2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on Any suggestions on a good offensive blue or white creature?
    It looks like you're running control, one of my favourite creatures for that kind of deck was Mist Dragon. it is damn near unkillable too.
    Rainbow Efreet is a less mana-intensive mist dragon.
    Iridescent Angel was mentioned above and is a lot of fun.
    Masticore is pretty sweet, but he craves more mana than your deck is running. His little brother, Razormane Masticore is a bit less resistant to removal, but he is a more efficient beater, easier on the mana, and available for around a dollar.
    Pristine Angel was a classic from mirrodin-kamigawa type 2
    Jareth, Leonine Titan was tons of fun back in odyssey-onslaught mono-white control
    Sunblast Angel can increase your removal density with a nice fatty body
    Frost Titan works if you drafted one, otherwise prolly too expensive
    Mageta the Lion is a reusable wrath on fatty stick
    Serra Angel... I can't believe you newfangled kids missed this one. Stupid baneslayer...
    Posted in: Casual & Multiplayer Formats
  • posted a message on My Attempt at The Cheese Stands Alone
    I had tried gixian shenanigans before (in a proxied test deck--this is my first actual real cheese build) and they just seemed... slow. By this I mean that you made yourself extremely vulnerable for 2 turns on end as you tried to combo off. It felt awkward and had a very high reliance on multi-mana lands (because how else do you get rid of the claws themselves). It seems the all-win deck settled on those cards because neither is dead on its own (tribe is an excellent blocker, and gix lets you pull life from chump-blocks or lets you pull clutch survival) rather than their efficiency.

    I liked spite when i was doing the research for this deck, but it leaves me too vulnerable if i ever try to run barren glory (cheese wins as a static effect, barren as a triggered) because they get one last hurrah to try to deal with me.

    I settled on apocalypse because it is the only thing that i saw capable of setting up the board state without leaving yourself vulnerable. The worst possible thing that can happen is them disenchanting your O-ring in response to apocalypse or them stifling the o-ring's return clause. Either way, while your win is neutralized, you are in no imminent danger and still stand a chance.

    I'm not trying to gun for the win outright (although i'm still debating the morningtide tutor as well as some nice enlightened tutors), I'm expecting to play almost like mono-w control.


    how long do you think the enchantress is gonna manage to stay on the board in multiplayer? I'm hopeful that as a 0/2 she'll seem un-imposing enough, but at the same time, i've found (to my dismay) that a simple sensei's divining top at our table makes you the threat (that everyone gangs up on). Will this board-based draw be uneffective or too risky?
    Posted in: Casual & Multiplayer Formats
  • posted a message on My Attempt at The Cheese Stands Alone
    I'm still kinda new here, but for awhile i've been thinking of building a Cheese deck. I pulled out my old playset and have been trying to finalize a list. This is essentially my attempt at a "fair combo" for multiplayer (Playing High Tide Mind's Desire to end every game by turn 3 stopped being fun after 2-3 games, and my Enduring Ideal deck isn't much fairer; my playgroup has a soft ban on combos since a game where five people all had combos tuned to win--typically by going infinite--by turn 4. slow combos that give more "fun" decks a chance to interact are open). I also mean for this to be another fun novelty deck deck that i can pull out every once in a while for a change of pace.

    I am currently at 67 cards, so i'm looking to cut, but new suggestions are fine. I don't want to shell out more that $5 for any card, and i'm trying to keep the budget tame. I'm running Final Judgment over Wrath for two reasons, mine are tied up elsewhere, and my meta is just discovering 12-post (cloudpost + vesuva +glimmerpost), so people have become very fond of darksteel collosus and and other large difficult to deal with threats. Not to mention that I don't want to kill a sundering titan just so that his goblin welder buddy can drop the next turn.

    the intended win condition is hide a cheese behind an o-ring and then blow the board with apocalypse (which conveniently also discards my hand). I hope to play kinda like mono-w control up until then (life gain, removal, etc.).

    I have one kinda unusual request, I only want to run cards that play nice under 6th edition rules (ie. pre-M10). In line with this, i would love to replace the journey to nowheres with anything that doesn't say "exile" or "battlefield". I'm very reluctant to shell out to pick up a playset of StPs, but at this point i don't see many other options.
    Posted in: Casual & Multiplayer Formats
  • posted a message on GMaD #201: Coalition Victory
    I think people are missing the the strengths of wish. If you are going to move a copy of transguild courier and coalition victory to the sideboard to support it, you will not get the full benefit of that sacrifice unless you run 4. Further, while wishes have some negative stigma, it is a very efficient tutor, it is only 2 mana and puts the card directly into hand. It also allows you to craft your wishboard to give you very strong niche-hate exactly when you want it in each game.

    Speaking of hate, I nominate culling sun as a wrath-effect that is runnable in the side or main to be fetched by the demands or wishes.

    EDIT: I vote against crystal quarry. how has nobody realized that you can't cast victory off the damned thing? quarry circumvents colour shortages, but victory requires you to have a board state where no colour shortage can exist.
    Posted in: Casual & Multiplayer Formats
  • posted a message on GMaD #201: Coalition Victory
    I would suggest 4 Glittering Wish to allow a wishboard and increase combo redundancy.

    (edit: still brand new and trying to figure out how to set up the card links, hopefully it worked this time)
    Posted in: Casual & Multiplayer Formats
  • posted a message on What this forum is for
    All Avatar and Sig Shops should go in the Avatar and Sig Shops forum.

    All things relating to the Weekly Contest should go in the Weekly Contest subforum.

    Everything else should go here.

    Hopefully, this will make the forum less cluttered, and make it easier to find threads that need to be at the top (for instance, the rules).
    Posted in: Random Requests & Critiques
  • posted a message on Rules Discussion
    Well as promised, here's the thread where you can discuss the rules, suggest changes, or tell me about your ideas.

    I would appreciate if you would keep the discussions in this thread from now on, and the contest threads for the contests.

    ok, now go, and enlighten me with your ideas Grin

    (ew, what's that gooy stuff, it makes the thread all Sticky)


    OP stolen from De Banaan
    Hurr Jackal
    Posted in: Weekly Contest
  • posted a message on Currently Suspended/Banned Users.
    This thread is meant to notify the members of MTGsalvation of recent bannings or suspensions.

    Members can view their Infractions and Warnings in their profile, which can be found on their profile page.
    For more information about the Infraction and Warning System, including up to date reasons for each, check the official Forum Rules.
    Posted in: Community Discussion
  • posted a message on The Rules (now including Rules for the Polls)
    General:
    • A new contest and a poll for the old contest is posted every Monday (give or take a few due to timezones).
    • You may not vote for your own entry.
    • Gimmick accounts cannot submit entries.
    • You may not post just to list the people you voted for; you must provide some additional content, such as your reasoning for voting as such.
    Submitting Entries:
    • You may send in entries until the poll is up.
    • Once you have posted an entry, you may only make minor changes to it. All such minor changes must be okayed by a contest moderator.
    • Entries that don't fit the theme are not allowed, unless allowed by the moderator.
    • All entries should be made in full by the submitter. This includes resizing
    • Your entry can only consist of one banner/avatar/wallpaper, unless otherwise specified. No rotating banners, no sets.
    • All entries have to be created for the contest; you cannot submit something you made for some other purpose.
    • All art must be cited. For card art, simple card tags will do, otherwise please provide the artist's name and a link to the art. Please note whenever any of this information is unavailable or if you used original pieces.
    • You may use non-magic art as long as the contest doesn't say otherwise.
    • If you have any question about whether your entry falls within the rules, please PM one of the moderators about it before posting the banner.
    Schedule:
    • Every week that ends in 0, we'll have a wallpaper contest.
    • Every other week will be either an avatar contest, a banner contest, or both.
    Banners:
    • Sig submissions cannot be larger than 600x100 or 450x150. They can be no smaller than 300x50 or 225x75. Given the theme, the sizes can vary.
    • Banners cannot be animated unless the theme states otherwise.
    • Animated banners cannot have a file size greater than 500 KB.
    Avatars:
    • Avatars must be between 50x50 and 100x100 pixels.
    • Avatars may be animated.
    • Avatars must be usable as a forum avatar. This means that they should be less than 40KB in filesize.
    Wallpapers:
    • Wallpapers must be between 800x600 and 1280x1024 pixels; no smaller or bigger.
    • Wallpapers cannot have animation.



    Trophies:
    • People who have won sufficiently many weekly contests will get a trophy (or multiple) for their efforts.
    • The first trophy will come at 5 wins, the second at 12, then 20, then 30.
      If and when somebody surpasses the 30 win mark, we will make rules for larger sums.
    - Le_Gambit and Krashbot
    Posted in: Weekly Contest
  • posted a message on Speakeasy Chat and Welcome Wagon
    Welcome to the Speakeasy, your friendly underground pub.

    Come on in, and grab a seat.

    Feel free to just shoot the breeze in here, both in this thread and in any narrower threads you make.

    Cheers
    Posted in: the Speakeasy
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.