It's SOP to wait until you're at L-2 for a claim, but if you're adamant about cutting to the chase, I won't stop you.
Ok now I'm sold. Town doesn't want to claim. Scum likes to claim when they have put work into making a convincing one.
You have got to be kidding me. It's almost like you've never seen sarcasm on the Internet before. /sarcasm
@ZDS: I'm willing to take another look at hawk and attack or defend him as I see fit, but now is not the time when I feel like investing energy into this thread.
If Day Two is anything like Day One, I will continue to be bitter. Better hope we actually have some leads after a flip or two.
I don't see why AI would have been bored with this game. No one else has been bored with the game. It's moving along at a fair clip, there are plenty of wagons, lots of people were excited for it and looking forward to joining it. Beyond that, he doesn't actually sound bored, he just sounds pissed off with the world. It's far more likely he's "bored" with the game because it's well-known that he hates playing as scum, and he's getting repeatedly reamed on day one by yours truly.
And you've somehow failed to consider that I might lose interest in a game in which everything I say is twisted and used against me by someone who has no idea how to read me and yet whose word is treated as tears from heaven. Fascinating.
@KoolKoal: Man it's almost like it's impossible to have more than one scumread or something.
Man, its like saying you want certain people dead first means you should be voting one of them rather than a third scumread who didn't even warrant mentioning in the post. Must be such a strong read you have on Togs for you to completely forgot about him for that post
"First" relative to zindabad, obviously, considering I am basing his alignment on yours. If all you've got on me is a misrepresentation, then you've got literally nothing.
I'm inclined to agree with dk that Atog is more likely to get replaced than lynched, which means it'll probably be you who gets strung up instead. But by all means continue to flail about.
@KoolKoal: Man it's almost like it's impossible to have more than one scumread or something.
@zindabad: I've made it clear that I have no intent of engaging with Azrael. At this point his arguments are so ridiculous that I don't care if I'm slandering him. Even if he's town, people would be foolish to listen to him.
@ZDS: I don't think anyone seriously thinks hawk is a viable lynch candidate at this point. Demonstrating that he is town would be a wasted effort.
@Proph: I'd settle for KK but I'd rather lynch Atog.
@Everyone who thinks Azrael's word is gospel: Wake the **** up.
Azrael's view of the gamestate is an Atari in the age of the Xbox.
zindabad, the people voting you are doing so for poor/scummy reasons, so I think voting you at this juncture is a terrible idea. I don't necessarily town-read you, but I want KoolKoal and scarbo dead first.
@ZDS: It's not so much that I gave up on the hawk PBPA because I couldn't make a compelling case, but more that other people became scummy enough that I didn't think hawk could realistically get lynched by deadline. Then I reconsidered the conviction of my read and realized that hawk and I have been playing similarly in some regards, despite my intense dislike of his current fly-by playstyle.
@hawk: You need to start explaining all of your votes. This isn't RVS any more.
*frown* I'm a little uncomfortable defending him so strongly when I see the viability of the ret-con angle as well as you do, but I get uncomfortable with the idea that he's dumb enough as scum to lie about what his stances were for essentially no reason (like, why not just say you messed up, as scum? Isn't that an unforced error?), yet also smart enough as scum to make several posts afterwards in a row explaining his entire posting history through that lens.
I have to go back and look at the sequence again, but what I remember are posts where both Rhand and yourself declared Vish looked Town and that AI then looked scummy for his opportunistic support of a Vish wagon. Your post in particular - the one where you said "psyche" (which was #190) - almost made it look like YOU were trapping. It seems like Atog may have seen that and been trying to find a way to avoid getting thrown in the same category as AI. Hence his comeback in #253 saying he really never had a scum read on Vish at all.
Atog even appeared to be trying to buddy you up in #208. He said you made a nice "catch" of AI. But this was before he came out and claimed he was essentially trying to do the exact same thing. That makes zero sense also. Looks to me like he got scared that you had laid a trap that he himself had fallen into, and was furiously backpedaling to try and make it appear like he never actually fell into it to begin with. Which is ironic because I don't see where you were actually laying any kind of trap to begin with, but he clearly read it like you were trapping, and tried to flatter you for it.
More shortly, pushing this out now to avoid a prod.
I'm glad you said this, because this post contributed nothing of worth.
I would like for you to explain your vote in this post, as well as provide your strongest town read.
Kinda unmotivated to finish the hawk PBPA right now, but the long and short of it is that hawk is probably bad town with an outside shot of being scum.
Can you give us the longer and less short of it, at least? (ie: why you got to this conclusion)
There are a lot of posts that rub me the wrong way, but I can also understand his mindset with regard to other points. I can put myself into his thought process without too much effort, making me think that we're the same alignment.
I did not read scarbo's longish post because it was very poorly formatted. I do recall something about the way he was consistently defending me was off-putting, like no townie should be that sure that I was not scum.
Kinda unmotivated to finish the hawk PBPA right now, but the long and short of it is that hawk is probably bad town with an outside shot of being scum.
I've seen zindabad suddenly perk up near a deadline before as scum. I believe it was Symbiote or Goo Mafia.
However, KoolKoal's reaction is causing me to second-guess that meta read. Sadly, I don't think lynching him is viable toDay.
I would still like Atog lynched. He hasn't done anything to convince me that he's town, and I don't think we can afford to have him as an unknown as the game continues.
Cryptic Command is my favorite card because it does everything a blue mage could want: Counter spells, bounce permanents, tap creatures, and/or draw cards!
Sorry Meg.
/replace
You have got to be kidding me. It's almost like you've never seen sarcasm on the Internet before. /sarcasm
@ZDS: I'm willing to take another look at hawk and attack or defend him as I see fit, but now is not the time when I feel like investing energy into this thread.
If Day Two is anything like Day One, I will continue to be bitter. Better hope we actually have some leads after a flip or two.
@Taredas: I'm not reading that. Clean up your posts.
And you've somehow failed to consider that I might lose interest in a game in which everything I say is twisted and used against me by someone who has no idea how to read me and yet whose word is treated as tears from heaven. Fascinating.
"First" relative to zindabad, obviously, considering I am basing his alignment on yours. If all you've got on me is a misrepresentation, then you've got literally nothing.
I'm inclined to agree with dk that Atog is more likely to get replaced than lynched, which means it'll probably be you who gets strung up instead. But by all means continue to flail about.
@zindabad: I've made it clear that I have no intent of engaging with Azrael. At this point his arguments are so ridiculous that I don't care if I'm slandering him. Even if he's town, people would be foolish to listen to him.
@ZDS: I don't think anyone seriously thinks hawk is a viable lynch candidate at this point. Demonstrating that he is town would be a wasted effort.
@Proph: I'd settle for KK but I'd rather lynch Atog.
@Everyone who thinks Azrael's word is gospel: Wake the **** up.
Why? He's got blinders on so badly you'd think he wore horseshoes.
zindabad, the people voting you are doing so for poor/scummy reasons, so I think voting you at this juncture is a terrible idea. I don't necessarily town-read you, but I want KoolKoal and scarbo dead first.
@hawk: You need to start explaining all of your votes. This isn't RVS any more.
#bless
@KoolKoal: Are you scum?
I'm glad you said this, because this post contributed nothing of worth.
I would like for you to explain your vote in this post, as well as provide your strongest town read.
There are a lot of posts that rub me the wrong way, but I can also understand his mindset with regard to other points. I can put myself into his thought process without too much effort, making me think that we're the same alignment.
I did not read scarbo's longish post because it was very poorly formatted. I do recall something about the way he was consistently defending me was off-putting, like no townie should be that sure that I was not scum.
I've seen zindabad suddenly perk up near a deadline before as scum. I believe it was Symbiote or Goo Mafia.
However, KoolKoal's reaction is causing me to second-guess that meta read. Sadly, I don't think lynching him is viable toDay.
I would still like Atog lynched. He hasn't done anything to convince me that he's town, and I don't think we can afford to have him as an unknown as the game continues.