• posted a message on Final Fantasy Mafia II - DAY 2 - One Replacement Needed!
    **** spreadsheets
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Final Fantasy Mafia II - DAY 2 - One Replacement Needed!
    Quote from RelmArrowny »
    ...huh.

    thoughts, Megiddo?
    on chemtrails? I think he was just overwhelmed. he barely wanted to play the game at all.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Final Fantasy Mafia II - DAY 2 - One Replacement Needed!
    1. That's not clear to me at all. It looks like he mustered up enough courage to talk back but it doesn't look like he believes it at all. Tell me how you get that impression from his post.
    2. Now that he's been called out and the spotlight is on him, he knows he has to or he's going to die.
    3. I can't remember the last time townProph made an intentionally bad argument.


    I definitely used bad phrasing earlier. He doesn't try to make bad arguments. He just makes bad arguments. There are two points that I consider "bad" here. First is that his post is just a giant self-meta post. It's in keeping with proph's attitudes as town to present that argument unironically and assume we will be convinced. Second is his assertion that he's obvtown, which is an obviously bad defense to the person who's trying to convince us to lynch him.

    what you are missing though is that proph always sound artificial regardless of alignment. You cannot look at his posts and say "this looks fake" to determine his alignment. Look at the mindset behind what he's doing rather than the language he is expressing it through.

    I have also seen this false-looking bravado before, which I've scumread him for in the past... but it turns out that this is just how he does bravado. It doesn't come naturally to him, so it looks really awfully fake when he tries to look tough.

    Proph's strength is in being logical and analytical. When he steps out of that comfort zone he inevitably ends up looking fake.

    Like I said earlier literally just keep waiting. If his posting rate drops off (especially under pressure) then I'll gladly reverse my view and attack Proph with you. It is that easy.

    So, in sum:

    1. This is how proph always sounds and it's not an alignment tell.
    2. I think this is a towntell. Keep an eye out for lurking.
    3. I misspoke earlier, see above for my explanation.

    I am very interested to see your full Proph case though.

    Also what was your point regarding his postcount?

    ---

    @relm I think I'm at
    5 cythare
    5 wheat

    but this is without rereading.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on GATECRASH: Day Six — Twisted Experiment
    The Strike Gold Vote Count 6.3 (As of post #2071)
    scarbo (2): 7hawk77, Archmage Eternal
    Archmage Eternal (2): Zindabad, Huntzilla
    7hawk77 (1): Scarbo
    Axelrod (1): Obzedat
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Final Fantasy Mafia II - DAY 2 - One Replacement Needed!
    I've decided I don't want to reread. But I'm here now and engaged. Ask me things. I will answer.

    Also @relm I just want to clarify your response to my earlier question. I did have a reason for asking if you knew what I did to you.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Final Fantasy Mafia II - DAY 2 - One Replacement Needed!
    hey cc

    what are your reads on the following players:

    Cythare
    Proph
    KK
    Me
    chemtrails

    and why?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Final Fantasy Mafia II - DAY 2 - One Replacement Needed!
    ^ see this is a townproph post

    1. clearly believes he is town
    2. actually standing up to somebody who is scumreading him
    3. using bad arguments and expecting us to believe them

    all of the elements are there.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Final Fantasy Mafia II - DAY 2 - One Replacement Needed!
    Quote from Iso »
    Quote from Wheat_Grinder »
    Why does Proph concern you more
    I don't read Proph as very confident or fluid at all, right now. Up until his " Frown " to me just now, he's been abdolutely paralyzed insofar as interacting with me meaningfully has gone. And that feign of an attempt at townie emotion came entirely too late to be a genuine reaction.
    I reserve the right to update this post in two hours, but I have not gotten this impression from him at all so far.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Final Fantasy Mafia II - DAY 2 - One Replacement Needed!
    ok my computer is here. I had to get the battery replaced. No V/LA required.

    Going to dinner with my dad now. I'll reread and post tonight.

    I don't believe that Seppel would make a game where some of the roles can't be claimed. That sounds insane.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Final Fantasy Mafia II - DAY 2 - One Replacement Needed!
    50/50 chance I'm V/LA (without a computer) for a day or two. If not, I'll reread and you'll hear from me this weekend. If so... when I'm around.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.