I reread Famous Historical Figures Mafia a month or so ago and that was such a fantastic game. Thank you for hosting it.
Flattery will get you everywhere. Even though I created the role, that's where I started to dislike including 3rd party roles just because. But I did enjoy the amount of flavor I put into that.
Through page 3. Kind of lolsy that I've been at L-2 since then.
hmm, @GJ, welcome my friend
you are L1, and everyone wants your neck
I am a bit indifferent? I still hate your slot, but I am more reserved than most
Well i have no computer ans 5 percent. So don't expect miracles from me tonight. This one page though from skimming makes me think at least proph isnt reading me as wolf.
I am going to have to /out for this. I was not expecting such a delayed start, and cannot promise I will be able to keep up with this game at the level I tend to commit to mafia.
I mentioned this in the discord and obviously you acknowledge this, but any style of hp type of game is going to be by default, with everything else being mountainous, wolf sided. The intimate knowledge of hp increases or loss, the option to be silent, and what alignment likely caused what is a huge boon for the wolf team. I know there is more than three, but all three that I can think of were decisive wolf victories (Final Fantasy, Flame Warriors, and now this).
I am also beyond pissed at why a role as weak of mine needed only 1 hp to function. I was actually a liability that could cost the town an extra mislynch if I ever got randomly targeted by a vit thief ability. Small mercy that I ate the whole poison.
I also don't think LW's role should have ever existed. I know this is where I get a lot of disagreement with, but sometimes, TvW is special enough with a bunch of mechanics running around. Especially if the role literally phases out after WC is achieved. I feel like too many hosts (even myself) want to add a neutral flavor win when the game really doesn't require it.
I would add to the cons of MC the fact that they themselves might have to move, and therefore going there could result in us having to move a 2nd time. The smaller playerbase con would also be that we would still be struggling to fill games most likely.
No. No popcorn. Let's stay on topic and not feed trolls.
The vast majority is voting to go, while the second highest (at almost 50% less than the first) says that it's probably time but aren't quite ready.
With 16 votes, are we waiting on a lot of players? Seems like if all the regulars we have were to show up and vote any other option but "head elsewhere", "head elsewhere" would still be in the lead by a wide margin.
Should we shift the focus of the conversation, then, to where we're going, instead of if?
I mean this with all due respect to those guys, but if they aren't ready now, when will they be? I don't want to wait for a mad scramble like when we thought the site was going to be gone a few years ago. We are already at the point of struggling to fill a 12 player mini, almost a week later.
I am all for leaving, and all for going to MU. I get history and yada yada, but the times are changing and I think having the voting tool is just such a godsend, as someone who was over there, came back here and realized how annoying it was to try and figure out votes.
I don't know for sure if they still have them, but there used to be long games (like, think a month deadline) back then that had nonMTGs players, so for those who do prefer the longer style for their games, you do have players you can pick up.
I just wasn't intending to play in this game, but then Osie asked and I forgot I was going to be in Michigan for a while. So I didn't mean to look as slimy as I did on day 1.
ZDS, why did you go Rhand over me? I thought that's what you were gearing towards?
As a result I changed my reads out of apparently nowhere, and now you and Johnny both have to fit me into pairings that make zero sense, round-peg-in-square-hole style. Credits to Highroller as well for not going after my throat as soon as the Day started.
Meanwhile, I did my best to reset my reads after Pokechu's misbonk. After I had been proven wrong once, I had all the reasons in the world not to go back on my one-man crusade as if nothing had happen
See, these two things don't mesh. I had not only Poke as a wolf but LW as a likely candidate. If I was wrong on one, I figured Grape was the most likely partner based on just not posting, but I for 1): I can't believe you can safe with a straight face Grape has been proactive. It's an awful read from you at best.
But to my point from the above, if I am town, and my team blew up in my face in the morning, why wouldn't I forget everything I know and try to figure it out? You just played a wolf game with as town where I did exactly the same thing, and proceeded to correctly 180 you and YMC. In this game, why wouldn't I re-evaluate and try to figure out where I went wrong, instead of going after Grape (who you think is town) also while having HR as a back up. That seems to be a much easier path for me as a wolf for victory, rather than trying to turn on Rhand who was leaning town, and you (who I was reading town)
My issue with your long winded post is that you aren't trying to see the game from a GJ town perspective. Rhand calling my game clean, but still hedging that I might be a wolf is lolable at best, and I have no idea how Grape can see that and still go "WeLl, GJ mAkEs ThE mOsT sEnSe." It's utterly ridiculous.
I have no idea where HR this game right now, other than imagining he is pulling his hair out trying to figure claims.
Flattery will get you everywhere. Even though I created the role, that's where I started to dislike including 3rd party roles just because. But I did enjoy the amount of flavor I put into that.
Through page 3. Kind of lolsy that I've been at L-2 since then.
Well i have no computer ans 5 percent. So don't expect miracles from me tonight. This one page though from skimming makes me think at least proph isnt reading me as wolf.
Would be willing to /sub
I am also beyond pissed at why a role as weak of mine needed only 1 hp to function. I was actually a liability that could cost the town an extra mislynch if I ever got randomly targeted by a vit thief ability. Small mercy that I ate the whole poison.
I also don't think LW's role should have ever existed. I know this is where I get a lot of disagreement with, but sometimes, TvW is special enough with a bunch of mechanics running around. Especially if the role literally phases out after WC is achieved. I feel like too many hosts (even myself) want to add a neutral flavor win when the game really doesn't require it.
I mean this with all due respect to those guys, but if they aren't ready now, when will they be? I don't want to wait for a mad scramble like when we thought the site was going to be gone a few years ago. We are already at the point of struggling to fill a 12 player mini, almost a week later.
And even if I did, I know you are lying. I have never threatened anyone.
I am sorry that you feel that way.
I don't know for sure if they still have them, but there used to be long games (like, think a month deadline) back then that had nonMTGs players, so for those who do prefer the longer style for their games, you do have players you can pick up.
/in
You don't even have to ask me osieorb
ZDS, why did you go Rhand over me? I thought that's what you were gearing towards?
See, these two things don't mesh. I had not only Poke as a wolf but LW as a likely candidate. If I was wrong on one, I figured Grape was the most likely partner based on just not posting, but I for 1): I can't believe you can safe with a straight face Grape has been proactive. It's an awful read from you at best.
But to my point from the above, if I am town, and my team blew up in my face in the morning, why wouldn't I forget everything I know and try to figure it out? You just played a wolf game with as town where I did exactly the same thing, and proceeded to correctly 180 you and YMC. In this game, why wouldn't I re-evaluate and try to figure out where I went wrong, instead of going after Grape (who you think is town) also while having HR as a back up. That seems to be a much easier path for me as a wolf for victory, rather than trying to turn on Rhand who was leaning town, and you (who I was reading town)
My issue with your long winded post is that you aren't trying to see the game from a GJ town perspective. Rhand calling my game clean, but still hedging that I might be a wolf is lolable at best, and I have no idea how Grape can see that and still go "WeLl, GJ mAkEs ThE mOsT sEnSe." It's utterly ridiculous.
I have no idea where HR this game right now, other than imagining he is pulling his hair out trying to figure claims.