• posted a message on The Wall Mafia - Day 4 - New Leadership
    Quote from Cyan »
    Seems like you're making a big deal out of nothing here. I still think that my plan of 'go with whatever Megiddo chose' is the best plan. No new meaningful information has entered the game since Megiddo died, and his choice is at least 100% trustworthy. But no one else that I care about the opinion of wants to go along with this, so..what else am I supposed to do? Of course I need time to reconsider. And I still haven't made up my mind.


    We have you tripping all over yourself, actually, which is pretty good "new" information. I'd also daresay that KCC refusing to claim at this juncture is pretty informative. Again - why would you trust Megiddo's choice over your own? Do you think Megiddo is a better player than you are? Do you not think you're town? This is an inconsistent mindset, and a scum one, as such.

    Quote from Cyan »
    And keep in mind, I made that post after you declared your unchangeable Elect for KCC. If you were correct that the scum team is me and KCC, why would I even bother with my suggestion there? I would just go along with you electing KCC and hope that you or Hunger could be convinced to vote for MP/Cythare at any point ever, which would instantly win the game for my scum team.


    Because it wouldn't tie you and [scumbuddy] together if one of you flipped scum. Additionally, there's a fair chance that Megiddo could have chosen you or KCC as the LC, which not only removes the information of "who elected whom" but also means neither of you have to convince anyone else to be in favor of one of you being the LC.

    Quote from Cyan »
    As for my claim. Should I have Seppeled it and just claimed whatever I felt like? Clearly that worked out very well for him. I claimed the role I was given. I am not bad at (false)claiming as scum, and you know it.


    Given the phrasing of Chris's ability and the nature of my own, as well as the existence of the LC, it's incredibly dubious that your role would ever exist in a game.

    Quote from Cyan »
    Like..I would have to be a godawful scum player for anything you are accusing me of here to make any sense whatsoever. I'm not, and you know it. So the question for me is, why are you reaching so hard to make me look bad here?


    You're also not a bad town player, and townCyan would not only NOT defer to another player's judgment when it comes to who to trust with a double vote, but would also know better than to claim "I'm a 1-Shot Vig! Oh, but my target MIGHT be random, herf derf!" At that point, you would simply either not shoot, ever, and you might even be better off claiming vanilla. But scumCyan has every reason not to claim vanilla, especially if your buddy is KCC. "Why didn't your shot go through last Night, Cyan?" "Oh, must have been that silly random clause, which means KCC took the bullet, which confirms both of us! Let's lynch Cythare/plum! Choo choo!" None of your play makes sense from a town perspective, which is what you should be arguing (another catch, I'd say) instead of explaining why your play DOESN'T make sense from a scum perspective (which it totally does) by strawmanning the issue.

    Quote from Cyan »
    Something seems very amiss now. I'm deciding between Hunger and KCC for my LC vote, but need to re-read some early(er) game interactions first.


    I'll tell you what's amiss - the blue in your role PM.

    Given that you have stated all game that you would not lynch me and I'm totally town and that my ability use can only make sense from a town perspective, etc., why are you unwilling to now elect me the LC? Is that so?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Wall Mafia - Day 4 - New Leadership
    (Oh, or making me the LC also works for my plan and essentially clears plum/Cythare if we lynch scum toDay and I'm the NK and clears me if plum/Cythare are the NK.)
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Wall Mafia - Day 4 - New Leadership
    I'm now completely fine with lynching Cyan and KCC without re-reading.

    KCC claiming "Bulletproof with stipulations" reads like the scum planning several phases ago that they were going to try to secure the LC role, coupled with Cyan's insistence that we "let Megiddo choose, though [Cyan] would probably choose [Iso] if prompted" but then "needing to reconsider" and his awful, awful claim of "I may or may not Vig somebody that I target, who knows!" has me pretty sold on this. Tie it all in with the sinister feeling I had from KCC that I couldn't explain when I was dreaming about this game, and I'm willing to overlook plum's "I have done absolutely nothing useful with my Tracker ability" in favor of lynching our obvious scum, here.

    Hunger, Cythare, your assessment on the above, please.

    I don't need to convince plum to lynch Cyan or KCC with me, at least, provided that the LC is somebody other than one of those three players.

    As such, I am most comfortable with Hunger being the LC toDay. It ekes out the slim chance that Cythare/plum are the scum (which I think is a far and away distant possiblity at this point), preventing them from becoming the LC in that tiny, tiny universe of probability, and prevents the two players I trust the least in this game (Cyan, KCC) from becoming the LC.

    @DCIII: Requesting a reconsideration to the rule that votes to elect an LC can not change due to the fact that I completely missed that rule the first time, please.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Full Deck Mafia: Day 2 - Blind Cut
    But I'm the most important person here ( trololololol ) and I said he could take the donut.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Wall Mafia - Day 4 - New Leadership
    ^
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Full Deck Mafia: Day 2 - Blind Cut
    I'm not sure how I missed that part. Facepalm

    Anyway, just because he added a bad point to the case doesn't mean the rest of the case is bad.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Wall Mafia - Day 4 - New Leadership
    Quote from masterplum »
    Indeed. That is why scum would lose

    toot


    no ur rong

    Quote from KittyCupCake »
    Quote from Iso »
    can you claim now
    I claimed Yesterday.


    Really. Where?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Full Deck Mafia: Day 2 - Blind Cut
    I don't really see how that's at all what he's saying. Why are you misrepresenting the case?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Wall Mafia - Day 4 - New Leadership
    (not that that could happen)
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Wall Mafia - Day 4 - New Leadership
    which is why we'd lose in an endgame scenario with both you and myself, presuming you're town.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.