2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on SCG Open: Charlotte
    Don't hate on Todd. He's there since Osyp missed his flight, and he's not awful. He knows the cards, knows what he's talking about. Usually.

    Still, this week is more interesting due to the availability of the DGM cards being (obviously) better. We're starting to see some actual variety. About time.
    Posted in: Standard Archives
  • posted a message on [Single Card Discussion] Deadbridge Chant
    I do think the best comparison here is to Staff of Nin. They're both drawing you an extra card each turn, and they're both (essentially) random.

    The upsides to Deadbridge Chant are substantial though. If you're packing any kind of GY manipulation, you can make the randomness much more manageable. It goes so well with Deathrite Shaman that the two were obviously made with each other in mind.

    The other major upside is that, if you randomly hit a creature, it goes onto the battlefield, not just to your hand. Whether this is the reanimator replacement for Rites post-rotation or just another fancy CA machine, I'm not sure. But even if it "just" hits a dork, that's still an extra card and a free, uncounterable body in play. That the wording says "choose" instead of "target", and "put it onto the battlefield" instead of "cast it", is very relevant.
    Posted in: Standard Archives
  • posted a message on Possibility Storm into... nothing?
    Possibility Storm is the card in question, and here's the scenario.

    The Enchantment is already in play, and a spell is cast from a player's hand. For the sake of argument, it's a Sorcery. That's all it is. Simple, to the point, sorcery.

    You begin exiling cards from that player's library looking for the next Sorcery. There isn't another one. What happens?

    - Does the player not get to cast anything off of the "cascade-storm" effect? Is that Sorcery effectively a dead card?

    - Do the exiled cards go back into the library in a random order? (You'd have gone through literally their whole remaining library at that point)

    Thanks.

    Original question restored. -Carsten
    Posted in: Magic Rulings Archives
  • posted a message on [[M14]] Return of Slivers
    And they did update the text to be "Sliver creatures you control..."

    Should make things even more obvious to newer players.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on SCG Open: Somerset, NJ Discussion Thread!
    LBSteve, as someone who professes to love control but wants to play a "viable" deck, just play Jund. It's the same play style but with discard instead of counters (exactly as black has always answered counters).

    Jund's game plan is this: Respond to threats, stall to the late game, use mass removal, outdraw your opponents, sweep when needed, and land a big bomb (Olivia). Card advantage exists in the format, but sometimes Jund doesn't need it. They just have stronger cards.

    I think you'll find that you enjoy the games much more if you just play the deck.
    Posted in: Standard Archives
  • posted a message on SCG Open: Somerset, NJ Discussion Thread!
    Play Block then. There are control decks in that format, although it's not much more diverse than Standard currently. MonoR, Esper Control, Junk Midrange, or RWB Midrange. There are a few rogue decks, but that's about it.

    In Standard, Jund plays very similarly to a control deck. It packs answers. True, it doesn't pack card draw, but it does have card advantage -- just it chooses to do that with discard or mass removal.
    Posted in: Standard Archives
  • posted a message on [SCD] Sire of Insanity
    Quote from VeroProDiGY
    For what other creatures?

    Sire of Insanity is not an activated ability, it is a triggered ability, so what other creature would you reanimate/cast.


    Whatever you just made your opponent discard would be my guess. Heartless Summoning lets you rip this thing T4, which is well before most people would be ready for it. And it would still be a 5/3, which sounds pretttttty good for 4 mana.

    I haven't been a big fan of HS before, but with this and maybe a few more pieces, I could see it working. Shame the Scrivener has only 1 toughness. Probably necessary for balancing.
    Posted in: Standard Archives
  • posted a message on SCG Open: Somerset, NJ Discussion Thread!
    Reanimator wins again. I wish I could say I was surprised, but it just does so much right.

    The more I see of Standard, the more I cannot wait for Innistrad to rotate. I'm ready... already. And DGM just got released. I want Sir Snaps-a-lot, GoST, Bonfire, Unburial Rites, Restoration Angel, and Thragtusk to rotate.
    Posted in: Standard Archives
  • posted a message on SCG Open: Somerset, NJ Discussion Thread!
    Quote from Pasab
    Replay right now, Jund vs Junk Rites, Junk player played two spells so Huntmaster flipped again bringing in a Wolf which attacked the same turn and Judge and Junk player were OK... :lmao:


    He actually got a rules violation for that. It was also his second of the tournament at that time. It did get caught.

    I find it so interesting how Junk Reanimator is still such a favorite. It simply has so much raw power in what it's doing, and it attacks along several axis. Case in point: Acidic Slime does amazing things when blinked, reanimated.
    Posted in: Standard Archives
  • posted a message on [SCD] Sire of Insanity
    Quick question: even if the opponent does have instant-speed removal, if you play this guy as your last play of Main phase 2 and pass, does the discard trigger still go on the stack?

    If so, yes, they might get to kill it, but then everyone still goes to 0 cards in hand.
    That's potent.

    I guess my question is whether the opponent gets the opportunity for priority before the end step after Main2.

    Playing this guy should usually end games. It's already done that a few times today, and even that's been against non-dedicated-control decks.
    Posted in: Standard Archives
  • posted a message on SCG Open: Somerset, NJ Discussion Thread!
    Sire is so sick. Expect that price to go sky high(er).
    Posted in: Standard Archives
  • posted a message on Frank Karsten Top 8 Playing Only Creatures
    Yeah, I'm not suggesting that having no sideboard is better, but I do believe that his lesson (that many people over-sideboard, and often) is worth learning. Sometimes people sideboard and think they're improving their deck, when the reality is the opposite.

    Naya Blitz is one of those decks that really walks the razor's edge. Some of the cards in the deck should be replaced in certain matchups, but you don't want to dilute what makes the deck effective of your opponent won't have to beat you, you'll have done that for him.
    Posted in: Standard Archives
  • posted a message on Challenge: Tibalt the Terribad
    I know it's not the best of its kin, but there's still a phoenix in standard to consider if you're really looking seriously at recursive beaters. Firewing Phoenix has a similar buyback to the new Pyrewild Shaman but without the requirement of creatures dealing damage first. It also has evasion, which might help enable the Shaman's buyback.

    I'm not saying it's a great card, even a good card, but it's another option. If you guys are going to make Tibalt work... well, you might need all the options you can get :p
    Posted in: Standard Archives
  • posted a message on Frank Karsten Top 8 Playing Only Creatures
    Quote from DarkRitual
    Eh... I mean, you don't see bringing in Boros Reckoner from the side against other aggro decks? Or perhaps Boros charm against control? Maybe Dryad Militant against Junk/control? I mean, you take away a little from the human subtheme, but only 8-10 of the non-land cards in the deck. Certainly you can't say in those matchups those cards wouldn't be better.


    For every card you add in, you have to take something out. What would a Dryad Militant be better than? It is important to look at the synergies the deck is running with, and for every non-human you add in, you're taking a risk.

    Especially cards like Boros Reckoner, which have steep casting cost requirements, you may realize that he'll be dead in-hand more often than he'd be profitable on the board. That's the reality of Naya Blitz.
    Posted in: Standard Archives
  • posted a message on Possibility Cursed
    Quote from MoonliteKnight
    This might be nitpicking,
    but isn't a better name for the deck 'Exhausted Possibilities'?


    I like this.

    This is the list I was testing tonight, and against even Naya Blitz it was splitting 50/50 post-board (when they brought in Thalia).


    Not the prettiest thing, but man... when those synergies get going, this deck is nuts. And ideally you set up the hard lock before they can Planar Cleansing you, or else you just lose.
    Posted in: Standard Archives
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.