Stickin with you and goin with Generic as scum as well
What page did you start reading the game at?
I suddenly attacked guardman? Seriously?
I was just looking through your posts to see where you had sided with Seppel when you comment came up on the PEDIT.
I think he's talking about post 120, where you ask him why he didn't include Guardman on his list, and post 132, where you stated that Guardman was ignoring reads, but I certainly wouldn't call either of those posts an "attack".
@Rodemy, can you explain why you thought Seppel was siding with Generic, and not say, Caex, who actually did call Guardsman scum?
I was just looking through your posts to see where you had sided with Seppel when you comment came up on the PEDIT.
I think he's talking about post 120, where you ask him why he didn't include Guardman on his list, and post 132, where you stated that Guardman was ignoring reads, but I certainly wouldn't call either of those posts an "attack".
@Rodemy, can you explain why you thought Seppel was siding with Generic, and not say, Caex, who actually did call Guardsman scum?
at answering other people's questions.
Also, he is Guardman, not Guardsman. This is (Green) Guardsman.
Where's my bowtie? I was wearing a bowtie, right? And what happened to my hands? They were here just a second ago... are these hooves? How am I supposed to pick up anything with hooves?
AND WHY IS THE ONLY THING TO EAT AROUND HERE PEARS!? I HATE PEARS!
I am starting to believe this being Battlestar Galactica Mafia was just an elaborate hoax to get all the doctors together in one place. Nyxu are you The Master?
Joke posts. ScumGuardman likes to open with joke posts.
EBWODP: @LnGrrrR: OGI stands for Ongoing Game Info.
Guardman incorrectly defines OGI. But this is where we start connecting the dots of the multiverse.
1) Seppel says there's "OGI" going on in the thread. Lists two townreads and a scumread.
2) Guardman sees the post, and becomes only concerned about himself as the scumread.
3) Guardman thinks that I'm pulling info from an ongoing game to explain why he's scum????
The leap of logic here is ridiculous! It's obvious that he's coming from a guilty mindset. He's creating reasons for his guilt and trying to defend against them!
I can walk you through my thought process and how it isn't scummy at all.
When I saw your post calling me scum and saw OGI, I thought it meant ongoing game info. This lead me to realize both of my posts so far this game have been joke posts. And given that I have recently shifted to a more fun posting style for myself which really came to ahead recently when I decided in Ongoing Game to just have a lot more fun in my posts. Given my flip in Ongoing Game, the fact I had only done RVS joke posts, the fact you said OGI (which I read as Ongoing Game Info), and the fact you called me scum made me think (correctly I might add) that you interpreted my The Doctors posts as indicative of scum me, which I wanted to refute, but since much of it related to Ongoing Game I decided to mention it, but not confront you on it because of respect of the Ongoing Game Rule. But because of circumstances I feel I have to push that rule a bit here. Anyways I decided to push to a more fun style because before Ongoing Game I had started to feel burned out and pressured in games. You could see it in some of the games I played that I was just off and not having fun. Realizing that I decided that I am at my best when I am having fun and have made a conscious shift towards having fun in games rather than being a try hard.
Caex: I can point you to several games where I joke throughout the RVS as town: Such as Clue Mafia and Kitteh Trek (links to the games can be found in my sig). Those games are also two of my stronger games as I enjoyed myself in them, which is the reason I made this shift.
It's just weird how you and Generic suddenly attacked him for nothing other than some offhand comments that you are suddenly trying to psycoanalyze into "HE'S MAFIA!" Sounds like you are just trying to throw the town towards lynching their own. WHICH IS WHY YOU ARE ON MY WATCH LIST.
When you get good at the game, you'll learn how to catch scum.
Also the fact you point out that he incorrectly defined OGI makes no sense. Why does that even matter? You use it as an argument, but it has nothing to do with anything.
The language of my sentence doesn't match his definition! I said there was OGI IN THE THREAD and he thinks I'm talking about some other game entirely! How can you reconcile that?
Your reasoning for a Scum gaurdsmen is the fact his first post was a joke. What about other people? they all posted jokes too.. but you single out Gaurdsmen from the bat because ONE person had some doubt. Seems to me like you are trying to play on that doubt and side with generic because you two are on the same team.
scumGuardman usually opens with jokes. I have no care for any other player's opening with jokes, since they are irrelevant to Guardman's alignment.
I find it funny you didn't try and argue for why i am voting against you. I also find it funny that you are more focused on pinning Gaurdsmen than you are saving your own ass... which by the way is on the line still.
Your reasons for voting me are stupid and I'm mostly going to be ignoring you until you get better at the game. You're behaving in a typical newbie fashion, voting because someone is "suspicious" or "weird." You are a guppy in a pool of sharks. You're supposed to learn from the sharks, not provoke them.
Also, he is Guardman, not Guardsman. This is (Green) Guardsman.
Fair enough. I wanted the answer to the question too, which is why I asked why he assumed Seppel was siding with Generic.
I read Generics question as more rhetorical than actual, which is why I asked Rodemy more directly.
Fair enough. I guess I should clarify that I'm all for others providing their thoughts on a question, but it should always be after the person who the question was directed at has a chance to answer. Otherwise, you're undermining the point of the question, since the person doesn't have to htink of their own reasoning (if, say, they are scum and may not have their own reasoning).
Could you guys provide some examples of other games he's been in where he started like this?
Ged's Normal he was Hitman who had to kill townies to win.
Kaizers Mafia.
Manipulator Mafia.
Annorax's Bastard Mod.
Indiana Jones and the Oracle's Secret.
Ghost Town.
Persona.
Smalltown Animaniacs.
Star Trek Myriad Universes II.
Angel mafia is an aberration in the trend, in that Guardman srsposted immediately.
...Damn, Guardman is scum a lot.
Quote from Guardman »
Caex: I can point you to several games where I joke throughout the RVS as town: Such as Clue Mafia and Kitteh Trek (links to the games can be found in my sig). Those games are also two of my stronger games as I enjoyed myself in them, which is the reason I made this shift
I can point to nine where you joke throughout the RVS as scum.
Everything scares me... kitties scare me... squirrels scare me... corpses....corpses bring forth a pletora of confusing feeling which i prefer not to dwell on...:p
Clue Mafia: Town, not jokey. Ged's Normal: Neutral, jokey. Kitteh Trek: Town, not jokey, but posted in all lolcats. (actually quite seriously) Magical Girls: Town, one joke after a random vote. Symbiote: Town, not jokey. TMS2: Town, not jokey.
There's six. It's hard to find scumgames when you have your games sorted in alphabetical order instead of some useful order.
Everything scares me... kitties scare me... squirrels scare me... corpses....corpses bring forth a pletora of confusing feeling which i prefer not to dwell on...:p
Seppel's "meaning of OGI" case against Guardman is really stretching it (ongoing game info is the more common use of that acronym). I do realize it is more likely that Guard jokes when he's scum, but I don't think meta should ever be the only thing to go on. Guard's posts since he stopped joking have been pretty good. While I disagree with Seppel, he isn't necessarily in a scum mindset because of it.
The first post contains a vote, and the second one is more serious than it seems. Only then do we get a third, jokey post.
The first post contains a joke vote and a joke. The second is somewhat serious, and mostly in the fact that it's true. But this is in response to an actual question, which is something completely different. The third post is completely jokey.
At this point though you are just being nitpicky to support your opinion and nothing I say I think will really change your opinion on this.
Seppel's "meaning of OGI" case against Guardman is really stretching it (ongoing game info is the more common use of that acronym). I do realize it is more likely that Guard jokes when he's scum, but I don't think meta should ever be the only thing to go on. Guard's posts since he stopped joking have been pretty good. While I disagree with Seppel, he isn't necessarily in a scum mindset because of it.
I'm feeling good about Rodemy now.
Cythare isn't acting normally. One to watch.
Generic is being scummy.
unvote
Vote: Generic
You couldn't wait for that opportunity could ya sir karn
Ok, I will play, what's your case against me this time Karny?
To clarify, this seems like a subtle and noncommittal way to plant that you think I'm scum without much supporting info. Have you read my past games?
I have read some of your past games.
That makes more sense then.
I strive to act differently in each game I play whenever possible, regardless of alignment (cue Iso's "YOU CAN'T META ME" :swear:). Helps keep things interesting.
This thread is moving rather quickly. I keep seeing things I want to say already said in the PEDITS.
@Karn, when you get the chance, what makes you feel good about Rodemy? I thought his tying of Generic to Seppel felt pretty forced/scummy, plus he seemed a little defensive when I voted him in RVS.
To clarify, this seems like a subtle and noncommittal way to plant that you think I'm scum without much supporting info. Have you read my past games?
I have read some of your past games.
That makes more sense then.
I strive to act differently in each game I play whenever possible, regardless of alignment (cue Iso's "YOU CAN'T META ME" :swear:). Helps keep things interesting.
This thread is moving rather quickly. I keep seeing things I want to say already said in the PEDITS.
@Karn, when you get the chance, what makes you feel good about Rodemy? I thought his tying of Generic to Seppel felt pretty forced/scummy, plus he seemed a little defensive when I voted him in RVS.
I didn't feel it was forced/scummy. In fact most of it I liked.
He was a little weird in rvs (hell, I thought he scumslipped first post) but it got explained, and Iso got modkilled for it.
This thread is moving rather quickly. I keep seeing things I want to say already said in the PEDITS.
@Karn, when you get the chance, what makes you feel good about Rodemy? I thought his tying of Generic to Seppel felt pretty forced/scummy, plus he seemed a little defensive when I voted him in RVS.
I didn't feel it was forced/scummy. In fact most of it I liked.
He was a little weird in rvs (hell, I thought he scumslipped first post) but it got explained, and Iso got modkilled for it.
I cannot disable the currently-active ticker at the bottom of this thread, try as I might.
Nor can I require everyone to set themselves invisible.
But for the love of toast stop using that out-of-game info.
EBWOP: Oh and yeah, Hansanator should probably stop lurking. Or at least make himself invisible if he's going to blatantly lurk.
Yea, he did that for hours last night
Sorry, I'll try to not lurk so much anymore.
I don't really have any important input to make as I have just been reading past posts trying to get a read on people. I'm not able to base accusations on people's typical scummy play-styles as this is my first time playing with any of you.
But yes, lurk less I shall.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"I'm a compulsive liar no matter what team I play on, but I'm trying to get better about it."
@Nyxu, sorry about that. I didn't realize that was out-of-bounds info.
@Hanson,
Thanks for posting! A few questions:
1) Have you played mafia on other sites? In real life?
2) Have you read other mafia games for the players in this game?
3) Do you have any reads at all? I don't need a full T/S list, but even a "X and Y player seem town, Z player seems scum" would at least give us some idea that you're actually forming your own ideas about the thread.
EBWOP: Oh and yeah, Hansanator should probably stop lurking. Or at least make himself invisible if he's going to blatantly lurk.
Yea, he did that for hours last night
Sorry, I'll try to not lurk so much anymore.
I don't really have any important input to make as I have just been reading past posts trying to get a read on people. I'm not able to base accusations on people's typical scummy play-styles as this is my first time playing with any of you.
But yes, lurk less I shall.
You don't have to metagame to get reads.
Here's a question: How do you feel about the current wagons?
1. Yes, I used to play forum mafia last year on a site called RockBandOutcasts. I played real life mafia at camp a few times, but that was years ago.
2. Other than the few excerpts of guardman's joke posts that were quoted earlier, I haven't read any previous games.
3. I have nothing concrete this early in the game. Despite my tenuous gut feeling that Asenion is scum, I think that Seppel's assault on Guardman is the closest thing, IMO, that we have to a lead; therefore, I will maintain my vote for the time being. Even if Seppel is wrong, I think that he is genuine in his opinion. To me, LnGrrrR seems pretty town because each post/question appears to be critically analyzing situations instead of mindlessly hopping on bandwagons. I'm feeling somewhat apathetic towards rodemy and generic and don't yet know what to think.
Like I said earlier, nothing is concrete and my reads will (hopefully) develop overtime.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"I'm a compulsive liar no matter what team I play on, but I'm trying to get better about it."
Seppel gets a gold star (and +1 Caexpoint) for coming to the exact same conclusion I did about Guardman.
I read pretty much all of Guardman's games. When he's scum he tends to open with multiple jokes. When he's town, he doesn't post for a while then comments on the current situation with a srspost. The more jokes, the more likely Guardman is to be scum.
Vote Guardman
{Magic: The RPG}
It's just weird how you and Generic suddenly attacked him for nothing other than some offhand comments that you are suddenly trying to psycoanalyze into "HE'S MAFIA!" Sounds like you are just trying to throw the town towards lynching their own. WHICH IS WHY YOU ARE ON MY WATCH LIST.
Also the fact you point out that he incorrectly defined OGI makes no sense. Why does that even matter? You use it as an argument, but it has nothing to do with anything. Just seems like you are using it to lure people in. it's like saying, 'THAT MAN DOESN'T LOVE CHOCOLATE ICE CREAM" to a bunch of chocolate ice cream lovers.
Your arguments don't seem too valid.
Your reasoning for a Scum gaurdsmen is the fact his first post was a joke. What about other people? they all posted jokes too.. but you single out Gaurdsmen from the bat because ONE person had some doubt. Seems to me like you are trying to play on that doubt and side with generic because you two are on the same team.
I find it funny you didn't try and argue for why i am voting against you. I also find it funny that you are more focused on pinning Gaurdsmen than you are saving your own ass... which by the way is on the line still..
Nope. Stickin with you and goin with Generic as scum as well
Could you guys provide some examples of other games he's been in where he started like this?
Club Flamingo Wins: 1!
I was just looking through your posts to see where you had sided with Seppel when you comment came up on the PEDIT.
I think he's talking about post 120, where you ask him why he didn't include Guardman on his list, and post 132, where you stated that Guardman was ignoring reads, but I certainly wouldn't call either of those posts an "attack".
@Rodemy, can you explain why you thought Seppel was siding with Generic, and not say, Caex, who actually did call Guardsman scum?
Club Flamingo Wins: 1!
at answering other people's questions.
Also, he is Guardman, not Guardsman. This is (Green) Guardsman.
Draft my cube! (630 cards)
I can walk you through my thought process and how it isn't scummy at all.
When I saw your post calling me scum and saw OGI, I thought it meant ongoing game info. This lead me to realize both of my posts so far this game have been joke posts. And given that I have recently shifted to a more fun posting style for myself which really came to ahead recently when I decided in Ongoing Game to just have a lot more fun in my posts. Given my flip in Ongoing Game, the fact I had only done RVS joke posts, the fact you said OGI (which I read as Ongoing Game Info), and the fact you called me scum made me think (correctly I might add) that you interpreted my The Doctors posts as indicative of scum me, which I wanted to refute, but since much of it related to Ongoing Game I decided to mention it, but not confront you on it because of respect of the Ongoing Game Rule. But because of circumstances I feel I have to push that rule a bit here. Anyways I decided to push to a more fun style because before Ongoing Game I had started to feel burned out and pressured in games. You could see it in some of the games I played that I was just off and not having fun. Realizing that I decided that I am at my best when I am having fun and have made a conscious shift towards having fun in games rather than being a try hard.
Caex: I can point you to several games where I joke throughout the RVS as town: Such as Clue Mafia and Kitteh Trek (links to the games can be found in my sig). Those games are also two of my stronger games as I enjoyed myself in them, which is the reason I made this shift.
When you get good at the game, you'll learn how to catch scum.
The language of my sentence doesn't match his definition! I said there was OGI IN THE THREAD and he thinks I'm talking about some other game entirely! How can you reconcile that?
scumGuardman usually opens with jokes. I have no care for any other player's opening with jokes, since they are irrelevant to Guardman's alignment.
Your reasons for voting me are stupid and I'm mostly going to be ignoring you until you get better at the game. You're behaving in a typical newbie fashion, voting because someone is "suspicious" or "weird." You are a guppy in a pool of sharks. You're supposed to learn from the sharks, not provoke them.
You trying to defend Gman and your rationalization of actions seems forced. I don't understand what you were trying to accomplish with that post.
Question: If Seppel does get a quick lynch on Gman and he flips town, how will that reflect on him? Why would he try to do this as scum?
I don't see scum motive in Seppel's actions and theory. I believe that he believes it, I'm still not convinced.
Outdated Mafia Stats
Fair enough. I wanted the answer to the question too, which is why I asked why he assumed Seppel was siding with Generic.
I read Generics question as more rhetorical than actual, which is why I asked Rodemy more directly.
Club Flamingo Wins: 1!
Fair enough. I guess I should clarify that I'm all for others providing their thoughts on a question, but it should always be after the person who the question was directed at has a chance to answer. Otherwise, you're undermining the point of the question, since the person doesn't have to htink of their own reasoning (if, say, they are scum and may not have their own reasoning).
Draft my cube! (630 cards)
Kaizers Mafia.
Manipulator Mafia.
Annorax's Bastard Mod.
Indiana Jones and the Oracle's Secret.
Ghost Town.
Persona.
Smalltown Animaniacs.
Star Trek Myriad Universes II.
Angel mafia is an aberration in the trend, in that Guardman srsposted immediately.
...Damn, Guardman is scum a lot.
I can point to nine where you joke throughout the RVS as scum.
{Magic: The RPG}
Ged's Normal: Neutral, jokey.
Kitteh Trek: Town, not jokey, but posted in all lolcats. (actually quite seriously)
Magical Girls: Town, one joke after a random vote.
Symbiote: Town, not jokey.
TMS2: Town, not jokey.
There's six. It's hard to find scumgames when you have your games sorted in alphabetical order instead of some useful order.
Animaniacs is unusual in that we picked our roles in the thread. I don't think it's a good example.
Clue Mafia: Here are my first three posts from Clue.
I think that qualifies as jokey.
I do my best when I am jokey regardless of alignment as my strongest games are all jokey, and is not overly indicative of my alignment.
Except when you claim unblockable undoccable cop, obviously.
{Magic: The RPG}
We picked roles before we were assigned alignments.
Seppel's "meaning of OGI" case against Guardman is really stretching it (ongoing game info is the more common use of that acronym). I do realize it is more likely that Guard jokes when he's scum, but I don't think meta should ever be the only thing to go on. Guard's posts since he stopped joking have been pretty good. While I disagree with Seppel, he isn't necessarily in a scum mindset because of it.
I'm feeling good about Rodemy now.
Cythare isn't acting normally. One to watch.
Generic is being scummy.
unvote
Vote: Generic
The first post contains a joke vote and a joke. The second is somewhat serious, and mostly in the fact that it's true. But this is in response to an actual question, which is something completely different. The third post is completely jokey.
At this point though you are just being nitpicky to support your opinion and nothing I say I think will really change your opinion on this.
You just missed my vote on Generic
OOC, how are you defining "normally"? We've played together in one game that is currently ongoing.
Draft my cube! (630 cards)
To clarify, this seems like a subtle and noncommittal way to plant that you think I'm scum without much supporting info. Have you read my past games?
Draft my cube! (630 cards)
Outdated Mafia Stats
I have read some of your past games.
I don't work with the carnival, I ain't no Karny.
I'll give you a case later, I'm on my phone now.
Disregard previous votecount.
That makes more sense then.
I strive to act differently in each game I play whenever possible, regardless of alignment (cue Iso's "YOU CAN'T META ME" :swear:). Helps keep things interesting.
Draft my cube! (630 cards)
@Karn, when you get the chance, what makes you feel good about Rodemy? I thought his tying of Generic to Seppel felt pretty forced/scummy, plus he seemed a little defensive when I voted him in RVS.
Club Flamingo Wins: 1!
Understandable.
Club Flamingo Wins: 1!
/Barn
Outdated Mafia Stats
I didn't feel it was forced/scummy. In fact most of it I liked.
He was a little weird in rvs (hell, I thought he scumslipped first post) but it got explained, and Iso got modkilled for it.
Yea, he did that for hours last night
"modkilled"
Draft my cube! (630 cards)
I cannot disable the currently-active ticker at the bottom of this thread, try as I might.
Nor can I require everyone to set themselves invisible.
But for the love of toast stop using that out-of-game info.
Sorry, I'll try to not lurk so much anymore.
I don't really have any important input to make as I have just been reading past posts trying to get a read on people. I'm not able to base accusations on people's typical scummy play-styles as this is my first time playing with any of you.
But yes, lurk less I shall.
Previous Mafia Experience:
Mafia aligned: 2/0 -100%
Town aligned: 4/3 - 57%
@Hanson,
Thanks for posting! A few questions:
1) Have you played mafia on other sites? In real life?
2) Have you read other mafia games for the players in this game?
3) Do you have any reads at all? I don't need a full T/S list, but even a "X and Y player seem town, Z player seems scum" would at least give us some idea that you're actually forming your own ideas about the thread.
Club Flamingo Wins: 1!
Since you've been trying to get a read, can you give me your gut reaction on 1 town and 1 scum?
Outdated Mafia Stats
Outdated Mafia Stats
You don't have to metagame to get reads.
Here's a question: How do you feel about the current wagons?
/barn lngrrr's questions.
Club Flamingo Wins: 1!
Previous Mafia Experience:
Mafia aligned: 2/0 -100%
Town aligned: 4/3 - 57%
This post above is awful.
All this has happened before. All this will happen again
Outdated Mafia Stats
2. Other than the few excerpts of guardman's joke posts that were quoted earlier, I haven't read any previous games.
3. I have nothing concrete this early in the game. Despite my tenuous gut feeling that Asenion is scum, I think that Seppel's assault on Guardman is the closest thing, IMO, that we have to a lead; therefore, I will maintain my vote for the time being. Even if Seppel is wrong, I think that he is genuine in his opinion. To me, LnGrrrR seems pretty town because each post/question appears to be critically analyzing situations instead of mindlessly hopping on bandwagons. I'm feeling somewhat apathetic towards rodemy and generic and don't yet know what to think.
Like I said earlier, nothing is concrete and my reads will (hopefully) develop overtime.
Previous Mafia Experience:
Mafia aligned: 2/0 -100%
Town aligned: 4/3 - 57%
Outdated Mafia Stats