MTG Salvation

You calm your tits, too, Bolly. You're both town. Stop pissing at each other.

Quote from Bolly

Excuse me, when did I say I was trying to get him to quote it? And how have I quoted mine? It's a close paraphrase. I've tried to pull this trick in a couple of other games on other forums where the win conditions are not provided in the first post (like in this game), and it actually caught scum on one occasion. I wasn't trying to get anyone modkilled.

Well stop playing underhanded and I'll trust you again. Until then, you're on my **** list.

At this point I'm considering requesting out. If you we are gonna play that way, I don't want any part of it.

Quote from Bolly

I really won't do anything like that again, and I'm sorry for trying it in the first place.

I'll accept the apology.

Unvote

Kay, now that that's out of the way, talk to me.

Okay, now that's over, some content.

As per my ability phrase...

If Pinky "doesn't even go here (North Shore)" she will be killed.

If Pinky does, nothing will occur.

Arnnaria, can you confirm through the mod that characters who do not go to our school are in the game?

ced, why Eron?

Please do, Bolly.

Miracule has requested replacement from this game. I have asked the people on the replace list please continue and I will let you know when a replacement has been found.

Vote Miracule

Overwhelmed noob scum.

Quote from Iso

Arnnaria, can you confirm through the mod that characters who do not go to our school are in the game?

Um, I don't know why I would even be able to ask that. It has nothing to do with my role, and the mod has been very specific about my wordings.

I can tell you what I can do. I suppose I could come up with a list of paraphrases that WEREN'T acceptable. But I don't know if that's considered PM quoting...

...wow. Did you just claim scum?

@Bolly.

Oh. Okay, that works.

Arnnaria, if your ability exclusively kills people that do not go to the school, I am inclined to believe that is the scum.

Anyone want to make this an autotown win with a mass character claim?

I dunno. Let's find out.

I want ced to give input on the character claim, though.

I hate massclaims, except in a few situations - LyoL is one of those I accept it, and in fact, encourage it, in.

And no, I'm counting you as "going to the school" unless I have a reason to believe otherwise, Bolly.

What if the scum have aliases?

This game takes place AFTER the movie. What if the character has graduated? Been expelled?

I'm not so sure this is a sure fire win.

Do you see any harm in the claim, though? If the scum have falseclaims, then at least we'll know to scrutinize claims more carefully when someone is put at L-2.

Quote from Iso

Do you see any harm in the claim, though? If the scum have falseclaims, then at least we'll know to scrutinize claims more carefully when someone is put at L-2.

I'm for it, but there are some pretty tricky loopholes (graduation, expulsion, etc.) that could make this very tricky.

Can you guys wait for the soft claim until I hear a response from the mod if I can post the paraphrases that were not acceptable?

That's a silly question - of course you can't post something the mod wouldn't allow you to post.

Quote from Arnnaria

I'm for it, but there are some pretty tricky loopholes (graduation, expulsion, etc.) that could make this very tricky.

Can you guys wait for the soft claim until I hear a response from the mod if I can post the paraphrases that were not acceptable?

Okay, the mod has given me permission to post one, and only one, mis-paraphrase. Let me pull it up.

I'm fine with claiming first, since it was my idea.

I'm Aaron Samuels.

Popcorn, next poster.

Damien, Too Gay to Function

Mis-Paraphrase:

If Pinky is town, it'll be like nothing ever happened.

Quote from MzztrTetris

Cady Heron/Sandra Olssen (Don't ask, I have no clue.)

Lol...

Cady goes to North Shore. I have no clue who Sandra is.

Vote MzztrTetris

Wow.

We just broke the game, then.

Thank you for being trigger happy, Arnnaria.

Yo Arnn don't vote yet.

Quote from Iso

Yo Arnn don't vote yet.

Yeah, I just screwed the pooch, didn't I?

What ced said.

Arnnaria, unvote.

We'll discuss after the name claim.

Quote from MzztrTetris

No, let me explain, based on my flavor, I believe that Blue has created some sort of alternate storyline that dates before the movie.

Arnaria, in the movie, where was Cady from, and was she homeschooled?

Her mother was doing anthropology work in Africa. Yes, she was homeschooled.

Unvote

Quote from Bolly

Oooooh, this spices things up. There was a Sandy Olsson in the movie Grease...I wonder if that's got anything to do with it. You guys need to trust me with my claim big time, okay?

I did research on this, too. This was the only information on it I could find - and there is no tie to Mean Girls.

Again, let's halt discussion until everyone nameclaims.

Um, I think everyone with a non-Mean Girls alias might be scum.

Quote from Bolly

The fact that I am Town means that you cannot be correct.

This is what happens when you flavour-game.

Wasn't my idea, go yell at Iso.

No, really. Stop waving your dicks at each other and wait for everyone to claim.

Please.



Also, tezz, second link didn't work.

Err, *second link under your name didn't work

Yeah, hold the phone here. The scum are the only ones who have reason to be worried or confused about whether their names might give them away. Discussing the implications of names while we're claiming them gives them that much more information to work with.

At this point, everyone needs to name claim. Then we figure out what it means.

I'm Trang Pak.

I won't post again until I've gotten the "all clear" from Iso.

tezz I'm really not seeing what you're getting at here. Please stop until everyone has claimed their name.

I'm Janis Ian.

First off I go to sleep, get up, go to brunch, get a building permit, come home, and turn on my computer to find 180 new posts... I need less of a life.

Secondly I'm Hillary Faye who changed her name to Emma Gerber.

Effective immediately Audinho Replaces Miracule

I'm behind as well with a vicious headache. I see the name claims going on.
I'm Regina George.

I'm Mr Duvall.
I see there's player replacing out after the "incident", from my experience the timming means it's scum replacing out.

unvote,vote miracule

I'm ready for D2.

Greetings, I'm replacing in for Miracule. Haven't had time to read the thread yet, but I understand there's a nameclaim going on.

I am Kevin Gnapoor.

I've got no knowledge of the flavor at all.

So I've gotten through half the thread, will read more later. Lots of Iso vs Pinky, not sure which side to choose there yet, will need to read the rest to get a better point of view.

Quote from pinkys_brain »

1) How active of a player are you?
2) Please link if able a finished game you were town and scum (one of each is all I ask).
3) Do you think RVS gives you information about players?
4) Miller claims, scummy, null or wait and see till later?

1. I'm fairly active and will post at least once per day
2. Town in Zodiac, scum in The Office. I don't think my meta has solidifyed enough that there's any point reading into the meta though.
3. RVS can sometimes be useful I think, I just haven't experienced it yet. At least it's a good way to prompt discussion.
4. This is my first game where someone has claimed Miller. I'll treat it as a null read.

More later.

DRey, you have an unanswered question.

Why?

But if he hadn't replaced out, then your vote wouldn't be on him?

But you said if he HADN'T replaced, your vote would be on him. But the replacement was the grounds you said you'd vote him on!

I understand what you're saying, but try to be a little clearer next time.