i saw that post; i never realized it was a response to mine
Batman can jump in here any time to clarify his own remarks. However, I think this is a pretty clear case. Batman never claimed to have secret information. What he said was:
Quote from Batman »
I will not, however be voting for imhungry. I think I know what he's up to. It's not smart, but he seems dead set on continueing.
Now, Batman bandwagonned on his original vote for imhungry, and later changed his rationale for voting. That's pretty suspect. However, the fact that he was willing to take heat from the town and not reveal his hunch about imhungry makes him less suspicious in my eyes. He was, if we believe him, trying to protect a possible power role. Obviously, a clever scum could pretend to be protecting a townie, but Batman hasn't shown himself to be very clever thus far. That's why my vote is on imhungry rather than batman.
@morris- you were one of the first defenders of imhungry, but you haven't said anything about him lately. Do you agree with my arguments?
@notstevie- anything new to say about either batman or imhungry?
@mozart- do you care to explain your vote any more?
@BBTigger and duberz- would you guys care to make at least one serious comment on the game so far?
@HunterDuck- Do you admit now that outing Batman as a possible cop was a mistake, or do you stand by it?
@chimichangaland- Do you even exist?
@Mr. DiFranco- If no one else posts, we can at least make this into an Ani discussion thread. I love Ani!
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Sig by, uh, me. The Untitled shop gave me an awesome Huey banner, but it just wasn't threatening.
@morris- you were one of the first defenders of imhungry, but you haven't said anything about him lately. Do you agree with my arguments?
the brutal truth is that i have extreme difficulty reading imhungry's writing. when he posts i just see "derf derf derfity derf i'm stupid". i'm clearly a horrible person...
batman's writing, however...
so i prodded him a little. and a good time was had by all
so when it comes to imhungry i've been a little lazy. maybe later...
but i can say with ease that i approve more of the way you've been discussing imhungry's posts than the method used by batman. voting for someone for spelling errors is dumb. voting for someone for lying is smart.
the question is: is your analysis right or not? i don't know yet...
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
if we could make cop cars that ran on human blood we would be set
@HunterDuck- Do you admit now that outing Batman as a possible cop was a mistake, or do you stand by it?
if we are to accept batman's subsequent post as an explanation, i believe he's no longer a possible suspect for cop - he didn't have information, he had a theory. that being said, it does give the mafia one less target to shoot for (which is, admitedly, not a good thing).
however, i'm still suspicious of batman based purely on silly voting and wishy-washy posting. unvote: batman
i'm also hesitant to vote for imhungry, as he strikes me not as mafia, but as idiot: he's just so newblet. his actions can't be taken for skill, and he's utterly unpredictable. any mafia tells he exudes shouldn't be accepted as signs that he is... well... mafia.
but, LAL is usually a fairly solid principle; i just don't know if it can be applied in this situation.
@BBTigger and duberz- would you guys care to make at least one serious comment on the game so far?
...
@chimichangaland- Do you even exist?
Agreed and seconded...
Quote from Wolfgang Amadeus »
@Mr. DiFranco- If no one else posts, we can at least make this into an Ani discussion thread. I love Ani!
You rock and thus win, I recently attended one of her concerts...she is amazing live.
I wonder, what with this being a music game and all, if Ani is possibly a character...or if Unsan even knows who she is...-_-, or if even folk is involved...actually it's really early in the morning, and I'm not even sure if there characters in this game.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
-[thread=14456]The [Untitled] Avatar and Sig shop![/thread] Avatar from:[thread=25376] [Epic Graphics][/thread]
You rock and thus win, I recently attended one of her concerts...she is amazing live.
I wonder, what with this being a music game and all, if Ani is possibly a character...or if Unsan even knows who she is...-_-, or if even folk is involved...actually it's really early in the morning, and I'm not even sure if there characters in this game.
it's a safe bet that roles are genres of music, i'd say
an analysis of imhungry
with post numbers instead of imhungry's username
Quote from 31 »
well this game is started and all i have to say is why vecna.... so ill random vote: notmafia for a bad french accent (if u were actually trying one)
not mafia wrote "le confirmed" instead of "confirmed." french people and their moutaches... sheesh.
Quote from 33 »
well morris if i think u r who i think u r then i no who u r (wow confusing) but ya that was good humor...
thanks barn :tongue2:
Quote from 38 »
well this game is going slowly.... and unvote plz dont be a lurker cause then when we come for u the votes will be really screwy
the game is going slowly after a meager 38 posts? what a noob
Quote from 41 »
actually i think that rikkos is still voting for unvote....
and ya fos:stevie i no ur not in the game but still i think after ur post u should be....
this is because of my vote on fadeblue. again, what a barn
it is worth noting that steviet92 meddled in this game even though he wasn't in it. otherwise imhungry would never have made this post
Quote from 44 »
well then ill unvote, vote:batman for the same reasons above
the reasons above was batman replacing notmafia. still trying to be funny...
Quote from 46 »
o well thats fine so ill unvote thx for clearin
this is because batman confirmed his lack of frenchiness. i urge you all to do the same.
Quote from 51 »
i think the reaason for only 1 death is cause of the not enough choices thingy.... i mean he held it 1 more day for that. we seem only to have 1 giant group of mafia (if there is only 1 group that would be like 6 ppl in a group)
don't these two statements contradict each other? at least he has an interesting theory about the serial killer possibly existing but being awol
Quote from 57 »
well i think i agree with True Beliver on the unvote thingy. as for the notstevie sayin that his main account is stevie is claiming so i wouldnt be surprised if unsan is upset....
imhungry is essentially right here. let's find the quote, shall we?
Also, FOS Mr DiFranco and FOS imhungry for FOSing my main account. That's just not very nice of you.
see? notstevie says his main account is that which imhungry FOS'd, which in #41 is clearly steviet92. this is essentially a claim.
Quote from 59 »
im not dont take it personally but someone brought it up so i responded....
this was in response to:
Are you trying to get me killed by the mod or something??? That's pretty sneaky of you, if you are.
WellOfLostGnomes did bring it up before imhungry in post #55
Quote from 61 »
Quote from notstevie92 »
I guess we'll see what's up in the end, but that still seems kinda fishy to me.
fishy.... so almost claiming to a point where u call it fake and then getting mad at somebody who thinks u claimed is not fishy?
this is what i mean when i say imhungry is stupid. he tries to defend himself and ends up saying nothing intelligible
Quote from 63 »
im not treing to get u killed.... i already said that i just thought that was alloitle beyond a joke....
if anyone can tell me what this post means, please do tell
Quote from 65 »
y would i want u killed to begin with?
because it's the mafia's job to kill the townies, right?
just sayin'
(what an idiot)
Quote from 68 »
i no what the mafias job is but i dont want to kill u cause u might help the town i just was pointing out that u pretty much claimed....
finally something that seems a little scummy
"i dont want 2 get u killed but i am just going to point out that you claimed, over and over again, til the mod takes notice or something..."
course, imhungry might just be clarifying his position. suspicious, yeah, a little. but not that easy... you need more to earn your noose
Quote from 70 »
im pretty sure it was vecna who said it wasnt stevie but i could be wrong...
btw this is how i noramally post...
vecna did say notstevie was, erm, not stevie (post 15)
Quote from 72 »
cause of his stupid joke... im just guessin i have no clue who these ppl r
"ho ho ho, morris' jokes are stupid"
well you're stupid
stupid head
Quote from 74 »
yes cause the joke gave some info away that i hope is true...
the joke i made just a second ago gives away some information you will find to be true
Quote from 76 »
then morris is good at sublimible hints (if the info is true and that is what he was doin)
[subliminal]imhungry is a stupid head[/subliminal]
Quote from 78 »
k but y should i tell u
this is response to the post about what the last letter of my name is.
Quote from 80 »
k fine i think his last letter is E (not in caps but the caps r so u can tell which letter)
allow me to assist you
morris
Quote from 82 »
well then what last letter did u get?
notstevie got L. this is a common misconception. there is more than one
Quote from 85 »
intresting but i still think its the person im thinkin of...
i am the voice inside your head
kill kill kill kill kill kill
Quote from 89 »
lol i think were talkin about morris...
can you dig it?
...
it's a shaft reference, you twits
Quote from 91 »
as for the spelling pard srry im a horrible speller (i will try and improve but again ive benn tryin for a long time...) as for the thing with stevie we were at first argueing about his *fake* claim.. but then we switched subjects and started guessin who ppl r and how is that a waste? also i do take this game seriosly and think other ppl should aswell
it's a waste because it doesn't matter
at all
but what do you care? you're a stupid head
Quote from 93 »
u dont have to belive me but I am telling the truth....
and the award for worst mafia post ever goes to...
Quote from 110 »
If to save myself all i have to do is spell better and not use abbrevations then i will do it
.... because that's what's really important
Quote from 116 »
But you are the person who brought it up, you voted for me on the grammar and said you were not voting for the grammar but for scummyness. Did I get something wrong or am I completly confused. (I think I got rid of all the spelling and grammar errors happy?)
the lack of question mark at the end of his sentence is truly hilarious
but seriously, he has a point. i should know, because i made it before he did.
***i want to point out that with, one very small exception, imhungry has been rather unscummy. sure, he pointed out that notstevie did something that could get him modkilled, but that's relatively okay because, uh, he did do something that could get him modkilled. this is also where i was defending him, because i don't think he did anything that horrible at this point. later on i stop defending him very much at all.***
Quote from 122 »
Because in my mind I still think that NotStevie is Stevie (I know that it has been said that he is Stevie). And wait if Vecna knew that NotStevie was not Stevie did he know who NotStevie really was?
earlier you very, very clearly indicated that vecna said notstevie was not stevie. do you not realize that vec is a freaking mod? is your ignorance really so deep? even in your case, such nearly-limitless obliviousness is hard to believe :slant:
maybe we give you the benefit of the doubt here. maybe we don't. in any case, let's just say you're flat-out wrong and move on.
Quote from 124 »
I answered the question truthfully now you can either belive it or say that I am lying. I am not going to lie to make you belive I am telling the truth.
guess what? they choose the "say you're lying" option
***some irrelevant posts where he completely fails to understand what batman is saying***
Quote from 132 »
I know who Vecna is and what he does but I still think if he is in the game he should not know other peoples blind accounts. I have heard of mafia and played many times before this.
so much for the benefit of the doubt
if you're going to vote for imhungry, this should be why
Quote from 135 »
I thought vecna was playing as of Anyone_but_me had vecna avy
@lurkers post or we will lynch you
the first part could very well be a lie to cover his ass
or he could actually be that stupid
i'm going with "entwine"
Quote from 137 »
I would like to find out myself too... he seams to know what I am doing when even I dont know what I am doing...
honesty, how refreshing :tongue2:
***imhungry does some posts where he gets mad at lurkers. a popular distraction***
Quote from 149 »
Well I agree with HunterDuck on this I think Batman is mafia that wanted to get attention away from himself by pointing out that I said or did something that only he know (ya only him not even me(repeated for like the third time today)) so I will vote:Batman
how can you acuse someone of directing attention away from themselves? you've been spamming up the thread with your pointless drivel since the very beginning
Quote from 151 »
Thats the type of spam we need to get rid of if we want the lurkers to post...
Its also irrelevent....
pot/kettle
Quote from 154 »
My vote on batman was so that he would tell us what he knows about me. I dont think anybody should be lynched untill everybody has posted (or died from mod kill of not posting...)
actually, your vote on batman was because you think he's mafia that wanted to get attention away from himself by point out that you said or did something that only he knows... him, not even you. if in the future you ever forget why you voted for someone, may i suggest scrolling up and reading your own posts
Quote from 158 »
Actually I just noticed that Stevies real name is StevieT92 I think now I realize that Not Stevie is not Stevie just wanted to clear that up. I know it may seem weird that as people pay attention to something I then change it, my reason is so when I saw people realizing that I checked my information about the two (by looking at one of stevies posts and came across the T
this is an unbelievable story. if you're gonna lie, you need to try better than that
*** at this point i make my post 161, where i said imhungry's "primary crimes include illiteracy and a childlike fascination with the irrelevant." i may have been wrong... as my analysis indicates, he was plenty stupid early on, and i had already dismissed him as a mere idiot***
Quote from 189 »
I already explained my vote on Batman. It wasnt a bandwagon vote but a vote to reveal what he knew about me
some 30 posts later imhungry is still holding to his story of why he voted for batman even though people who can read had already, uh, read. what he posted. and commented on it. :slant:
conclusion time!
so what are the facts on imhungry?
- he's the most prolific poster in the thread. by far. this indicates that he's playing real aggressively, and thus has the greatest chance of making errors
- he's clearly more used to live mafia games (which are more talking-based) than he is with the internet kind
- he is illogical at times. the whole fiasco with the (second) t in stevie's name is simply weird
- he's a liar. he voted for one reason, then said he voted for a different reason
- last, but not least, he is a stupid head.
until now, i'd overlooked imhungry's lie. i failed to notice it within the sea of stupid that is his post style. besides, he seemed really out of his element, so it seemed sort of innocent. so i dismissed it for a long time... however, the time of neglect is now over! unvote, then vote imhungry. "lynch all liars" is what they tell me back at the ranch
by the way, fos batman. you're not off the hook yet
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
if we could make cop cars that ran on human blood we would be set
Well, it goes without saying that, there is a lot of evidence piled up on imhungry. That is mostly because the thread has been rather...dead. With imhungry not posting anything resembling a defense (actually, not posting at all), we have had nothing better to do then review his (many) posts. Needless to say, it's 6:30 in the morning and I haven't slept in a while...leading me to my point. I must say that Morris has put more jokes, subliminal jokes, and puns, both blatant and subtle, in that last post then I have ever seen in one area. That includes the book I wrote titled "Witty puns to use in forums" (that also, like the brain of imhungry, doesn't exist).
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
-[thread=14456]The [Untitled] Avatar and Sig shop![/thread] Avatar from:[thread=25376] [Epic Graphics][/thread]
I just noticed this. Imhungry's first post in the game...
Quote from Serf_or_Surf?, Post 30 »
Did they really need to kill our Vecna charecter? Come on mafia, he isn't that good a player....
Quote from imhungry, Post 31 »
well this game is started and all i have to say is why vecna.... so ill random vote: notmafia for a bad french accent (if u were actually trying one)
This is in response to anyone_but_me being killed. Could it be that imhungry really did think Vecna was playing??? What kind of a mind are we dealing with here?
btw, serf, we haven't heard from you in quite a while.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Sig by, uh, me. The Untitled shop gave me an awesome Huey banner, but it just wasn't threatening.
Both of imhungry's and Batman's sudden disappearances are very disconcerting. imhungry especially needs to post some sort of comprehensible defense. I doubt this will happen though.
morris, that was by far the most amusing PBP I've ever read. However, the only new evidence you brought up was your undeniable proof that imhungry is indeed a stupid head. Overall, I'm still unconvinced that imhungry is anything else. *paints the kettle red*
Quote from Wolfgang Amadeus »
@Mr. DiFranco- If no one else posts, we can at least make this into an Ani discussion thread. I love Ani!
Quote from WellOfLostGnomes »
You rock and thus win, I recently attended one of her concerts...she is amazing live.
Hells yeah. Ya hear that folks? Get to talkin' or this game will be commandeered for the discussion of liberalist folk music!
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"i live in new york, new york, the city that never shuts up
in the daylight everything is so gory you can hear snatches of stranger's sorry stories
and i moved there from buffalo
but that's nothing the trico plant moved to mexico
left my uncle standing out in the cold
said here's your last paycheck have fun growing old"
morris, that was by far the most amusing PBP I've ever read. However, the only new evidence you brought up was your undeniable proof that imhungry is indeed a stupid head. Overall, I'm still unconvinced that imhungry is anything else. *paints the kettle red*
thanks
however, imhungry is a liar. #149 and #154 directly contradict each other i don't know if that's new but it's evidence sure enough
i'm honestly not all that sure imhungry is scum either. this early in the game such things are quite difficult. but he's a liar *shrug* so i am comfortable with my vote
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
if we could make cop cars that ran on human blood we would be set
That has been brought up, and I still feel it very likely could have been a mistake on his part. He is, afterall, a stupid head.
I'm tempted to vote imhungry simply because I don't see any other leads, but I'm just not convinced he's mafia.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"i live in new york, new york, the city that never shuts up
in the daylight everything is so gory you can hear snatches of stranger's sorry stories
and i moved there from buffalo
but that's nothing the trico plant moved to mexico
left my uncle standing out in the cold
said here's your last paycheck have fun growing old"
Sorry for my dissapearance folks, I was sick. Looking at the computer screen made me puke. : Puke: (It needs to come back)
I'll fully catch up tonight and start posting again. Promise.
I must say though, I have read the PBPA on imhungry and I think I was off base with my theory on imhungry. I still believe he is faking it, but I dout that it's to protect a power role.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Thanks bobinite of the Untitled Shop for the banner. Which, Ironicly I can't see right now.
as much as we all love PBPAs, i'm going to have to reiterate myself and again say that while LAL is normally a good principle, it's unwise to apply in it such an extreme situation (he's an idiot.)
but there's not much else going on, and a vote could make him appear. another one, i mean. vote imhungry
@notstevie- anything new to say about either batman or imhungry?
Not really. I just got back from a friend's, and I'm still having trouble figuring out whether they are just silly or scum. Hard to say for sure right now.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
AHHH MOTHERLAND!!!! (For the ignorant: I am Russia)
Team im gOnna be gone for a feW days, stupid court subpeoNa's. hopefully, i will be back and Very active after I Get back. I think imhungry is mafia, and he is trying to draw attention to himself to affect the late game.
[QUOTE=BBtigger]Team im gOnna be gone for a feW days, stupid court subpeoNa's. hopefully, i will be back and Very active after I Get back. I think imhungry is mafia, and he is trying to draw attention to himself to affect the late game.
Vote Hungry[/QUOTE]
Well...I'm glad that after enough people complained (about bad grammar and poor posting style) everyone has started making sense and cleaning things up. Also, "capping" random letters makes reading and comprehending posts so much easier, I wish everyone would do it. [/end sarcasm]
Why would mafia draw attention to themselves to "affect the late game"? Actually, mafia members know that they really should try not to stand out too much in the beginning. I think that he might have realized this too late and that could be the reason for his sudden disappearance.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
-[thread=14456]The [Untitled] Avatar and Sig shop![/thread] Avatar from:[thread=25376] [Epic Graphics][/thread]
now that the "day" has gone this far, and the inevitable conclusion is clear (imhungry would have been lynched) i have something to tell you all...
i'm the cop
not only that, but i was rather lucky last night. clearly with a name like rice cakes, someone must be evil. at least that what i thought. and a quick investigation proved me right. he is most assuredly "evil" so unvote imhungry and vote rikos.
i have been planning on telling you all this from the beginning, but i wanted to see what would happen over the course of the day. i think we learned a lot more this way than if i had just come out with it in the beginning
i came out now because i hit a scum last night. if i'd hit a townie i probably wouldn't be copclaiming right now. the way i see it is, why lynch "in the dark" when you know you can hit? eh?
in any case, the doctor's job henceforth is to keep me alive and y'all better get around to unvoting. from this point on the day is fairly straightforward, wouldn't ya say?
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
if we could make cop cars that ran on human blood we would be set
not only that, but i was rather lucky last night. clearly with a name like rice cakes, someone must be evil. at least that what i thought. and a quick investigation proved me right. he is most assuredly "evil" so unvote imhungry and vote rikos.
in any case, the doctor's job henceforth is to keep me alive and y'all better get around to unvoting. from this point on the day is fairly straightforward, wouldn't ya say?
Well....uh.....yeah. As this would be a terrible Mafia tactic, except to flush out the Cop I am inclined to believe it. So, barring a counterclaim, I guess you've got my vote.
I guess this means we lose our Vig tonight. :-(
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Thanks bobinite of the Untitled Shop for the banner. Which, Ironicly I can't see right now.
I always hate to miss a lynch and I really thought we were going to. With morris being protected by the doc, we could win just off of that. So, to the doc(in case it isn't obvious), do NOT role claim. We need you alive.
And no morris, no one vig claimed. I don't know why batty said that, he may have gotten this game mixed up with another one.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"i live in new york, new york, the city that never shuts up
in the daylight everything is so gory you can hear snatches of stranger's sorry stories
and i moved there from buffalo
but that's nothing the trico plant moved to mexico
left my uncle standing out in the cold
said here's your last paycheck have fun growing old"
now that the "day" has gone this far, and the inevitable conclusion is clear (imhungry would have been lynched) i have something to tell you all...
i'm the cop
not only that, but i was rather lucky last night. clearly with a name like rice cakes, someone must be evil. at least that what i thought. and a quick investigation proved me right. he is most assuredly "evil" so unvote imhungry and vote rikos.
Hmmmmmmm, You don't see a cop claim this early in the game that often.
Risky tactic, but I guess there's more then one way to skin a cat.:kitty:
It maybe a costly tactic but we will have to try to capitalize on it.
vote rikos
I suggest everyone join in and come tomorrow if Morris is lying we lynch him like a lying little rat.
If he's not lying, I say we ride this horse till it drops. Waaa Hooooo!:dance2:
Doctor, I hope you know what to do tonight. Protect Morris.
Guys, I'm actually much more inexperienced at this mafia stuff than I was trying to let on...
Are you?
Quote from Wolfgang Amadeus »
Is there any possible way that morris's claim could be a mafia tactic? I can't think of any reason a scum would do this, but I want to be positive.
It's possible he's trying to draw the real cop into a counterclaim, but only a stupid cop would fall for this, and if he doesn't, it's a bad play for the mafia (we just lynch him tomorrow, or even have the vig shoot him tonight [after learning how to make subliminal claims, well, subliminal, of course]). In short, even if he is stupid mafia, our best course is still to lynch Rikos; a one-for-one trade helps the town.
Vote Rikos.
FOS on WA stands; he might be looking for a way to save Rikos here.
I was trying to come up with the worst possible scenario for what could happen if morris is lying.
Worst case: Morris is some kind of mafia investigator. He investigated Rikos and found out Rikos has some power role. So when he sees we might lynch his buddy imhungry, he claims cop and says Rikos is scum. Conveniently, Rikos is out of town and can't roleclaim to defend himself. We lynch one of our power roles and we all say "oops." In the night, our vig (assuming it wasn't Rikos) kills morris and during the day we lynch imhungry. Thus we trade one of our power roles for two mafia, including one of their power roles.
I guess this still sounds like a good trade for the town. I think I just convinced myself.
Unvote. Vote Rikos.
But still, I want you guys to be thinking. Is there anything that I (we) overlooked? Could this possibly benefit the mafia in any way?
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Sig by, uh, me. The Untitled shop gave me an awesome Huey banner, but it just wasn't threatening.
But still, I want you guys to be thinking. Is there anything that I (we) overlooked? Could this possibly benefit the mafia in any way?
Well, considering morris' claim is true, which I do agree with your logic on what would happen if he's lying, I'd say that lynching one of their members would not benefit them. There are probably only 4-5 mafia with a game this sized, so hitting one of their number on the first day is always great. It seems a little convieniant that our cop got it right on the first check, I can only hope our luck continues.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
-[thread=14456]The [Untitled] Avatar and Sig shop![/thread] Avatar from:[thread=25376] [Epic Graphics][/thread]
after we get done with this, we'll move on to phase two: phasing out all dairy and replacing it with that cheap powdered-milk stuff that makes your cofee taste bad :weird3:
we will scour the earth
yes, we have plans... within plans! bwa ha ha :grin2:
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
if we could make cop cars that ran on human blood we would be set
after we get done with this, we'll move on to phase two: phasing out all dairy and replacing it with that cheap powdered-milk stuff that makes your cofee taste bad :weird3:
we will scour the earth
yes, we have plans... within plans! bwa ha ha :grin2:
After which, we must abolish the metric system!
The only way morris is lying is if there is some unknown factor here. He could be a paranoid cop, but those aren't very common. He could be scum, outing another scum in an attempt to gain the towns trust, but it's a little early for that kind of tactic. I feel inclined to believe that he's telling the truth.
After much contemplation, I've also decided that the last letter of his name is actually a lowercase 5. *nods reassuringly*
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"i live in new york, new york, the city that never shuts up
in the daylight everything is so gory you can hear snatches of stranger's sorry stories
and i moved there from buffalo
but that's nothing the trico plant moved to mexico
left my uncle standing out in the cold
said here's your last paycheck have fun growing old"
I'm waiting until mid-day tomorrow until I vote rikos. I want to make sure there is no counter claim. Although at this point, I am fairly sure there wont be one.
And the fact that no one seems to know about the Vig gives me hope that he'll fly under the radar. :-D I doubt it though.
Morris: Did you like my mansion? I had to re-do it a while ago. Some nut job I saved some years back tried to burn it down. Go figure.:tongue2:
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Thanks bobinite of the Untitled Shop for the banner. Which, Ironicly I can't see right now.
Morris: Did you like my mansion? I had to re-do it a while ago. Some nut job I saved some years back tried to burn it down. Go figure.:tongue2:
nice place
but the martinis need some work. when you get some time you're going to have to beat some sense into that butler of yours
i've considered the paranoid cop thing too :slant: my opinion is that if i'm somehow wrong you should just lynch me. can't be too careful about them mafioso types. i'd die knowing that the reason is that mod tricked me but that's between me and him
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
if we could make cop cars that ran on human blood we would be set
I'm waiting until mid-day tomorrow until I vote rikos. I want to make sure there is no counter claim. Although at this point, I am fairly sure there wont be one.
And the fact that no one seems to know about the Vig gives me hope that he'll fly under the radar. :-D I doubt it though.
Morris: Did you like my mansion? I had to re-do it a while ago. Some nut job I saved some years back tried to burn it down. Go figure.:tongue2:
Wait, is it not normal for there to only be one cop? There were two cops in Kamigawam mafia, weren't there?
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"i live in new york, new york, the city that never shuts up
in the daylight everything is so gory you can hear snatches of stranger's sorry stories
and i moved there from buffalo
but that's nothing the trico plant moved to mexico
left my uncle standing out in the cold
said here's your last paycheck have fun growing old"
Well the evidence is obvious unvote:Hungry Vote: Rikos
@Difranco: Generally I think it is normal for there to only be one cop, but there is also the possibility of a backup cop or more than one cop. We can't really know.
Ok well with night coming, I'd like to say that I hope that the doc listens to Morris, we've got a good start and I'd hate to lose him this early. See you all in the morning (I hope)!
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
-[thread=14456]The [Untitled] Avatar and Sig shop![/thread] Avatar from:[thread=25376] [Epic Graphics][/thread]
Sorry for my absence over the last couple of days, I've been sick. Vote: Rikos. no thought needs to be put into this at all, someone claims inspector and fingers a mafioso. We lynch the mafioso, and the doc protects morris. If the vig really was making a subliminal claim, and wasn't a mafia member setting up a future claim, then they will die, but it isn't a big loss. I don't want someone so stupid as to make such an obvious subliminal claim day 1 without any reason wielding vig powers. its probally for the best that he gets killed, as I doubt he'd be able to hit a mafioso anyway.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I was hanging from a tree
Unaccustomed to such violence
Jesus looking down on me
I'm prepared for one big silence
How'd I ever end up here?
Must be through some lack of kindness
Well sorry for not posting I was on a 2 day overnight with camp (yay today was my final day). I would vote for Rikos, but it seams like he has 10 votes the number that you need to be linched so I wont vote.
hi this is chimichangaland,i had to switch accounts because my computer didnt seem to be able to confim my account.i didnt realize this until i had to confirm the game and it wouldnt let me post.i am a noob so......ya.im tryin to get caught up on wats goin on.srry for the inconvenience.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
~[]D [] []V[] []D~
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Batman can jump in here any time to clarify his own remarks. However, I think this is a pretty clear case. Batman never claimed to have secret information. What he said was:
Now, Batman bandwagonned on his original vote for imhungry, and later changed his rationale for voting. That's pretty suspect. However, the fact that he was willing to take heat from the town and not reveal his hunch about imhungry makes him less suspicious in my eyes. He was, if we believe him, trying to protect a possible power role. Obviously, a clever scum could pretend to be protecting a townie, but Batman hasn't shown himself to be very clever thus far. That's why my vote is on imhungry rather than batman.
@morris- you were one of the first defenders of imhungry, but you haven't said anything about him lately. Do you agree with my arguments?
@notstevie- anything new to say about either batman or imhungry?
@mozart- do you care to explain your vote any more?
@BBTigger and duberz- would you guys care to make at least one serious comment on the game so far?
@HunterDuck- Do you admit now that outing Batman as a possible cop was a mistake, or do you stand by it?
@chimichangaland- Do you even exist?
@Mr. DiFranco- If no one else posts, we can at least make this into an Ani discussion thread. I love Ani!
Sig by, uh, me. The Untitled shop gave me an awesome Huey banner, but it just wasn't threatening.
the brutal truth is that i have extreme difficulty reading imhungry's writing. when he posts i just see "derf derf derfity derf i'm stupid". i'm clearly a horrible person...
batman's writing, however...
so i prodded him a little. and a good time was had by all
so when it comes to imhungry i've been a little lazy. maybe later...
but i can say with ease that i approve more of the way you've been discussing imhungry's posts than the method used by batman. voting for someone for spelling errors is dumb. voting for someone for lying is smart.
the question is: is your analysis right or not? i don't know yet...
if we are to accept batman's subsequent post as an explanation, i believe he's no longer a possible suspect for cop - he didn't have information, he had a theory. that being said, it does give the mafia one less target to shoot for (which is, admitedly, not a good thing).
however, i'm still suspicious of batman based purely on silly voting and wishy-washy posting. unvote: batman
i'm also hesitant to vote for imhungry, as he strikes me not as mafia, but as idiot: he's just so newblet. his actions can't be taken for skill, and he's utterly unpredictable. any mafia tells he exudes shouldn't be accepted as signs that he is... well... mafia.
but, LAL is usually a fairly solid principle; i just don't know if it can be applied in this situation.
Agreed and seconded...
You rock and thus win, I recently attended one of her concerts...she is amazing live.
I wonder, what with this being a music game and all, if Ani is possibly a character...or if Unsan even knows who she is...-_-, or if even folk is involved...actually it's really early in the morning, and I'm not even sure if there characters in this game.
-[thread=14456]The [Untitled] Avatar and Sig shop![/thread] Avatar from:[thread=25376] [Epic Graphics][/thread]
Awards:
Elegant Mafia: The Joker, Mafia MVP
it's a safe bet that roles are genres of music, i'd say
with post numbers instead of imhungry's username
not mafia wrote "le confirmed" instead of "confirmed." french people and their moutaches... sheesh.
thanks barn :tongue2:
the game is going slowly after a meager 38 posts? what a noob
this is because of my vote on fadeblue. again, what a barn
it is worth noting that steviet92 meddled in this game even though he wasn't in it. otherwise imhungry would never have made this post
the reasons above was batman replacing notmafia. still trying to be funny...
this is because batman confirmed his lack of frenchiness. i urge you all to do the same.
don't these two statements contradict each other? at least he has an interesting theory about the serial killer possibly existing but being awol
imhungry is essentially right here. let's find the quote, shall we?
Also, FOS Mr DiFranco and FOS imhungry for FOSing my main account. That's just not very nice of you.
see? notstevie says his main account is that which imhungry FOS'd, which in #41 is clearly steviet92. this is essentially a claim.
this was in response to:
Are you trying to get me killed by the mod or something??? That's pretty sneaky of you, if you are.
WellOfLostGnomes did bring it up before imhungry in post #55
this is what i mean when i say imhungry is stupid. he tries to defend himself and ends up saying nothing intelligible
if anyone can tell me what this post means, please do tell
because it's the mafia's job to kill the townies, right?
just sayin'
(what an idiot)
finally something that seems a little scummy
"i dont want 2 get u killed but i am just going to point out that you claimed, over and over again, til the mod takes notice or something..."
course, imhungry might just be clarifying his position. suspicious, yeah, a little. but not that easy... you need more to earn your noose
vecna did say notstevie was, erm, not stevie (post 15)
"ho ho ho, morris' jokes are stupid"
well you're stupid
stupid head
the joke i made just a second ago gives away some information you will find to be true
[subliminal]imhungry is a stupid head[/subliminal]
this is response to the post about what the last letter of my name is.
allow me to assist you
morris
notstevie got L. this is a common misconception. there is more than one
i am the voice inside your head
kill kill kill kill kill kill
can you dig it?
...
it's a shaft reference, you twits
it's a waste because it doesn't matter
at all
but what do you care? you're a stupid head
and the award for worst mafia post ever goes to...
.... because that's what's really important
the lack of question mark at the end of his sentence is truly hilarious
but seriously, he has a point. i should know, because i made it before he did.
***i want to point out that with, one very small exception, imhungry has been rather unscummy. sure, he pointed out that notstevie did something that could get him modkilled, but that's relatively okay because, uh, he did do something that could get him modkilled. this is also where i was defending him, because i don't think he did anything that horrible at this point. later on i stop defending him very much at all.***
earlier you very, very clearly indicated that vecna said notstevie was not stevie. do you not realize that vec is a freaking mod? is your ignorance really so deep? even in your case, such nearly-limitless obliviousness is hard to believe :slant:
maybe we give you the benefit of the doubt here. maybe we don't. in any case, let's just say you're flat-out wrong and move on.
guess what? they choose the "say you're lying" option
***some irrelevant posts where he completely fails to understand what batman is saying***
so much for the benefit of the doubt
if you're going to vote for imhungry, this should be why
the first part could very well be a lie to cover his ass
or he could actually be that stupid
i'm going with "entwine"
honesty, how refreshing :tongue2:
***imhungry does some posts where he gets mad at lurkers. a popular distraction***
how can you acuse someone of directing attention away from themselves? you've been spamming up the thread with your pointless drivel since the very beginning
pot/kettle
actually, your vote on batman was because you think he's mafia that wanted to get attention away from himself by point out that you said or did something that only he knows... him, not even you. if in the future you ever forget why you voted for someone, may i suggest scrolling up and reading your own posts
this is an unbelievable story. if you're gonna lie, you need to try better than that
*** at this point i make my post 161, where i said imhungry's "primary crimes include illiteracy and a childlike fascination with the irrelevant." i may have been wrong... as my analysis indicates, he was plenty stupid early on, and i had already dismissed him as a mere idiot***
some 30 posts later imhungry is still holding to his story of why he voted for batman even though people who can read had already, uh, read. what he posted. and commented on it. :slant:
conclusion time!
so what are the facts on imhungry?
- he's the most prolific poster in the thread. by far. this indicates that he's playing real aggressively, and thus has the greatest chance of making errors
- he's clearly more used to live mafia games (which are more talking-based) than he is with the internet kind
- he is illogical at times. the whole fiasco with the (second) t in stevie's name is simply weird
- he's a liar. he voted for one reason, then said he voted for a different reason
- last, but not least, he is a stupid head.
until now, i'd overlooked imhungry's lie. i failed to notice it within the sea of stupid that is his post style. besides, he seemed really out of his element, so it seemed sort of innocent. so i dismissed it for a long time... however, the time of neglect is now over! unvote, then vote imhungry. "lynch all liars" is what they tell me back at the ranch
by the way, fos batman. you're not off the hook yet
-[thread=14456]The [Untitled] Avatar and Sig shop![/thread] Avatar from:[thread=25376] [Epic Graphics][/thread]
Awards:
Elegant Mafia: The Joker, Mafia MVP
This is in response to anyone_but_me being killed. Could it be that imhungry really did think Vecna was playing??? What kind of a mind are we dealing with here?
btw, serf, we haven't heard from you in quite a while.
Sig by, uh, me. The Untitled shop gave me an awesome Huey banner, but it just wasn't threatening.
morris, that was by far the most amusing PBP I've ever read. However, the only new evidence you brought up was your undeniable proof that imhungry is indeed a stupid head. Overall, I'm still unconvinced that imhungry is anything else. *paints the kettle red*
Hells yeah. Ya hear that folks? Get to talkin' or this game will be commandeered for the discussion of liberalist folk music!
in the daylight everything is so gory you can hear snatches of stranger's sorry stories
and i moved there from buffalo
but that's nothing the trico plant moved to mexico
left my uncle standing out in the cold
said here's your last paycheck have fun growing old"
however, imhungry is a liar. #149 and #154 directly contradict each other i don't know if that's new but it's evidence sure enough
i'm honestly not all that sure imhungry is scum either. this early in the game such things are quite difficult. but he's a liar *shrug* so i am comfortable with my vote
I'm tempted to vote imhungry simply because I don't see any other leads, but I'm just not convinced he's mafia.
in the daylight everything is so gory you can hear snatches of stranger's sorry stories
and i moved there from buffalo
but that's nothing the trico plant moved to mexico
left my uncle standing out in the cold
said here's your last paycheck have fun growing old"
I'll fully catch up tonight and start posting again. Promise.
I must say though, I have read the PBPA on imhungry and I think I was off base with my theory on imhungry. I still believe he is faking it, but I dout that it's to protect a power role.
Thanks bobinite of the Untitled Shop for the banner. Which, Ironicly I can't see right now.
but there's not much else going on, and a vote could make him appear. another one, i mean. vote imhungry
Not really. I just got back from a friend's, and I'm still having trouble figuring out whether they are just silly or scum. Hard to say for sure right now.
AHHH MOTHERLAND!!!!
(For the ignorant: I am Russia)
GutterPwn
Vote Hungry
Vote Hungry[/QUOTE]
Well...I'm glad that after enough people complained (about bad grammar and poor posting style) everyone has started making sense and cleaning things up. Also, "capping" random letters makes reading and comprehending posts so much easier, I wish everyone would do it. [/end sarcasm]
Why would mafia draw attention to themselves to "affect the late game"? Actually, mafia members know that they really should try not to stand out too much in the beginning. I think that he might have realized this too late and that could be the reason for his sudden disappearance.
-[thread=14456]The [Untitled] Avatar and Sig shop![/thread] Avatar from:[thread=25376] [Epic Graphics][/thread]
Awards:
Elegant Mafia: The Joker, Mafia MVP
now that the "day" has gone this far, and the inevitable conclusion is clear (imhungry would have been lynched) i have something to tell you all...
i'm the cop
not only that, but i was rather lucky last night. clearly with a name like rice cakes, someone must be evil. at least that what i thought. and a quick investigation proved me right. he is most assuredly "evil" so unvote imhungry and vote rikos.
i have been planning on telling you all this from the beginning, but i wanted to see what would happen over the course of the day. i think we learned a lot more this way than if i had just come out with it in the beginning
i came out now because i hit a scum last night. if i'd hit a townie i probably wouldn't be copclaiming right now. the way i see it is, why lynch "in the dark" when you know you can hit? eh?
in any case, the doctor's job henceforth is to keep me alive and y'all better get around to unvoting. from this point on the day is fairly straightforward, wouldn't ya say?
Well....uh.....yeah. As this would be a terrible Mafia tactic, except to flush out the Cop I am inclined to believe it. So, barring a counterclaim, I guess you've got my vote.
I guess this means we lose our Vig tonight. :-(
Thanks bobinite of the Untitled Shop for the banner. Which, Ironicly I can't see right now.
-[thread=14456]The [Untitled] Avatar and Sig shop![/thread] Avatar from:[thread=25376] [Epic Graphics][/thread]
Awards:
Elegant Mafia: The Joker, Mafia MVP
Vote Rikos
I always hate to miss a lynch and I really thought we were going to. With morris being protected by the doc, we could win just off of that. So, to the doc(in case it isn't obvious), do NOT role claim. We need you alive.
And no morris, no one vig claimed. I don't know why batty said that, he may have gotten this game mixed up with another one.
in the daylight everything is so gory you can hear snatches of stranger's sorry stories
and i moved there from buffalo
but that's nothing the trico plant moved to mexico
left my uncle standing out in the cold
said here's your last paycheck have fun growing old"
Vote: |Evil scum| Rikos |/Evil Scum|
-[thread=14456]The [Untitled] Avatar and Sig shop![/thread] Avatar from:[thread=25376] [Epic Graphics][/thread]
Awards:
Elegant Mafia: The Joker, Mafia MVP
3 - Rikos [morris, Mr DiFranco, WellOfLostGnomes]
2- Batman [notstevie92, Mozart]
4 - imhungry [Wolfgang Amadeus, Emerys, Mr. Maestro, Hunter Duck]
1 - Mr DiFranco [duberz]
10 to lynch!
OMFG linkage
we reconciled our differences sipping martinis in the glow of wayne manor's fireplace, listening to a tasteful recording of fine jazz
Hmmmmmmm, You don't see a cop claim this early in the game that often.
Risky tactic, but I guess there's more then one way to skin a cat.:kitty:
It maybe a costly tactic but we will have to try to capitalize on it.
vote rikos
I suggest everyone join in and come tomorrow if Morris is lying we lynch him like a lying little rat.
If he's not lying, I say we ride this horse till it drops. Waaa Hooooo!:dance2:
Doctor, I hope you know what to do tonight. Protect Morris.
when and where did you find that kitty? it's so cute....
It's in the Animals and such CATagory.
I saw it and thought it was PURRfect.:D
I'm not sure on this, do we need to unvote before we vote for someone else?
Just to be safe:
unvote rikos
unvote imhungry
vote rikos
That should do it.
Is there any possible way that morris's claim could be a mafia tactic? I can't think of any reason a scum would do this, but I want to be positive.
If the town assures me that morris's claim is close to 100% believeable, I will switch my vote over.
Too bad Rikos isn't here to roleclaim or anything. It could give us more info.
Sig by, uh, me. The Untitled shop gave me an awesome Huey banner, but it just wasn't threatening.
unvote batman, vote rikos.
AHHH MOTHERLAND!!!!
(For the ignorant: I am Russia)
GutterPwn
Are you?
It's possible he's trying to draw the real cop into a counterclaim, but only a stupid cop would fall for this, and if he doesn't, it's a bad play for the mafia (we just lynch him tomorrow, or even have the vig shoot him tonight [after learning how to make subliminal claims, well, subliminal, of course]). In short, even if he is stupid mafia, our best course is still to lynch Rikos; a one-for-one trade helps the town.
Vote Rikos.
FOS on WA stands; he might be looking for a way to save Rikos here.
Worst case: Morris is some kind of mafia investigator. He investigated Rikos and found out Rikos has some power role. So when he sees we might lynch his buddy imhungry, he claims cop and says Rikos is scum. Conveniently, Rikos is out of town and can't roleclaim to defend himself. We lynch one of our power roles and we all say "oops." In the night, our vig (assuming it wasn't Rikos) kills morris and during the day we lynch imhungry. Thus we trade one of our power roles for two mafia, including one of their power roles.
I guess this still sounds like a good trade for the town. I think I just convinced myself.
Unvote. Vote Rikos.
But still, I want you guys to be thinking. Is there anything that I (we) overlooked? Could this possibly benefit the mafia in any way?
Sig by, uh, me. The Untitled shop gave me an awesome Huey banner, but it just wasn't threatening.
Well, considering morris' claim is true, which I do agree with your logic on what would happen if he's lying, I'd say that lynching one of their members would not benefit them. There are probably only 4-5 mafia with a game this sized, so hitting one of their number on the first day is always great. It seems a little convieniant that our cop got it right on the first check, I can only hope our luck continues.
-[thread=14456]The [Untitled] Avatar and Sig shop![/thread] Avatar from:[thread=25376] [Epic Graphics][/thread]
Awards:
Elegant Mafia: The Joker, Mafia MVP
after we get done with this, we'll move on to phase two: phasing out all dairy and replacing it with that cheap powdered-milk stuff that makes your cofee taste bad :weird3:
we will scour the earth
yes, we have plans... within plans! bwa ha ha :grin2:
After which, we must abolish the metric system!
The only way morris is lying is if there is some unknown factor here. He could be a paranoid cop, but those aren't very common. He could be scum, outing another scum in an attempt to gain the towns trust, but it's a little early for that kind of tactic. I feel inclined to believe that he's telling the truth.
After much contemplation, I've also decided that the last letter of his name is actually a lowercase 5. *nods reassuringly*
in the daylight everything is so gory you can hear snatches of stranger's sorry stories
and i moved there from buffalo
but that's nothing the trico plant moved to mexico
left my uncle standing out in the cold
said here's your last paycheck have fun growing old"
kthx gg no re
And the fact that no one seems to know about the Vig gives me hope that he'll fly under the radar. :-D I doubt it though.
Morris: Did you like my mansion? I had to re-do it a while ago. Some nut job I saved some years back tried to burn it down. Go figure.:tongue2:
Thanks bobinite of the Untitled Shop for the banner. Which, Ironicly I can't see right now.
7 - Rikos [morris, Mr DiFranco, WellOfLostGnomes, Emerys, notstevie92, True Believer, Wolfgang Amadeus]
1 - Batman [Mozart]
2 - imhungry [Mr. Maestro, Hunter Duck]
1 - Mr DiFranco [duberz]
10 to lynch!
OMFG linkage
AHHH MOTHERLAND!!!!
(For the ignorant: I am Russia)
GutterPwn
but the martinis need some work. when you get some time you're going to have to beat some sense into that butler of yours
i've considered the paranoid cop thing too :slant: my opinion is that if i'm somehow wrong you should just lynch me. can't be too careful about them mafioso types. i'd die knowing that the reason is that mod tricked me but that's between me and him
Wait, is it not normal for there to only be one cop? There were two cops in Kamigawam mafia, weren't there?
in the daylight everything is so gory you can hear snatches of stranger's sorry stories
and i moved there from buffalo
but that's nothing the trico plant moved to mexico
left my uncle standing out in the cold
said here's your last paycheck have fun growing old"
probably back monday afternoon
@Difranco: Generally I think it is normal for there to only be one cop, but there is also the possibility of a backup cop or more than one cop. We can't really know.
Thanks bobinite of the Untitled Shop for the banner. Which, Ironicly I can't see right now.
-[thread=14456]The [Untitled] Avatar and Sig shop![/thread] Avatar from:[thread=25376] [Epic Graphics][/thread]
Awards:
Elegant Mafia: The Joker, Mafia MVP
Unaccustomed to such violence
I'm prepared for one big silence
Must be through some lack of kindness
Image by Brom
Sig by, uh, me. The Untitled shop gave me an awesome Huey banner, but it just wasn't threatening.
He was Li'l Jon. He defaced the world of music as we know it, making him an evil mafia bastard.
It's night 2! You have until Thursday night to send me choices!
OMFG linkage