Unvote, Vote Silent prophet for being invisible.
Also, he might be scummy... Being unactive, then suddenly extremely active is strange.......
Care to explain why you have no suspicion of Godless Angel then? He openly admitted to being invisible. Silent Prophet also willingly changed out of it when asked to do so. I won't explain his participation (leave him to explain this), but I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt for the time-being.
Guys, when double posting, please start the post with either EDIT or EBWOP/EBWODP (Edit by Way of Double Post) so fade knows to merge. Also, using the preveiew post button helps you see any posts made while you were typing yours, i strongly advise it. Lets NOT make it any harder for fade to merge.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Mafia MVP Harry Potter Mafia!
Logical Reasoning is dead; Long Live Stupidity
Quote from Seppel »
I love Joboman, Poggy, Niv, and Vezok, because, while they may not be the best players, they still try to win. Having fun is the most important thing to a game, but I've learned that if you don't try to win, then you're ruining everyone else's fun.
No, no it doesnt :p.
For the moment, Rogue seems the most suspicious to me. Wuffles_II was already at a vote, and he put then second vote.
Not much, but its usually enough to get a lynch first day -_-
Random voting is officially over. Unvote. Yes, I know it seems like I'm running away after being suspected, but it's the first time I've checked the thread since the end of rando-voting.
No, no it doesnt :p.
For the moment, Rogue seems the most suspicious to me. Wuffles_II was already at a vote, and he put then second vote.
Not much, but its usually enough to get a lynch first day -_-
Your protective attitude toward Wuffles is interesting. He got a second vote, and you're already retaliating with a lynch threat?
Random voting is officially over. Unvote. Yes, I know it seems like I'm running away after being suspected, but it's the first time I've checked the thread since the end of rando-voting.
Whoa whoa whoa there, RR. Who gave you the authority to call the end to random voting. Not all of the players have even came back since the start of the day yet (which only started just this morning). Fos: Rouge Rogue
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
If you're town and I'm mafia, you've already lost. You just don't know it yet.
Well, I meant that we were getting out of it, and I, at least was done with it. Sorry if I sounded like I meant something else. Also, if it's slightly scummy that I put a second vote on Wuffles, why do I now have two 'random' votes?
Care to explain that any further? I'm quite opposed to voting to someone that requests to be voted for so early like that.
I did some mulling over this. It doesn't really make sense for a mafia member to get any benefit out of this statement. I'm going to assume that he has some ability that's good for the town when he's lynched. So, Unvote: Alx, Vote: Godless Angel
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
If you're town and I'm mafia, you've already lost. You just don't know it yet.
I did some mulling over this. It doesn't really make sense for a mafia member to get any benefit out of this statement. I'm going to assume that he has some ability that's good for the town when he's lynched. So, Unvote: Alx, Vote: Godless Angel
While that may be true in a specialty game, or a normal game, this is a newb game. I highly doubt that loran would put an abiltiy like that into a newb game. It WOULD be a cool ability, though. * Silent Prophet takes notes.
While that may be true in a specialty game, or a normal game, this is a newb game. I highly doubt that loran would put an abiltiy like that into a newb game. It WOULD be a cool ability, though. * Silent Prophet takes notes.
Yeah, that and since this is a newbie game, Godless Angel could just be not understand that being voted for is generally a bad thing. But remind me to try to sign up for the next mafia game SP runs.
Also, I am blinded by the 1000 post smiley bonanza. That and the quantity of green fonts... But again, it would be a little beyond a newbie game for it to be some sort of posting restriction. I'm going to go out on a limb and say coincidence.
Yeah, that and since this is a newbie game, Godless Angel could just be not understand that being voted for is generally a bad thing. But remind me to try to sign up for the next mafia game SP runs.
Also, I am blinded by the 1000 post smiley bonanza. That and the quantity of green fonts... But again, it would be a little beyond a newbie game for it to be some sort of posting restriction. I'm going to go out on a limb and say coincidence.
This is why I'll unvote if he comes back and says it was an understanding. For now, I'll just assume voting for him = good thing.
EBWODP: "misunderstanding", not understanding. I need sleep.
The green isn't a voting restriction. I have used green for a good while because it matches up with my clan, sort of. It's hard to explain, but it's my identity, and it sucks that so many people in this game also use green. I might end up using a different colour so it's less confusing.
@WhytePanther. I don't have enough experience to run any kind of mafia game. I DID want to do the newb game, but like I said...not enough experience. If I do get a chance to host, it will be fun for all involved.:D
Unvote, Vote Coiled Flame As usual, your insane suppositions (read: SP is "scummy" for confirming last) only serve to discredit you and annoy Wuffles_II.
I did some mulling over this. It doesn't really make sense for a mafia member to get any benefit out of this statement. I'm going to assume that he has some ability that's good for the town when he's lynched. So, Unvote: Alx, Vote: Godless Angel
Yeah, that and since this is a newbie game, Godless Angel could just be not understand that being voted for is generally a bad thing. But remind me to try to sign up for the next mafia game SP runs.
Also, I am blinded by the 1000 post smiley bonanza. That and the quantity of green fonts... But again, it would be a little beyond a newbie game for it to be some sort of posting restriction. I'm going to go out on a limb and say coincidence.
yeah guys i was not exactly serious.
But i have been a vanilla townie who got lynched in the other two games i played here, so why break the cycle?
School was fun, i got my maths assignment.
Vote:atlseal
that wasn't ungrounded and i'm pretty undecided as to whether he is scum or not. but i missed the random voting.
and he voted me.
But i have been a vanilla townie who got lynched in the other two games i played here, so why break the cycle?
School was fun, i got my maths assignment.
Vote:atlseal
that wasn't ungrounded and i'm pretty undecided as to whether he is scum or not. but i missed the random voting.
and he voted me.
this post is too long
OMG, please change your font colour man, my eyes are bleeding after trying to read that. I realise it looks really nice on the Dark skin, but so does a nice red.
Sorry for the misunderstanding, Godless, Unvote: Godless Angel. I would have appreciated that it was a joke in the original post, but whatever. Be back later.
EBWOP: What I mean to say is that, had I known you were joking, I wouldn't have voted for you. Sorry for the misunderstanding.
Right now my top suspects, in no order, are Good+Evil, WhytePanther, Wuffles and Stormblind. The former two because they hardly ever posted anything (flying under radar?) and the latter two because of post 63.
Can you guys please stop voting for people not in the game? It's getting kind of confusing... and it's only funny the first time it's done. Wow, look, Star Wars Mafia, let's all lynch George Lucas, very funny, ha ha.
On a more serious note, FOS Silent Prophet, Cubus and Coiled Flame. Their posts have this greenish hue about them, clearly a case of scummy cooperation.
Ok, that was actually not on a serious note.
Alx just seems to get really annoyed at a blatent joke early, early, early in the game. Not quite sure what to make of it, but it is worth a note.
No, no it doesnt :p.
For the moment, Rogue seems the most suspicious to me. Wuffles_II was already at a vote, and he put then second vote.
Not much, but its usually enough to get a lynch first day -_-
I would hardly say that two votes, especially in the random voting phase, can lead to a lynch of a player, especially when it's 7 to vote. Apparently, in a normal game of mafia, the ratio is about 3 town: 1 mafia. So, with 12 players we can deduce that there are probably around 3 mafia members among us. Which means that the most the votes could increase from 2 is to 5. I'd say the danger zone is probably one more when it gets to 3, because then all it takes is one easily swayed town member to tip the scales and end in a mislynch. Also, voting for yourself always looks scummy in my eyes (if you turn out to be scum, people can't go back later and see your earlier "random voting" choices).
Random voting is officially over. Unvote. Yes, I know it seems like I'm running away after being suspected, but it's the first time I've checked the thread since the end of rando-voting.
Even though he offered an explaination, something about that post still irks me. It still seems to me like he wants everyone to stop random voting at that point. Although, we have seemingly eased up on the randomness now.
I dunno, myself, I kinda see StormBlind still at a point where he's just trying to have fun with the game. Nothing wrong with that really. The self vote should probably come off the next time he comes on (unless he really is scum, in which case, by all means.) I don't think he was defending Wuffles so much as attacking Rouge. I'm really not sure if either is founded yet. I think atlseal is reading too much into this. FoS: atlseal
I suppose the random voting phase really is over this time, and it's time for me to put my hat in somewhere. I'm starting to like my old random vote again. Godless makes a few comments in #81 that bother me. The OMGUS vote is blatant, but the vanilla townie comment seems a little out of place for someone who has next to no pressure on them, as well as his comment that his post was too long. It doesn't take a lot of reading old game to figure out that was a fairly short post, which means he might have felt he said more than he should have.
Vote: Godless Angel
@Cubus: Your font is dark enough to be readable, don't sweat it, it's the neon greens that are annoying.
I didn't realize that The post that he voted for me for being invisible was right after the post that G_A came out and admitted to it also. Am I supposed to believe that Coiled didn't see the post right before his? I would LOVE to see an explaination.
I dunno, myself, I kinda see StormBlind still at a point where he's just trying to have fun with the game. Nothing wrong with that really. The self vote should probably come off the next time he comes on (unless he really is scum, in which case, by all means.) I don't think he was defending Wuffles so much as attacking Rouge.
Well, now that you told him to remove the self-vote, I'm sure he will...
Uhm, I believe it was *me*, not atlseal, who's been "reading too much into it". Didn't you mean to FOS Alx?
Well, atlseal IS the one who actually voted for him. I suppose the same can be said for you as well. But if you want some attention: We're only about 24 hours into this game, it does seem a little early to try to attract attention to people who haven't posted a whole lot.
ok sorry. I was just applying some pressure, i don't enjoy having any votes.
Unvote
Yes, i felt there was more i could say. But they were suspicions which were very close to being ungrounded. So i'll wait until i have something to back them with.
That comment about the townie was just me being bitter.
Oh and i've had this font since the start of the year, thereabouts.
However, I'm still suspicious of Sp's sudden surgence in activity. Unvote, FOS Silent Prophet
I am confused on what sudden surge in activity you are reffering to. Are you comparing my playstyle to other games I've played, or are you still talking about me being the last to confirm?
EBWODP:
Quote from Wuffles post 100 »
I fail to see how someone defending ME makes ME suspicious.
I think he's saying that the fact that he is defending you so adamantly suggests that he knows something about your allignment. If that's the case, the only thing it could mean is that you are both mafia. I don't have an opinion one way or the other yet, but it seems like that's the conclusion that alx is suggesting.
@ Coiled Flame. When you answer my question. Please, be as clear and unconfusing as possible.
Sp: I myay be wrong on this, or it may be just that I didn't notice, or you just don't post then. However, the reason behind my FOS os this:
During the random period, I think you're only post was to confirm. I'mnot sure, but I didn't notice you a lot. Now, when the random period ended, you suddenly went way up in the number of posts you have made in this thread.
Now that I think over it however, it could just be that you don't really care about the fun-voting period. Un-FOS
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Sig and Avvy by Mr. Stuff
Quote from Zombiemachine »
Treefolk most probably eat dwarves, hence their absence.
:D:D:D
Quote from MajoraX »
So 9th Edition just stuck its middle finger up at Christianity.
Looking for people to test T2 with me on MWS, Pacific or Mountain time preffered
meh...I usually just post once or twice in the random-voting portion of it. I think I had answered this before somewhere, but I'm just not into the whole randomness at the beginning. Thank you for the clear, concise response.
@ Coiled - Granted, but please try to read the thread before making such...odd...remarks about people. FoSes and Votes should not be thrown around as carelessly as your posting style seems to indicate.
And I'm going to vote the next person who mentions "Posting restriction". There is no way in HELL that there would EVER be a PR in a newb mafia game.
But, Godless, please, for the sake of everyone's eyesight, please change your color to a slightly less abusive one
Vote for me guys.
oh, and i'll change out of invisible mode for you
Also, he might be scummy... Being unactive, then suddenly extremely active is strange.......
Sig and Avvy by Mr. Stuff
Looking for people to test T2 with me on MWS, Pacific or Mountain time preffered
Care to explain that any further? I'm quite opposed to voting to someone that requests to be voted for so early like that.
Care to explain why you have no suspicion of Godless Angel then? He openly admitted to being invisible. Silent Prophet also willingly changed out of it when asked to do so. I won't explain his participation (leave him to explain this), but I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt for the time-being.
Logical Reasoning is dead; Long Live Stupidity
Are we out of the randomness? If so, what innactivity of mine are you speculating on?
Official Deschanel Stalker of The Called
Sig and Avvy by Mr. Stuff
Looking for people to test T2 with me on MWS, Pacific or Mountain time preffered
Does that answer your inquiry?:teach:
Official Deschanel Stalker of The Called
For the moment, Rogue seems the most suspicious to me. Wuffles_II was already at a vote, and he put then second vote.
Not much, but its usually enough to get a lynch first day -_-
EBWODP: Apologies intended, danm lack of edit, anyway.
unvote... and... vote.... STORMBLIND
Your protective attitude toward Wuffles is interesting. He got a second vote, and you're already retaliating with a lynch threat?
Whoa whoa whoa there, RR. Who gave you the authority to call the end to random voting. Not all of the players have even came back since the start of the day yet (which only started just this morning). Fos: Rouge Rogue
Unvote, Random Vote Rouge
Sig and Avvy by Mr. Stuff
Looking for people to test T2 with me on MWS, Pacific or Mountain time preffered
1000 POSTS 1000 POSTS 1000 POSTS
There is a postcount bragging thread in Speak Your Mind. There's no need for posts like this outside of there.
Sig and Avvy by Mr. Stuff
Looking for people to test T2 with me on MWS, Pacific or Mountain time preffered
By the way CF, how many posts per page do you use?
Official Deschanel Stalker of The Called
Sig and Avvy by Mr. Stuff
Looking for people to test T2 with me on MWS, Pacific or Mountain time preffered
I did some mulling over this. It doesn't really make sense for a mafia member to get any benefit out of this statement. I'm going to assume that he has some ability that's good for the town when he's lynched. So, Unvote: Alx, Vote: Godless Angel
While that may be true in a specialty game, or a normal game, this is a newb game. I highly doubt that loran would put an abiltiy like that into a newb game. It WOULD be a cool ability, though. * Silent Prophet takes notes.
Official Deschanel Stalker of The Called
Yeah, that and since this is a newbie game, Godless Angel could just be not understand that being voted for is generally a bad thing. But remind me to try to sign up for the next mafia game SP runs.
Also, I am blinded by the 1000 post smiley bonanza. That and the quantity of green fonts... But again, it would be a little beyond a newbie game for it to be some sort of posting restriction. I'm going to go out on a limb and say coincidence.
This is why I'll unvote if he comes back and says it was an understanding. For now, I'll just assume voting for him = good thing.
EBWODP: "misunderstanding", not understanding. I need sleep.
@WhytePanther. I don't have enough experience to run any kind of mafia game. I DID want to do the newb game, but like I said...not enough experience. If I do get a chance to host, it will be fun for all involved.:D
Official Deschanel Stalker of The Called
Anyone like my custom??
Sig and Avvy by Mr. Stuff
Looking for people to test T2 with me on MWS, Pacific or Mountain time preffered
Ebwop: Your custom has been done before.
The only roles i could possibly see in newb mafia are:
Roleblocker (for mafia)
Cop
Doc
Backup
Vig (probably one-shot vig)
Mason (maybe)
Unvote, Vote Coiled Flame As usual, your insane suppositions (read: SP is "scummy" for confirming last) only serve to discredit you and annoy Wuffles_II.
Anyways, back to trolling
yeah guys i was not exactly serious.
But i have been a vanilla townie who got lynched in the other two games i played here, so why break the cycle?
School was fun, i got my maths assignment.
Vote:atlseal
that wasn't ungrounded and i'm pretty undecided as to whether he is scum or not. but i missed the random voting.
and he voted me.
this post is too long
by that i mean i'll stop if you want
EBWOP: What I mean to say is that, had I known you were joking, I wouldn't have voted for you. Sorry for the misunderstanding.
I find Godless Angel's request to vote for him to be a tad strange, and atlseal's interpretation even stranger - but neither is necessarily indicative of being mafia.
For now I'll keep my vote parked on Good+Evil, at least until he posts substance.
Alx just seems to get really annoyed at a blatent joke early, early, early in the game. Not quite sure what to make of it, but it is worth a note.
He never answered my question about why he voted for silent prophet and not godless angel when both admitted they were guilty of being invisible.
I would hardly say that two votes, especially in the random voting phase, can lead to a lynch of a player, especially when it's 7 to vote. Apparently, in a normal game of mafia, the ratio is about 3 town: 1 mafia. So, with 12 players we can deduce that there are probably around 3 mafia members among us. Which means that the most the votes could increase from 2 is to 5. I'd say the danger zone is probably one more when it gets to 3, because then all it takes is one easily swayed town member to tip the scales and end in a mislynch. Also, voting for yourself always looks scummy in my eyes (if you turn out to be scum, people can't go back later and see your earlier "random voting" choices).
Even though he offered an explaination, something about that post still irks me. It still seems to me like he wants everyone to stop random voting at that point. Although, we have seemingly eased up on the randomness now.
Cubus pointed this out. It hadn't even occurred to me, but this is an OMGUS vote when he states that he missed the random voting.
-----
Of all of the above, I'm most suspicious of StormBlind at the moment, so Vote: StormBlind as my primary scum suspect at the moment.
I will post content after I eat. One or two people seem to be...fishy.
Official Deschanel Stalker of The Called
I didn't find 63 suspicious because of the selfvote, but because of the agressive defense of Wuffles.
I suppose the random voting phase really is over this time, and it's time for me to put my hat in somewhere. I'm starting to like my old random vote again. Godless makes a few comments in #81 that bother me. The OMGUS vote is blatant, but the vanilla townie comment seems a little out of place for someone who has next to no pressure on them, as well as his comment that his post was too long. It doesn't take a lot of reading old game to figure out that was a fairly short post, which means he might have felt he said more than he should have.
Vote: Godless Angel
@Cubus: Your font is dark enough to be readable, don't sweat it, it's the neon greens that are annoying.
I didn't realize that The post that he voted for me for being invisible was right after the post that G_A came out and admitted to it also. Am I supposed to believe that Coiled didn't see the post right before his? I would LOVE to see an explaination.
Official Deschanel Stalker of The Called
Well, now that you told him to remove the self-vote, I'm sure he will...
Uhm, I believe it was *me*, not atlseal, who's been "reading too much into it". Didn't you mean to FOS Alx?
Well, atlseal IS the one who actually voted for him. I suppose the same can be said for you as well. But if you want some attention: We're only about 24 hours into this game, it does seem a little early to try to attract attention to people who haven't posted a whole lot.
As for my statement, truth be told, it IS a common newb tactic for mafia to second vote someone, ESPECIALLY this early in the game.
Truthfully NO meaingful analysis can be made from my... 2 posts?
Either way, scum or town, that is a HORRIBLY agressive play... which only serves the mafia's interests, not the towns.
Another common tactic is to try to point the finger at as many people as possible. which Gives me a FOS: ATLSeal.
Unvote
Yes, i felt there was more i could say. But they were suspicions which were very close to being ungrounded. So i'll wait until i have something to back them with.
That comment about the townie was just me being bitter.
Oh and i've had this font since the start of the year, thereabouts.
However, I'm still suspicious of Sp's sudden surgence in activity.
Unvote, FOS Silent Prophet
Sig and Avvy by Mr. Stuff
Looking for people to test T2 with me on MWS, Pacific or Mountain time preffered
VOTING SOMEONE BECAUSE THEY CHOSE *NOT* TO LURK...WTF?
I actually think it's an OMGUS vote in (very bad) disguise.
Alx:
I fail to see how someone defending ME makes ME suspicious.
I am confused on what sudden surge in activity you are reffering to. Are you comparing my playstyle to other games I've played, or are you still talking about me being the last to confirm?
EBWODP:
I think he's saying that the fact that he is defending you so adamantly suggests that he knows something about your allignment. If that's the case, the only thing it could mean is that you are both mafia. I don't have an opinion one way or the other yet, but it seems like that's the conclusion that alx is suggesting.
@ Coiled Flame. When you answer my question. Please, be as clear and unconfusing as possible.
Official Deschanel Stalker of The Called
It just points toward a potential connection between the two of you, that's all. Or maybe I'm reading too much into it, as someone already said.
During the random period, I think you're only post was to confirm. I'mnot sure, but I didn't notice you a lot. Now, when the random period ended, you suddenly went way up in the number of posts you have made in this thread.
Now that I think over it however, it could just be that you don't really care about the fun-voting period.
Un-FOS
Sig and Avvy by Mr. Stuff
Looking for people to test T2 with me on MWS, Pacific or Mountain time preffered
Official Deschanel Stalker of The Called
And I'm going to vote the next person who mentions "Posting restriction". There is no way in HELL that there would EVER be a PR in a newb mafia game.
But, Godless, please, for the sake of everyone's eyesight, please change your color to a slightly less abusive one
First things, first - Unvote
Random voting time is over, so from now anything posted will take a more serious note.
Pressure time.
Unvote, Vote Whyte Panther