Sorry, don't mean to come into this topic rudely, but I have no clue how in the hell Knightfall is in the tier 2 forums.
It's not that the deck is bad, but looking through this entire topic of lists, MTGGoldfish, MTGtop8, googling, articles, there's no coherent list of this deck whatsoever. It's a mishmash of ***** that no one can agree with yet.
A lot of these tier 1 and tier 2 lists have a fairly established set list with flex spots and numbers to tweak, especially the Zoo lists, but this---it's honestly all over the place, which is disappointing, because it has potential. Right now, the last few pages look like an all in version, which is just a *****tier version of UR Twin.
I hope the pro tour coming up helps establish some form of consistency in the Knightfall archetype, because as of now, I truly believe this should still be in the creative subset
If you go back a whole 1 page it tells you why this got pushed up to tier 2.
The thread IS a mess and they know it because they went and pushed 3 decks into this one thread. The reason why people don't agree is because of those 3 different decks that ended up sharing this thread with the original Knightfall deck.
My problem with Windbrisk Heights is that more times than not one of two things happen to me. First I don't get to cast the card. Second when I do cast the card it's a win more type thing.
How do you guys feel about his splits on Sorin and Gideon? He said he would rather have Gideon, but every time I have Sorin is just feels amazing.
Now hold on a minute. I'm the target audience and I am very much excited by lands that efficiently give me access to my colors. In fact, 85% of people I know would be excited by good lands for their commander decks. IMO It would be quite the opposite of a "big fail", and would certainly not drive the value down, but rather increase the value if people want these efficient lands in their decks (which, if we're still talking about fetches, they do).
They have said time and time again that most players don't care for the lands. I know quite a few play groups that don't care about them as they are table top casual. The table tops make up most of the market.
I haven't played against many Scapeshift opponents and I was wondering if you guys bring in the Leylines. I know they have Cryptic and Repeal but is it still worth it? I know they will just bounce it when they won't deal with it until they have the combo.
I was wondering if you guys are running Simian Spirit Guide? If so what do you think about Faithless Looting. There are times you can afford to discard the two cards imo. I haven't play many games with it but I was just wondering if that was an option.
My question about the Rock deck match up. I've been bringing in my 2 Hibernation vs them and it seems to work. They tend to snag it with a thoughtseize.
My main question is how do you guys feel about that?
http://www.mtgtop8.com/event?e=13392&d=278543&f=MO
If you go back a whole 1 page it tells you why this got pushed up to tier 2.
The thread IS a mess and they know it because they went and pushed 3 decks into this one thread. The reason why people don't agree is because of those 3 different decks that ended up sharing this thread with the original Knightfall deck.
How do you guys feel about his splits on Sorin and Gideon? He said he would rather have Gideon, but every time I have Sorin is just feels amazing.
Also a normal fun one of Meren also maybe?
Thanks!
If Bloom Titan is not banned in the OGW then this land will make that deck very gross.
They have said time and time again that most players don't care for the lands. I know quite a few play groups that don't care about them as they are table top casual. The table tops make up most of the market.
I was wondering if anyone could do a render of Seton, Krosan Protector. I've looked everywhere and can't seem to find a good one. Can anyone help?
Thanks!
Thanks!
How much do you like the main deck Gut Shots?
Edit:
Just saw your videos. You answered it there.
My main question is how do you guys feel about that?