2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on AI safety
    Quote from Highroller »
    If I just use a little imagination, I can come up with freaking Middle Earth. Is Gandalf real? Should I start worrying about whether there's a Balrog in the next cave?


    I assume you have at least a little imagination. So please submit one book and a trilogy of books where you create an entire high fantasy world with deep character development.

    If you cannot produce these works I will have to assume that you have less than a little imagination. If you produce no writings I will have to assume you have no imagination. If either of the last two cases describes you, a person with less than a little imagination or no imagination, then please disregard my previous post. That post was clearly designed for people with at least a little imagination. Which you have graciously defined as the culmination of Tolkien's greatest books.

    Full disclosure I have never read a Tolkien book. If he has better books than the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings trilogy I apologize for not knowing about them
    Posted in: Debate
  • posted a message on Remove Andrew Jackson from the $20?
    I would also add Hellen Keller to the mix.
    Posted in: Debate
  • posted a message on Remove Andrew Jackson from the $20?
    What about abigail adams or mary "pitcher" hays?
    Posted in: Debate
  • posted a message on AI safety
    We have already created computers that can learn from past experience.

    http://www.newyorker.com/tech/elements/deepmind-artificial-intelligence-video-games

    If you just use a little imagination it is easy to see why Elon Musk spent his money. Humans are advancing faster and faster every year. If we have a computer that can learn how to play games and is constanlty looking for better plays it will not take that long to create human level A.I.
    Posted in: Debate
  • posted a message on Child Immigrants
    By now I am sure most Americans have some familiarity with the large influx of children immigrants. My question for the thread is what do you think should be the solution to this problem.

    My solution would be something like this

    1.) Inspect all the children for any health or life threatening problems.

    2.) Determine which children want to go back home.

    3.) For the the children that want to stay we put them in the immigration system.

    4.) We set them up with education/job training opportunities.

    5.) When the children reach age 16 they should work to pay for the debt incurred by the state.
    Posted in: Debate
  • posted a message on Should the Washington Redskins change their name?
    Quote from billydaman »

    Depends on the harm. We've been through this. If there is tangible proof of harm (namely monetary) an equitable amount money should be paid to the victim. I have not seen or heard of any tangible harm occurring to a Native American or Native Americans due to the Washington Redskins name. I personally do not consider feelings as tangible harm. If we are speaking legally, please make your point instead of asking 20 questions.
    So we should punish people's right to free speech depending on the harm created by that free speech. I assume monetary harm and physical harm are apart of that belief. Are there any non-monetary and non-physical harms that would be apart of that belief?
    Posted in: Debate
  • posted a message on Should the Washington Redskins change their name?
    Quote from algebra »
    Quote from billydaman »
    I'm not sure of potential. I see there needs to exist actual harm. I'm still wondering how this is relevant to the Redskins issue.
    If harm can be shown from a type of speech that type of speech should be punished?


    Billydman you have forgotten this question. What is your answer? This question was spawned off our discussion revolving around why slander should be punished by the government.
    Posted in: Debate
  • posted a message on 8-4
    Quote from FTW1987 »
    Feedback: Generally opening on-color rares and having every other player stay out of green and pass you bombs seems good. Nice draft pool!!

    Congrats on the split!

    Yea this draft was pretty lucky. Green was wide open, but I had only every seen green paired with blue. I did not see any blue coming so I paniked on what to do. This format has some powerful synergy decks. I attack.

    As for your deck, your curve has a lot of 5s and seems a little slow to get there if you dont have Sol Ring, Fyndhorn Elves, Nature's Lore or Sylvan Library in your opener. Yeah, I get you want to maximize fatties, but you also want early plays when you don't get lucky draws. Maybe maindeck Fastbond to help ramp? Or the Death Buzzard to hold off weenies?

    Fastbond came in every game usually siding out hymm. Death Buzzard won me a game against goblins. I usually sided out one jungle wurm and the predatory nightstalker.

    P2P6 -- I think Grizzly Fate is a better 5-drop than Jungle Wurm. IMO Jungle Wurm is pretty mediocre.

    I actually thought about that play alot. Why i chose the wurm had to do with the fact that I could reanimate or eureka the wurm and not the grizzly fate

    P2P11 -- Do you see yourself playing Tangle much? Dauthi Mercenary is a fine 3-drop, you don't have many 3-drops, etc.

    I wanted a creature that could block. The shadow turned me off. I did side in tangle against the goblins deck. He would build up an army and cast falter to alpha strike me.

    P2P12 -- It's unlikely you're splashing red at this point, and if Fires is going around that late (and if people are passing you such good green cards), there's probably no one playing RG. No reason to hate this. Meanwhile Tribute to the Wild is a solid sideboard card against Astral Slide.dec, something aggro typically struggles with. Fledgling Djinn is not amazing in your strategy but is still an early drop and gives you some way to interact with flyers. Either seem like decent sideboard cards.

    I did not think about an answer for slide. I was afraid of the deck too. I started gettign scared that black was drying up and should I be red instead of black, but that was just my jitters not a defensible pick

    P3P2 -- I'd have been pretty tempted to grab the Edric and splash blue with Krosan Tuskers. Normally I'd say Roar of the Wurm, but I guess you didn't have any discard outlets yet at that point.

    I really wanted the roar. I really thought I would see a mongrel by now. I started thinking that my plan was dead in the water. No discard outlets reanimater FTW.

    P3P3 -- Reanimate! Card is good, even better in GB decks with fatties, even better if you can nab any Wild Mongrels or Putrid Imps later. (apparently it wheeled anyway!)

    I did not think that I would be able to get the fatties into the yard.
    Posted in: Sealed Pool & Draftcap Discussion
  • posted a message on 8-4
    Pack 1 pick 1:
    Benalish Trapper
    Counterspell
    Skirk Prospector
    Fyndhorn Elves
    Predatory Nightstalker
    Aftershock
    Radiant's Judgment
    Krovikan Sorcerer
    Giant Strength
    Afterlife
    Fires of Yavimaya
    Famine
    Salt Flats
    --> Sol Ring
    Goblin General (FOIL)

    Pack 1 pick 2:
    Gustcloak Harrier
    Frantic Search
    Spark Spray
    --> Fyndhorn Elves
    Dark Ritual
    Skywing Aven
    Solar Blast
    Radiant's Judgment
    Ophidian
    Giant Strength
    Kezzerdrix
    Pine Barrens
    Power Sink
    Tyrant's Choice (FOIL)

    Pack 1 pick 3:
    Mistmoon Griffin
    Counterspell
    Goblin Commando
    Krosan Vorine
    Paralyze
    Tribute to the Wild
    Death's-Head Buzzard
    Elephant Guide
    Fallen Askari
    Armor of Thorns
    --> Animate Dead
    Burning of Xinye
    Kindle (FOIL)

    Pack 1 pick 4:
    Mistmoon Griffin
    Counterspell
    Goblin Commando
    --> Krosan Vorine
    Skirge Familiar
    Claws of Wirewood
    Putrid Imp
    Provoke
    Mesmeric Fiend
    Rocky Tar Pit
    Gaea's Embrace
    Reckless Charge (FOIL)

    Pack 1 pick 5:
    Teroh's Faithful
    Killer Whale
    Skirk Drill Sergeant
    Skirge Familiar
    Keeneye Aven
    Gilded Light
    Skywing Aven
    Tranquil Thicket
    Thopter Squadron
    --> Penumbra Wurm
    Nightscape Familiar (FOIL)

    Pack 1 pick 6:
    Obsessive Search
    Chartooth Cougar
    Benevolent Bodyguard
    Choking Tethers
    Beetleback Chief
    --> Jungle Wurm
    Addle
    Aftershock
    Krovikan Sorcerer
    Pillaging Horde

    Pack 1 pick 7:
    Killer Whale
    Goblin Matron
    Paralyze
    Fallen Askari
    Armor of Thorns
    Sudden Strength
    Blazing Specter
    --> Fastbond
    Gustcloak Harrier (FOIL)

    Pack 1 pick 8:
    Skirk Prospector
    Urborg Uprising
    Renewed Faith
    Skyshroud Forest
    Grasslands
    --> Symbiotic Wurm
    Karn, Silver Golem
    Skirge Familiar (FOIL)

    Pack 1 pick 9:
    Skirk Prospector
    --> Aftershock
    Krovikan Sorcerer
    Giant Strength
    Afterlife
    Fires of Yavimaya
    Salt Flats

    Pack 1 pick 10:
    Spark Spray
    Dark Ritual
    Radiant's Judgment
    Giant Strength
    Kezzerdrix
    --> Pine Barrens

    Pack 1 pick 11:
    Krosan Vorine
    --> Paralyze
    Tribute to the Wild
    Death's-Head Buzzard
    Armor of Thorns

    Pack 1 pick 12:
    Skirge Familiar
    Claws of Wirewood
    Putrid Imp
    --> Provoke

    Pack 1 pick 13:
    --> Skirge Familiar
    Gilded Light
    Tranquil Thicket

    Pack 1 pick 14:
    --> Addle
    Pillaging Horde

    Pack 1 pick 15:
    --> Armor of Thorns

    ------ VMA ------

    Pack 2 pick 1:
    Choking Tethers
    Goblin Matron
    Phantom Nomad
    Circular Logic
    Goblin Patrol
    Basking Rootwalla
    Urborg Uprising
    Falter
    Brilliant Halo
    Krovikan Sorcerer
    Dreampod Druid
    Reanimate
    Mountain Valley
    --> Berserk
    Afterlife (FOIL)

    Pack 2 pick 2:
    Benalish Trapper
    Counterspell
    Skirk Prospector
    --> Predatory Nightstalker
    Elephant Guide
    Carnophage
    Claws of Wirewood
    Fledgling Djinn
    Tribute to the Wild
    Fires of Yavimaya
    Akroma's Blessing
    Gaea's Embrace
    Burning Wish
    Falter (FOIL)

    Pack 2 pick 3:
    Hulking Goblin
    Noble Templar
    Rescind
    Beetleback Chief
    Urborg Uprising
    Mesmeric Fiend
    Tangle
    Dauthi Mercenary
    --> Nature's Lore
    Goblin Trenches
    Turnabout
    Cruel Bargain
    Secluded Steppe (FOIL)

    Pack 2 pick 4:
    Obsessive Search
    Spark Spray
    Claws of Wirewood
    Fledgling Djinn
    Tribute to the Wild
    Lonely Sandbar
    Fallen Askari
    Fires of Yavimaya
    Empyrial Armor
    --> Hymn to Tourach
    Shivan Wurm
    Death's-Head Buzzard (FOIL)

    Pack 2 pick 5:
    Goblin General
    Krosan Vorine
    Spinal Graft
    Exile
    Aquamoeba
    Reckless Charge
    Shelter
    Owl Familiar
    Skyshroud Forest
    --> Eureka
    Fledgling Djinn (FOIL)

    Pack 2 pick 6:
    Soltari Trooper
    Goblin Patrol
    --> Jungle Wurm
    Dark Ritual
    Wall of Diffusion
    Barren Moor
    Seal of Cleansing
    Solar Blast
    Grizzly Fate
    Renewed Faith (FOIL)

    Pack 2 pick 7:
    Spark Spray
    Elvish Aberration
    --> Chainer's Edict
    Scrivener
    Tranquil Thicket
    Reckless Charge
    Reviving Vapors
    Animate Dead
    Salt Flats

    Pack 2 pick 8:
    Chartooth Cougar
    Gustcloak Harrier
    --> Krosan Tusker
    Scrivener
    Kindle
    Seal of Cleansing
    Goblin Goon
    Goblin Patrol (FOIL)

    Pack 2 pick 9:
    Goblin Patrol
    Urborg Uprising
    Falter
    Brilliant Halo
    Krovikan Sorcerer
    --> Dreampod Druid
    Mountain Valley

    Pack 2 pick 10:
    Skirk Prospector
    --> Claws of Wirewood
    Fledgling Djinn
    Tribute to the Wild
    Fires of Yavimaya
    Falter (FOIL)

    Pack 2 pick 11:
    Hulking Goblin
    Urborg Uprising
    --> Tangle
    Dauthi Mercenary
    Cruel Bargain

    Pack 2 pick 12:
    Spark Spray
    Fledgling Djinn
    Tribute to the Wild
    --> Fires of Yavimaya

    Pack 2 pick 13:
    --> Spinal Graft
    Reckless Charge
    Shelter

    Pack 2 pick 14:
    --> Goblin Patrol
    Seal of Cleansing

    Pack 2 pick 15:
    --> Reckless Charge

    ------ VMA ------

    Pack 3 pick 1:
    Benevolent Bodyguard
    Choking Tethers
    Beetleback Chief
    Arrogant Wurm
    Tyrant's Choice
    Falter
    Barren Moor
    Renewed Faith
    Keeneye Aven
    Chain Lightning
    Sarcomancy
    Prophetic Bolt
    Flood Plain
    --> Deranged Hermit
    Tranquil Thicket (FOIL)

    Pack 3 pick 2:
    Teroh's Faithful
    Temporal Fissure
    Orcish Lumberjack
    --> Simian Grunts
    Choking Sands
    Gilded Light
    Scrivener
    Seal of Cleansing
    Man-o'-War
    Deathreap Ritual
    Pine Barrens
    Roar of the Wurm
    Edric, Spymaster of Trest
    Killer Whale (FOIL)

    Pack 3 pick 3:
    Deftblade Elite
    Obsessive Search
    Chartooth Cougar
    Jungle Wurm
    Urborg Uprising
    Sudden Strength
    Claws of Wirewood
    Putrid Imp
    --> Provoke
    Cloud Djinn
    Reanimate
    Smokestack
    Waterfront Bouncer (FOIL)

    Pack 3 pick 4:
    Soltari Emissary
    Repel
    Orcish Lumberjack
    Giant Mantis
    Secluded Steppe
    --> Death's-Head Buzzard
    Claws of Wirewood
    Nightscape Familiar
    Tribute to the Wild
    Serendib Efreet
    Bad River
    Wall of Diffusion (FOIL)

    Pack 3 pick 5:
    Mistmoon Griffin
    Goblin Commando
    --> Wild Mongrel
    Paralyze
    Gilded Light
    Skywing Aven
    Tranquil Thicket
    Aftershock
    Radiant's Judgment
    Ivory Tower
    Stoic Champion

    Pack 3 pick 6:
    Rescind
    Chartooth Cougar
    Gustcloak Harrier
    Choking Tethers
    Giant Mantis
    --> Paralyze
    Forgotten Cave
    Aftershock
    Ivory Tower
    Goblin Commando (FOIL)

    Pack 3 pick 7:
    Brindle Shoat
    Putrid Imp
    Provoke
    Lonely Sandbar
    Nature's Lore
    Blazing Specter
    Devout Witness
    --> Sylvan Library
    Rescind (FOIL)

    Pack 3 pick 8:
    Temporal Fissure
    Orcish Lumberjack
    Elvish Aberration
    Ophidian
    Wall of Diffusion
    Mana Prism
    Thopter Squadron
    --> Norwood Priestess

    Pack 3 pick 9:
    Benevolent Bodyguard
    Choking Tethers
    Beetleback Chief
    Falter
    Renewed Faith
    Sarcomancy
    --> Tranquil Thicket (FOIL)

    Pack 3 pick 10:
    Temporal Fissure
    Orcish Lumberjack
    Choking Sands
    Seal of Cleansing
    Deathreap Ritual
    --> Pine Barrens

    Pack 3 pick 11:
    Jungle Wurm
    Urborg Uprising
    Claws of Wirewood
    Putrid Imp
    --> Reanimate

    Pack 3 pick 12:
    Orcish Lumberjack
    --> Giant Mantis
    Claws of Wirewood
    Tribute to the Wild

    Pack 3 pick 13:
    Goblin Commando
    Gilded Light
    --> Tranquil Thicket

    Pack 3 pick 14:
    Chartooth Cougar
    --> Ivory Tower

    Pack 3 pick 15:
    --> Provoke


    Feedback appreciated. This was my second VMA draft.

    I split the finals after defeating an ok red/blue splash black storm deck that brain frezzed me on turn 5. Then I had to defeat a goblin burn mono red deck.
    Posted in: Sealed Pool & Draftcap Discussion
  • posted a message on Should the Washington Redskins change their name?
    Quote from billydaman »
    I'm not sure of potential. I see there needs to exist actual harm. I'm still wondering how this is relevant to the Redskins issue.
    If harm can be shown from a type of speech that type of speech should be punished?
    Posted in: Debate
  • posted a message on Should the Washington Redskins change their name?
    Quote from billydaman »
    If you want me to focus on my opinioins on slander, open another thread. I do not find slander a relevant topic here. You and Tiax interjected a slanderous name into the disussion mutliple times. This slanderous name is not synomous or relevant to the Redskins issue. One, you target me specifically, in order for it to have some sembalance to "Redskins" you have to remove my indivduality (i.e. name) from it. Two, for it to be similar, you'd have to change it to rapist, hick, redneck, honkey, etc, etc. Three, with the inclussion of my name into the name, it leaves no doubt who you are talking about and its not a football team or an orgazantion. Its easily understood that when someone mentions Redskins in causaul coverastaion, they are talking about a football team, not person or group.

    It's a flawed anaology meant to obsfugate the issue.
    I do not think that "billydman is a rapist" is analogous to "redskins." I want to understand how you can argue on one hand that using a term that is insulting to a group of people "redskin" is fine, insulting one person "billdman is a rapists" is wrong? I understand your argument for the use of "redskin" I find your argument flawed and unconvincing. I do not fully understand why you think you should be able to punish my freedom of speech to say "billdman is a rapist."

    So again do you believe that you have the right to punish my freedom of speech because tangible harm could happen, but before any tangible harm has been proven?
    Posted in: Debate
  • posted a message on Should the Washington Redskins change their name?
    Quote from billydaman »
    No I did not. I've answered this. Because it can have a tangible cost to the person who is being slandered. There is no tangible cost to Native Americans when the Redskins uses "Redskins".
    So slander should be illegal because it could cause tangible harm? My free speech should be restricted because something could happen? You think that free speech should be restricted if there is a chance that tangible harm could happen before any tangible harm has been proven?
    Posted in: Debate
  • posted a message on Should the Washington Redskins change their name?
    Quote from billydaman »
    I'm sorry, I had this discussion with Tiax and answered these questions.

    When I say Redskins, I'm talking about a football team and everyone knows I'm talking about a football team unless you are just stupid.
    You dodged my question. Why is slander wrong?
    Posted in: Debate
  • posted a message on Should the Washington Redskins change their name?
    Quote from billydaman »
    Sure. Pretty much what fluffy said.
    So you believe that I should be able to trademark "billydman is a rapists," and you believe you should be able to sue me for slander. On what grounds do you have to punish me for my free speech?
    Posted in: Debate
  • posted a message on Should the Washington Redskins change their name?
    Quote from billydaman »
    Quote from billydaman »
    I do not disagree they have the power to do it. I do not think they should have this power.
    Power to limit the kind of trademarks based on offendeness, sorry was not clear. Not surprising this was not obvious to some.

    Although I do have some objections to trademarks, patents and such.
    So you do believe that the government should protect trademarks. How should the government choose which trademarks to protect? Should the government spend time and resources protecting the "washington billydman is a rapists" trademark why or why not?
    Posted in: Debate
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.