MTG Salvation

Hi everyone,

I'm currently collecting how people in the cube community feel about Theros Beyond Death, and I would be remiss to miss out on MTGSalvation as a place to gather data! I did the same thing for Throne of Eldraine, and you can see the results of that data collection here - Throne of Eldraine Community Testing. Many of the members of the community here participated!

Cube lists of all shapes and sizes are welcome! You can either fill out this survey or post your testing list below, along with card rankings. For card rankings, a rank of 1 means that you think the card is unlikely to make it through testing or you're unexcited about testing it. A rank of 2 means that you're medium on the card, but you think it has a decent shot of making it through testing. A rank of 3 means that the card is a windmill slam inclusion in your list. Feel free to use fractional rankings (ie 2.5).

As an example - here's my testing list for my 450 unpowered cube

Shatter the Sky - 2.5
Agonizing Remorse - 1.5
Thassa's Intervention - 2.5
Eidolon of Obstruction - 2
Kroxa, Titan of Death's Hunger - 2
The First Iroan Games - 1
Phoenix of Ash - 2
Polukranos, Unchained - 1
Tectonic Giant - 1
Atris, Oracle of Half-Truths - 2?
Nadir Kraken - 3
Woe Strider - 1
Elspeth, Sun's Nemesis - 3
Ashiok, Nightmare Muse - 2
Omen of the Sea - 1
Wolfwillow Haven - 1.5
Uros, Titan of Nature's Wrath - 1

Cool idea. I submitted my response.

Wow, I never saw the first vote, but the article layout and graphics are incredible! I didn't test a lot of cards from this newest set unfortunately, but I'll post what cards I have playtested

Quote from NotScottMescudi »

Wow, I never saw the first vote, but the article layout and graphics are incredible! I didn't test a lot of cards from this newest set unfortunately, but I'll post what cards I have playtested

Thassa's Intervention - 3
Elspeth, Sun's Nemesis - 2
Woe Strider - 1

Thanks! We're going to be wrapping up survey collection soon, so if you haven't submitted your testing/include list yet please do! We're looking at ~60 Cubers that shared with us.

Elspeth Conquers Death - 1
Nadir Kraken - 1
Thassa, Deep-Dwelling - 2
Kiora Bests the Sea God - 1
Thassa's Intervention - 1.5
Woe Strider - 2.5
Nightmare Shepherd - 2
Underworld Breach - 3
Ash Phoenix - 2
Tectonic Giant - 1.5
Ashiok, Nightmare Muse - 2
Uro, Titan of Nature's Wrath - 2.5
Kroxa, Titan of Death’s Hunger - 1.5
Klothys, God of Destiny - 1.5
Shadowspear - 2

Thanks so much to everyone that responded! Across all the various niches of the Cube community, we managed to get 84 responses. You can find the finished article here!

Some really interesting findings come out. The results make me want to test Thassa, Deep Dwelling.

Quote from Tjornan »

Thanks so much to everyone that responded! Across all the various niches of the Cube community, we managed to get 84 responses. You can find the finished article here!

Some really interesting findings come out. The results make me want to test Thassa, Deep Dwelling.

In the Pauper subform one poster called Satyr's Cunning the worst card in the set -- and I can't see how they were wrong. Seems 100% uncubeableunplayable.