tbh I'd be fine in the world where Rodemy was town, nad we killed him and shadow/tom won because of how ridiculous this is.
I'm so bad at this game I don't know who it is and I'm composed of like fifteen different wafflemakers all beeping like crazy and its impossible to tell which ones need to be flipped and which are cooked.
beautiful imagery
but why are you ok with that?
i, ummm, really expected someone to look at a me/shadow team. we've largely run this game. collectively led ~every lynch. i can totally see us playing this way as partners.
Ok, I'm going to go back and ISO Tom and Rodemy. More tomorrow.
yeah you ******* better if you think youve put in more than me
what the **** is this supposed to mean!? You better start dialing it down Tom, I really don't want to turn this another player misconduct pissing match that I always seem to find myself in. I'm trying very hard to not do this for a third game in a row.
I still have put forth some pretty good effort into this game compared to other people still alive, namely Rodemy and Tom.
is bull*****.
I'm top poster by a pretty wide margin, with way more effort than I put in in my normal playstyle.
Playstyle has slipped quite a bit since I replaced myself, but still.
Bull*****.
the internal disconnect within your posts is mindboggling
Explain?
hi im rodemy
i can tell the alignment of people pushing me but only scum have ever tried to lynch me
i put in more effort as scum, but also im bad at scum and barebones was a fluke
tom is scum because he's thought i was scum all game. ive known he was scum all game.
I mean, it's possible that it's Rod/Terry. And I really want you to be town. I probably need to go iso Rod in BB, cause his indignation just looks so townie to me.
of course he's indignant when he only responds to the parts that he thinks are the wrong reasons for catching him.
Ah, also forgot: JeyK's vote on Eternal is semi-useless because we know she wants to lynch EternalLurker, as she has since early D1. By continuing to keep her vote on there, she isn't putting any new information into the thread, and I think she has proven that she can't push a good case against Eternal. So nothing is gained, and continuing to repeat various versions of "Scummy but I can't put my finger on it" won't help.
My vote 1) got his attention and 2) signifies I am willing to lynch him, which I think is new information.
I read this and realised it could apply to me as well. By focusing on JeY, I've been ignoring other players.
I'm not moving my vote for previously stated reasons, but I am going to pull back and look over things to see what else is going on.
@Anak, what do you think of Pa Tennis's attack on me? Do you agree it is a misrep or take his side?
Also, because he actually posted. Why does it feel like half the game is lurking? Tubba, Cantrip, and SL need to post, and really, everyone needs to start posting more. I don't want to be stuck in another situation like yesterDay.
It was requested. Like at least two days ago. For a guy who wants to lean on people for a lack of posting, he hasn't exactly been tearing up the megabytes. However it is refreshing to see people noticing that JeY has done almost next to nothing to help solve the game.
The timing of kaba's claim is a little smelly, but without a counter claim it's hard to dismiss it out of hand. That being said, I've been back and forth on him this whole game. This whole claim issue has me going in circles again. scumKaba claims to avoid lynch, doesn't die at night, and has no new info for the following day?? townKaba claims to avoid mislynch, doesn't dieat night and has no new info for the following day?? Only one of those scenarios makes sense to me. The only way I can figure kaba being completely truthful is that scum somehow knew Vaimes was power, but from briefly re-reading I can't see anything that would indicate that. I think we need to unpack and discuss this.
@Tubba, because if you think Cantrip is scummy, he's just going to coast the next Day or so with hardcore lurking. Not sure if you've noticed, but wagons on lurkers don't really go anywhere.
Also, the amount of people doubting Kaba right now is pretty ridiculous. He's been alive one Night. If he is alive toMorrow, maybe. But right now everyone is throwing shade at his claim, and it makes it easier for scum to jump in and try to discredit the un-counter-claimed cop.
I'll be available, though if it gets to 28 or 29 hours from now that's my sleeping time so I promise nothing past that.
If we aren't asking an extension, I ask everyone to list their top 3 lynch candidates, REGARDLESS of how likely you think that lynch is toDay. We can work that out later.
1) Lurker/Cantrip/Terry
2) Pa Tennis
3) Tubba Fett
@PizzaGuy, respectfully disagree with you. My point is that looking at the vote counts is a lot quicker than ISO'ing Killjoy for me. Re: scumspects, I usually focus on the one or two people I find scummiest, and then work the rest out as the game goes along. If you ask me to name four scum suspects right off, I probably won't be very strong on them. Even Tubba, my third read, I'm not that certain of. I try to latch on to the one or two people I think are scummy, determine their alignment, and go from there.
NULL
Rodemy: Another waffle read for me, Rodemy seems to be playing a similar game to Eternal, pushing at perceived weaknesses and applying pressure to get responses.
<snip> SCUM
GF21: I didn't have a good read on Blues, but Grapefruit's entry post claiming town feels bad, and by basically rehashing the feed and adding no new thoughts, except for a dubious claim that Rodemy is town, basing that claim on Rodemy being essentially unreadable is also troublesome for me.
It was requested. Like at least two days ago. For a guy who wants to lean on people for a lack of posting, he hasn't exactly been tearing up the megabytes. However it is refreshing to see people noticing that JeY has done almost next to nothing to help solve the game.
The timing of kaba's claim is a little smelly, but without a counter claim it's hard to dismiss it out of hand. That being said, I've been back and forth on him this whole game. This whole claim issue has me going in circles again. scumKaba claims to avoid lynch, doesn't die at night, and has no new info for the following day?? townKaba claims to avoid mislynch, doesn't dieat night and has no new info for the following day?? Only one of those scenarios makes sense to me. The only way I can figure kaba being completely truthful is that scum somehow knew Vaimes was power, but from briefly re-reading I can't see anything that would indicate that. I think we need to unpack and discuss this.
What I'm guessing happened is they have a roleblocker and decided to just RB me and try to kill someone else. Like I'd be surprised if Vaimes didn't save me last night, and since I was an obvious Doctor target the right play is to RB me and just try to hit the doctor, as long as the roleblocker is alive. I was really close to just claiming roleblocked to keep them wasting it on me but decided against it
Wait.. what?
few things wrong with this.
A: How would claiming roleblocked keep them wasting it on you when they will know they didn't do it...
B: Your assumption that they have a roleblocker is very.. confident.
With this line of reasoning, you should never have claimed that you had one shot so they WOULD keep wasting it on you (assuming they even have an RB)
This is exactly what's been bugging me. Kaba is either lying or at best not telling the whole truth here. The people who keep saying not to worry about it, should start to consider worrying about it!
NULL
Rodemy: Another waffle read for me, Rodemy seems to be playing a similar game to Eternal, pushing at perceived weaknesses and applying pressure to get responses.
<snip> SCUM
GF21: I didn't have a good read on Blues, but Grapefruit's entry post claiming town feels bad, and by basically rehashing the feed and adding no new thoughts, except for a dubious claim that Rodemy is town, basing that claim on Rodemy being essentially unreadable is also troublesome for me.
why would tubba call the claim that rodemy is town "dubious" other than to be able to lynch grape when rodemy flipped scum?
obviously it didnt happen that way. we lynched grape first.
but tubba was null on rodemy. its, like, a really minor perspective slip that he knows rodemy is scum. and makes no goddamn sense at all if rodemy is town
Maybe it's just obvious to me since he's confirmed scum now and I had already basically figured it out before that, but rods defense of... Basically reductive dismissal of the pretty massive amount of points against him to the one or two things he thinks he can defend against is blatant as ****.
He's so full of ***** right now all I can do is laugh
Rod brought this up, but I would have anyway, I believe Rodemy-Tom are strongly unaligned for Rodemy not knowing that Pa was Tom despite it being revealed in thread. The more I think about it, the more I think Rodemy probably has to be town because of this, as the only person left who didn't know him before this game is Terry, and I am not super on board with a Terry-Rodemy team...I think?
it's perfect though.
Rod didn't notice, and lngrr/tubba/Terry would have no reason to bring it up in scum chat. Terry played in a game I modded but thats nothing. Tubba was new. Lngrr is apparently experienced but I've never seen him before.
You would have talked about me in scum chat. Like, 90+% of the time.
Maybe you would have told him to derp about it but, like, why?
I also want to note that his newest reasoning is that I've been scumreading him forever which is, like, partially true. I thought he was scum day 1 and never really thought he was town while I mostly ignored him to lynch lngrrr.
But he has actually pushed me every day in some form.
but why are you ok with that?
i, ummm, really expected someone to look at a me/shadow team. we've largely run this game. collectively led ~every lynch. i can totally see us playing this way as partners.
I'm top poster by a pretty wide margin, with way more effort than I put in in my normal playstyle.
Playstyle has slipped quite a bit since I replaced myself, but still.
Bull*****.
Some pretty nifty flavor about local kids thinking I'm a witch
Rodemy just throwing ***** at a wall rn
i can tell the alignment of people pushing me but only scum have ever tried to lynch me
i put in more effort as scum, but also im bad at scum and barebones was a fluke
tom is scum because he's thought i was scum all game. ive known he was scum all game.
why would tubba call the claim that rodemy is town "dubious" other than to be able to lynch grape when rodemy flipped scum?
obviously it didnt happen that way. we lynched grape first.
but tubba was null on rodemy. its, like, a really minor perspective slip that he knows rodemy is scum. and makes no goddamn sense at all if rodemy is town
<3
He's so full of ***** right now all I can do is laugh
Rod didn't notice, and lngrr/tubba/Terry would have no reason to bring it up in scum chat. Terry played in a game I modded but thats nothing. Tubba was new. Lngrr is apparently experienced but I've never seen him before.
You would have talked about me in scum chat. Like, 90+% of the time.
Maybe you would have told him to derp about it but, like, why?
But he has actually pushed me every day in some form.