2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on Dreadhorde Butcher
    Pump to like 5 and then thud for the win, because you're dealing the combat triggers too.

    DMG | Power After
    1 | 2
    3 | 3
    6 | 4
    10 | 5
    THUD!


    Hey, anything that makes Thud a viable constructed wincon is alright in my book.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Mothership Spoilers 4/5 - Massacre Girl and Tomik
    Quote from Crag979 »
    I get that part, but is there a priority check after each trigger or do they all occur at the same time for each set killed. So, three 1/1 creatures killed= 3 priority checks (each counter leads to a priority/response check) or 1 priority check for the opponent to answer three -1/-1 counters?


    THree separate triggers. So yeah, you can respond between them, but keep in mind that each death throws more and more triggers onto the stack too. If you're worried about bouncing something, the quicker it happens, the better.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Pollenbright Druid & Bloom Hulk


    Saw these on the spoiler page, but didn't see a thread.

    Two mana proliferate is insane. Polly might just make it into my Atraxa Superfriends deck. At the most downside, you can get the counter on Atraxa.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Mothership Spoilers 4/5 - Massacre Girl and Tomik
    Quote from Crag979 »
    Would a stack then be created for each instance to check for more creatures that die? Seems like a loop will be created. Also, are there points that your opponent would be able to answer?


    Thats exactly what happens. Its essentially a chain reaction boardwipe. First the 1 toughnesses all die, then the 2s, and you work your way up. Only real way to stop it is to have X-Y>1 where X is a creatures toughness and Y is the number of creatures with a lower toughness on the battlefield.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Mothership Spoilers 4/5 - Massacre Girl and Tomik
    A Last Laugh that kills indestructibles (and doesnt go away once the crying starts). That is just disgusting

    I feel the main point of Tomik is to shut down Life From The Loam
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Mobilized District
    Hands Across Ravnica had a good turnout this year
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on "Mizzium Tank" - a rare vehicle - @MtgBigMagic spoiler
    Quote from xequalsy »
    Quote from Pollaski »
    Solid Limited card (basically monored Piston-Fist Cyclops with upside). Cant see it landing in my Depala EDH deck. Not a huge fan of the trigger being automatic- one of the best thimgs about Vehicles is they survive Wraths.


    This still survives Wraths. Just can choose not to cast an instant on the turn a player might wrath.


    Your Wrath. One of the nice things to do with Deps is to clear the board, then drop a couple cheap creatures (or Peacewalker Colossus) and start swinging
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on "Mizzium Tank" - a rare vehicle - @MtgBigMagic spoiler
    Quote from Pollaski »
    Solid Limited card (basically monored Piston-Fist Cyclops with upside). Cant see it landing in my Depala EDH deck. Not a huge fan of the trigger being automatic- one of the best thimgs about Vehicles is they survive Wraths.
    Yeah which still isn't a problem here.

    Also this is one of those situations where you are basically gambling with Depala. On one hand you don't necessarily need to take this vehicle. But on the other hand, there is no telling when the next vehicle will show up or how good it is or possibly what color it is.

    All I'm personally seeing is a legit upgrade for Depala decks here. I can think of a few vehicles I would toss for this.


    Not at CMC 3. Maybe above that, like a Ballista Charger or Aradara Express. But I find this a ton weaker than pretty much every 3 except Daredevil Dragster. The prowess is nice, but consistently getting off noncreatures (especially at the level to make this really hum) seems a stretch.

    If anything, Id.much rather run this in Zada, Hedron Grinder
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on "Mizzium Tank" - a rare vehicle - @MtgBigMagic spoiler
    Solid Limited card (basically monored Piston-Fist Cyclops with upside). Cant see it landing in my Depala EDH deck. Not a huge fan of the trigger being automatic- one of the best thimgs about Vehicles is they survive Wraths.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on 4 Lords of Limited preview cards
    I love the art on all these.

    1. Guilds dont matter much when the alternative is total annhilation.

    2. Kaya doin ghosts a solid and gettin proliffed for her efforts (esp since shes now had 3 cards and 1 total + ability. She needs it!)

    3. Wait, isnt that the woman in Mission Briefing?
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [LEAK][BOOK SPOILER DISCUSSION] Ok....yeah... cool cards and all....WHO DIES ALREADY?
    Quote from krishnath »
    Quote from Mishotem »
    Quote from scottjhebert »
    Jace doesn't die. Chandra doesn't die. Liliana doesn't die. They're the three most popular PWs.


    This...shouldn't matter. Popularity shouldn't affect plot. I'll invoke Game Of Thrones and leave it at that.

    I do think that if Jace DOES live, his newfound attitude of actually taking responsibility for the choices he's made may lead him to quit the Gatewatch in favor of actually being the Guildpact.


    Of supporting cast, Sorin and Nahiri are pretty clearly going to live, as there is no reason to narratively show their feud continuing unless they will continue it into the future.


    Or it gets resolved in the story, one way or the other.


    I hope Tamiyo doesn't die.


    We need her for the Return To Kamigawa.

    Jaya likely dies.

    Teyo, Davriel, and the Wanderer are all too new to die, IMO.

    Ral Zarek probably dies. I hope Vraska doesn't, but she might.

    The odds that any given GR PW dies is pretty high given the relative glut of them they have. Domri Rade almost certainly will die, given that he seems the most pro-Bolas PW out there.

    By the same token, Dovin could die.

    Tezzeret likely lives.


    Agree about Jaya. Teyo probably ends up replacing Gideon if Gideon dies. Unless Liliana brings him back. I've said for a while either Jace or Vraska goes. Domri just bugs me for some reason, he could go. Dovin seems like a non-character and his inclusion on Bolas' side is just weird to begin with, not for personality reasons but just pure odds. The only actual connection between Dovin and Bolas was the Gatewatch. How did they meet? How did he get recruited? Unless Bolas' influence on Liliana's contract has more of a hold on her than we know about? Or Bolas is the Raven Man, and she's been his unwitting spy on the Gatewatch this entire time?

    And Tezzeret needs to give the Bridge tech to Phyrexia.

    Then there's all the redshirts - Arlinn, Ashiok, Huatli, etc. Flip a coin. My personal doubt is that the body count of known characters will be pretty low. Three maybe, at most?


    The connection between Bolas and Dovin is Tezzeret. Dovin would never have allowed Tezz to take over on Kaladesh unless the latter hand something really powerful backing him up, I.e. Bolas.


    I'm not sure of that Baan is very much under the mantle of the "well-intentioned extremist", and if he thinks you are an asset to his vision (like Tezzeret was on Kaladesh, despite his personality issues), he's more than happy to defer to you.

    I can see Baan going either way here. On one hand, he is a fundamentally decent person who just has... ideas on way society could function. That's the whole reason he took over the Azorious, and Bolas' true intentions are kinda anathemic to that. Also, the flavor text of Dovin's Veto strongly suggest there's something deeper at work with him.

    As far as who I think lives or dies...

    Samut- 75% sure she dies. This is way too personal of a situation for her, and I can see it costing her.

    Bolas- 75% sure he lives. He's going to lose, but I don't think he dies.

    Ashiok- Almost certain they live. One of the few true villians here, will be needed further down.

    Kasmina- 50/50. Could be a hook for post-WAR storytelling, could be a mauve shirt. We'll have to see.

    Domri- Almost certain he dies. He'll have bought too hard into the end-raze for it to be otherwise.

    Teyo- Almost certain he lives. The way he's marketed, it seems like they have plans for him.

    Ral Zarek- Leaning towards him dying. His position is too volitaile.

    Tamiyo- Leaning towards her living. She's a fairly non-action girl to begin with, but shown to be a survivor. I can see her helping come up with a plan to beat Bolas, but don't see her on the front lines in harms way when it happens.

    Karn- Completely certain he lives.

    Jaya- Almost completely certain she dies. I was amazed she survived Dominaria.

    Tibalt- Already confirmed to have survived

    The Wanderer- Almost completely certain she lives. Something tells me she's going to get herself intentionally trapped with the immortal sun, though, to stop her planeswalking "curse". Either way, she's too intriguing to off yet.

    Kiora- 50/50. I can see her doing something entirely reckless and stupid that gets her killed.

    Sorin- Probably lives, unless Ugin gets completely fed up with him.

    Teferi- 75% certain he lives. If he's going to die, I think its going to be in the New Phyrexia story.

    Angrath- 75% certain he dies. I don't think there's much else to use him for.

    Baan- 75% certain he dies. Almost certain he dies, if not a hero, not the villian we all think he is.

    Ajani- Confirmed lived.

    Arlinn- 75% certain she dies. What else is there for her?

    Ob Nixilis- Completely certain he lives. Just too good a villian to side-swipe him in another guys story.

    Jiang- Completely certain he lives. I don't think they're going to off someone they invested heavily in to market to the Asian market.

    Huatli- 50/50. Her story's done, but I can see her being usable in the future.

    Sarkhan- 75% certain he's going to die. This is too personal for him.

    Saheeli- Almost certain she's going to live. If anything, Huatli saves her in a heroic sacrifice.

    Narset- 75% certain she lives. I think Wizards has more planned for her.

    Nahiri- 75% certain she dies. I think the Sorin/Nahiri feud gets a casualty, and I don't think the survivor's going to be all that happy about it in the end.

    Ugin- 50/50. But he'll be instrumental in Bolas' defeat

    Davriel- Completely certain he lives. Just too cool to kill, right?

    Vraska- 75% certain she survives, although I totally can see her going out in a heroic sacrifice.

    Kaya- 75% certain she lives. I think Wizards has more for her.

    Jace- 75% certain he lives. We need to go back to Vryn.

    Gideon- 50/50. Hazoret's warning from the last Amonkhet story should be blaring very loudly right now. Especially with the Amonkhet gods coming into play.

    Liliana- 75% certain she lives. That trailer tried WAY too hard to convince us she was going to die, and we still need to figure out this Raven Man stuff.

    Nissa- Almost certain she lives.

    Chandra- Confirmed survivor

    Vivien- 50/50. This was the moment she was created for, after all.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on Problems with a best friend and MTG
    Man, this sounds like my Junior High days, when every freaking game you'd eat a Hymn to Tourach on Turn 2.

    Honestly, I can sympathize with the both of you. There ain't nothing wrong with playing to win, but if the way you play to win ends up turning a lot of people off, you quickly find yourself with no one to play with. One of the reasons commander's so good- the prospect of a 3 on 1 does a good job of keeping players a little more fair. Even then, I'm careful about running a deck like my Animar deck, because it can be pretty alienating to enough people when it properly goes off, and I know my playgroups don't want to face it every game.

    My best advice is to build another deck designed to disrupt the way he plays, and to force him into building a different deck to combat it, which opens up the meta between you (is it a meta if its two players?) to where you're each playing more decks, which might open it up to where you can play in the playstyle you like from time to time. Barring that, play more multiplayer formats, or, worst comes to worse- just don't play Magic with him.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on Role Reversal
    That's a nice tool for a certain greathearted... wait.

    What are you doing here, Ajani? That... that's Zedruu's title. What did you do to Zedruu, Ajani? What did you do?!?


    Zedruu went to live on a farm, Rosy...
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [LEAK][BOOK SPOILER DISCUSSION] Ok....yeah... cool cards and all....WHO DIES ALREADY?
    Wait, where does Ral die? It looks like Dack dies, but even that's slightly ambiguous.

    That said, the new Chandra comic came out today, which takes place after War of the Spark.

    Chandra, Ajani, and Tibalt are all alive, but Chandra's VERY PTSD'd about someone (or multiples) dying, and feels guilt over it.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on war of the spark seems like a high power set
    I'd go with Dominaria. Pushing rare/mythic mechanics into uncommon.

    Posted in: New Card Discussion
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.