@Squee if you agree with me, vote Void, he's now pushing for the "next bit thing" Proph right after Brinato wagon didn't pan out. The guy is scum.
@leon vote Void
@Iso vote Void
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The game is not being dumbed down. Control is doing fine; Draw-Go is not the only kind of control. Aggro is doing fine; Red Deck Wins is not the only kind of aggro. Creature combat is an important core concept and belongs in every color. Mythic rarity is not destroying the game. People whine too much for no good reason. Magic is more popular than ever, so keep calm, brew some decks and play some damn cards.
DRay:
Why are you being so persistent with calling for votes on Void?
At the moment, it's probably the only thing stopping me from voting him.
BE:
Your entire case on Proph seems to be based on his past behaviors. That doesn't seem like a terribly strong base at this stage of the game, got anything more on him?
Void:
You're being awful deflective when it comes to some of the stuff DRay's posted about you. There's only so much asking for more clarification can do, if you think the accusations are general, then at least make a general rebuttal.
At the moment all you seem to have done is follow BE and jump from Brin to Proph.
Do you think that not noticing the fake name is scummy? Why do you think that scum tend to skip over things? If anything, I would expect scum to be more careful.
In Void's case, yes. And scum can skip over things because they already know people's alignments and digging up information about people isn't really in their best interests.
DRay:
Why are you being so persistent with calling for votes on Void?
At the moment, it's probably the only thing stopping me from voting him.
Because he's scum.
Let's see if I got this right:
a)You feel Void is scum.
b)You don't feel I'm scum. (if I'm wrong please explain how I'm scummy)
and yet you are wary of voting him because of my influence? o.O
I'm bored, both of my games are sloooow, let's make things happen so I can join other games.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The game is not being dumbed down. Control is doing fine; Draw-Go is not the only kind of control. Aggro is doing fine; Red Deck Wins is not the only kind of aggro. Creature combat is an important core concept and belongs in every color. Mythic rarity is not destroying the game. People whine too much for no good reason. Magic is more popular than ever, so keep calm, brew some decks and play some damn cards.
He's more likely to give content without being prodded when he's town. He also tends to have stronger suspicions; this game, he just gave two relatively weak suspicions, and no vote.
Gahhhhhhhhh, had a post all typed up that I spent a half hour on, after spending a bunch of time reading.
Then Firefox ate it.
Drey, why Void over Proph? And don't say "Because Void is scum!" I want actual reasons.
Parinoid is town. Len and BE are probable town as well.
Proph's catching up post is awful, specifically targetting fluffy the way he did.
I agree LaL is not perfect. But, liars still should have pressure to explain what they did. Brin did, and I realized that his gambit was just bad. Before, I mistook that bad for being scum. Which is obviously wrong.
Unvote
That's the cliff notes from before, as I now am out of time to say anything more.
The way Proph and Void have been acting, it wouldn't surprise me if they're buddies. And right now, I feel stronger about Proph.
I agree, Proph made it perfectly clear they were buddies but:
a)Proph is newbier, so more prone to do bad plays that can be confused with sum plays
b)Void tried to deflect into Proph
c)Void is more experienced, so a higher threat to town than Proph, if Proph really is scum he will self-destruct soon enough.
d)Void wagon is bigger, so it will be easier to reach consensus.
Drey, why Void over Proph? And don't say "Because Void is scum!" I want actual reasons.
Parinoid is town. Len and BE are probable town as well.
Proph's catching up post is awful, specifically targetting fluffy the way he did.
Reasons above. Why do you say Parinoid, Len and BE are town?
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The game is not being dumbed down. Control is doing fine; Draw-Go is not the only kind of control. Aggro is doing fine; Red Deck Wins is not the only kind of aggro. Creature combat is an important core concept and belongs in every color. Mythic rarity is not destroying the game. People whine too much for no good reason. Magic is more popular than ever, so keep calm, brew some decks and play some damn cards.
pinkys_brain 10
Wolf with a Bass 8
The Cold Monarch 7
Prophylaxis 7
fluffyn00b 7
Squeege 6
Anaklusmos 6
Mod
PLayers that post less than the mod:mad1:
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The game is not being dumbed down. Control is doing fine; Draw-Go is not the only kind of control. Aggro is doing fine; Red Deck Wins is not the only kind of aggro. Creature combat is an important core concept and belongs in every color. Mythic rarity is not destroying the game. People whine too much for no good reason. Magic is more popular than ever, so keep calm, brew some decks and play some damn cards.
It has nothing to do with Parinoid being town or not town. Scum is fully capable of saying truthful and reasonable stuff as well. So it's more about me thinking that Parinoids post was reasonable, which I do.
But if you want my opinion about Pari, fine. I do think him townish, he never gave me a reason not to, by now. I also liked that he didn't simply follow Void and Blue in their anti-Brin campaign. But if that's townish or scummish depends on Brin being scum or town, of course.
But to think its reasonable, you would have to think its geniune, and while scum can be geniune, it is more of a town trait, ergo why I was asking if you thought paranoid was town.
I know that I didn't panic from BE's post cause I wanted to unvote already before BE's post was even in. Because I thought it was a mistake, not because Blue said so.
So, I can be pretty sure it wasn't Blue who made me all jibbly about my vote.
Let me rephrase Which of your original reasons for voting did you believe to be mistaken when you gave your justfication? For refrence:
Quote from Miss Len »
for none of his answers being probable or townie-ish, or satisfying my need for explanations.
Yes, I'll try, and sorry it was a pain to read this.
I'm looping into many directions because I like to question the things people say. That is all the things that are said, or at least many of them.
Iso is my main account's username here. BlueElectric is a gimmick account wherein I pretended to be somebody I'm not to experiment with different playstyles so people could not base my different behavioral trends on my past play and call out the differences.
I knew there was something about you I didn't like...
pinkys_brain 10
Wolf with a Bass 8
The Cold Monarch 7
Prophylaxis 7
fluffyn00b 7
Squeege 6
Anaklusmos 6
Mod
PLayers that post less than the mod:mad1:
I had to reread a game about to hit 4000 posts, and my internet access at college got noteably worse. Sue me if I am only able to post once a day or once every other day.
I agree, Proph made it perfectly clear they were buddies but:
a)Proph is newbier, so more prone to do bad plays that can be confused with sum plays
b)Void tried to deflect into Proph
c)Void is more experienced, so a higher threat to town than Proph, if Proph really is scum he will self-destruct soon enough.
d)Void wagon is bigger, so it will be easier to reach consensus.
A and B are somewhat decent points, but I don't agree with C (dead scum is dead scum, and Proph is the type that could coast if left alone), and I don't think D is true (at least, not anymore).
The thing with A is that I just looked at his town/scum games not too long ago, and this looks like his scum game. He's prone to looking scummy as town, but it's scummy in a different way; as town, he'll use poor reasoning (as he's still learning), as scum, he's non-commital.
B is the only thing that makes me want to vote Void over Proph. To be fair to Void though, he has been doing his own thing, and actively pressuring people (a town tell for newer players, even if I thought his push on Brinatoo was bad). It's enough to make me want to watch him a little longer.
Quote from LenKenneth »
I don't feel that way about Void. Maybe I missed something if you're all soooo convinced that he's scum. But at the moment, if it wasn't for Proph to be there and be scummier than them all, I'd rather see Drey lynched for pushing the Void-vote-matter as much as he does. It shouldn't be in the interest of town to rush the others to a vote when they don't feel entirely sure about it.
Pushing hard for a lynch like Drey is isn't usually a scum tell (in fact I'd say town do it more often than scum). Maybe once we know more alignments, but even then, scum don't tend to like to be that commital.
Quote from fluffyn00b »
Have I contributed a lot? No. Have I tried? Yes. Having a busy personal schedule shouldn't be enough to call me out as scum.
You've been posting, but you haven't given your opinion until your last post. I definitely understand being busy, but it seems like you have time to post.
Let's see if I got this right:
a)You feel Void is scum.
b)You don't feel I'm scum. (if I'm wrong please explain how I'm scummy)
and yet you are wary of voting him because of my influence? o.O
I'm bored, both of my games are sloooow, let's make things happen so I can join other games.
For some reason, I'm wary of people who tell me to do something with such vigor. It's just the way I am.
I want to see how everyone's fallen recently and at least 1 more post from Void before I commit.
Speaking of which: @ Pinky: Can we get a vote count plz?
;p The problem with you playing under this pseudonym is that some people might know if you are Iso if you were on the scumteam. Assuming you were forced to reveal yourself in a mafia chat. This is all assumption, but you do realize the harm that would be in you being kept a secret, right? If you are scum, you might have just condemned your team ;p
What?
Quote from Brinatoo »
Then I need Engrish lessons because the chain is fuzzled.
Good thing we have public education!
Quote from Brinatoo »
Do you still believe that a nameclaim is risky in a basic?
In a Basic where I'm not comfortable with the flavor, yes.
Quote from Brinatoo »
You thought I was scum too in that one And I will figure you out, Mister.
I'm looking at WikiMafia (or whatever the website is called) at the WIFOM section again for a better understanding, but you know this already, don't you?
(btw, knowing that you're ISO makes 1000 times more sense.)
Hahaha Please explain why.
Quote from Squeege »
This isn't crap play disguised as a gambit, because what he did (falseclaimed his rolename to encourage a mass nameclaim), can only be described as a gambit. It could be either a scum or town gambit, but it's not like he did something scummy and then said "lol, gotcha guiz, I was just trying to catch the scum!!1!".
My policy on gambits is generally that if it's obvious, it's a town gambit.
Quote from Squeege »
Actually, she acts just like Iso (and yes, I will always refer to her as a she, as she's a character being played by Iso).
Did she? I thought my play was rather different as BE. I'm typically more bull-headed as Iso. And how do you know how I play, anyway? I was in like, one game with you as Iso, and you replaced out in that one and that was like my 3rd game.
BE:
Your entire case on Proph seems to be based on his past behaviors. That doesn't seem like a terribly strong base at this stage of the game, got anything more on him?
Not based solely on that, but also on the fact that he hasn't actually done anything thus far.
I knew there was something about you I didn't like...
</3
Quote from The Cold Monarch »
Hey ISO!!! Does this look familiar at all?
Please enlighten me. DRey isn't really providing much but he's not playing his scum game, IMO. I can sniff out DRey probably better than I can sniff you out.
I'm okay with another vote on Proph to see what he claims.
@ISo now that you are outted just play as iso already.
Just to advance the game, as I'm fine with a Proph claim too. unvote, vote Proph
When I have more time I will respond to stuff.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The game is not being dumbed down. Control is doing fine; Draw-Go is not the only kind of control. Aggro is doing fine; Red Deck Wins is not the only kind of aggro. Creature combat is an important core concept and belongs in every color. Mythic rarity is not destroying the game. People whine too much for no good reason. Magic is more popular than ever, so keep calm, brew some decks and play some damn cards.
If you're a power role, then what's with you all but ignoring this game?
Even now you post just a bare bones claim without responding to anything that's said about/to you.
If you're a power role, then what's with you all but ignoring this game?
Even now you post just a bare bones claim without responding to anything that's said about/to you.
I've been busy. I will post later today because one of my games is finished. I just wanted to get the claim out.
Just an FYI: I will be out of town this weekend. While I'm gone I asked Artifice101 to keep an eye on this game for me and to do vote counts and if someone is lynched while I'm away for that weekend to post the results of the lynch so the game does not get stagnant while I'm on my trip.
I will be gone frim 02/17 - 02/20.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I am female, hear me roar!
mafia win/lose record
town (12) 6/6
mafia (2) 2/0
Cult (1) 1/0
3rd party (0) 0/0
In a Basic where I'm not comfortable with the flavor, yes.
That should be the other way around, when the flavor is difficult to fabricate town should be MORE comfortable on hearing claims. For example on Osteria you suggested a mass claim because it would be harder for scum.
I don't know if I'm buying either, but what's your suggestion? Maybe lynch him?
--------
I knew I should've sticked with him. unvote, vote:Void
@everyone DO NOT BREADCRUMB YOUR POWERS, IF YOU HAVE SOME REASON FOR NOT SUSPECTING HIM (WATCHER, TRACKER OR SOMETHING) DON'T DO ANYTHING, only if you are the real cop you are allowed of going on and CC him.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The game is not being dumbed down. Control is doing fine; Draw-Go is not the only kind of control. Aggro is doing fine; Red Deck Wins is not the only kind of aggro. Creature combat is an important core concept and belongs in every color. Mythic rarity is not destroying the game. People whine too much for no good reason. Magic is more popular than ever, so keep calm, brew some decks and play some damn cards.
@Iso: In that last game with scum D-rey, he was pretty much sure I was town, and then the second I started to question him, he quickly turned on me and started to think I was scum. Now I question him why I am obvious town, he backtracks, and then states until now, like my question ruined his vision on me. I just don't like how it looks.
Also, I think you have thought me scum in every single game, which was actually starting to get irritating.
@Cop claim: I would change it to say any non-tracker investigative role could cc, but that's just me mod gaming. Frankly, I don't like Artifice's example of a 4 PR games, or Seppel's heavy investigation game (although, at least the justification was a confirmed 0 protection roles).
Refusing to vote void, noted. ALso you really didn't have any reason for not suspecting Brin huh? Is this how you jump off stinky wagon?
Note what you want. And I have reason for unvoting Brin, I just haven't explicitly stated it, yet.
Quote from DRey »
That should be the other way around, when the flavor is difficult to fabricate town should be MORE comfortable on hearing claims. For example on Osteria you suggested a mass claim because it would be harder for scum.
Actually, I suggested a name claim in Osteria because I had a (wrong) theory about the flavor of it. Either way, yeah.
Quote from DRey »
One more vote to mass name claim.
You mean against?
Quote from DRey »
I don't know if I'm buying either, but what's your suggestion? Maybe lynch him?
Yes.
@TCM: The only reason my read on you in Osteria wavered was because Levine actually made some fair points. And Flame Warriors was just so terrible that that was a cluster****, though I'm sure you remember the post where you were like, "Holy. Is Iso really that good or just lucky?" At any rate, what else do you find you don't like about DRey this game?
And why, praytell, don't you believe that Proph is the Cop?
I should be asking you the same.
Proph's game play doesn't have the feel of him being a Town PR of any sort. Since no one is going to CC (and if there is another invexstigation role they should not speak up) then I will keep my vote off for now, but IGMEOH (H = Him if it isn't obv.)
Don't know. If I'm convinced he's lying, then I would keep pushing. But yeah, no counterclaim. I just can't see why he should claim cop if he's neither cop nor scum...
Town could safely claim town. No need to lie to the co-townies. And I see no reason why non-cop-town should claim cop. So, only people left to claim cop are cop and scum. From my point of view.
Or he could be a Vanilla Town desperately trying to stop his lynch. But I think he's scum.
TCM, are you picking up what I'm putting down, here?
By contributing, I mean actually scumhunting, providing content, etc. Analyzing people's posts.
I would recommend you get a mentor for your next game.
This is Proph’s first post outside of RVS. I don’t see a Town PR making this post. I know that if I were a Town PR that I would be making every post count. This one does nothing at all and holds no context for the game. Hypocrisy thy name is Prophylaxis.
This is the most convincing post that Proph is not a Town PR. I highly doubt anyone would forget about a game that they are a Town PR in because of the importance of their Role.
This whole post is reaching. You're looking for any reason to call me scum.
This is a spam post:
Also, he has played in three games so far on the mafia subforum, and this is his third one. His first two games were scum, and he has put that "[Insert Game Here] scum" on his second game, in which Iso called him out:
Well, I still think that vanilla town at least shouldn't claim cop, cause it could lead to confusion later on in the game and thus, hurt town. If he's done that or not, I cannot say. Still waiting for his post to hear more.
I know of a couple of players that you won't like because they tend to claim PR's when Vanilla. Gambits can be fun though.
I don't like how the game is slowing because we are waiting for Proph... Which could be some time since he is chronic lurker at times.
LenKen:
Is that an okay nickname or is LK better? Also, what is your read on paranoid thus far?
@Iso: In that last game with scum D-rey, he was pretty much sure I was town, and then the second I started to question him, he quickly turned on me and started to think I was scum. Now I question him why I am obvious town, he backtracks, and then states until now, like my question ruined his vision on me. I just don't like how it looks.
I'm not backtracking I still really, really think you are town. But I noticed we think alike, our reads in Osteria were the same (while scum there I was playing my town game) so I reserve the right to be wrong.
Well, I still think that vanilla town at least shouldn't claim cop, cause it could lead to confusion later on in the game and thus, hurt town. If he's done that or not, I cannot say. Still waiting for his post to hear more.
You are right, but there's no reason for continue this conversation, Proph is probably lying scum, but until we hear a CC he will not be lynched today, no matter how scummy he is. Let's just lynch his scumbuddy Void.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The game is not being dumbed down. Control is doing fine; Draw-Go is not the only kind of control. Aggro is doing fine; Red Deck Wins is not the only kind of aggro. Creature combat is an important core concept and belongs in every color. Mythic rarity is not destroying the game. People whine too much for no good reason. Magic is more popular than ever, so keep calm, brew some decks and play some damn cards.
I know of a couple of players that you won't like because they tend to claim PR's when Vanilla. Gambits can be fun though.
If one does that as town 99% of the times they are doing it wrong.
Please never do this as town, even if you think it's a good idea. I've only lied as town once in more than a year playing.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The game is not being dumbed down. Control is doing fine; Draw-Go is not the only kind of control. Aggro is doing fine; Red Deck Wins is not the only kind of aggro. Creature combat is an important core concept and belongs in every color. Mythic rarity is not destroying the game. People whine too much for no good reason. Magic is more popular than ever, so keep calm, brew some decks and play some damn cards.
DRey:
It's not because Jay knows the entire family. It's the fact that he use to know the Mafia. That last line in Proph's flavor bugs me. That and his posting is not that of a PR. I see your still pushing hard for my lynch even though you yourself don't believe Proph.
What are your reasons for not believing Proph?
Why do you view Iso as scum? Quotes if you could please.
@leon vote Void
@Iso vote Void
Mythic rarity is not destroying the game. People whine too much for no good reason. Magic is more popular than ever, so keep calm, brew some decks and play some damn cards.
Why are you being so persistent with calling for votes on Void?
At the moment, it's probably the only thing stopping me from voting him.
BE:
Your entire case on Proph seems to be based on his past behaviors. That doesn't seem like a terribly strong base at this stage of the game, got anything more on him?
Void:
You're being awful deflective when it comes to some of the stuff DRay's posted about you. There's only so much asking for more clarification can do, if you think the accusations are general, then at least make a general rebuttal.
At the moment all you seem to have done is follow BE and jump from Brin to Proph.
That is correct.
K.
fluffy has also not really contributed. This isn't a good thing to go by, considering that it feels weighted in content anyway.
In Void's case, yes. And scum can skip over things because they already know people's alignments and digging up information about people isn't really in their best interests.
Let's see if I got this right:
a)You feel Void is scum.
b)You don't feel I'm scum. (if I'm wrong please explain how I'm scummy)
and yet you are wary of voting him because of my influence? o.O
I'm bored, both of my games are sloooow, let's make things happen so I can join other games.
Mythic rarity is not destroying the game. People whine too much for no good reason. Magic is more popular than ever, so keep calm, brew some decks and play some damn cards.
He's more likely to give content without being prodded when he's town. He also tends to have stronger suspicions; this game, he just gave two relatively weak suspicions, and no vote.
The way Proph and Void have been acting, it wouldn't surprise me if they're buddies. And right now, I feel stronger about Proph.
Then Firefox ate it.
Drey, why Void over Proph? And don't say "Because Void is scum!" I want actual reasons.
Parinoid is town. Len and BE are probable town as well.
Proph's catching up post is awful, specifically targetting fluffy the way he did.
I agree LaL is not perfect. But, liars still should have pressure to explain what they did. Brin did, and I realized that his gambit was just bad. Before, I mistook that bad for being scum. Which is obviously wrong.
Unvote
That's the cliff notes from before, as I now am out of time to say anything more.
a)Proph is newbier, so more prone to do bad plays that can be confused with sum plays
b)Void tried to deflect into Proph
c)Void is more experienced, so a higher threat to town than Proph, if Proph really is scum he will self-destruct soon enough.
d)Void wagon is bigger, so it will be easier to reach consensus.
Reasons above. Why do you say Parinoid, Len and BE are town?
Mythic rarity is not destroying the game. People whine too much for no good reason. Magic is more popular than ever, so keep calm, brew some decks and play some damn cards.
pinkys_brain 10
Wolf with a Bass 8
The Cold Monarch 7
Prophylaxis 7
fluffyn00b 7
Squeege 6
Anaklusmos 6
Mod
PLayers that post less than the mod:mad1:
Mythic rarity is not destroying the game. People whine too much for no good reason. Magic is more popular than ever, so keep calm, brew some decks and play some damn cards.
Have I contributed a lot? No. Have I tried? Yes. Having a busy personal schedule shouldn't be enough to call me out as scum.
sig by DarkNightCavalier
Avatar by perv90210.
Currently Running
Cryffyl
But to think its reasonable, you would have to think its geniune, and while scum can be geniune, it is more of a town trait, ergo why I was asking if you thought paranoid was town.
Let me rephrase Which of your original reasons for voting did you believe to be mistaken when you gave your justfication? For refrence:
That seems reasonable.
Much. Information processing...
I knew there was something about you I didn't like...
Hey ISO!!! Does this look familiar at all?
@D-rey: Which post would that be? The post where I ask you why I am obvious town so early, despite knowing I HATE the use of "obvious town".
I had to reread a game about to hit 4000 posts, and my internet access at college got noteably worse. Sue me if I am only able to post once a day or once every other day.
The GJ way path to no lynching:
I didn't tally up the post counts, but It seems that you're posting this just so you appear more involved in the game.
sig by DarkNightCavalier
Avatar by perv90210.
Currently Running
Cryffyl
A and B are somewhat decent points, but I don't agree with C (dead scum is dead scum, and Proph is the type that could coast if left alone), and I don't think D is true (at least, not anymore).
The thing with A is that I just looked at his town/scum games not too long ago, and this looks like his scum game. He's prone to looking scummy as town, but it's scummy in a different way; as town, he'll use poor reasoning (as he's still learning), as scum, he's non-commital.
B is the only thing that makes me want to vote Void over Proph. To be fair to Void though, he has been doing his own thing, and actively pressuring people (a town tell for newer players, even if I thought his push on Brinatoo was bad). It's enough to make me want to watch him a little longer.
Pushing hard for a lynch like Drey is isn't usually a scum tell (in fact I'd say town do it more often than scum). Maybe once we know more alignments, but even then, scum don't tend to like to be that commital.
You've been posting, but you haven't given your opinion until your last post. I definitely understand being busy, but it seems like you have time to post.
Who are your top 3 scum suspects, and why?
I didn't call you scum. I didn't call you anything but I certainly think you are unproductive town, at best.
Whenever you have time.
For some reason, I'm wary of people who tell me to do something with such vigor. It's just the way I am.
I want to see how everyone's fallen recently and at least 1 more post from Void before I commit.
Speaking of which:
@ Pinky: Can we get a vote count plz?
want -> would like
Keeping the family in line vote count:
Void (2) brinatoo, Drey
fluffyn00b (1) Prophylaxis
Prophylaxis (4) BlueElectric, Void, Squeege, LenKenneth
Not voting:
fluffyn00b
The Cold Monarch
Wolf with a Bass
Parinoid
Anaklusmos
With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch
mafia win/lose record
town (12) 6/6
mafia (2) 2/0
Cult (1) 1/0
3rd party (0) 0/0
mafia record
Also known at mafiascum as farside22
Can do.
What?
Good thing we have public education!
In a Basic where I'm not comfortable with the flavor, yes.
Maybe someday, Brinatoo.
No.
Hahaha Please explain why.
My policy on gambits is generally that if it's obvious, it's a town gambit.
Did she? I thought my play was rather different as BE. I'm typically more bull-headed as Iso. And how do you know how I play, anyway? I was in like, one game with you as Iso, and you replaced out in that one and that was like my 3rd game.
Scummy, but he actually provides content. Town Proph is a great wagon to have for analysis purposes.
Only if Proph flips town.
Not based solely on that, but also on the fact that he hasn't actually done anything thus far.
Don't make a personal commitment to a Mafia game if you can't see it through.
</3
Please enlighten me. DRey isn't really providing much but he's not playing his scum game, IMO. I can sniff out DRey probably better than I can sniff you out.
I'm okay with another vote on Proph to see what he claims.
Accidentally posted in pinkfloyd's game as BE and then posted as Iso thereafter and was like "oh god dammit". Then it spread from there.
I only have two. I've been suspicious of Brinatoo all along because of the fake names, yet Void seems to be extremely trigger-happy.
@Paranoid- I have the time to play it through, I just don't have the time to make 45-paragraph multi-quotes.
sig by DarkNightCavalier
Avatar by perv90210.
Currently Running
Cryffyl
Just to advance the game, as I'm fine with a Proph claim too. unvote, vote Proph
When I have more time I will respond to stuff.
Mythic rarity is not destroying the game. People whine too much for no good reason. Magic is more popular than ever, so keep calm, brew some decks and play some damn cards.
DRey volunteering to help put more information in the thread? Unbelievable!
Dude, you've got me and BE mixed up.
The last time I mentioned you was when I started giving you an Awkward Stare Every Now and Then.
I am Jay Pritchett, the cop.
I know everyone because I'm the leader of the family, but I forget in my old age who is scum.
I win when all of the mafia members are evicted from the household.
Even now you post just a bare bones claim without responding to anything that's said about/to you.
I've been busy. I will post later today because one of my games is finished. I just wanted to get the claim out.
More later today.
I will be gone frim 02/17 - 02/20.
mafia win/lose record
town (12) 6/6
mafia (2) 2/0
Cult (1) 1/0
3rd party (0) 0/0
mafia record
Also known at mafiascum as farside22
That should be the other way around, when the flavor is difficult to fabricate town should be MORE comfortable on hearing claims. For example on Osteria you suggested a mass claim because it would be harder for scum.
One more vote to mass name claim.
I don't know if I'm buying either, but what's your suggestion? Maybe lynch him?
--------
I knew I should've sticked with him.
unvote, vote:Void
@everyone DO NOT BREADCRUMB YOUR POWERS, IF YOU HAVE SOME REASON FOR NOT SUSPECTING HIM (WATCHER, TRACKER OR SOMETHING) DON'T DO ANYTHING, only if you are the real cop you are allowed of going on and CC him.
Mythic rarity is not destroying the game. People whine too much for no good reason. Magic is more popular than ever, so keep calm, brew some decks and play some damn cards.
@Iso: In that last game with scum D-rey, he was pretty much sure I was town, and then the second I started to question him, he quickly turned on me and started to think I was scum. Now I question him why I am obvious town, he backtracks, and then states until now, like my question ruined his vision on me. I just don't like how it looks.
Also, I think you have thought me scum in every single game, which was actually starting to get irritating.
@Cop claim: I would change it to say any non-tracker investigative role could cc, but that's just me mod gaming. Frankly, I don't like Artifice's example of a 4 PR games, or Seppel's heavy investigation game (although, at least the justification was a confirmed 0 protection roles).
The GJ way path to no lynching:
Note what you want. And I have reason for unvoting Brin, I just haven't explicitly stated it, yet.
Actually, I suggested a name claim in Osteria because I had a (wrong) theory about the flavor of it. Either way, yeah.
You mean against?
Yes.
@TCM: The only reason my read on you in Osteria wavered was because Levine actually made some fair points. And Flame Warriors was just so terrible that that was a cluster****, though I'm sure you remember the post where you were like, "Holy. Is Iso really that good or just lucky?" At any rate, what else do you find you don't like about DRey this game?
More to come later
@Bold: Tell me why you think that.
@Underlined: Would YOU push against an uncounterclaimed Power Role without reason?
P.S., Proph is still lying about being the Cop.
Surely you have more to say than that.
I should be asking you the same.
Proph's game play doesn't have the feel of him being a Town PR of any sort. Since no one is going to CC (and if there is another invexstigation role they should not speak up) then I will keep my vote off for now, but IGMEOH (H = Him if it isn't obv.)
The bolded is what convinces me the most.
paranoid:
I was checking into my other games at the time. As you can see I followed up with more.
One of my reasons is his recent performance in Random Mafia 4.
Could you quote examples of how you believe this is true and explain why?
So flavor?
Possible Masons in the game?
Why would you think that, with a claimed Cop?
Or he could be a Vanilla Town desperately trying to stop his lynch. But I think he's scum.
TCM, are you picking up what I'm putting down, here?
I think that was sufficient to express my bother at 1/4 of the field posting to promise more content later.
I expressed my doubts about the claim almost as soon as it was made. Proph promised more later, so I'm waiting.
Pure speculation.
-------------------
Small PBPA of Proph and why I don't believe his claim.
This is Proph’s first post outside of RVS. I don’t see a Town PR making this post. I know that if I were a Town PR that I would be making every post count. This one does nothing at all and holds no context for the game. Hypocrisy thy name is Prophylaxis.
This is the most convincing post that Proph is not a Town PR. I highly doubt anyone would forget about a game that they are a Town PR in because of the importance of their Role.
This post gets a little better, but the hypocrisy returns with his comment on Fluffly minus the siggy comment. His reason for me is okay at best.
Hypocrisy thy name is Prophylaxis.
I’ve already mentioned why this claim bothers me.
Still nothing from Proph and as mentioned, not committing to a vote on anyone even though suspicion is there.
I know of a couple of players that you won't like because they tend to claim PR's when Vanilla. Gambits can be fun though.
I don't like how the game is slowing because we are waiting for Proph... Which could be some time since he is chronic lurker at times.
LenKen:
Is that an okay nickname or is LK better? Also, what is your read on paranoid thus far?
Keeping the family in line vote count:
Void (2) brinatoo, Drey
fluffyn00b (1) Prophylaxis
Prophylaxis (2) BlueElectric, LenKenneth
Not voting:
fluffyn00b
The Cold Monarch
Wolf with a Bass
Parinoid
Anaklusmos
Squeege
Void
With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch
mafia win/lose record
town (12) 6/6
mafia (2) 2/0
Cult (1) 1/0
3rd party (0) 0/0
mafia record
Also known at mafiascum as farside22
State them ASAP, I really don't want to ask for the fourth time.
Nope, if you and Void are against it, I favor it. Brin is also probably town.
Are you really saying Proph is scum because he said his character knows everyone on the series? Please get lynched.
If it isn't obvious, if you are a mason, do not address this.
You are right, but there's no reason for continue this conversation, Proph is probably lying scum, but until we hear a CC he will not be lynched today, no matter how scummy he is. Let's just lynch his scumbuddy Void.
Mythic rarity is not destroying the game. People whine too much for no good reason. Magic is more popular than ever, so keep calm, brew some decks and play some damn cards.
Please never do this as town, even if you think it's a good idea. I've only lied as town once in more than a year playing.
Mythic rarity is not destroying the game. People whine too much for no good reason. Magic is more popular than ever, so keep calm, brew some decks and play some damn cards.
DRey:
It's not because Jay knows the entire family. It's the fact that he use to know the Mafia. That last line in Proph's flavor bugs me. That and his posting is not that of a PR. I see your still pushing hard for my lynch even though you yourself don't believe Proph.
What are your reasons for not believing Proph?
Why do you view Iso as scum? Quotes if you could please.
Did not mean for the emotioncon to be present in the title of my last post.
Len:
I can't remember if you stated this or not. How much experience do you have? And sorry if I over looked TCM asking you the same question.