2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • 1

    posted a message on Peter Mohrbacher News?
    He takes mail-in's. You can check out his website for where to send your cards, or if you'd prefer to have him sign your cards in person, I'm sure you could e-mail him about his upcoming schedule: http://www.vandalhigh.com/about-me/

    A lot of artists have websites these days, and most will take mail-in's if you provide postage (I like to give them a donation as a thank you). It can't hurt to search for their site/e-mail and ask.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • 1

    posted a message on [[M14]] Path of Bravery
    Quote from KilroyWasHere
    Soul Sisters approves.


    I'd rather just play Honor of the Pure
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • 12

    posted a message on [M14] Thoughtseize
    Quote from turkey23
    Show me one successful D&T list with 4 Hymns and 4 Thoughtseizes main and i'll show you four successful lists (Ad Nauseum Tendrils, High Tide, Esper Control, Junk Zoo) with 4 Thoughtseizes and no Hymns main. Hymn > Thoughtseize, I'll grant you. But BB is too untenable and they often only have one card you care about.


    I'm not sure which is more implausible: finding Hymn in D&T, a mono-white deck, or finding Thoughtseize in High Tide, a mono-blue deck.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • 5

    posted a message on Legendary/Planeswalker Rules Change Poll
    The poll needs stronger options, such as "I abhor...", "I hate...", "I WILL NEVER PLAY MAGIC AGAIN", "DIE MARO DIE"
    Posted in: Opinions & Polls
  • 1

    posted a message on The Death of a Strategy
    Quote from jimmyrussles77
    Wah, wah im a control player and i dont like aggro.
    Or im an aggro player and i dont like control.

    Let this thread have 2 or 3 pages of arugeing and let it die off.

    We get one every few days anyways.


    Right? There should be a sticky. If there is one I'm unaware of, it should be in this sub-forum. Not that anyone would use it. People love making special snowflake posts.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • 4

    posted a message on The Death of a Strategy
    There should be a sticky somewhere for topics like this. Call it "The Official 'Magic was Better Back in my Day' Thread" or "Get off My Lawn, Netdeckers" or something.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • 1

    posted a message on M14 - 10 playmats from Ultra Pro
    Doubt it's anything insane. Maybe there's a new cycle of bad dual lands. Making all 10 playmats land seems so meh after they've done it for RTR and Gatecrash though. I want dragons and explosions on my playmats, dammit!

    Can't wait for the "OMG 5 10 PLAYMATS + ANNIVERSARY= ORIGINAL SNOW DUALS" speculation post.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • 1

    posted a message on What value difference (if any) do you apply to trading legacy for standard cards?
    Moat is maybe a bad example because of the lofty value, but if you substitute in FoW, Wasteland, or Jace TMS, he'd be right. I can count on one hand the amount of times I've been able to trade Standard to Legacy on equal price values. I can't recall how many people have inquired about my Legacy staples and were willing to trade more value in Standard cards.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • 1

    posted a message on Stuff you don't "get".
    Quote from jonboyjon

    And with the Atheist stuff - I had always been under the impression that right wing America believed that if you were Atheist you were immoral, because morals are a religious thing and if you don't subscribe to religion you can't have morals.


    No, that's really only a small percentage of right wing Americans. Probably around the same percentage of far left Americans that believe if you're religious you must be uneducated, because science can disprove parts of the Bible, and if you don't believe in science, you're practically worthless.

    For the record, I say this as a pagan Libertarian, so I have no lot with either party. WAR casting meaningless votes
    Posted in: Talk and Entertainment
  • 1

    posted a message on GP Trial etiquette?
    Quote from Slayer Alex
    seems to me like its just better to win the tournament with no intentions of going. Forget about etiquette. lol


    Etiquette is key. As CorpT said, if you want to play competitively, having a playtest group is important. You would not be welcome playing with me if I offered to let you have all the prizes we would win minus the byes and you said, "No thanks. I don't want to go to the GP, but I'm going to play out anyway." You'd be surprised how much you can gain by helping other people out and scooping (more prizes! potentially a playtest partner/group!).

    EDIT: I don't get why anybody would want to play out in this scenario. Does no one understand strategic decision making? The options are:

    GP guy wins: gets byes + big prize
    Timmy loses: gets small prize

    Timmy wins: wastes byes, opens Worldspine Wurm in big prize pool, freaks out
    GP guy loses: gets small prize, smashes Timmy's bike.

    Split
    GP guy: gets byes
    Timmy: gets all the prizes

    *assuming GP Guy's only goal is GP byes, and Timmy wants to get some sweet cards for his Dumb Green Creatures deck*

    Split is by far the best result for both players. There's no logical reason to play out. "Winning" is not a logical reason. If you're at the event, you're either there because you want to win and earn byes at the GP, and would benefit from splitting, or you're there to have fun/win/win prizes, in which case, you still benefit from the split. Unless of course, you would rather be listed as the event winner and let the byes go to waste than earn more prizes. In that case, you're an illogical person, so my point still stands.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.