And I know why you want to know. Since this seems like your typical he said/he said kind of deal, we might as well choose which one we want to lynch, and then make sure there's enough votes on the other person so that, if the person we lynch comes up town, I can vig the other. If I had to vig, then we couldn't do it that way.
So far, I'm leaning towards Jerub. I can't see much reason for scum to not just trade 1 for 1 in a game like this, where NKs seem to be scarce and/or non-existent, and especially to trade with someone who is vanilla.
But anywho, with 8 people left, we need to have 3 votes on whoever we want to potentially vig. And with needing 5 votes to lynch, that means we need everyone voting. I'm not voting for him quite yet, because I just want to check back through the thread to see if there's any reason to think that Jerub might be lying, though. And I want to make sure we get all the votes right for my ability to go off, so I think I'll be the hammer here so I can make sure that it goes off without any problems.
If someone claims that they are an unlynchable, unkillable, octa-voter, with 4 daykills and 6 doc-protects, then technically lynching that person solely based on his claim would be gaming the mod, but I would be just fine doing that.
If someone claims that they are an unlynchable, unkillable, octa-voter, with 4 daykills and 6 doc-protects, then technically lynching that person solely based on his claim would be gaming the mod, but I would be just fine doing that.
@Gamerz: If you have the necessary amount of votes to vig someone, do you have to kill the person or do you just then have the option to kill that person?
If someone claims that they are an unlynchable, unkillable, octa-voter, with 4 daykills and 6 doc-protects, then technically lynching that person solely based on his claim would be gaming the mod, but I would be just fine doing that.
*shrug* I can't tell people where to vote, only that we need to have at least 3 people voting for the person that we want to vig. Personally, I think Manders is the scum here, but either way, with this plan, we lynch whichever one is scum anyways.
That does remind me, though. If this plan is going to work, I need you to guide me again, SB.
If someone claims that they are an unlynchable, unkillable, octa-voter, with 4 daykills and 6 doc-protects, then technically lynching that person solely based on his claim would be gaming the mod, but I would be just fine doing that.
*shrug* I can't tell people where to vote, only that we need to have at least 3 people voting for the person that we want to vig. Personally, I think Manders is the scum here, but either way, with this plan, we lynch whichever one is scum anyways.
That does remind me, though. If this plan is going to work, I need you to guide me again, SB.
Ofcourse. At this point i put more stock into you then i do into zebi or buranri. Cause if you think about it, and if Jerub is telling the truth, i DONT SEE 3 information roles in this game. The 2 doctors make sense, especially since one was appearently the SK doctor, but... 3!? information roles?
Ill stick my vote on jerub just to make sure we hit the 3 required before manders takes her fall.
Vote Jerubbaal
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
[19:59] greymon90210: Hey StormBlind how tall are you? "I'm six money *****, don't forget it"
"The Critics always said that we'd only have a black president when pigs flu"...
Flavor for my RB was basically that I was interrupted from meditating (how I track) and slowly fell asleep. I woke up in the morning and only remembered various happy objects/images.
Flavor for my RB was basically that I was interrupted from meditating (how I track) and slowly fell asleep. I woke up in the morning and only remembered various happy objects/images.
I target a player each night. If the player is roleblocked, i counteract that and undo the roleblock. The flavor is that i have extensive wilderness training, and due to the amount of wilderness in canada, i have a talent for directing people along the safest paths of the forest, causing those trying to inhibit them from being able too after becoming lost in the forest.
This might not mean anything but these flavor things don't really match up. From SB's role it's implied that he can guide people along the safest path of the forest. I was thinking that this may mean that the roleblocker gets people lost inside a forest and SB is the counter to that by showing them the path. If SB is anti-roleblock, what's his counter for that roleblock flavor? Why does he need to be a special wilderness guide in order to wake people up (which I assume would be the counter)? I could be off on this and SB's flavor is just flavor and I shouldn't interpret it to mean anything, but still it bothers me a bit.
Keep the WIFOM open, we don't want the scum to be able to confidently RB anyone they want. (and you would only need to be guided if MH flipped town)
On the contrary, I think I'd rather have the rest of the town confident that what we're trying to accomplish will go down as planned. That way, if something goes wrong, then you can blame either me or Stormblind and not have to worry about either of us going off on some tangent of 'well, I thought I'd try this' I mean, think about it, we're already set for me going to vig someone specific anyways.
If someone claims that they are an unlynchable, unkillable, octa-voter, with 4 daykills and 6 doc-protects, then technically lynching that person solely based on his claim would be gaming the mod, but I would be just fine doing that.
On the contrary, I think I'd rather have the rest of the town confident that what we're trying to accomplish will go down as planned. That way, if something goes wrong, then you can blame either me or Stormblind and not have to worry about either of us going off on some tangent of 'well, I thought I'd try this' I mean, think about it, we're already set for me going to vig someone specific anyways.
yeah I guess this is also true. Especially as I'm a bit suspicious of SB atm.
unvote, Vote Jerubaal
That takes care of the 3 votes required (although I think it should be 2) for Gamerz vig.
Eh count: 4/6
Syrenz
SB
Gamerz
Buranri
We need eh's from Jerubaal and EP.
On a side note, I'm sad we lynched Joboman, would have been interesting to see his role play out .
MTGS stats (won/played)
As scum - 3/5
As town - 5/7
As neutral - none
(I really have been scum a lot)
I'm now writing for Eye of the Vortex, come check out MTG articles and other geek culture
I also moderate the MTG forum, so register (it's free) and voice your thoughts.
So... I'm fine with lynching MH and vigging jerubbaal if she flips scum.. We should wait for eh's, however, and I'll wait for a vote count to vote wherever my vote is needed.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Signature from Nakamura and Heroes of the Planes Studios.
So firstly you shouldn't be losing you're ability from the lack of snow, as you specifically said you protect them in the igloo. Secondly, what do you actually do? Protect people with snow or inside the igloo?
If someone claims that they are an unlynchable, unkillable, octa-voter, with 4 daykills and 6 doc-protects, then technically lynching that person solely based on his claim would be gaming the mod, but I would be just fine doing that.
Really? Why? I was thinking the other way around...
With Jerub being alive today and having stated that he was flavorcopping MH last night MH knows (if she's scum) that she's going down today and she knows her case on SB isn't going to get him lynched before her. Her big case on SB looks like a final try to distance herself from SB before she gets lynched.
And what do you think his motivation for lying would be, knowing he would be killed if you turned up as Terry Fox,Town hero?
Because, think about it. No scum have been killed, so it's safe to assume there's probably three left. It's pretty close to end of game, so yeah, once you guys mislynch me, you'll vig Jerub, but that still leaves 2 scum alive to possibly win the game.
Slightly amused by how fabricated Manders' response is.
Die, scum.
I'm as good as dead, so I'll go ahead and post my thoughts on everybody:
Syrenz - town. This is typical town Syrenz play.
Gamerz - leaning town, but in no way is he "confirmed" town
Zebi - He still feels off to me. Neutral
Buranri - also feels off. Ability's pretty confirmed, but not necessarily town. Neutral
Shibui - town. Yeah, this new doc information (him only doccing RafK) makes sense flavorwise, and makes me feel he's pretty much confirmed.
jerubbaal - Die, scum.
SB - I still don't like him. Probable scum.
Because, think about it. No scum have been killed, so it's safe to assume there's probably three left. It's pretty close to end of game, so yeah, once you guys mislynch me, you'll vig Jerub, but that still leaves 2 scum alive to possibly win the game.
SK counts as scum. In a mini I'd imagine that there's 3 scum and if there's an SK I'm guessing 1 SK 2 mafia for total scum.
Pretty sure you're scum trying to make us worry about an additional nonexistent scum anyways.
I've either built myself around them or they built me around themselves.
Technically speaking flavorwise if you lose your ability you should die as well I think, because you aren't Nootaikok Pukkeenegak, Inuit Guy Living in Igloo, you're igloo and if you lose the igloo you lose yourself. That might be wrong though because I'm confused about your whole thing. And it's irrelevant anyways, so let's move onwards.
I believe we have all the required eh's and I don't see anything else we need to do, so let's proceed with lynching MH please.
With Jerub being alive today and having stated that he was flavorcopping MH last night MH knows (if she's scum) that she's going down today and she knows her case on SB isn't going to get him lynched before her. Her big case on SB looks like a final try to distance herself from SB before she gets lynched.
Well, here's the flaw i see with this.
A) We have zero proof that there even *IS* a mafia kill.
B) Due to the fact there HAVE been no kills except for the one last night against Rafk, im starting to wonder if perhaps this is just a high scum count game with little / no killing roles. I.E. 3-4 scum + an SK. There have been almost no powers floating around, and this would basically nullify the use of the doctors, AND make the tracker / watcher pretty much useless.
Also, of note, I do not appreciate you basically flinging flavor mud everywhere. So far, you've attacked my flavor for being a guide, WHICH WAS PRECISELY ANSWERED IN MY FLAVOR CLAIM
The flavor is that i have extensive wilderness training, and due to the amount of wilderness in canada, i have a talent for directing people along the safest paths of the forest, causing those trying to inhibit them from being able too after becoming lost in the forest.
You've started attacking EP's flavor as well (that is definitely how i read your last post, subtle mudflinging). And i KNOW You're atleast a good enough player to know better then to attack a player based on flavor.
Im going to give YOU a re-read, because your attacks are based on near no substance (Flavor), and little on anything else. Especially given what we've seen so far from this setup.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
[19:59] greymon90210: Hey StormBlind how tall are you? "I'm six money *****, don't forget it"
"The Critics always said that we'd only have a black president when pigs flu"...
Well, here's the flaw i see with this.
A) We have zero proof that there even *IS* a mafia kill.
B) Due to the fact there HAVE been no kills except for the one last night against Rafk, im starting to wonder if perhaps this is just a high scum count game with little / no killing roles. I.E. 3-4 scum + an SK. There have been almost no powers floating around, and this would basically nullify the use of the doctors, AND make the tracker / watcher pretty much useless.
I'm not sure how this is relevant to my quote.
Also, of note, I do not appreciate you basically flinging flavor mud everywhere.
I'm not basing cases solely on flavor, I'm noting and speculating inconsistencies with flavor.
So far, you've attacked my flavor for being a guide, WHICH WAS PRECISELY ANSWERED IN MY FLAVOR CLAIM
I really don't see how this answers anything.
You've started attacking EP's flavor as well (that is definitely how i read your last post, subtle mudflinging). And i KNOW You're atleast a good enough player to know better then to attack a player based on flavor.
My speculation on EP's flavor was not meant as an attack at all. It's simple speculation.
Im going to give YOU a re-read, because your attacks are based on near no substance (Flavor), and little on anything else. Especially given what we've seen so far from this setup.[/b][/color][/font]
MH is most likely to be scum due to Jerub's reveal, I think you're likely to be scum if MH is due to my first post that you quote here and because I've been suspicious of your claim for a bit now. So what attacks are based on just flavor?
With Jerub being alive today and having stated that he was flavorcopping MH last night MH knows (if she's scum) that she's going down today and she knows her case on SB isn't going to get him lynched before her. Her big case on SB looks like a final try to distance herself from SB before she gets lynched.
Well, here's the flaw i see with this.
A) We have zero proof that there even *IS* a mafia kill.
B) Due to the fact there HAVE been no kills except for the one last night against Rafk, im starting to wonder if perhaps this is just a high scum count game with little / no killing roles. I.E. 3-4 scum + an SK. There have been almost no powers floating around, and this would basically nullify the use of the doctors, AND make the tracker / watcher pretty much useless.
I'm not sure how this is relevant to my quote.
I misunderstood. Although, this DOES paint a good point for my above statement: I doubt the mafia have a NK or they would have killed Jerub.
Quote from syrenz »
I'm not basing cases solely on flavor, I'm noting and speculating inconsistencies with flavor. ... Dude, that *IS* Basing an argument on flavor. That is the EPITOME of trying to use flavor text from ngiht abilities / ability descriptions to get someone lynched / make them look bad.
Also, ask any good player, speculation of ANYTHING Based off flavor is terrible.
From SB's role it's implied that he can guide people along the safest path of the forest. I was thinking that this may mean that the roleblocker gets people lost inside a forest and SB is the counter to that by showing them the path. If SB is anti-roleblock, what's his counter for that roleblock flavor? Why does he need to be a special wilderness guide in order to wake people up (which I assume would be the counter)? I could be off on this and SB's flavor is just flavor and I shouldn't interpret it to mean anything, but still it bothers me a bit.
I answered by QUOTING that my ability basically loses those who would try to inhibit a player from getting their action off by losing them IN The forest. You're just playing dumb now.
My speculation on EP's flavor was not meant as an attack at all. It's simple speculation.
Again, speculation based off flavor, and thats about it. And its speculation that definitely doesnt paint him in a favourable light. If anything, it's subtly calling his entire role into question.... again, based off flavor.
MH is most likely to be scum due to Jerub's reveal, I think you're likely to be scum if MH is due to my first post that you quote here and because I've been suspicious of your claim for a bit now. So what attacks are based on just flavor?
Cept, you've said this ONCE, and quoted flavor reasons multiple times. In what order do you think most people will note them? You're using reasons that could be justifiable, and using them to... do nothing, and instead harping on speculative flavor.
Excuse me if i dont like that.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
[19:59] greymon90210: Hey StormBlind how tall are you? "I'm six money *****, don't forget it"
"The Critics always said that we'd only have a black president when pigs flu"...
Also, ask any good player, speculation of ANYTHING Based off flavor is terrible.
That's not true at all. I don't know if you were following Asphodel Meadows but one of the mafia was Fox who was Jean-Baptiste d'Avignon. Now Fox claimed Jean-Baptiste d'Avignon Town Doctor who was in a wheelchair after a plane crash or something. In the bottom of the first post of the sign-up thread for that game there's a flavor piece that completely shows that Fox was falseclaiming. That's speculation based on flavor. The situation is obviously different from over here and is merely meant to show that flavor does have importance.
If something doesn't make sense flavorwise it may not warrant a vote but I feel it's worth looking at all the same.
I answered by QUOTING that my ability basically loses those who would try to inhibit a player from getting their action off by losing them IN The forest. You're just playing dumb now.
I misinterpreted that. I thought that you guided people along the right path in the forest from those who tried to lead them off their path. I didn't see that you were saying that you lose the RB'er in the forest.
Again, speculation based off flavor, and thats about it. And its speculation that definitely doesnt paint him in a favourable light. If anything, it's subtly calling his entire role into question.... again, based off flavor.
Mostly me being confused about things. I do not see EP as scum especially as his SK protection/kill thing makes sense both mechanically and flavorwise.
Cept, you've said this ONCE, and quoted flavor reasons multiple times. In what order do you think most people will note them? You're using reasons that could be justifiable, and using them to... do nothing, and instead harping on speculative flavor.
Okay so I just looked over my posts on the past couple of pages. I went over EP's flavor with him to try to get a better understanding of it and stated my confusion over it. I state that there was an inconsistency between your flavor and Zebi's RB flavor. Nowhere did I imply that I was voting anyone or thought someone was scum based on flavor.
If someone claims that they are an unlynchable, unkillable, octa-voter, with 4 daykills and 6 doc-protects, then technically lynching that person solely based on his claim would be gaming the mod, but I would be just fine doing that.
Dun worry Stormblind. It's only been 2 days since the votecount.
----------------------------------
And so at the turn of the first millenia after Christ, was when our great nation of Canada was first discovered by Vikings and was colonized by a small settlement at Newfoundland(*). At least, this was the only known settlement as we know it now.
Then the English and French came, and eventually Canada as we know it came into being. However the descendants of those vikings never forgot their claim on the land and so had come back to well, reclaim these lands in the name of Odin.
However Ravens aren't a good source of information, so with some too-old information, a Viking tried passing off as Terry Fox.
Well we Canadians might not care too much about history(**), but we sure as hell know what Terry Fox looks like.
That viking didn't last long.
bman65 MandersHex - VIKINGS, Mafia Berserker - Lynched Day 4
----------------------------------
Yeah night shouldn't last that long. Extenuating circumstances last time.
"This just in! Breaking news! Canada faces it's greatest crisis of it's history! Maple syrup production has been halted!"
"Factories have claimed that they don't know what has happened with the sudden disappearance of Maple Syrup from their production lines. Ontario especially are clamoring for answers as Ottawa and Toronto are about to break out in riots as Canadians everywhere are up in a rage to missing out their most important ingredient of breakfast."
"It's not looking pretty here in Vancouver either as riots have already broken out; rioters have pulled stock American syrup out of the malls and are mass dumping it in the Pacific. The national guard as been sent but there is no way this'll end peacefully."
Bunrari - MAPLE SYRUP, Town Watcher - Nightkilled Night 4
----------------------------------
With 6 alive it's 4 to lynch.
If you think you should have received a PM and haven't, PM me IMMEDIATELY.
For ☺☺☺☺s sake. Targetted buranri. Figured they'd take a potshot at zebi or gamerz, and since buranri's been tracking zebi lately, hoped that would give us a scum.
It was the best play I could think of.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
[19:59] greymon90210: Hey StormBlind how tall are you? "I'm six money *****, don't forget it"
"The Critics always said that we'd only have a black president when pigs flu"...
And I know why you want to know. Since this seems like your typical he said/he said kind of deal, we might as well choose which one we want to lynch, and then make sure there's enough votes on the other person so that, if the person we lynch comes up town, I can vig the other. If I had to vig, then we couldn't do it that way.
So far, I'm leaning towards Jerub. I can't see much reason for scum to not just trade 1 for 1 in a game like this, where NKs seem to be scarce and/or non-existent, and especially to trade with someone who is vanilla.
But anywho, with 8 people left, we need to have 3 votes on whoever we want to potentially vig. And with needing 5 votes to lynch, that means we need everyone voting. I'm not voting for him quite yet, because I just want to check back through the thread to see if there's any reason to think that Jerub might be lying, though. And I want to make sure we get all the votes right for my ability to go off, so I think I'll be the hammer here so I can make sure that it goes off without any problems.
yes, that was the purpose of this question
Lair of the Cat (Mafia Stats)
Is it 3 votes or 30% of the vote?
Lair of the Cat (Mafia Stats)
Also, so that Zebi can track me if he wants to...
Eh?
Lair of the Cat (Mafia Stats)
SB and everyone else, please get in your eh's
Lair of the Cat (Mafia Stats)
That does remind me, though. If this plan is going to work, I need you to guide me again, SB.
Ofcourse. At this point i put more stock into you then i do into zebi or buranri. Cause if you think about it, and if Jerub is telling the truth, i DONT SEE 3 information roles in this game. The 2 doctors make sense, especially since one was appearently the SK doctor, but... 3!? information roles?
Ill stick my vote on jerub just to make sure we hit the 3 required before manders takes her fall.
Vote Jerubbaal
Okay cool
Keep the WIFOM open, we don't want the scum to be able to confidently RB anyone they want. (and you would only need to be guided if MH flipped town)
Lair of the Cat (Mafia Stats)
Lynch/Vig(?) sounds good.
Sign up for League of Legends!
This might not mean anything but these flavor things don't really match up. From SB's role it's implied that he can guide people along the safest path of the forest. I was thinking that this may mean that the roleblocker gets people lost inside a forest and SB is the counter to that by showing them the path. If SB is anti-roleblock, what's his counter for that roleblock flavor? Why does he need to be a special wilderness guide in order to wake people up (which I assume would be the counter)? I could be off on this and SB's flavor is just flavor and I shouldn't interpret it to mean anything, but still it bothers me a bit.
Lair of the Cat (Mafia Stats)
On the contrary, I think I'd rather have the rest of the town confident that what we're trying to accomplish will go down as planned. That way, if something goes wrong, then you can blame either me or Stormblind and not have to worry about either of us going off on some tangent of 'well, I thought I'd try this' I mean, think about it, we're already set for me going to vig someone specific anyways.
yeah I guess this is also true. Especially as I'm a bit suspicious of SB atm.
unvote, Vote Jerubaal
That takes care of the 3 votes required (although I think it should be 2) for Gamerz vig.
Eh count: 4/6
Syrenz
SB
Gamerz
Buranri
We need eh's from Jerubaal and EP.
On a side note, I'm sad we lynched Joboman, would have been interesting to see his role play out .
Lair of the Cat (Mafia Stats)
Certainly not opposed to this plan, eh. A falseclaim is pretty black and white.
Slightly amused by how fabricated Manders' response is.
MTGS stats (won/played)
As scum - 3/5
As town - 5/7
As neutral - none
(I really have been scum a lot)
I'm now writing for Eye of the Vortex, come check out MTG articles and other geek culture
I also moderate the MTG forum, so register (it's free) and voice your thoughts.
Lair of the Cat (Mafia Stats)
So... I'm fine with lynching MH and vigging jerubbaal if she flips scum.. We should wait for eh's, however, and I'll wait for a vote count to vote wherever my vote is needed.
Signature from Nakamura and Heroes of the Planes Studios.
MAFIA STATS
Scum
Basic 17 (Afterlife) - lose
Basic 15 (Coffeehouse) - win
Duel Monsters - lose
Manipulator - lose
Town
Anita Blake - lose
Basic 17 (Demonata) - lose
Canada - ongoing
Ongoing
Basic 24
Igloos are made out of snow...
Really? Why? I was thinking the other way around...
Do you cover a person in snow and then protect him like that, or do you bring him inside the igloo and protect him like that?
With Jerub being alive today and having stated that he was flavorcopping MH last night MH knows (if she's scum) that she's going down today and she knows her case on SB isn't going to get him lynched before her. Her big case on SB looks like a final try to distance herself from SB before she gets lynched.
Lair of the Cat (Mafia Stats)
Because, think about it. No scum have been killed, so it's safe to assume there's probably three left. It's pretty close to end of game, so yeah, once you guys mislynch me, you'll vig Jerub, but that still leaves 2 scum alive to possibly win the game.
Die, scum.
I'm as good as dead, so I'll go ahead and post my thoughts on everybody:
Syrenz - town. This is typical town Syrenz play.
Gamerz - leaning town, but in no way is he "confirmed" town
Zebi - He still feels off to me. Neutral
Buranri - also feels off. Ability's pretty confirmed, but not necessarily town. Neutral
Shibui - town. Yeah, this new doc information (him only doccing RafK) makes sense flavorwise, and makes me feel he's pretty much confirmed.
jerubbaal - Die, scum.
SB - I still don't like him. Probable scum.
Tired of corporate corruption ruining your favorite MtG site?
Come join ours!!
We even have Mafia!!
SK counts as scum. In a mini I'd imagine that there's 3 scum and if there's an SK I'm guessing 1 SK 2 mafia for total scum.
Pretty sure you're scum trying to make us worry about an additional nonexistent scum anyways.
Lair of the Cat (Mafia Stats)
Technically speaking flavorwise if you lose your ability you should die as well I think, because you aren't Nootaikok Pukkeenegak, Inuit Guy Living in Igloo, you're igloo and if you lose the igloo you lose yourself. That might be wrong though because I'm confused about your whole thing. And it's irrelevant anyways, so let's move onwards.
I believe we have all the required eh's and I don't see anything else we need to do, so let's proceed with lynching MH please.
Lair of the Cat (Mafia Stats)
Well, here's the flaw i see with this.
A) We have zero proof that there even *IS* a mafia kill.
B) Due to the fact there HAVE been no kills except for the one last night against Rafk, im starting to wonder if perhaps this is just a high scum count game with little / no killing roles. I.E. 3-4 scum + an SK. There have been almost no powers floating around, and this would basically nullify the use of the doctors, AND make the tracker / watcher pretty much useless.
Also, of note, I do not appreciate you basically flinging flavor mud everywhere. So far, you've attacked my flavor for being a guide, WHICH WAS PRECISELY ANSWERED IN MY FLAVOR CLAIM
You've started attacking EP's flavor as well (that is definitely how i read your last post, subtle mudflinging). And i KNOW You're atleast a good enough player to know better then to attack a player based on flavor.
Im going to give YOU a re-read, because your attacks are based on near no substance (Flavor), and little on anything else. Especially given what we've seen so far from this setup.
I'm not sure how this is relevant to my quote.
I'm not basing cases solely on flavor, I'm noting and speculating inconsistencies with flavor.
I really don't see how this answers anything.
My speculation on EP's flavor was not meant as an attack at all. It's simple speculation.
MH is most likely to be scum due to Jerub's reveal, I think you're likely to be scum if MH is due to my first post that you quote here and because I've been suspicious of your claim for a bit now. So what attacks are based on just flavor?
Lair of the Cat (Mafia Stats)
I misunderstood. Although, this DOES paint a good point for my above statement: I doubt the mafia have a NK or they would have killed Jerub.
I'm not basing cases solely on flavor, I'm noting and speculating inconsistencies with flavor. ... Dude, that *IS* Basing an argument on flavor. That is the EPITOME of trying to use flavor text from ngiht abilities / ability descriptions to get someone lynched / make them look bad.
Also, ask any good player, speculation of ANYTHING Based off flavor is terrible.
Okay, you said this LAST page.
I answered by QUOTING that my ability basically loses those who would try to inhibit a player from getting their action off by losing them IN The forest. You're just playing dumb now.
Again, speculation based off flavor, and thats about it. And its speculation that definitely doesnt paint him in a favourable light. If anything, it's subtly calling his entire role into question.... again, based off flavor.
Cept, you've said this ONCE, and quoted flavor reasons multiple times. In what order do you think most people will note them? You're using reasons that could be justifiable, and using them to... do nothing, and instead harping on speculative flavor.
Excuse me if i dont like that.
That's not true at all. I don't know if you were following Asphodel Meadows but one of the mafia was Fox who was Jean-Baptiste d'Avignon. Now Fox claimed Jean-Baptiste d'Avignon Town Doctor who was in a wheelchair after a plane crash or something. In the bottom of the first post of the sign-up thread for that game there's a flavor piece that completely shows that Fox was falseclaiming. That's speculation based on flavor. The situation is obviously different from over here and is merely meant to show that flavor does have importance.
If something doesn't make sense flavorwise it may not warrant a vote but I feel it's worth looking at all the same.
I misinterpreted that. I thought that you guided people along the right path in the forest from those who tried to lead them off their path. I didn't see that you were saying that you lose the RB'er in the forest.
Mostly me being confused about things. I do not see EP as scum especially as his SK protection/kill thing makes sense both mechanically and flavorwise.
Okay so I just looked over my posts on the past couple of pages. I went over EP's flavor with him to try to get a better understanding of it and stated my confusion over it. I state that there was an inconsistency between your flavor and Zebi's RB flavor. Nowhere did I imply that I was voting anyone or thought someone was scum based on flavor.
Lair of the Cat (Mafia Stats)
Sign up for League of Legends!
[2/5] MandersHex - jerubbaal, emo_pinata
[3/5] jerubbaal- MandersHex, Stormblind, Syrenz
Signature from Nakamura and Heroes of the Planes Studios.
MAFIA STATS
Scum
Basic 17 (Afterlife) - lose
Basic 15 (Coffeehouse) - win
Duel Monsters - lose
Manipulator - lose
Town
Anita Blake - lose
Basic 17 (Demonata) - lose
Canada - ongoing
Ongoing
Basic 24
Sign up for League of Legends!
vote MandersHex
:/
Sign up for League of Legends!
Tired of corporate corruption ruining your favorite MtG site?
Come join ours!!
We even have Mafia!!
@mmod: hurry up and get this scum dead.
[5/5] MandersHex - jerubbaal, emo_pinata, Bunrari, Zebi, Gamerz
[2/5] jerubbaal- MandersHex, Stormblind, Syrenz
Dun worry Stormblind. It's only been 2 days since the votecount.
----------------------------------
And so at the turn of the first millenia after Christ, was when our great nation of Canada was first discovered by Vikings and was colonized by a small settlement at Newfoundland(*). At least, this was the only known settlement as we know it now.
Then the English and French came, and eventually Canada as we know it came into being. However the descendants of those vikings never forgot their claim on the land and so had come back to well, reclaim these lands in the name of Odin.
However Ravens aren't a good source of information, so with some too-old information, a Viking tried passing off as Terry Fox.
Well we Canadians might not care too much about history(**), but we sure as hell know what Terry Fox looks like.
That viking didn't last long.
bman65MandersHex - VIKINGS, Mafia Berserker - Lynched Day 4----------------------------------
Yeah night shouldn't last that long. Extenuating circumstances last time.
* - citation required
** - a lie
I'm writing the scene Saturday. I need to catch up in another mafia game first.
Writing day...
"Factories have claimed that they don't know what has happened with the sudden disappearance of Maple Syrup from their production lines. Ontario especially are clamoring for answers as Ottawa and Toronto are about to break out in riots as Canadians everywhere are up in a rage to missing out their most important ingredient of breakfast."
"It's not looking pretty here in Vancouver either as riots have already broken out; rioters have pulled stock American syrup out of the malls and are mass dumping it in the Pacific. The national guard as been sent but there is no way this'll end peacefully."
Bunrari - MAPLE SYRUP, Town Watcher - Nightkilled Night 4
----------------------------------
With 6 alive it's 4 to lynch.
If you think you should have received a PM and haven't, PM me IMMEDIATELY.
Lair of the Cat (Mafia Stats)
Signature from Nakamura and Heroes of the Planes Studios.
MAFIA STATS
Scum
Basic 17 (Afterlife) - lose
Basic 15 (Coffeehouse) - win
Duel Monsters - lose
Manipulator - lose
Town
Anita Blake - lose
Basic 17 (Demonata) - lose
Canada - ongoing
Ongoing
Basic 24
Lair of the Cat (Mafia Stats)
"last" night
Lair of the Cat (Mafia Stats)
It was the best play I could think of.
Also, why did you figure they'd take a potshot at anyone when you clearly stated you didn't believe they had a kill?
Lair of the Cat (Mafia Stats)