You had said you planned on explaining your DJ read after he showed up. I don't like how reserved you've been all throughout the end of Yesterday and then Today not giving reasons for your actions, first waiting on Meg and DJ, then waiting on DJ, and then not providing them even after DJ posted. You also reserved your vote until the wagon on him started to move. You were on the BE wagon early Yesterday and then switched to Rez after getting pressure, /barned my case and then mostly clammed up and let the competing wagons argue. You haven't made effort to provide your own reasoning to your cases outside of the formatting issue with BE at the beginning of the game and you haven't been scum hunting. Odd iGem is where I want my vote barring new info on the Antny clear.
Vote: Odd iGem
I did not say that. I said I would provide my reasoning, and I did. Compared to everyone else in this game, Megiddo is someone I would expect to be a high-priority NK target. Since iRebel fessed up to vigging Burning_Earth, that means he wasn't the NK unless he was:
a) the target of both the NK and a vig; or
b) iRebel is lying (and therefore scum)
I caught Deathjoey targeting Megiddo last Night and there was theoretically no scum kill last Night. I shared the info that I had, then Megiddo voted Deathjoey, which confirmed my suspicion. What more is there to say? Incidentally, his lack of content and stingy voting yesterday weren't great, but are not my main reason.
You had said you planned on explaining your DJ read after he showed up. I don't like how reserved you've been all throughout the end of Yesterday and then Today not giving reasons for your actions, first waiting on Meg and DJ, then waiting on DJ, and then not providing them even after DJ posted. You also reserved your vote until the wagon on him started to move. You were on the BE wagon early Yesterday and then switched to Rez after getting pressure, /barned my case and then mostly clammed up and let the competing wagons argue. You haven't made effort to provide your own reasoning to your cases outside of the formatting issue with BE at the beginning of the game and you haven't been scum hunting. Odd iGem is where I want my vote barring new info on the Antny clear.
Vote: Odd iGem[/quote]
I did not say that. I said I would provide my reasoning, and I did. Compared to everyone else in this game, Megiddo is someone I would expect to be a high-priority NK target. Since iRebel fessed up to vigging Burning_Earth, that means he wasn't the NK unless he was:
a) the target of both the NK and a vig; or
b) iRebel is lying (and therefore scum)
I caught Deathjoey targeting Megiddo last Night and there was theoretically no scum kill last Night. I shared the info that I had, then Megiddo voted Deathjoey, which confirmed my suspicion. What more is there to say? Incidentally, his lack of content and stingy voting yesterday weren't great, but are not my main reason.
@Meg/DCIII: I'll provide reasoning after DJ shows up.
@DCIII: Megiddo isn't a suspect of mine.
Why does everyone feel the need to wait for X person to show up before answering questions?
I'm here, is there some outstanding question that I haven't answered that prevents you from doing your thing?
I'm about half way done with my re-read.
I still don't like meggido.
I'm not sure what I think of dk now. His recent attitude feels weird and the 2 other neighbours being town were a bit unexpected. How often is there all town neighbourhoods?
DC and Irebel are now in my town pile.
I wanted to wait because my reason for suspecting you is partly based on your play yesterDay and partly based on last Night. I know you targeted Megiddo last Night, and compared to everyone else here, he is probably high on the list of NK options.
I really just don't have much else to say. I feel like we've been talking in circles. My vote's been on rezombied for a while, and that's where it's staying. If there are any specific questions for me, I'd be happy to oblige, but I'm not jonesing to dig around for more stuff toDay on my own.
This is not a town reaction. It's a variation of "lynch the other guy first". Even if B_E is town, why would you be self-voting tomorrow if you're town?
In general, why are so many people disengaged with this game right now?
I think it's also somewhat a result of half the players in the game thinking B_E is scum and the other half thinking Rez is scum. Because they're two of the neighbors, everyone is convinced the other group is wrong and nobody is willing to budge.
I've said that if b_e is town that I will self-vote tomorrow.
This is not a town reaction. It's a variation of "lynch the other guy first". Even if B_E is town, why would you be self-voting tomorrow if you're town?
2nd Vote: OddiGem. His vote is basically a barn of Void's reasoning for making the vote a serious(?) vote. While the reasoning is kinda weak given the fact that it is on a newer player, it is at least justified.
@iGem: Mind explaining the exact reason for said vote?
Sure.
My reasoning for voting B_E was based on:
-Needing to clarify/reformat an RVS vote. This just read as unnecessary to me.
-Disliking his reaction to Void's vote. It looked too self-conscious to me.
@Kosa:
Please explain why that is a Town mindset only?
Because he took the time to link the name/alignments and notice that there wasn't an option where's he's listed as town. I wouldn't expect scum noticing it, much less pointing it out.
This is ridiculous. He basically just read a sentence that was broken out into its own paragraph and saw that he was listed as scum in both options. There's nothing town-specific about that at all.
Not answering that question.
What happened to providing your reasoning on Megiddo and also to providing your claim?
Did you not read the exchange above? I wanted to see if Megiddo might come forward about being targeted last Night.
I did not say that. I said I would provide my reasoning, and I did. Compared to everyone else in this game, Megiddo is someone I would expect to be a high-priority NK target. Since iRebel fessed up to vigging Burning_Earth, that means he wasn't the NK unless he was:
a) the target of both the NK and a vig; or
b) iRebel is lying (and therefore scum)
I caught Deathjoey targeting Megiddo last Night and there was theoretically no scum kill last Night. I shared the info that I had, then Megiddo voted Deathjoey, which confirmed my suspicion. What more is there to say? Incidentally, his lack of content and stingy voting yesterday weren't great, but are not my main reason.
---------------
Fixed. Also:
Unvote
Vote Deathjoey
in the event that quote snafu counts as a vote.
Did you not read the exchange above? I wanted to see if Megiddo might come forward about being targeted last Night.
You had said you planned on explaining your DJ read after he showed up. I don't like how reserved you've been all throughout the end of Yesterday and then Today not giving reasons for your actions, first waiting on Meg and DJ, then waiting on DJ, and then not providing them even after DJ posted. You also reserved your vote until the wagon on him started to move. You were on the BE wagon early Yesterday and then switched to Rez after getting pressure, /barned my case and then mostly clammed up and let the competing wagons argue. You haven't made effort to provide your own reasoning to your cases outside of the formatting issue with BE at the beginning of the game and you haven't been scum hunting. Odd iGem is where I want my vote barring new info on the Antny clear.
Vote: Odd iGem[/quote]
I did not say that. I said I would provide my reasoning, and I did. Compared to everyone else in this game, Megiddo is someone I would expect to be a high-priority NK target. Since iRebel fessed up to vigging Burning_Earth, that means he wasn't the NK unless he was:
a) the target of both the NK and a vig; or
b) iRebel is lying (and therefore scum)
I caught Deathjoey targeting Megiddo last Night and there was theoretically no scum kill last Night. I shared the info that I had, then Megiddo voted Deathjoey, which confirmed my suspicion. What more is there to say? Incidentally, his lack of content and stingy voting yesterday weren't great, but are not my main reason.
Vote Deathjoey
I wanted to wait because my reason for suspecting you is partly based on your play yesterDay and partly based on last Night. I know you targeted Megiddo last Night, and compared to everyone else here, he is probably high on the list of NK options.
@DCIII: Megiddo isn't a suspect of mine.
I would like to hear from Megiddo and Deathjoey, and am interested in a Deathjoey lynch today.
You're missing the point.
This is not a town reaction. It's a variation of "lynch the other guy first". Even if B_E is town, why would you be self-voting tomorrow if you're town?
What? I don't understand this explanation at all.
Sure.
My reasoning for voting B_E was based on:
-Needing to clarify/reformat an RVS vote. This just read as unnecessary to me.
-Disliking his reaction to Void's vote. It looked too self-conscious to me.
This is ridiculous. He basically just read a sentence that was broken out into its own paragraph and saw that he was listed as scum in both options. There's nothing town-specific about that at all.