Just an idea I came up with. Haven't been able to test it yet, but was looking for help with the sideboard and possible improvements to the land base before I sink money into it, as well as any ideas/cards I might have missed.
Gist of the deck is that I want to be sacrificing dudes to Butcher with Cutthroat and Liliana on the board, but it should function fairly well as an aggressive deck even without everything online, as well as being resilient because Liliana and the Command can bring dudes back, but a lot of my guys can come back on their own anyway. Outpost Sieges and Ob are just extra card advantage, but are probably the least necessary cards to the overall strategy and I'm considering maybe moving the Sieges to the sideboard in favour of more removal.
Nirkana Assassin is probably the worst card in the deck and I'd be cutting it in favour of Ob Nixilis Reignited, who is arguably the strongest planeswalker in standard at the moment. While Scoured Barrens is nice, I wouldn't run 4. Your curve is really low and your deck looks pretty aggressive, and having 6 taplands between that and the manlands is probably too many. I'd cut back to 2 or 3.
Other than that, it looks like it has potential. Let us know how it goes.
Please learn to format your decklists. This is ridiculously hard to read. Put titles in there with the number (e.g. Land (24)) and leave gaps between the lands, creatures, spells, etc.
That aside, Countermages advice was pretty spot on. I don't know about black over red, although Drana and Kalastria Healer are definitely good enough to consider it. I do think Woodland Wanderer is so good that it should be a 4-of in every 3-colour green deck, but Felidar Sovereign is doing nothing for you and shouldn't even be in your sideboard. It's not a finisher at all. It costs 6 and hits for 4 and has no evasion. Wanderer will be bigger than that more often than not, as well as having Trample to get damage in.
As I said, Mentor out, Brimaz in, I expect Brimaz will provide more Devotion, better combat situations, and be best friends with Gideon.
Just a brief note on this one: Brimaz's cat token does not contribute to Gideon's 2 other required creatures. Where it says "attacked", it means that they had to be declared as attackers. Since the cat token enters already attacking, it was not declared as an attacker and so does not help Gideon flip. The rule is, in my opinion, a bit convoluted, but that's the way it is.
That aside, I really like the deck. Although I like pretty much anything that manages to run Archangel of Tithes so...
You must have 15 cards in your sideboard, and as far as I can tell you've only got 6. It's not an "up to" or "minimum" type deal, it's a "must have exactly 15 cards, or no sideboard at all" type deal.
What currency are these prices listed in? Things are far more expensive in Australia than in the US or UK, and even here there's no way anyone is paying $95.44 for a Thoughtseize or $63.80 for Hangarback Walker.
I have it in my sideboard. With my elf deck, I usually chord for her to play against the mirror matches. She's very effective and I'm all for using her.
You said the card was lackluster. The card is not lackluster. I see no hairs being split.
No you were splitting hairs, as you responded to the first sentence and not the rest of the comment. What did the last sentence say? Thats right that I thought she was awesome. And her presence has been lackluster, sorry that I had to spell it out for your illiterate ass.
Well OK, let's devolve into childish name calling, how mature! "I think she is truly awesome" is different to "this card is legitimately good". Some people think Dragonlord Kolghan is an awesome card because they like what it does, it's a dragon and it's not completely terrible, that doesn't necessarily mean it's a competitive card that should be played in any deck that can play it. There are multiple reasons for thinking a card is awesome.
At the end of the day though, I misinterpreted what you were saying. Whatever, I'm human, mistakes were made. If you want to continue to act like a child and spit insults then go for it.
2 Battlefield Forge
4 Bloodstained Mire
3 Caves of Koilos
3 Mountain
4 Nomad Outpost
1 Shambling Vent
4 Smoldering Marsh
2 Swamp
4 Hangarback Walker
4 Bloodsoaked Champion
4 Zulaport Cutthroat
4 Flamewake Phoenix
3 Liliana, Heretical Healer
4 Butcher of the Horde
1 Ob Nixilis Reignited
Instant (10)
4 Kolaghan's Command
4 Crackling Doom
2 Mardu Charm
Enchantment (3)
3 Outpost Siege
Gist of the deck is that I want to be sacrificing dudes to Butcher with Cutthroat and Liliana on the board, but it should function fairly well as an aggressive deck even without everything online, as well as being resilient because Liliana and the Command can bring dudes back, but a lot of my guys can come back on their own anyway. Outpost Sieges and Ob are just extra card advantage, but are probably the least necessary cards to the overall strategy and I'm considering maybe moving the Sieges to the sideboard in favour of more removal.
Other than that, it looks like it has potential. Let us know how it goes.
That aside, Countermages advice was pretty spot on. I don't know about black over red, although Drana and Kalastria Healer are definitely good enough to consider it. I do think Woodland Wanderer is so good that it should be a 4-of in every 3-colour green deck, but Felidar Sovereign is doing nothing for you and shouldn't even be in your sideboard. It's not a finisher at all. It costs 6 and hits for 4 and has no evasion. Wanderer will be bigger than that more often than not, as well as having Trample to get damage in.
Does it check twice?
Source.
Just a brief note on this one: Brimaz's cat token does not contribute to Gideon's 2 other required creatures. Where it says "attacked", it means that they had to be declared as attackers. Since the cat token enters already attacking, it was not declared as an attacker and so does not help Gideon flip. The rule is, in my opinion, a bit convoluted, but that's the way it is.
That aside, I really like the deck. Although I like pretty much anything that manages to run Archangel of Tithes so...
I dig it. How many Chords and Angels do you run?
Well OK, let's devolve into childish name calling, how mature! "I think she is truly awesome" is different to "this card is legitimately good". Some people think Dragonlord Kolghan is an awesome card because they like what it does, it's a dragon and it's not completely terrible, that doesn't necessarily mean it's a competitive card that should be played in any deck that can play it. There are multiple reasons for thinking a card is awesome.
At the end of the day though, I misinterpreted what you were saying. Whatever, I'm human, mistakes were made. If you want to continue to act like a child and spit insults then go for it.