While I still strongly believe that any format like this one has to have an official ban list so memory and research aren't factors, it is true that that wasn't made clear this time, and it really does seem like some people took it for granted that Dark Depths wasn't available. So, as excited as I was to have won a round, I guess I am in favor of throwing it out now.
Having heard the discussion, I will strike this week from the league. In future weeks, any time there is a banlist that is officially supported, it will be added to the OP, even when it's hundreds of cards long. Then when you wonder if you can use a card, rather than trying to remember if it was played, you can check the list. In turn, the moderator will verify the list before adding it to the OP. So league 46 will go to 5 weeks, and this week's results won't be added as a part of that. If anyone has further concerns, please private message this account.
If said future round is declared as "cards on this X hundred card list are banned", fine, although I think that's pretty bad as formats go (you have to individually check for every powerhouse card in the format, just in case).
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
This signature left intentionally blank.
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
And I discovered that yes, Dark Depths was submitted this year :/
While I still strongly believe that any format like this one has to have an official ban list so memory and research aren't factors, it is true that that wasn't made clear this time, and it really does seem like some people took it for granted that Dark Depths wasn't available. So, as excited as I was to have won a round, I guess I am in favor of throwing it out now.
Follow me to be notified when weekly Perfect Hand Magic results are posted