Just wanted to let you guys know that I'm still here. I can't actually post right now but I'll do it in the morning when I wake up. I think I have some ideas of where some people could have screwed up (either as mafia, or newbs), but I'll post later. See you guys.
Hmm... You think I'm a noob? Look at the title of the thread, I'm a noob of the noobiest kind. Yeah, I guess you're right about the claiming, though I really don't see how much it could benefit the mafia if only I claimed... Wow, I bet the mafia will nightkill me tonight if I keep going on about this role that is safe to claim. I guess I'll stop talking about that then.
Well, this is a post, but I don't think this will help the town find anybody to lynch. I have a feeling this will keep going till I come up with another stupid idea and I get lynched, or Doob makes another random comment and he gets lynched. And since I don't really think at this point that either of us is mafia, that would be a problem.
Something about his last paragraph reminds me of my play from newb mafia five. Suggesting a bad idea, then using a the I'm a newb defense, and finally saying that the mafia will just kill you tomorrow but if my hunch is correct he will be alive and saying the mafia is setting him up.
It seems sort of silly to ridicule a company for marketing efforts. Of course they are going to hype upcoming products, every company on the face of the planet does it, and it works, thats why they do it. There isn't really any sense complaining about it. If you don't like the marketing, ignore it.
I'm not the one who suggested that I'm a newb, Kops is. And we are all newbs, so I think the defense is quite solid.
The mafia will kill either somebody who is coming close to them (if they can get them without showing their identities in the process), a power role if they can find one, or somebody who is helping the town. The mafia may believe that I am in the second category, and then kill me.
I'm not saying that they definitely will, I was just saying that it is a possibility and thus I would like to stray away from the subject.
Hmm... Methinks my play must truly suck. Still, isn't it a little weird to start a bandwagon based on how similar my play is to a previous game's scum?
4 votes on me now, 7 to lynch. I don't like where this is going. If avabob turns his FOS to a vote, and the remaining Doob bandwagoners switch to me, I'm gone. A big if, but one I'm not quite comfortable with. Serge is feeling scummy to me, but not quite enough yet to FOS.
Um, Sorryguy? How can I have 2 FOSes on me if only avabob is FOSing me? Is the mistake in the number or the names? If in the names, this is worse than I thought.
Um, Sorryguy? How can I have 2 FOSes on me if only avabob is FOSing me? Is the mistake in the number or the names? If in the names, this is worse than I thought.
God I suck. I copy and pasted Keeper out of FOSing you because he voted you but forgot to change the numbers. You only have one FOS.
I typed out a post defending Charlie, but didn't seem to come up with an argument against the similar play one presented by Serge. By the end of it, I had come to two conclusions. First of all, vote Jlo until he actually posts something constructive. I'll unvote him as soon as he either posts or is replaced. Second, I should probably go read Newb 5 and come to my own conclusions about Charlie's innocence. My own impressions of him have been not scumy up until this point, however. I will say that much.
Serge, if I may be honest, played quite awful in 5. Hunted Charlie's play in this game is replicating that of the last. I see little to be confused about in this situation.
HC is playing the look-at-me, i-don't-have-a-clue-what's-going-on card, in hopes that people will see he's just a townie. Thus far, I've found this unlikely.
Is it possible that he's truely that clueless? Quite. But he's coming off worse and worse to me, while Doob seems to have slipped away into nothingness.
FOS: Doob and Jlo, just because they need to be posting.
so are we getting a replacement for jlo? and i think its also time for a modprod @doob 'cause its been 3 days and 25 minutes since he last posted, lol
I told Jlo I would seek a replacement if he did not post in a day and replace him if he does not in two. I may have to even if he does post, depending on how much he does so after he posts. I have found a replacement and said replacement has read the whole thread so if he need come in we can do so.
As for Doob I just issued a prod. We shall see about him. d#s also needs to be more active and if he does post before tommorow I will also prod him.
Guys, I don't see where you're going here. Apparently my play is similar to the play of a scum in a past game. I don't really think this is that similar, but even if it is, mark one scum point for me. Great, now me, Doob, and a tiny bit Serge all have marks against them. I believe those are the three people that have started a scare so far.
So what now? Lynch me? I don't think it is in the best interests of the town to lynch me. It isn't in the best interests of the town to lynch anybody with this little information. There is no further information I have to give. I proposed claiming, which is what started this new bandwagon, but apparently that is a bad idea too.
So now what? I'm sure you're all very happy that you found another scummy action, but this is still nowhere near a lynch, and we're back to our original problem.
As I stated before, I think Serge feels scummy to me, but even I know that that information is useless to the town.
EBWODP: Now might be a good time to mention this tiny bit of a backup plan:
IF I do die and turn up townie, investigate Serge. I was thinking, and realized that if they could still post, a dead (and thus confirmed) townie would have far more power than a live one. I won't propose that it happen now because I think it would make me look suspiscous, and I am hovering at 4 votes and an FOS and I really don't want to get any closer to my death.
[quote=Hunted Charlie]
So what now? Lynch me? I don't think it is in the best interests of the town to lynch me. It isn't in the best interests of the town to lynch anybody with this little information. [quote]
uhh... so are you saying we should go no lynch? cause that is DEFINATELY not in our best interests... i dunno but your last couple of posts just seem more and more scummy to me, but im not sure yet so i will hold off my vote
Just to clarify, I am definitely NOT suggesting No Lynch. That is bad for the town and should only be used in VERY extreme situations. I am just saying that I don't think we can lynch anybody right now, and I don't see where we will get enough information to be able to lynch anybody.
I don't want to go no lynch, but there is nobody TO lynch. Very different things.
EBWODP: By the way, I would just like to note that I will nameclaim at 5 votes and fullclaim at 6. I think these are pretty good places to do these at, so any objections to that should be voiced now.
Personally, I think lynching one of the most active players in the game is probably a bad idea. However I, along with pretty much everyone else, don't have a better idea.
I also realize that if I keep defending Charlie and he turns up scum I'm in big trouble.
Um. Yes. Are you implying that this would be a bad thing?
I clearly stated that as soon as Jlo (or his replacement) actually posts, I'll stop voting for him.
Objectively, I'm unsure on pretty much everyone at this point. I do not consider myself a good evaluator of scum in this game. At this point, I'm pretty much ready to believe almost anyone should they say they're not scum. And everyone will. So from my point of view, the best course of action is to vote the person who's giving us the least information.
Hence the vote. I don't see how this is a bad idea.
i just checked... jlo has actually been online today so its not like hes on vacation or something... if he is ignoring his prods i call for the replacement to replace him in the next couple of hours cause i really want some feedback from him
sorryguy can we plz get an idea of when jlo's replacement is going to be in? i dont want any1 lynched b4 that, but im pretty sure HC is gonna get my vote, so for now FOS: hunted charlie
Ok, since Jlo is apparently going to be replaced sometime soon, I'll go ahead and unvote. Kops, don't expect the replacement to hit tonight, as even if they show up this evening they'll still have to read the thread.
[quote=SorryGuy]I told Jlo I would seek a replacement if he did not post in a day and replace him if he does not in two. I may have to even if he does post, depending on how much he does so after he posts. I have found a replacement and said replacement has read the whole thread so if he need come in we can do so.[quote]
Sounds more and more like I will be lynched. Everybody says that they don't want to, but 4 votes and 4 FOSes beg to differ. Everybody should slow down. Fast lynches are bad for the town, and the bandwagon on me grew like lightning.
well... i think im gonna have to reread the thread on that one but iirc its been about 10 pages and youre at 3 votes rite now... i dont call that lightning but im gonna go double check now
ok firstly, i apologize for my repeated double posts, ill try to stop... its just that preview doesnt exactly do everything it should lol
secondly: here is recap of votes @ HC
p. 6: jlo votes, never shows up again to unvote so cant rly count this as part of a wagon
p. 8: serge votes
p. 10: absolutionis votes, serge unvotes
p. 13: absolutionis votes... again (without ever unvoting)? not sure why but thought i should mention it
p. 14: serge revotes, keeper votes
and no more votes since then, i didnt actually look up foses although i guess i can if u want me to
lastly, in my previous vote i just realized that ged unvoted jlo, not hc, so you are actually at 4 still, not 3
So it's not really a bandwagonning yet per se. It's kind of serge and Ged and I being overly suspicious on multiple occasions and a randomvote by Jlo...
I don't see myself as being that suspicious of anyone at this point, and I haven't voted anyone yet with the intentions of getting them lynched. I agree with the rest of that though.
just btw, i pmed our mod regarding the replacement so hopefully he will update us soon
Yeah, sorry, I was defending myself from attacks in another mafia game. Anyway I am yet to read this thread so a vote count is forthcoming but bluesoul will be replacing Jlo in this game. His role has been sent and he has read most of the thread so expect to see him soon.
First, of all, my computer has finally been healed, so I can stop trying to steal computers to post on.
Absolutionis: Fine, you don't have to call it a bandwagon. Maybe it is just random votes and oversuspiscion. However, I am still in a real danger of lynch. I have four FOSes on me, and many people have said that they want to change their FOSes to a vote. If only 3 of the 4 people with FOSes chose to do that, I would be lynched. Gone. A loss for the town.
Frankly, I am also finding myself in the position of being locked down by the town. One more vote would have me nameclaim, two for roleclaim, three for death. I don't want even one more vote on me, and since everything I say seems to be suspiscious, I really can't say anything too important at all. Anytime somebody says something big or important, somebody will probably disagree with it. If that person votes me, I am closer to the lynch.
Finally, although the votes may show that this has not been a very fast bandwagon, the posts say otherwise. There was a little bit of suspiscion on me at the beginning, but it just rocketed up a page or three ago.
I think all of you need to think about whether you really want to lynch me (or anybody) because of oversuspiscion and random voting.
well, i definately think its time for a name claim, so im gonna go ahead and vote hunted charlie but that vote will definately come off as soon as he claims whether no matter what, the question is will i revote later, i just want to see his claim cause it could clear some things up
Ok, I didn't really want to do this, but here is my nameclaim:
I am SorryGuy.
By the way, I should tell you in advance that my name doesn't fit too well with my ability. I suspect this is the case for multiple people, but don't say if it is or not, because that might somehow help the mafia.
Please remove your vote, Kops, as I am now at a very precarious position.
Hmm... Now I have a question. Is this nameclaim going to be enough for the group, or will I need to roleclaim? I think this is enough because it is pretty certain that SorryGuy is in the game (I think) and somebody else could easily counterclaim.
He means that given the reasonable knowledge of anyone, they would probably suspect that SorryGuy is in the game. Thus, assuming he is and no one counter-claims SorryGuy, then Hunted_Charlie is allegedly cleared.
No. I am certain that Sorryguy is in this game. I am not certain if it is certain that SorryGuy is in this game. Sorry for the confusing wording. I know that SorryGuy is in this game, I just don't know if everybody else knows. By the way, I really hope everybody that is lurking will leave a comment on this, because I want to end this little assault as soon as possible.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
(click for extendo-sig)
[thread=1306][/thread]
Check my New Sig-Making Thread for some amazing art.
Well, this is a post, but I don't think this will help the town find anybody to lynch. I have a feeling this will keep going till I come up with another stupid idea and I get lynched, or Doob makes another random comment and he gets lynched. And since I don't really think at this point that either of us is mafia, that would be a problem.
vote Hunted Charlie
Something about his last paragraph reminds me of my play from newb mafia five. Suggesting a bad idea, then using a the I'm a newb defense, and finally saying that the mafia will just kill you tomorrow but if my hunch is correct he will be alive and saying the mafia is setting him up.
The mafia will kill either somebody who is coming close to them (if they can get them without showing their identities in the process), a power role if they can find one, or somebody who is helping the town. The mafia may believe that I am in the second category, and then kill me.
I'm not saying that they definitely will, I was just saying that it is a possibility and thus I would like to stray away from the subject.
I read Newb Mafia 5 this morning, and I see the same things that serge does. For now, it's going to be Vote: Hunted Charlie
4 votes on me now, 7 to lynch. I don't like where this is going. If avabob turns his FOS to a vote, and the remaining Doob bandwagoners switch to me, I'm gone. A big if, but one I'm not quite comfortable with. Serge is feeling scummy to me, but not quite enough yet to FOS.
4 Hunted Charlie - Jlo, Absolutionis, serge, KeeperEUSC
2 Doob - darkasecas, d24478667
FOS Count:
3 Doob - avabob, Hunted Charlie, serge
1 Hunted Charlie - avabob
1 avabob - Absolutionis
1 Absolutionis - avabob
1 Jlo - avabob
God I suck. I copy and pasted Keeper out of FOSing you because he voted you but forgot to change the numbers. You only have one FOS.
I'm curious as to what you mean...
I typed out a post defending Charlie, but didn't seem to come up with an argument against the similar play one presented by Serge. By the end of it, I had come to two conclusions. First of all, vote Jlo until he actually posts something constructive. I'll unvote him as soon as he either posts or is replaced. Second, I should probably go read Newb 5 and come to my own conclusions about Charlie's innocence. My own impressions of him have been not scumy up until this point, however. I will say that much.
HC is playing the look-at-me, i-don't-have-a-clue-what's-going-on card, in hopes that people will see he's just a townie. Thus far, I've found this unlikely.
Is it possible that he's truely that clueless? Quite. But he's coming off worse and worse to me, while Doob seems to have slipped away into nothingness.
FOS: Doob and Jlo, just because they need to be posting.
I told Jlo I would seek a replacement if he did not post in a day and replace him if he does not in two. I may have to even if he does post, depending on how much he does so after he posts. I have found a replacement and said replacement has read the whole thread so if he need come in we can do so.
As for Doob I just issued a prod. We shall see about him. d#s also needs to be more active and if he does post before tommorow I will also prod him.
Vote Count:
4 Hunted Charlie - Jlo, Absolutionis, serge, KeeperEUSC
2 Doob - darkasecas, d24478667
1 Jlo - Ged
FOS Count:
4 Doob - avabob, Hunted Charlie, serge, KeeperEUSC
1 Hunted Charlie - avabob
1 avabob - Absolutionis
1 Absolutionis - avabob
2 Jlo - avabob, KeeperEUSC
Seven to lynch.
So what now? Lynch me? I don't think it is in the best interests of the town to lynch me. It isn't in the best interests of the town to lynch anybody with this little information. There is no further information I have to give. I proposed claiming, which is what started this new bandwagon, but apparently that is a bad idea too.
So now what? I'm sure you're all very happy that you found another scummy action, but this is still nowhere near a lynch, and we're back to our original problem.
As I stated before, I think Serge feels scummy to me, but even I know that that information is useless to the town.
IF I do die and turn up townie, investigate Serge. I was thinking, and realized that if they could still post, a dead (and thus confirmed) townie would have far more power than a live one. I won't propose that it happen now because I think it would make me look suspiscous, and I am hovering at 4 votes and an FOS and I really don't want to get any closer to my death.
So what now? Lynch me? I don't think it is in the best interests of the town to lynch me. It isn't in the best interests of the town to lynch anybody with this little information. [quote]
uhh... so are you saying we should go no lynch? cause that is DEFINATELY not in our best interests... i dunno but your last couple of posts just seem more and more scummy to me, but im not sure yet so i will hold off my vote
I don't want to go no lynch, but there is nobody TO lynch. Very different things.
I also realize that if I keep defending Charlie and he turns up scum I'm in big trouble.
Is that why your vote now stands on the least active player?
I clearly stated that as soon as Jlo (or his replacement) actually posts, I'll stop voting for him.
Objectively, I'm unsure on pretty much everyone at this point. I do not consider myself a good evaluator of scum in this game. At this point, I'm pretty much ready to believe almost anyone should they say they're not scum. And everyone will. So from my point of view, the best course of action is to vote the person who's giving us the least information.
Hence the vote. I don't see how this is a bad idea.
Not that FoS's mean anything much anyways...
very true, it completed eluded me....
FOS Hunted Charlie. for the same reason as above.
i beg to differ
secondly: here is recap of votes @ HC
p. 6: jlo votes, never shows up again to unvote so cant rly count this as part of a wagon
p. 8: serge votes
p. 10: absolutionis votes, serge unvotes
p. 13: absolutionis votes... again (without ever unvoting)? not sure why but thought i should mention it
p. 14: serge revotes, keeper votes
and no more votes since then, i didnt actually look up foses although i guess i can if u want me to
lastly, in my previous vote i just realized that ged unvoted jlo, not hc, so you are actually at 4 still, not 3
Yeah, sorry, I was defending myself from attacks in another mafia game. Anyway I am yet to read this thread so a vote count is forthcoming but bluesoul will be replacing Jlo in this game. His role has been sent and he has read most of the thread so expect to see him soon.
Absolutionis: Fine, you don't have to call it a bandwagon. Maybe it is just random votes and oversuspiscion. However, I am still in a real danger of lynch. I have four FOSes on me, and many people have said that they want to change their FOSes to a vote. If only 3 of the 4 people with FOSes chose to do that, I would be lynched. Gone. A loss for the town.
Frankly, I am also finding myself in the position of being locked down by the town. One more vote would have me nameclaim, two for roleclaim, three for death. I don't want even one more vote on me, and since everything I say seems to be suspiscious, I really can't say anything too important at all. Anytime somebody says something big or important, somebody will probably disagree with it. If that person votes me, I am closer to the lynch.
Finally, although the votes may show that this has not been a very fast bandwagon, the posts say otherwise. There was a little bit of suspiscion on me at the beginning, but it just rocketed up a page or three ago.
I think all of you need to think about whether you really want to lynch me (or anybody) because of oversuspiscion and random voting.
Battle Royale Mafia
(Come see who won!)
I am SorryGuy.
By the way, I should tell you in advance that my name doesn't fit too well with my ability. I suspect this is the case for multiple people, but don't say if it is or not, because that might somehow help the mafia.
Please remove your vote, Kops, as I am now at a very precarious position.
Opinions please on how far I need to go.
if u are sorryguy... how are you not sure