All users will need to merge their MTGSalvation account with a new or existing Twitch account starting Sept 25th. You can merge your accounts by clicking here. Have questions? Learn more here.
Dismiss
 
A Reckoning on Kamigawa
 
The Magic Market Index for Oct 20, 2017
 
The Magic Market Index for Oct 13, 2017
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Quote from Rhand »
    Really? I was so convinced Tom was in a town!tunnel there Smile


    To be honest, I think I play exactly the same as scum and town.

    It leads to me playing quite good as scum, and pretty poor as a townie (not always, but probably on average).

    I think I'd rather it be the other way around, as it would improve my win rate, but I guess I can still take pride in my deceptive skills.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Thank you for the congrats, friends. That was a tough game and I really wasn't sure I was gonna win. I don't think I gave anyone a good enough reason to lynch me, but I was certainly worried about being accused.

    What happened to you Megs? Fallout from the car hit? I hope you're doing okay.

    I don't know when I'll play again, but I probably will someday. Maybe soon as I'm hyped about this win.

    Seems as though the MTGS community is slowly dying though. If we want to preserve it, we need to start encouraging people both online and IRL to come try out a game here on MTGS. Or make an organized effort to join with another community.

    GG
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    I'm accusing you, D_V
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    it's megs or DV
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Quote from tomsloger »
    unvote
    vote rhand


    Would be cool if we won now but gonna start rereading


    That's L-0, I think. Cool.

    Rhand if you get here before the mod, spare us the trouble and state your alignment
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Quote from D_V »
    Unvote Vote Rhand

    **** it Rhands speaking nonsense again.

    I'm like 50-50 now. I always suspect Rhand more than Tom, but... I just know tomorrow my votes going to be on Rhand tomorrow with out this *****. So its better for me to eliminate a red herring now. Or possibly just lynch scum.


    Well this is out of left field.

    Weren't you the guy who said you couldn't understand the Rhand wagon and that my reasoning about him being scum was bad? And the guy who said I was worlds apart the scummiest player in the game?

    Because now it reads like you're saying Rhand is scummy, and scummier than you think I am, and hoping on the wagon pretty much built with my reasoning.

    If we lynch Rhand (likely) and he's not scum you have some explaining to do
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    I think D_V isn't who we will lynch, or should lynch. Beyond that I'll reassess him in the case of a mislynch.

    I concur that just lynching in general should be our #1 priority with the clock ticking down.

    Join back on Rhand wagon. Don't know what people are talking about the reasoning being bad, just ISO Rhand. Look at his 2nd and 3rd posts. Bad vote on Hunt, followed by a bad vote on you (Tomsloger for anyone else reading the reiteration of my reasoning). These posts could be excusable as poking around at the beginning of the game, but then his 5th post confirms that he's serious about them. His 6th post is hopping back on the Hunt wagon after I gave that wagon a big push, and he says he wants to lynch. Then Hunt shows up, and I ask why Rhand isn't moving his vote like I did. Rhand gives in easily and implies that he might move his vote soon. Then his latest post he does just that, voting Tomsloger once more with little explanation.

    Now that I've looked it over again I'm even happier about my vote.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    wait a sec,

    Quote from tomsloger »
    **** it
    vote DV

    lets have a DVCFD
    Quote from tomsloger »
    [2] Tom - Huntzilla, DV
    [2] tomsloger - Rhand, Tom
    [2] Rhand - Cythare, tomsloger

    Not Voting: Megiddo

    nice wagons.


    You clearly voted for D_V then later you attempt to do a vote count and show your vote still on Rhand... Are you not aware of where your votes at?

    If you were serious about D_V, I'd expect it to be reflected in that vote count
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Quote from tomsloger »
    Quote from Tom »

    I said I think tomsloger is more scummy now (because of his behavior on Rhand wagon)

    what behavior on the rhand wagon?

    I was referring to the second line I wrote in post 104.

    But hold the phone, complete 180, tomsloger is almost certainly town after all. Unvote

    Sloger has been a mediocre contributor all game, until now. Post 110 was fantastic (I didn't even catch that myself), and basically everything since has been pretty good.

    I see a townie getting more concerned and involved as the game end draws nearer. I'd expect scum to do basically the opposite, and post less near the end unless it were to defend themselves from a lynch.

    Vote: Rhand

    Lets lynch him, so that in the case that he flips town we actually have time to reassess.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Quote from D_V »

    I think that he is making weak cases and seeing what sticks. Hes jumping all over right now.

    Says he thinks Rhand is more scummy then votes you?

    Hes just fishing for a lynch.

    I've got a slight town read on Megs. Its megs though.


    Elaborate on what is weak in my reasoning for Rhand or anyone else.

    Yes I've moved my vote several times recently. Methodically.

    I said I think tomsloger is more scummy now (because of his behavior on Rhand wagon), then voted him. Where are you getting anything contrary from?

    I am fishing for a lynch. On one of those three specific people (two, realistically). ASAP, because like I said I won't be able to post on the last day of the game.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Hunt, am I still tunneling Megs in your opinion? Weird

    tomsloger calls Cythare and me out for "not having great reasoning" for voting Rhand then proceeds to announce he has no good reasons himself.

    Completely happy with tomsloger lynch. Even moreso than Rhand. Vote: Sloger

    I'm at least 85% confident the scum is within those two or Megiddo.

    ---

    I get up early on Saturday and then get off work at the same time the game ends. I likely won't be able to post that day, the 19th. Meaning I only have today and tomorrow to post. I'm a strong advocate of lynching someone today so I actually have time to accuse someone.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Quote from Huntzilla »
    I still think it's Tom (not sloger) because of the fear mongering of time, and the way he's actively posting. Why would actively posting be a bad thing you ask? Scum know that there's only a few days (meatworld) to this gane and the easiest play is to skate by until the end. Scum will be hyper- vigilant this game in order to avoid lynch/end suspicion. I don't think Tom cares about finding real scum, just sowing dissension amongst us all.


    This is ridiculous. You just described what town behavior should be in a game like this.

    I think Cyth is just coming back frtom an absence and doing his thing.


    Indeed. He strikes me as flippant town more than scum in the two posts to his name. He's gotta post more but that's all I have against him.

    Glad my vote got Hunt to do something, but I can't see him as scum, despite him thinking I'm "worlds apart the scummiest in the game for actually trying".

    Assuming a no-go on Megs I'm interested in lynching Rhand or tomsloger.

    tomsloger because post 34 stinks, and an ISO reveals that it is surprisingly his only real contribution to the game.

    Rhand because his ISO reveals bad reasoning for pretty much everything. His first two votes are just easy gimmie votes that in reality stink, he then proceeds to leave his options open even with Cythare (who he hasn't mentioned except for being one of his 3 suspects), then hops on Hunt wagon to L-1 with the intention of lynching, followed by no unvote after Hunt finally gives thoughts. Vote: Rhand
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Quote from tomsloger »
    @other tom ima need you to back up that cythare townread.


    Ima need you to back up that cythare sscumread. So far all I see is you voting him for reasons that are hypocritical.

    huntz wagon sucks. hes null as ****.

    There are less than 3 days left and he's done nothing despite showing up to make posts. I don't know if that's his M.O., but I ignore meta anyway on principle.

    Megs is worse and my first choice of a lynch, but I can see that it won't happen as of now.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    I can't make my points against Megs clearer than they already are, and nobody is interested. While I have a hard time agreeing with everyong about giving him the benefit of the doubt as a townie who wasted the first half of the entire game with a fluff posts and a joke-plan, I'll turn my attention elsewhere.

    Quote from tomsloger »
    cyth having bad feels about me and rhand when rhand had one post and i had 3 one of which he presumably agreed on since it was about rhand and that's a little weird.
    vote cythare

    It's ironic that you'd vote Cythare for disliking both you and Rhand. It means you yourself dislike both Cythare and Rhand, which is essentially the same situation, no?

    Quote from Huntzilla »
    lynch me.... dooooo it

    This sums up your gameplay. Vote: Huntzilla

    Cythare and D_V strike me as town.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Quote from D_V »
    Cythare actually seems like scum since that post contained almost nothing at all.

    Megs is town.


    Have you read Megs' posts?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.