2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • 1

    posted a message on Rumor…return….of…priceless treasures (very huge “if”)
    Quote from Tormented »
    Quote from Grixh »
    Quote from the n00b king »


    Anyways, now that we know its confirmed to be Legends, most folks only think about the RL stuff, but don't realize that Legends was a gargantuan set with an insane amount of chaff. Plus I heard a rumour that they were boxes that had been sent back to WotC for being defective back in the day (either containing cards from Sheet A or B but not both).


    They confirmed exactly which cards will be available. There's a list of cards they just didn't open due to print run weirdness: https://magic.wizards.com/en/articles/archive/feature/lost-legends-2022-07-21

    Good to see some transparency. Smile


    I am more interested in the cards not included - there can't be some sort of licensing issue as they are just repackaging the cards (It seemed that Harold McNeil was left out for one - possibly because of his political leanings). Gwendlyn because of her profession? But craw giant, pyrotechnics? It's not artist (they would have mentioned crookshank kobolds, spinal villain, etc)

    And what of the cards they didn't include - did they just bonfire Cleanse/pradesh gypsies/imprison cards - cards that were much more questionable bannings than say invoke prejudice (I mean seriously - we all knew that card was wrong in 94).
    I can guess at a couple possibilities. On one hand, there's a few of the cards that might have been revoked for similar reasons to Pradesh et al, even if they didn't hit the threshold for banning from the card image gallery entirely. Stuff like Barbary Apes and Pyrotechnics (due to featuring the name Navajo, which may not the be preferred naming for the tribe) strike me as likely candidates for that. On the other hand, for a promotion where they know players are going to probably compare notes/post stories on line, they may have set a minimum number of a card opened to include it? If (due to similar print run weirdness) they only opened say, 3 Sylvan Libraries, leaving it on the list of cards in the set might get them blasted later if none of those 3 are opened by someone who posts it online. ...That said, I only just noticed that all the money cards on the list of "opened but left out" are Harold's, so I'm leaning away from the second reason.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • 1

    posted a message on [CLB][CUBE] Undermountain Adventurer
    Quote from asmallcat »
    Can I just say I hate that the templating on this card is "Add GG" then "Add six G." Why isn't it "Add GGGGGG"?! That would look so much better.
    It's because of Kaladesh/Energy. While it's nice looking to have GGGGGG in a vacuum/isolated card, it becomes extremely confusing when you've got cards with EEEEEEEE and cards with EEEEEE next to each other, and you're trying to parse quickly exactly how much energy you need. So when you need to create more than 5 of a resource, they short hand it because that many symbols in a row can be hard to read.
    Posted in: Cube Card and Archetype Discussion
  • 1

    posted a message on [NEC] Upgrades Unleashed precon — Jumbo Commander preview
    Quote from Ryperior74 »
    Smoke sprits' aid seriously will they stop making Dockside Extortionist more broken than it is?
    Smoke Spirits' Aid has exactly 0 interaction with Dockside Extortionist? They're still your enchantments, even if they're on your opponents creatures.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • 1

    posted a message on [NEO] Mindlink Mech — Games Academy Brescia Preview
    Quote from Sloop »
    Nice! Thanks a lot!


    So the copied Scute Swarm Vehicle token won‘t „return“ to being something else at the end of Turn right? (as it doesn‘t „remember“ being the Original Scute Swarm or Mindlink Mech before)
    Correct. As far as the Vehicle tokens are concerned, they copied a 4/3 flying artifact vehicle Scute Swarm, so that's what they are. It's the same rule that makes it so that when you Clone a Clone you get a copy of whatever the clone was copying, not another Clone.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • 1

    posted a message on [NEO] Mindlink Mech — Games Academy Brescia Preview
    Quote from Sloop »
    So I have both Scute Swarm and Mindlink Mech on the Battlefield and at least five Lands in play.
    Now I crew the Mech with the Scute Swarm and play another Land.

    Will I now get 2 normal Scute Swarm tokens or 1 normal and another one that's a 4/3 flying artifact creature vehicle?
    And if I do get the vehicle version, will that token stay that way and can it duplicate through its Landfall ability like the other Scute Swarm tokens/copys?
    The second. Normally, making a copy of a crewed vehicle would get you a third option you didn't consider (an uncrewed version of the Vehicle), but Mindlink Mech has a copy ability built into it. So you'd copy the copy, which in this case would be a 4/3 flying artifact vehicle Scute Swarm, and since it would have all the relevant text from Scute Swarm, it would continue making copies in other turns when you play a land.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • 2

    posted a message on [VOW] Welcoming Vampire— Weekly MTG preview
    Quote from Flisch »
    Feel like they should've kept the template "Whenever <condition> the first time each turn, <effect>.". That way it'd read less like a nerf and more like a natural part of the ability and it'd be less disappointing reading the awkward rider at the very end.
    That would cause sequencing issues. Using that template, if you played Welcoming Vampire after a 2-drop enters the battlefield, you can't get a card anymore for the rest of the turn.
    It's really amusing to me how many people are calling for strictly worse versions of templating, just because "this ability triggers once each turn" is at the end?
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • 1

    posted a message on WOTC Confirmed we will give the TWD cards in MTG universe version of cards on the list
    They either need to pare down the list (eliminating the chaff) or put a list card in EVERY set booster. Their stinginess is far beyond welcome.
    As far as we can tell, the frequency of these cards will be seperate from The List's size. If they're guarenteeing one in every 8 set boosters, they'd have to be either 50% of The List (unlikely), or they're effectively a seperate "slot" from the normal The List. The latter seems far more likely to me. So the main question mark to me is whether they'll be supplating "normal" pulls, meaning that the frequency of other The List cards will go down to 1/8 (to make it 1/4 packs having "The List" cards in them), or if they'll be supplemental. Either way, there should be plenty in circulation.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • 1

    posted a message on [MID] Smoldering Egg // Ashmouth Dragon and Vivisection reprint— Comicbook.com previews
    Who thought that vivisection was overtuned as a common?
    Likely less "overtuned" and more "much stronger in an environment where decayed tokens are rampant and thus the cost to sacrificing a creature is much lower."
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • 1

    posted a message on [MID] Brian Kibler -- Moonveil Regant
    Quote from Ryperior74 »
    Quote from Mana Goat »
    With New Capenna coming down the pipe this might be a strong card to invest in.


    oh yea thats a great point out this is probably a prep for that set.

    wont last long though once dominaria united comes it this rotates out
    That is incorrect. Midnight Hunt rotates with the fall/Q3 set in 2023, not Dominaria United. Dominaria will rotate out the 4 sets before Midnight Hunt, as normal.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • 1

    posted a message on [MID] "Mysterious Tome" // "Creepy Chronicle"— Athelars preview
    While mechanically the effects could probably be done without being double sided, it loses *all* of the flavor. A version of the card that works with counters would have no room for flavor text at all, much less the two pieces seen here. And without transformation, the feeling of "flipping through" the book disappears.

    This is not the sort of card that would make you add DFC's to a set, but once they're already in, it's an interesting and flavorful design that makes good use of them.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.