| Name | Subtype | Color | Cost | Rarity | Set | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Keeper of Progenitus | Elf Druid | Green | Rare | Shards of Alara | $1.32 | |
| Progenitus | Hydra Avatar | Multi | Mythic Rare | Conflux | $9.45 +$0.16 | |
| Progenitus | Hydra Avatar | Multi | Mythic Rare | Modern Masters | $10.14 | |
| Progenitus | Hydra Avatar | Multi | Mythic Rare | From the Vault: Legends | - | |
| Progenitus | Hydra Avatar | Multi | Special | Grand Prix Promos | - | |
| Relic of Progenitus | - | Colorless | Uncommon | The Brothers' War Commander | ||
| Relic of Progenitus | - | Colorless | Uncommon | Modern Event Deck | ||
| Relic of Progenitus | - | Colorless | Uncommon | Eternal Masters | $5.03 | |
| Relic of Progenitus | - | Colorless | Uncommon | Modern Masters | $5.32 ($0.04) | |
| Relic of Progenitus | - | Colorless | Common | Planechase | $5.25 | |
| Relic of Progenitus | - | Colorless | Common | Shards of Alara | $5.20 +$0.20 |