I think you misunderstood me. I don't care about how fast the lynch happens, I just think that we have to lynch somebody, and Jlo was the person who had contributed the least. No one currently looks scummy to me, really. Just because Jlo posted doesn't mean he contributed anything. He stopped in to vote me for confusing him (By the way, I must be really bad about that, cause Absolutionis did the same thing) and then say that he wanted a custom tag. He still hasn't contributed much.
Basically, I'm saying that you can talk as long as you want, but unless you make people claim (better for mafia than for us) or the mafia messes up (I think pretty unlikely at this point), we'll have to lynch somebody. And if it comes down to lynching somebody, I'd pick Jlo over anybody else here.
My vote stands, as he is the one I currently would pick to lynch, but don't take that to mean that I want him lynched right now.
By the way, Absolutionis, I don't understand your comment about me "fading out". I believe I have been one of the more active posters in this game. I just haven't done one of those long and annoying posts in a while. 'Cause they're annoying.
By the way, Absolutionis, I don't understand your comment about me "fading out". I believe I have been one of the more active posters in this game. I just haven't done one of those long and annoying posts in a while. 'Cause they're annoying.
Yeah... I'm not voting you... yet...
I'm just FoSing because it seems moderately shady that you stopped making long posts all of a sudden...
By the way, Absolutionis, I don't understand your comment about me "fading out". I believe I have been one of the more active posters in this game. I just haven't done one of those long and annoying posts in a while. 'Cause they're annoying.
or important for everyone to know your analysis of the game state... This seems like a cop out
Quote from Hunted Charlie »
I think you misunderstood me. I don't care about how fast the lynch happens, I just think that we have to lynch somebody, and Jlo was the person who had contributed the least. No one currently looks scummy to me, really. Just because Jlo posted doesn't mean he contributed anything. He stopped in to vote me for confusing him (By the way, I must be really bad about that, cause Absolutionis did the same thing) and then say that he wanted a custom tag. He still hasn't contributed much.
Basically, I'm saying that you can talk as long as you want, but unless you make people claim (better for mafia than for us) or the mafia messes up (I think pretty unlikely at this point), we'll have to lynch somebody. And if it comes down to lynching somebody, I'd pick Jlo over anybody else here.
My vote stands, as he is the one I currently would pick to lynch, but don't take that to mean that I want him lynched right now.
Why do you want someone lynched so badly? Stop being so impatient, seriously. It is against the town's wishes/advantage to speed-lynch. We don't want a lynch this early as it ends the town's ability to gather information. While we have to lynch somebody, it doesn't have to be now, does it. You say you don't care if he is lynched now, but then you give maintain your vote, with no real backing. You say he is the most suspicious, why?
It seems sort of silly to ridicule a company for marketing efforts. Of course they are going to hype upcoming products, every company on the face of the planet does it, and it works, thats why they do it. There isn't really any sense complaining about it. If you don't like the marketing, ignore it.
I never called Jlo the most suspicious. I called him the one who contribute the least, and thus, if deciding who to lynch, the person I would lynch. As I said, I really don't have anybody to be suspicious of yet.
Also, I really don't want a speed-lynch. He has 1 or 2 votes now, with 7 to lynch. I don't see why I can't leave my vote on him to pressure him to do something, contribute.
@absolutionis: Sorry I stopped making so many long posts, I found myself annoying in my first one and I really didn't want to bother seeing as they only made me seem suspicious.
SorryGuy, is there a time limit on the day as of yet? That could also effect the reasonableness of pressing someone.
At some point a deadline may be set but currently I have no motivation or reason to set one. You all have been active and the day is going along well. If things begin to drag then I may set on but it would not be soon.
Vote Count:
2 Hunted Charlie - Jlo, serge
1 Jlo - Hunted Charlie
I was checking this page all day. I was waiting for someone else to say something for me to comment on, since I had said all I need to for the moment.
I expect the silence was because of school, although that didn't seem to stop the chat yesterday.
On the topic of school, I go back to it tomorrow, so expect WAY less posting from me on weekdays from now on. Homework and such. Although I could try to sneak in a post or two from school...
Well, I didn't have school yesterday because it was a teacher plan day or something. But like I said, at this point I've got nothing to say that would be very constructive.
Same here as Emersax. Speaking of Em, you said you weren't going to say anything that hadn't been said. But what are your opinions on the current issues? Same question goes out to everyone, really.
Requested analysis? Well, I didn't see that, but whatever. Assuming you mean analysis of the players, here goes (This might take a while, as I'm going post-by-post on Kops):
Kops:
#3: random vote #7 overdefensive, against making list of famous posters, mentions shaman mafia #8 not much #15 explains shaman mafia reference, dodges irrevelevant question #30 Explains EBWODP, supports not claiming, mentions TFE #41 discourages posting for reaction #46 says to stop random votes#85 unimportant, WHERE HAS HE BEEN? #95 unimporant #100 Jlo still hasn't spoken
Overall, I'd say he isn't very suspicious, though he vanished for a bit.
Jlo: Posted nothing game related.
Avabob: Makes good sense, slightly too aggressive. Jumping on everybody.
Darkasecas: Hasn't posted much, pretty good but nothing particularly helpful.
Emersax: Average, goes along with most everything. Indicates mafia?
Serge: Seems pretty OK, a bit of a buddy with Avabob, though Avabob doesn't seem to buddy with him, so maybe just a tag-along with Avabob.
Ged: Fairly helpful when he comments, which isn't much.
D#s: Whole "posting for reactions" thing pretty scummy, along with post #32, aside from that he seems fine.
Doob: Weird comment still unexplained, FOS's the great one (OK, so I won't count that against him. Still, weird comment)
Keeper: Hasn't posted too much either, but when he does he seems pretty townie. I'd call him the most confirmed, in my mind, of everybody.
Absolutionis: Pretty good, but about half of his posts are accusational or aggressive.
Anyway, that is my analysis of the peoples. I would have good post-by-post on everybody, but I was too tired after I did it for Kops.
lol... should i be flattered or what? and i havnt had anything to say so far because nobody looks overly scummy to me although i do have 1 or 2 hunches that i dont care to mention and what do you mean where have i been???? my last post was 100 as you said... not even 20 posts ago
Ged- Like I said earlier I don't think a lynch in the near future is necessary unless some scum screws up, but how likely that is to happen I'm not sure of. I would like Jlo to post something relevant to the game as it would be nice to get his view on things. I've really got no big suspicions as of now.
No, I was asking a post-specific question. At #85, where had you been for the last 40 posts, was the question. It is better than a lot of people on this thread, but a little weird still.
ok fine i just didnt have anything to say, i really havnt this whole game actually, and im pretty sure i didnt dodge any irrelevant question... i answered it quite clearly in my opinion...
I'm fine with that answer. By the way, thanks to serge and avabob for suggesting the analysis. It really helped me solidify my views about a lot of people. As I go through again, i'm starting to fell more and more like Avabob isn't scum. Serge-- well, I keep getting a suspicious vibe from him. (Yes, I know I will be attacked because I didn't provide a reason.)
I have filtered through all the posts and have come up with my own ideas... so lets keep this rolling shall we?
well, I'm glad you posted to say you have thoughts. Would you like to share those thoughts with us. We can only "keep this rolling" if people post their thoughts (and post at all)
Dammit, Jlo. Lurking does no one good. Post. FOS: Jlo If you can't get on enough, ask for a replacement
Actually, im not too sure what to make of all this randomness...yet. i thought i would throw you guys off by having you think i knew what was going on... i didnt expect to be called out on it.
Actually, im not too sure what to make of all this randomness...yet. i thought i would throw you guys off by having you think i knew what was going on... i didnt expect to be called out on it.
i am still FOS you (avabob)
lame. Don't say anything unless you have something to back it up. Yes, expect to get called on stuff. We want to find the mafia and this is the way to do it. We can't find the mafia if people just say random stuff and confuse the town, which seems an awful lot like what you are trying to do here. You even say that you are trying to throw us off by having us think that you knew what you were doing. And there are some interesting and telling posts here, already. It isn't all random. I would appreciate it if you could actually read the posts and think about what people are saying. FOS: Doob.
Well, Captain Townie, protector of all... i explained in the post when i first FOSed. You are very into protecting the town, how do we know you arent BSing us. very curious...
Well, Captain Townie, protector of all... i explained in the post when i first FOSed. You are very into protecting the town, how do we know you arent BSing us. very curious...
So we are now just accusing everyone who claims they are town of being mafia? That isn't logical, because everyone in the game (unless they are a dumbass) will say that they are town. Noone will say they are mafia, so everyone is suspicious?
and no, I'm not being overly protective, I'm just pointing out possible errors or possible scummy actions. I am not saying "OMG I AM TEH TOWN." I'm saying what would be best for the town, and pointing out who is violating that. Well, as for me BSing you, I think that is getting into WIFOM territory (I BS you, you know I BS you, so you don't accept what I say, but then I realize you know and don't BS you, but then you realize that and take what I say as truth, so I BS, and so on.) I hope that made sense, ask me about it later if you want to.
Is it really curious? Or logical, as I want to win?
I feel that you may be taking this a bit personal... if it seemed i was attacking you, i certaily was not. i was just throwing ideas out there and it is very well possible that you are trying to come off a sure townie and are a mafia. With all that aside i must say that we are the only to stirring the pot right now and some input from other players would help.
I feel that you may be taking this a bit personal... if it seemed i was attacking you, i certaily was not. i was just throwing ideas out there and it is very well possible that you are trying to come off a sure townie and are a mafia. With all that aside i must say that we are the only to stirring the pot right now and some input from other players would help.
This is true, I see that a whole bunch of people are on right now. Why don't you guys help further the discussion
Wow. Very, very suspicious comments from Doob there.
First, you claim to have formulated ideas, don't share them with us, then claim that you did it "to throw us off". I'll assume you meant throwing off the mafia, otherwise I'd give you my vote. But how would thinking that you're thinking hurt the mafia? It just doesn't make sense.
Then you claimed that it is possible that avabob was "trying to come off as a sure townie and are the mafia". Yeah. That is what ALL the mafia are trying to do.
For the reasons above, I FOS Doob and expect an explanation soon, as right now it seems like a slip-up of a mafia trying to go into the "I have ideas" crowd without actually having ideas.
well I think it's suspicious that Dood says he has some ideas and then when he is asked to post them he says he has nothing FoS Dood aside from that I haven't seen anything particulary scummy from other people
By the way, Doob, unless you get a good explanation soon I will give my vote to you, as you certainly seem more suspicious than Jlo (or anyone else) right now. Note that I don't want a speed-lynch, and I don't want this misinterpreted like I do. Votes are a very, very good way of making pressure, since unlike FOS's they carry the possibility of death.
One last note: I think the mafia are playing very well in this game, as they seem to be far less obvious so far than in any of the games I've lurked in.
I would just like to put a bit of emphasis on one of Doob's posts: (I don't know how to use the quote tags, so...)
"Well, Captain Townie, protector of all... i explained in the post when i first FOSed. You are very into protecting the town, how do we know you arent BSing us. very curious... "
I really don't understand what is so curious about this. Anybody could be BSing us. I could, you could, Avabob could, ANYBODY COULD.
That is the whole point of Mafia. So instead, could I have a real reason your FOS is on Avabob?
Duh, i know that anyone could be BSing us... but it seems that he is making an overly protective case... that is why. check the post when i FOSed him the first time.
Edit with a double post.
Actually, i think its pretty interesting that everyone is pinning me. that truly reflects the comment that the mafia are doing a very good job. but just because i mentioned to have some ideas and not had any at that time, i sure have some now.
Hunted Charlie, you keep coming out of nowhere when people seem to be pinning one person... good bandwagon skills.
Avabob has seemed overly zealous in protecting the town... yeah maybe he is a townie, maybe hes not. but to me that set him apart from other players.
So if you suspect me go on ahead, just notice that other people have come off suspicious too and some people havent come off as anything, which can be considered just as suspicious.
Alright, with that taken care of...
I have my doubts that Doob is a mafia. He's too reckless and too open in his talking. He doesn't act defensive enough even when people seem to be against him.
Added to that the fact that it took forever for him to confirm, despite the fact that he was online after the PMs were sent out. I don't know about you all, but if I were a mafia or someone special, I would waste no time to get on these forums and say "SUP" or something. I see Doob as a vanilla townie with no idea what to do.
I've had Hunted Charlie on FoS for awhile now, for reasons mentioned before. Just that fact that Hunted Charlie is so quick to FoS someone for, what seemed to me, as a simple quarrel between avabob and Doob. It just seems that Hunted Charlie was too quick to believe the obvious (to me) randomness of Doob enough to attack him.
I have FoS on avabob merely because Hunted Charlie defended him so quickly. That and because avabob has been overly aggressive. I understand that some people are overly aggressive by nature. It's just the way they are. Ah well, hence it's only a FoS. However, the vote stays, I think Hunted Charlie is shady.
Hmm... My post didn't show up just now, so I guess I'll write it again.
1) Doob, you still haven't answered my argument about why you tried to "throw us off". Seeing as it is the only lead we've got, I really need an explanation before I can remove my vote.
2) Avabob has never been overly defensive, not that I've seen. He seems overly aggressive, which can be a very good thing, actually.
3) I don't see why I am being called overzealous. Both of my votes so far have been made very carefully, and I challenge you to find a vote that was made without proper reasoning. Just because I talk a lot and jump on things very fast doesn't mean I'm scum.
I'd just like to point out a couple things: First of all, avabob: FOS means Finger of Suspicion (although I'm sure I spelled that wrong). Secondly, anyone else heard of the lynch all liars tactic? This implies we lynch Doob. While that's probably to rash even for me, be warned in the future everyone that I support that theory. Lying does no good to the town unless you're protecting a power role (and even then, find a better way).
Posting from school computers, I dropped my iBook and it broke. I'll try to post from one of my family's computers. Don't expect many posts until it is fixed. I can't post right now cause I dont' want to get caught and I want a donut.
Well i guess if talking and sparking interest is bad in a mafia game consider it lesson learned.... this is my first game by the way, and by the tone of it Ged, its seems as if you have played before... maybe not here but on other forums.
Secondly, anyone else heard of the lynch all liars tactic? This implies we lynch Doob. While that's probably to rash even for me, be warned in the future everyone that I support that theory. Lying does no good to the town unless you're protecting a power role (and even then, find a better way).
I thought about this too, but couldn't think of a way to present it that didn't seem scummy. Thanks for doing so. I also believe that Doob was being pretty dumb with his comment. I think however, that he may just be a misguided townie. If it comes to random lynch, he's probably one of our choices.
Doob- No, I've never played before and I know the Lynch all Liars strategy by browsing through here.
I played with him last game and he even referenced the last game he was in. I fail to see how you can go through an entire game of mafia and not know what Fos stands for.
It seems sort of silly to ridicule a company for marketing efforts. Of course they are going to hype upcoming products, every company on the face of the planet does it, and it works, thats why they do it. There isn't really any sense complaining about it. If you don't like the marketing, ignore it.
Yea, I've never played before (except in the ill-fated secret-society mafia that can be found as the first game ever here on MTGS; really, it's like the last post on the last page of the archives), I just have read many a game and have paid attention to the community for a year or two now.
I'm also not pushing the LAL tactic because this is a newb game and everyone is bound to make mistakes. I'm sure I have by now. Still, be warry in the future everyone. Lying can only hurt us.
Serge, I really don't think that's a good reason for voting for someone. I can see your point, but what would lying about not know what FOS means get you as scum? I can easily see just not bothering to ask about it.
Doob, you don't need to lie to spark interest. You keep dodging my question, and you look more and more suspiscous each time.
By the way, thanks for bringing up LAL, Ged. I hadn't really thought of that, but I now see that as yet another reason for me to keep my vote on Doob.
Serge, that really isn't any reason to vote avabob. If you were feeling really harsh or something you might FOS him, but I just don't see how his actions deserved a vote.
Basically, I'm saying that you can talk as long as you want, but unless you make people claim (better for mafia than for us) or the mafia messes up (I think pretty unlikely at this point), we'll have to lynch somebody. And if it comes down to lynching somebody, I'd pick Jlo over anybody else here.
My vote stands, as he is the one I currently would pick to lynch, but don't take that to mean that I want him lynched right now.
Yeah... I'm not voting you... yet...
I'm just FoSing because it seems moderately shady that you stopped making long posts all of a sudden...
or important for everyone to know your analysis of the game state... This seems like a cop out
Why do you want someone lynched so badly? Stop being so impatient, seriously. It is against the town's wishes/advantage to speed-lynch. We don't want a lynch this early as it ends the town's ability to gather information. While we have to lynch somebody, it doesn't have to be now, does it. You say you don't care if he is lynched now, but then you give maintain your vote, with no real backing. You say he is the most suspicious, why?
I'd like to hear some analysis, please
(click for extendo-sig)
[thread=1306][/thread]
Check my New Sig-Making Thread for some amazing art.
Vote Hunted Charlie
When I placed the vote it was in joke tags but I wasn't joking.
Also, I really don't want a speed-lynch. He has 1 or 2 votes now, with 7 to lynch. I don't see why I can't leave my vote on him to pressure him to do something, contribute.
@absolutionis: Sorry I stopped making so many long posts, I found myself annoying in my first one and I really didn't want to bother seeing as they only made me seem suspicious.
At some point a deadline may be set but currently I have no motivation or reason to set one. You all have been active and the day is going along well. If things begin to drag then I may set on but it would not be soon.
Vote Count:
2 Hunted Charlie - Jlo, serge
1 Jlo - Hunted Charlie
FOS Count:
3 Hunted Charlie - darkasecas, avabob, Absolutonius
1 avabob - Doob
1 Absolutonius - avabob
1 Doob - KeeperEUSC
1 KeeperEUSC - Doob
1 Jlo - darkasecas
I return from classes only to realize that nobody has posted anything since last night...
And my name is mispelled, what a bonus!
And I thought about posting earlier, but realized I didn't have anything to say that hasn't already been said.
But from the relentless barrage of postings last night, it was an awkward silence today...
I expect the silence was because of school, although that didn't seem to stop the chat yesterday.
On the topic of school, I go back to it tomorrow, so expect WAY less posting from me on weekdays from now on. Homework and such. Although I could try to sneak in a post or two from school...
And Hunted C, both serge and I have requested analysis. Can we have one please?
(click for extendo-sig)
[thread=1306][/thread]
Check my New Sig-Making Thread for some amazing art.
Kops:
#3: random vote #7 overdefensive, against making list of famous posters, mentions shaman mafia #8 not much #15 explains shaman mafia reference, dodges irrevelevant question #30 Explains EBWODP, supports not claiming, mentions TFE #41 discourages posting for reaction #46 says to stop random votes#85 unimportant, WHERE HAS HE BEEN? #95 unimporant #100 Jlo still hasn't spoken
Overall, I'd say he isn't very suspicious, though he vanished for a bit.
Jlo: Posted nothing game related.
Avabob: Makes good sense, slightly too aggressive. Jumping on everybody.
Darkasecas: Hasn't posted much, pretty good but nothing particularly helpful.
Emersax: Average, goes along with most everything. Indicates mafia?
Serge: Seems pretty OK, a bit of a buddy with Avabob, though Avabob doesn't seem to buddy with him, so maybe just a tag-along with Avabob.
Ged: Fairly helpful when he comments, which isn't much.
D#s: Whole "posting for reactions" thing pretty scummy, along with post #32, aside from that he seems fine.
Doob: Weird comment still unexplained, FOS's the great one (OK, so I won't count that against him. Still, weird comment)
Keeper: Hasn't posted too much either, but when he does he seems pretty townie. I'd call him the most confirmed, in my mind, of everybody.
Absolutionis: Pretty good, but about half of his posts are accusational or aggressive.
Anyway, that is my analysis of the peoples. I would have good post-by-post on everybody, but I was too tired after I did it for Kops.
Enjoy.
well, I'm glad you posted to say you have thoughts. Would you like to share those thoughts with us. We can only "keep this rolling" if people post their thoughts (and post at all)
Dammit, Jlo. Lurking does no one good. Post. FOS: Jlo If you can't get on enough, ask for a replacement
(click for extendo-sig)
[thread=1306][/thread]
Check my New Sig-Making Thread for some amazing art.
i am still FOS you (avabob)
lame. Don't say anything unless you have something to back it up. Yes, expect to get called on stuff. We want to find the mafia and this is the way to do it. We can't find the mafia if people just say random stuff and confuse the town, which seems an awful lot like what you are trying to do here. You even say that you are trying to throw us off by having us think that you knew what you were doing. And there are some interesting and telling posts here, already. It isn't all random. I would appreciate it if you could actually read the posts and think about what people are saying. FOS: Doob.
And out of curiousity, what is the FOS for?
(click for extendo-sig)
[thread=1306][/thread]
Check my New Sig-Making Thread for some amazing art.
So we are now just accusing everyone who claims they are town of being mafia? That isn't logical, because everyone in the game (unless they are a dumbass) will say that they are town. Noone will say they are mafia, so everyone is suspicious?
and no, I'm not being overly protective, I'm just pointing out possible errors or possible scummy actions. I am not saying "OMG I AM TEH TOWN." I'm saying what would be best for the town, and pointing out who is violating that. Well, as for me BSing you, I think that is getting into WIFOM territory (I BS you, you know I BS you, so you don't accept what I say, but then I realize you know and don't BS you, but then you realize that and take what I say as truth, so I BS, and so on.) I hope that made sense, ask me about it later if you want to.
Is it really curious? Or logical, as I want to win?
(click for extendo-sig)
[thread=1306][/thread]
Check my New Sig-Making Thread for some amazing art.
This is true, I see that a whole bunch of people are on right now. Why don't you guys help further the discussion
(click for extendo-sig)
[thread=1306][/thread]
Check my New Sig-Making Thread for some amazing art.
First, you claim to have formulated ideas, don't share them with us, then claim that you did it "to throw us off". I'll assume you meant throwing off the mafia, otherwise I'd give you my vote. But how would thinking that you're thinking hurt the mafia? It just doesn't make sense.
Then you claimed that it is possible that avabob was "trying to come off as a sure townie and are the mafia". Yeah. That is what ALL the mafia are trying to do.
For the reasons above, I FOS Doob and expect an explanation soon, as right now it seems like a slip-up of a mafia trying to go into the "I have ideas" crowd without actually having ideas.
FoS Dood
aside from that I haven't seen anything particulary scummy from other people
By the way, Doob, unless you get a good explanation soon I will give my vote to you, as you certainly seem more suspicious than Jlo (or anyone else) right now. Note that I don't want a speed-lynch, and I don't want this misinterpreted like I do. Votes are a very, very good way of making pressure, since unlike FOS's they carry the possibility of death.
One last note: I think the mafia are playing very well in this game, as they seem to be far less obvious so far than in any of the games I've lurked in.
I would just like to put a bit of emphasis on one of Doob's posts: (I don't know how to use the quote tags, so...)
"Well, Captain Townie, protector of all... i explained in the post when i first FOSed. You are very into protecting the town, how do we know you arent BSing us. very curious... "
I really don't understand what is so curious about this. Anybody could be BSing us. I could, you could, Avabob could, ANYBODY COULD.
That is the whole point of Mafia. So instead, could I have a real reason your FOS is on Avabob?
Edit with a double post.
Actually, i think its pretty interesting that everyone is pinning me. that truly reflects the comment that the mafia are doing a very good job. but just because i mentioned to have some ideas and not had any at that time, i sure have some now.
Hunted Charlie, you keep coming out of nowhere when people seem to be pinning one person... good bandwagon skills.
Avabob has seemed overly zealous in protecting the town... yeah maybe he is a townie, maybe hes not. but to me that set him apart from other players.
So if you suspect me go on ahead, just notice that other people have come off suspicious too and some people havent come off as anything, which can be considered just as suspicious.
(click for extendo-sig)
[thread=1306][/thread]
Check my New Sig-Making Thread for some amazing art.
unFoS hunted Charlie
Vote Hunted Charlie
FOS avabob
Alright, with that taken care of...
I have my doubts that Doob is a mafia. He's too reckless and too open in his talking. He doesn't act defensive enough even when people seem to be against him.
Added to that the fact that it took forever for him to confirm, despite the fact that he was online after the PMs were sent out. I don't know about you all, but if I were a mafia or someone special, I would waste no time to get on these forums and say "SUP" or something. I see Doob as a vanilla townie with no idea what to do.
I've had Hunted Charlie on FoS for awhile now, for reasons mentioned before. Just that fact that Hunted Charlie is so quick to FoS someone for, what seemed to me, as a simple quarrel between avabob and Doob. It just seems that Hunted Charlie was too quick to believe the obvious (to me) randomness of Doob enough to attack him.
I have FoS on avabob merely because Hunted Charlie defended him so quickly. That and because avabob has been overly aggressive. I understand that some people are overly aggressive by nature. It's just the way they are. Ah well, hence it's only a FoS. However, the vote stays, I think Hunted Charlie is shady.
1) Doob, you still haven't answered my argument about why you tried to "throw us off". Seeing as it is the only lead we've got, I really need an explanation before I can remove my vote.
2) Avabob has never been overly defensive, not that I've seen. He seems overly aggressive, which can be a very good thing, actually.
3) I don't see why I am being called overzealous. Both of my votes so far have been made very carefully, and I challenge you to find a vote that was made without proper reasoning. Just because I talk a lot and jump on things very fast doesn't mean I'm scum.
~HC
I thought about this too, but couldn't think of a way to present it that didn't seem scummy. Thanks for doing so. I also believe that Doob was being pretty dumb with his comment. I think however, that he may just be a misguided townie. If it comes to random lynch, he's probably one of our choices.
Doob- No, I've never played before and I know the Lynch all Liars strategy by browsing through here.
vote avabob
I played with him last game and he even referenced the last game he was in. I fail to see how you can go through an entire game of mafia and not know what Fos stands for.
Yea, I've never played before (except in the ill-fated secret-society mafia that can be found as the first game ever here on MTGS; really, it's like the last post on the last page of the archives), I just have read many a game and have paid attention to the community for a year or two now.
I'm also not pushing the LAL tactic because this is a newb game and everyone is bound to make mistakes. I'm sure I have by now. Still, be warry in the future everyone. Lying can only hurt us.
Serge, I really don't think that's a good reason for voting for someone. I can see your point, but what would lying about not know what FOS means get you as scum? I can easily see just not bothering to ask about it.
I've pretty much agreed with the statements made on this page about him, and I think it's fair to take my FOS off of him and place it elsewhere.
I believe in LAL, when we have nothing else to go off of. I don't really find the FOS thing that out-of-the ordinary.
I don't have enough to base anything off at the moment, and I'll stay where I am
FTR: Tomorrow's my birthday, I can pretty much guarentee I won't be able to post
By the way, thanks for bringing up LAL, Ged. I hadn't really thought of that, but I now see that as yet another reason for me to keep my vote on Doob.
Serge, that really isn't any reason to vote avabob. If you were feeling really harsh or something you might FOS him, but I just don't see how his actions deserved a vote.
means why did you FOS me? (@doob) not wat does fos mean