All users will need to merge their MTGSalvation account with a new or existing Twitch account starting Sept 25th. You can merge your accounts by clicking here. Have questions? Learn more here.
The Magic Market Index for Jan 12, 2018
Treasure Cruisin' Tempered Steel
The Magic Market Index for Jan 5, 2018
  • posted a message on Echo's MTG Template 2.0
    Let me put it this way: If WotC adopted these frames, I would honestly consider selling everything I own in attempts to collect foil versions of everything.

    ...anyway. Amazing frames. The only problem I have with them is the expansion symbol. I would prefer it to be at the very bottom left of the card, right next to the artist credit. I don't want the symbol to just be on the typeline (I've always felt that was a mistake made early on in Magic's history that now can't be fixed), and having it in the place you've put it I'm not too sure I like how it interacts with the art.

    Aside from that: Font's are good choices, multicoloured lines and some awesome background textures just make this feel more like a real Magic frame than anything I've seen before.

    Keep up the good work!
    Posted in: Artwork
  • posted a message on A Tragic Passing: Richie Proffitt, aka PolarBearGod, has just passed away
    I've added a tribute to my sig, that's about all I could think of doing.

    I'll miss him. Least of all for the great work he did in the Fantasy Art for Card Creation thread. I've spent many an hour killing bandwitdh admiring everything he did for MtGSally.

    (Ironically my sig pic seems to fit, even though I made it last year...)
    Posted in: News
  • posted a message on Community Card Frame: Alpha + Beta
    The one on the right.

    I can't explain why I like it, it just "feels" like a better border for the art box. I think its because you have the mana cost crossing it, therefore its not such a "hard" edge as the rest of the frame.

    (Also, am I correct in assuming you intend to array the power/toughness vertically to the left of the textbox? I can't imagine where the copywrite/set number would go.)
    Posted in: Artwork
  • posted a message on Community Card Frame: Alpha + Beta
    If I may add my two cents:

    The second frame in the first post (Angel of Salvation and Jaya) would be an amazing extended art frame. However, for a "normal" version of the frame, I would suggest two minor alterations.

    1) Get rid of the transparency. This enables you to apply a texture to the frame (instead of just a colour) without it clashing with the artwork. Maybe as an example redo Jaya with that texture used in the two Kamahl frames in your second post?

    2) Extend the text box all the way to the edges of the card. The attached image (hopefully) shows how I feel this should be done. Maybe even possibly flatten the type box? (extensions shown in red. Excuse my shoddy Paint skills)

    Posted in: Artwork
  • posted a message on Does anyone here like Space the Convergence?
    Ancestral Recall
    Blaze of Glory
    Dark Ritual
    Lightning Bolt
    Giant Growth
    Black Lotus
    Glimpse the Unthinkable

    The theme is the original cycle of 1cc instants in First Edition, or at the very least have 1cc in general.

    P.S. Has anybody else noticed how well the card type symbols match this frame? It's almost like they were designed to go together. And having the colour symbol in the corner would be useful in some kind of "landless" format where cards become lands.
    Posted in: Artwork
  • posted a message on Another template strike back
    At the risk of sounding like I'm just going "me too!", title font 8 and the third text box seem to be the best.

    The other two text boxes are really obvious, and impact on the artwork (and text in the case of the first one). In any extended art template, the most important thing is making the text as easy to read as possible while still keeping the artwork looking good, and I feel the third frame achieves this with the least "random arbitrary lines" around the text.

    Krashbot above has already mentioned why the 8th title font is good, so I don't need to just repeat what they have said.

    Look forward to having this available (PSD or even MSE2) soon.

    EDIT: Yeah, I would put the mana cost on the left, but I appear to be in the minority about that...
    Posted in: Artwork
  • posted a message on I herd you likd Mudkipz?!
    Don't worry Virot, I got the reference.

    Of course I liek Mudkipz, but a cat is fine too. Kitty
    Posted in: Artwork
  • posted a message on D&D-themed set after 'Doughnut'?
    The biggest problem I see with this is the sheer scope of it all. Can you imagine trying to fit arcane magic, divine magic, shadow magic, pact magic, truename magic, psionics, node magic, combat stances, and incarnum all into five colors in one block?

    And then inevitably fans would create their own sets based on third-party supplements, like Iron Kingdoms, DragonMech, or The Book of Erotic Fantasy :o.

    Magic already has most of the core D&D races and classes as creature types, and personally I'm not missing Bard, Gnome or Drow at all. I'm pretty sure we can even squeeze in Beholders as Eyes. Possibly give them protection from sorceries and instants to mimic the anti-magic eye?
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on Funny Scenes At Tournaments
    At the Lorwyn prerelease I traded away my foil Dryad's Caress for a Revised Edition Ornithopter, just because the guy wanted the "foily cleavage".

    Posted in: the Speakeasy
  • posted a message on [LOR] 4 New cards including Goatnapper... (confirmed)
    I've seen this ability before. It's "Loyalty—Reveal" from VS. (Not that I play or anything...)

    Still, good to see it being used in a tribal block. Obvious reinforcement of the theme, although on turn one it seems more about luck than skill (*cough*Leylines*cough*). It's the first thing I would think of if I had been working on Lorwyn (and thank the Card Gods I'm not).
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Cranial Insertion: Conspiracy to Commit Delay
    There's a (very minor) mistake in the answer to the sixth question (about the Commandeered Delay):

    Quote from Binary »
    So regardless of who controls the Delay, it's the spell's owner (the player who started the spell with that game in his/her deck) that will play the spell when the last time counter is removed.

    should be

    So regardless of who controls the Delay, it's the spell's owner (the player who started the game with that spell in his/her deck) that will play the spell when the last time counter is removed.
    Apart from that, great article as always. I especially liked the narrative style for the first question about the animated land. (Who says rules questions have to be boring?)
    Posted in: Articles
  • posted a message on Onslaught Week?
    Apologies if this has already been covered/in the wrong place. Just delete this and we can all pretend it never happened.


    I first saw this from MaRo's article on Monday:

    Quote from Mark Rosewater on Monday »
    Join me next week when the onslaught begins.

    'Possibly there would be some kind of spoilers or something next week, an "onslaught" of new info', is what first went through my head, but then I saw this yesterday:

    Quote from Mike Flores on Thursday »
    The Onslaught doesn't begin this week...

    Why is "Onslaught" capitalised? Is this a hint that next week's theme will be the Onslaught set/block?

    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on [LOR?] Goldmeadow Harrier token art
    You can add an expansion symbol there ~__^

    If I figure out how to import expansion symbols into MSE while this thread is still alive, I just might.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [LOR?] Goldmeadow Harrier token art
    Just made this in Magic Set Editor. Artwork looks a little squashed.

    NOTE: I'm only guessing the casting cost. Unless one of the many rumourmongers around here wants to correct me, I'm going to assume that it just costs W.

    EDIT: Thanks Teppic. Artwork credit added.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on The Five-Year Plan
    •Tribe/affiliation becoming more important than colour
    Players having power and toughness
    System more combat-focused, but no trample, first strike, or protection
    Setting based on another product line, possibly in a different format you're saying that Magic will become WoW?

    Sweet. Maybe they can do a crossover set!

    Posted in: Speculation
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.