Thanks for pointing me to that. I reread the first few pages of wwe and that is indeed not his usual scum meta at all.
He bussed Kosa right off the bat in wwe. Cythare interactions might be telling.
To me, you're as close to a confirmed townie as it gets without mod confirmation or cop result. I think I rather like to have you around and use no muffins at all.
Or wifom on wether you'll use it tonight or another night or not at all at least, so that you remain a threat big enough to NK.
If you claim your action and use it, scum won't need to kill you because you'll starve anyways (barring donations, but since those are out in the open, we can't count on using them successfully anymore), costing us a townie at no cost for scum.
The thing is that I dismissed AE as town very fast when I was catching up.
He seemed to be very clearly not in his scum meta.
If he is the scum out of you two, then he has learned to control his early game meta.
One of Iso/Shockwave is scum. My reaction to Iso's counterclaim-that-wasn't was a bit of OMGUS and I think, based on claims, that Shockwave is the more likely player to be scum. But Iso has gone out of his way to make a bunch of posts that clear himself when I flip town, no matter what happens at night, and throw suspicion on multiple other players.
From the 3 claims, your is most likely to be scum because
* 2 out of 3 give muffins. 1 doesn't (Shockwave)
* 2 out of 3 use a muffin to activate their ability. 1 doesn't (Iso)
==> It makes more sense that the odd one out in each case is town because that diversifies town more.
If you flip town, I lean more towards Iso being scum than Shockwave at this point because of how he counterclaimed you and then backpedaled on it being a counterclaim.
These two posts from AG are bad.
-snip-
Is this part of your answer to me? Do you only have 2 scumreads?
Kaze, AG and Taredas are likely town. It makes no sense for scum to have to semi-suicide to use an ability.
I do not agree with this, especially if either Shockwave or Iso are scum and are trueclaiming their role. AG or Kaze can use a powerful scum ability and be kept alive for an extra day (or two) by their partner.
Doing the math for Iso, I noticed that AG's role is not as suicidal as I thought it to be. And one donation of muffin enables a 2nd use of his ability, giving scum a good target to use their donation ability on. So yeh, you're right about that.
I don't believe that Kaze's is a scum ability. That really is near-suicidal and hurts scum bad if they want to use it. The inverse - having a townie that has to decide whether his survival or his ability is worth more - makes a lot more sense to me.
Hm. Fair enough I guess.
I need to reread you. I have a scumread on you and a townread on AE, but everyone seems to assume it's the other way around wih townreads on you and null/scumreads on AE.
Oh I just copied Iso's without checking if it's correct.
I take back the fake-soundingness of the claim. That was based on Iso's post where he sums up all the claims.
That makes Dkings - PrP - Kosa the most likely scumteam in my perception instead of Dkings - PrP - Storyteller.
Iso - 4/0 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 5's lynch
Rhand - 4/0 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 5's lynch
storyteller - 4/1 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 3's lynch
PopeRonPaul - 5/0 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 6's lynch
Kosakosa - 5/1 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 4's lynch (last night no ability)
Tavanio - 5/1 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 4's lynch (last night no ability)
Shockwave07 - 5/1 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 4's lynch (last night no ability)
dkingsland967 - 5/1 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 4's lynch (last night no ability)
AtheistGod - 5/2 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 4's lynch (2 last nights no ability)
Kazekirimaru - 5/3 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 3's lynch (last night no ability)
Taredas - 5/X - Ignoring because of multiple possible ability uses per Night
Tanarin - 6/2 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 3's lynch
PrP and Iso are non-aligned pair : I am pretty sure that scum has exactly 1 role that doesn't use muffins. Lynching Dkings should solve this.
Kaze, AG and Taredas are likely town. It makes no sense for scum to have to semi-suicide to use an ability.
I lean towards Tanarin having a town ability as well.
Storyteller's claim seems fake and him having no stance on the claiming is iffy.
Based on this, a PrP - Dkings - Storyteller team seems most plausible.
Kosa > Tanarin if the above is incorrect.
Exalted! That game is good. I didn't know it still exists.
I never owned any cards, but I have played with a friends deck a few times. That's ages ago though.
I don't play Pokemon. My brother used to. I always felt too old for that game.
He bussed Kosa right off the bat in wwe. Cythare interactions might be telling.
Or wifom on wether you'll use it tonight or another night or not at all at least, so that you remain a threat big enough to NK.
If you claim your action and use it, scum won't need to kill you because you'll starve anyways (barring donations, but since those are out in the open, we can't count on using them successfully anymore), costing us a townie at no cost for scum.
The thing is that I dismissed AE as town very fast when I was catching up.
He seemed to be very clearly not in his scum meta.
If he is the scum out of you two, then he has learned to control his early game meta.
I'm gonna reread both of you.
From the 3 claims, your is most likely to be scum because
* 2 out of 3 give muffins. 1 doesn't (Shockwave)
* 2 out of 3 use a muffin to activate their ability. 1 doesn't (Iso)
==> It makes more sense that the odd one out in each case is town because that diversifies town more.
If you flip town, I lean more towards Iso being scum than Shockwave at this point because of how he counterclaimed you and then backpedaled on it being a counterclaim.
Is this part of your answer to me? Do you only have 2 scumreads?
Doing the math for Iso, I noticed that AG's role is not as suicidal as I thought it to be. And one donation of muffin enables a 2nd use of his ability, giving scum a good target to use their donation ability on. So yeh, you're right about that.
I don't believe that Kaze's is a scum ability. That really is near-suicidal and hurts scum bad if they want to use it. The inverse - having a townie that has to decide whether his survival or his ability is worth more - makes a lot more sense to me.
I need to reread you. I have a scumread on you and a townread on AE, but everyone seems to assume it's the other way around wih townreads on you and null/scumreads on AE.
I take back the fake-soundingness of the claim. That was based on Iso's post where he sums up all the claims.
That makes Dkings - PrP - Kosa the most likely scumteam in my perception instead of Dkings - PrP - Storyteller.
Rhand - 4/0 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 5's lynch
storyteller - 4/1 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 3's lynch
PopeRonPaul - 5/0 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 6's lynch
Kosakosa - 5/1 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 4's lynch (last night no ability)
Tavanio - 5/1 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 4's lynch (last night no ability)
Shockwave07 - 5/1 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 4's lynch (last night no ability)
dkingsland967 - 5/1 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 4's lynch (last night no ability)
AtheistGod - 5/2 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 4's lynch (2 last nights no ability)
Kazekirimaru - 5/3 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 3's lynch (last night no ability)
Taredas - 5/X - Ignoring because of multiple possible ability uses per Night
Tanarin - 6/2 - Using ability as often as possible, all town lynches = Dead on Day 3's lynch
Average Day of death: 4
You only had Tanarin right
Kaze, AG and Taredas are likely town. It makes no sense for scum to have to semi-suicide to use an ability.
I lean towards Tanarin having a town ability as well.
Storyteller's claim seems fake and him having no stance on the claiming is iffy.
Based on this, a PrP - Dkings - Storyteller team seems most plausible.
Kosa > Tanarin if the above is incorrect.
You're so eager... With the (hopefully) last scum being either you or him, this makes me uncomfortable.
I never owned any cards, but I have played with a friends deck a few times. That's ages ago though.
I don't play Pokemon. My brother used to. I always felt too old for that game.
I still don't understand that Karn got lynched Day 1.
His role was clearly designed to give you two less power.
Town should've stayed clear of that.
This basically means it's 2 to lynch now.
And that it is in fact lylo, which means AE or iRebel must be scum.