2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on Mafia: Dominaria Style - The Power Nine (GAME OVER - THE TOWN WIN!)
    @Killjoy
    Btw once u drop that case on why Proph is town, u need to tell me how you plan go get anyone else in this game voted out, except for Eco maybe

    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mafia: Dominaria Style - The Power Nine (GAME OVER - THE TOWN WIN!)
    @Eco
    Btw u saying that Grape not re-evaluating makes him a wolf, is wrong. Go look at his MU game where he buried my partner. I tried hard to get this dude off my partner with his crazy reachy case, to no avail. If he thinks you are a wolf, he will re-evaluate when he thinks it needs to happen, not when you think he should.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mafia: Dominaria Style - The Power Nine (GAME OVER - THE TOWN WIN!)
    Its interesting, if the team is exactly Killjoy/Eco

    Killjoy is defending you
    Eco is defending you and me

    cause from my PoV, I am never voting Grapefruit

    Killjoy is never getting a vote off on me, nor is he ever getting a vote off on grape
    so they are pretty much setting each other up, to cross vote each other
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mafia: Dominaria Style - The Power Nine (GAME OVER - THE TOWN WIN!)
    @Proph
    so we both came to the same team then? Eco/Killjoy
    the team I had before Killjoy called my posts personal attacks, and threw my brain off
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mafia: Dominaria Style - The Power Nine (GAME OVER - THE TOWN WIN!)
    @KJ
    still waiting for that Proph town case
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mafia: Dominaria Style - The Power Nine (GAME OVER - THE TOWN WIN!)
    Quote from Ecophagy »
    Quote from Prophylaxis »
    Eco: Have you done anything this game realistically that you can point to and say "this is out of my scum range"?


    Honestly? I don't think so. Maybe I wouldn't bother to go as in depth on Last's meta as scum, but I can't know for sure. But as arrogant as it sounds, I feel like my scum range is (or at least was) virtually infinite. You know the right way to read me is to try and look behind my posts and work out if I'm truly trying to work things out or not.
    i mean going through the motions is fine, but u somehow failed to see the circumstances of grapes eod vote, and then found other reasons to make him look bad.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mafia: Dominaria Style - The Power Nine (GAME OVER - THE TOWN WIN!)
    Quote from Ecophagy »
    Also if you think my case on Proph is irrelevent then ok? It wasn't for you, it was to write out my thought processes for everyone. If you think there are posts Proph has made that are more important that I have overlooked then feel free to tell me so we can actually talk about it.
    I think me and you like and hate different things from Proph/Grape

    you argue that Osie flipping town, means that Grape should have re-evaluated his read on Proph, because Osie liked them
    where exactly has anyone listened to a dead players reads this game?

    I am also trying to understand the wolf motivation for Grape to switch his read on Osie after it was revealed he was Osie.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mafia: Dominaria Style - The Power Nine (GAME OVER - THE TOWN WIN!)
    idk anymore, we are too all over the place for this game to ever end in a town win, I think

    try to talk to me about Killjoy when u get a chance, since from your PoV the team is exactly Killjoy/Grape
    and they are possibly the only team that doesn't have much of anything removing the possibility of its existence, I sound Grape voting Killjoy near EoD yesterday

    you and Grape also don't really have much removing the possibility of the team
    I can't really see myself re-evaluating Grape honestly

    but as it stands, this is where we are

    Killjoy thinks Proph is town
    I think Grape/Killjoy are town
    Grape thinks the wolf team is exactly Proph/Killjoy
    You think Grape is bad, and that me and proph are town

    so from each perspective

    Grape: Proph/Killjoy
    Me: Proph/Eco
    Eco: Grape/Killjoy?
    Proph: (Grape/Killjoy/Eco)
    Killjoy: (Grape/Me/Eco)

    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mafia: Dominaria Style - The Power Nine (GAME OVER - THE TOWN WIN!)
    GRAPE VOTED OSIE AS SELF-PRESERVATION
    and what exactly did that flip have to do with his read of Proph?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mafia: Dominaria Style - The Power Nine (GAME OVER - THE TOWN WIN!)
    harsh, maybe? Im definitely not the best at talking about my dissatisfaction without projecting my idea of how the game should be played
    In terms of Proph, there are too many, "I believe this is what he would", going on
    but I guess that's mafia for you, you decide what you think is happening
    ultimately though, I think most of what you said is irrelevant, at least irrelevant in the sense that it doesn't help me see town!Proph here
    cause I look at him differently

    though the frustration towards DV and trying to get low posters killed before top posters, looks good?
    but like it was incorrect, so meh

    on a micro level a lot of the stuff he does just feels like an attempt to look uninformed, and ignoring those posts are bad, because a lot of that style is the crux of Proph's scum play

    but if you want me to think you are a wolf, you are doing a good job in the sense of removing Proph, since in that world, its you/Killjoy
    and I vote you first. Anyways, I think this game all about pocketing Killjoy right now, since he is town in my eyes, and probably will win or lose this game today.

    You talking about Proph is good in that sense, but Proph talking about me is weird in that sense
    meh

    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mafia: Dominaria Style - The Power Nine (GAME OVER - THE TOWN WIN!)
    Thurs is my day off, I'll be on and off pretty much all day
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mafia: Dominaria Style - The Power Nine (GAME OVER - THE TOWN WIN!)
    did you really push him though? like Dota literally buried himself, and you were just beating down the lower posters, which would be easy for you to do, and correct from either alignment I think?

    I know full well how much you struggle with TMI, but I know you aren't incapable of pushing bad town

    If you are truly town here, my most comfortable option would be Eco, the literal invisible player

    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mafia: Dominaria Style - The Power Nine (GAME OVER - THE TOWN WIN!)
    I mean I tend to notice this a lot from Killjoy, so it's truly hard to say if there is actually a separation between his alignments and how he plays
    Hence, why I adopted the phrase, "its killjoy doing killjoy things"
    I arguably hate that he has only ever voted at EoD and never has put his money where his mouth is, that is just so wolfy to me

    Voting Proph is going to be a pain, in town!killjoy worlds, I need his case sooner than later, so I can break it down
    in wolf!killjoy worlds, its irrelevant since I trust that town!Eco doesn't vote my towncore which is you, with his town read of me (referring to w/e lylo turns out be)

    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mafia: Dominaria Style - The Power Nine (GAME OVER - THE TOWN WIN!)
    I mean his high/low mindset is bad, since even though from my perspective, I know it exists, given my now town read of KJ, it just came out of no where, when the other easier world could have just been a bunch of low posters. He spent most of the game ignoring both me and Proph on a macro level, taking w/e micro post he liked, swapping us back and forth

    is it bad? yes? is it malicious? maybe? I'm going towards no, and I think there are better things to highlight if you want to bury wolf!Killjoy here
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mafia: Dominaria Style - The Power Nine (GAME OVER - THE TOWN WIN!)
    Quote from Grapefruit21 »
    Quote from Lastwhisper »
    Killjoy has been robotic all game
    are we reading different games???

    Did you read the body pillow post? That is entirely unrobotic, quite human, and reasonably funny. Plus you can catch glimpses of frustration at times before then.

    Like he gets annoyed at the pushback from Proph about his 1 high/1 low theory and then you as well. He's more sleepwalking than robotic to me. He's been genuinely human throughout but just not active or probing to his own standards. There is none of the KJ following his own lead doggedly and doing his own thing.
    ok ill give you the bodybag post had "something", and by something I mean "words", and probably more emotion than anything else he has done, up until telling me I am attacking him personally

    don't agree with his Proph bounce back being "human" though
    nor do I believe he has "not been doing his own thing"
    its day 3 and Killjoy is still playing like its Day 1
    Eco is literally invisible
    and I am still telling you that I don't believe this is wolf!killjoy anymore

    I want to vote Proph or Eco now
    Maybe go read Axel's read of Killjoy?


    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.