Hello Cube Enthusiasts! The Ranking Project Continues!
This thread is to vote on your top 20 LANDS cards for cube per the following prompt:
Please rank the top 20 (Lands) cards in cube in consideration of the below factors:
- How critical this card is to winning.
- How frequently you would maindeck this card in a deck playing this color/guild/shard/wedge (or just in general if colorless).
- How important is this card within your cube.
Voting: You have from M-F to vote for your top 20. You can only vote for cards printed through M20 (this includes anything from M20).
Please list your top 20 using a numbered list with Spoiler Tags/Card Tags (see my vote for a formatting example).
You do not have to vote for options you do not personally have experience with, but you certainly may if you feel comfortable doing so.
Votes after Friday are not guaranteed to count (same goes for edits). Nothing other than your votes should be posted here and no partial lists will be accepted.
Results will be compiled and presented by the Sunday following the day you voted.
What cards go here and what cards do not
* Lands that have any kind of colored cost are categorized as that color or combination of colors. That means Treetop Village is considered GREEN, while Raging Ravine and Kessig Wolf Run are both considered red/green (Gruul) GUILD.
* Lands that produce only one color of mana were also categorized as that color. Anything that produces more colors is to be voted here. So Tolarian Academy is a BLUE card, but Vivid Creek is voted on here as a LAND card, just like any 'dual land' that doesn't fall in the above rule about cost.
* Remember that the draft-referencing Conspiracy land Paliano, the High City can be voted for here, but the silver-bordered lands City of Ass, R&D's Secret Lair and Mishra’s Toy Workshop cannot.
Voting on Similar Cards
- While I recognize that many cubes prefer to mix and match cycles based on what is most desirable for a given guild, the voting here is by cycle. E.G. the Fastlands (Copperline Gorge and company) are 1 entry on your list.
- Using cycle names would be a big help to me so I don't have to spend extra time identifying the cycle you reference with a single card while compiling. Known cycles include:
Hmmm...thought I was sticking to 2016's script but I pretty clearly ruled out manlands in the guild voting....So, yeah Manlands need to go here if not there. I will let everyone who has voted know by PM and adjust the OP. Thank You.
Edit: I have included manlands as an eligible vote. Please note that these are voted on as a cycle (meaning 1 slot only) just like the others. I know many people break them up and only run some, but we didn't discuss changing are voting process for lands from previous years in the main project thread so this is how we are proceeding.
This thread is to vote on your top 20 LANDS cards for cube per the following prompt:
Please rank the top 20 (Lands) cards in cube in consideration of the below factors:
- How critical this card is to winning.
- How frequently you would maindeck this card in a deck playing this color/guild/shard/wedge (or just in general if colorless).
- How important is this card within your cube.
Voting: You have from M-F to vote for your top 20. You can only vote for cards printed through M20 (this includes anything from M20).
Please list your top 20 using a numbered list with Spoiler Tags/Card Tags (see my vote for a formatting example).
You do not have to vote for options you do not personally have experience with, but you certainly may if you feel comfortable doing so.
Votes after Friday are not guaranteed to count (same goes for edits). Nothing other than your votes should be posted here and no partial lists will be accepted.
Results will be compiled and presented by the Sunday following the day you voted.
What cards go here and what cards do not
* Lands that have any kind of colored cost are categorized as that color or combination of colors. That means Treetop Village is considered GREEN, while Raging Ravine and Kessig Wolf Run are both considered red/green (Gruul) GUILD.
* Lands that produce only one color of mana were also categorized as that color. Anything that produces more colors is to be voted here. So Tolarian Academy is a BLUE card, but Vivid Creek is voted on here as a LAND card, just like any 'dual land' that doesn't fall in the above rule about cost.
* Remember that the draft-referencing Conspiracy land Paliano, the High City can be voted for here, but the silver-bordered lands City of Ass, R&D's Secret Lair and Mishra’s Toy Workshop cannot.
Voting on Similar Cards
- While I recognize that many cubes prefer to mix and match cycles based on what is most desirable for a given guild, the voting here is by cycle. E.G. the Fastlands (Copperline Gorge and company) are 1 entry on your list.
- Using cycle names would be a big help to me so I don't have to spend extra time identifying the cycle you reference with a single card while compiling. Known cycles include:
* ABU Duals Lands (Tundra, Scrubland...)
* ONS/ZEN Fetch Lands (Polluted Delta, Scalding Tarn...)
* RAV Shock Lands (Temple Garden, Sacred Foundry...),
* M10/ISD Check Lands (Glacial Fortress, Woodland Cemetery...)
* ICE/AP Pain Lands (Karplusan Forest, Battlefield Forge...)
* MR Slow Fetches (Rocky Tar Pit...)
* RAV Bounce Lands (Dimir Aqueduct, Izzet Boilerworks...)
* SHM Filter Lands (Graven Cairns, Flooded Grove...)
* SOM/KLD Fast Lands (Copperline Gorge...)
* THS/M20 Scry Lands (Temple of Deceit, Temple of Mystery...)
* ALA/KTK Tri-Lands (Seaside Citadel, Mystic Monastery...)
* LRW Vivid Lands (Vivid Meadow...)
* BFZ Tango Lands (Prairie Stream, etc.)
* FUT/MHZ Horizon Lands
* Urzatron Lands
* Manlands (Stirring Wildwood, etc.)
If I'm missing any let me know....
* Evolving Wilds = Terramorphic Expanse (You cannot vote on Fabled Passage as it is newer then M20. You may vote on Prismatic Vista though. )
* City of Brass does not equal Mana Confluence.
Let me know if you have any questions! 2016 Results for Reference
Voting for lands is now OPEN!
1. Prismatic Vista
2. Grand Coliseum
3. Mana Confluence
4. ONS/ZEN Fetches
5. Ancient Tomb
6. City of Brass
7. ABUR Duals
8. Strip Mine
9. Ash Barrens
10.Maze of Ith
11. RAV Shock Lands
12. Evolving Wilds
13. Mishra's Factory
14. Wasteland
15. Manlands
16. Karn's Bastion
17. Mutavault
18. Rishadan Port
19. Blast Zone
20. Aether Hub
-
View User Profile
-
View Posts
-
Send Message
Staff01. Library of Alexandria
02. Mana Confluence
03. City of Brass
04. ONS / ZEN Fetches
05. ABU Duals
06. Prismatic Vista
07. Strip Mine
08. Wasteland
09. RAV Shock Lands
10. Mishra's Factory
11. Mutavault
12. Ash Barrens
13. FUT / MH1 Horizon Lands
14. Allied / Enemy Manlands
15. Grand Coliseum
16. Rishadan Port
17. Terramorphic Expanse / Evolving Wilds
18. Maze of Ith
19. Blast Zone
20. ICE / AP Pain Lands
My High Octane Unpowered Cube on CubeCobra
01 Library of Alexandria
02 Strip Mine
03 Prismatic Vista
04 Mana Confluence
05 City of Brass
06 ONS/ZEN Fetch Lands
07 Wasteland
08 Ancient Tomb
09 ABU Dual Lands
10 Mishra's Factory
11 Ash Barrens
12 Mutavault
13 RAV Shock Lands
14 FUT/MH1 Horizon Lands
15 Maze of Ith
16 Rishadan Port
17 WWK/BFZ Manlands
18 Gemstone Mine
19 Grand Coliseum
20 Evolving Wilds/Terramorphic Expanse
My 630 Card Powered Cube
My Article - "Cube Design Philosophy"
My Article - "Mana Short: A study in limited resource management."
My 50th Set (P)review - Discusses my top 20 Cube cards from OTJ!
Edit: I have included manlands as an eligible vote. Please note that these are voted on as a cycle (meaning 1 slot only) just like the others. I know many people break them up and only run some, but we didn't discuss changing are voting process for lands from previous years in the main project thread so this is how we are proceeding.
01 Strip Mine
02 ONS/ZEN Fetch Lands
03 Prismatic Vista
04 Library of Alexandria
05 Wasteland
06 Ancient Tomb
07 ABU Dual Lands
08 Mana Confluence
09 City of Brass
10 Mishra's Factory
11 Ash Barrens
12 Mutavault
13 RAV Shock Lands
14 FUT/MH1 Horizon Lands
15 Maze of Ith
16 Rishadan Port
17 WWK/BFZ Manlands
18 Evolving Wilds/Terramorphic Expanse
19 Gemstone Mine
20 Grand Coliseum
01 Library of Alexandria
02 ONS/ZEN Fetch Lands
03 ABU Dual Lands
04 Prismatic Vista
05 Mana Confluence
06 City of Brass
07 RAV Shock Lands
08 Ancient Tomb
09 Mishra's Factory
10 Mutavault
11 Ash Barrens
12 FUT/MH1 Horizon Lands
13 Strip Mine
14 Rishadan Port
15 Maze of Ith
16 Wasteland
17 WWK/BFZ Man Lands
18 Grand Coliseum
19 Gemstone Mine
20 Terramorphic Expanse (Evolving Wilds)
MTGS Average Peasant Cube 2023 Edition
Follow me. I tweet.
The 10-card guild manlands that both fix mana and turn into creatures. The WWK cycle and the newer enemy versions.
My 630 Card Powered Cube
My Article - "Cube Design Philosophy"
My Article - "Mana Short: A study in limited resource management."
My 50th Set (P)review - Discusses my top 20 Cube cards from OTJ!
2. Strip Mine
3. ABU Duals
4. Fetches
5. Shocks
6. Prismatic Vista
7. Mana Confluence
8. City of Brass
9. Ancient Tomb
10. Maze of Ith
11. Mishra's Factory
12. Horizon Lands
13. Ash Barrens
14. Mutavault
15. Wasteland
16. Blast Zone
17. Manlands
18. Evolving Wilds / Terramorphic Expanse
19. Fast Lands
20. Pain Lands
The list on cube cobra
Read my blog on cube - Latest post June 2nd 2022
2. Strip Mine
3. ONS/ZEN Fetches
4. ABU Duals
5. Prismatic Vista
6. Mana Confluence
7. City of Brass
8. Wasteland
9. RAV Shocklands
10. Ancient Tomb
11. Mishra's Factory
12. Horizon Lands
13. Maze of Ith
14. Rishadan Port
15. Mutavault
16. Ash Barrens
17. WWK/BFZ Manlands
18. Gemstone Mine
19. Grand Coliseum
20. Evolving Wilds/Terramorphic Expanse
Cheers,
rant
My Cube
CubeCobra: https://cubecobra.com/cube/overview/5f5d0310ed602310515d4c32
Cube Tutor: http://cubetutor.com/viewcube/1963
1. ABUR duals
2. ONS/ZEN Fetches
3. Horizon Lands
4. RAV shocks
5. Strip Mine
6. Library of Alexandria
7. Ancient Tomb
8. Prismatic Vista
9. M10/ISD Check Lands
10. WWK/BFZ manlands
11. Mishra's Factory
12. Mutavault
13. City of Brass
14. Mana Confluence
15. ICE/AP Pain Lands
16. SHM Filter Lands
17. SOM/KLD Fast Lands
18. ALA/KTK Tri-Lands
19. Ash Barrens
20. Terramorphic Expanse
[180 classic cube]
1. Library of Alexandria
2. Strip Mine
3. Prismatic Vista
4. Mana Confluence
5. City of Brass
6. Wasteland
7. ONS/ZEN Fetch
8. Grand Colosseum
9. Ash Barrens
10. Evolving Wilds/Terramorphic Expanse
11. ABU Dual Lands
12. RAV Shock Lands
13. Ancient Tomb
14. Mishra's Factory
15. FUT/MHZ Horizon Lands
16. City of Traitors
17. Rishadan Port
18. WWK/BFZ manlands
19. ICE/AP Pain Lands
20. Mutavault
2) Strip Mine
3) City of Brass
4) Prismatic Vista
5) Ancient Tomb
6) Wasteland
7) Library of Alexandria
8) Fetchlands
9) ABU Dual Lands
10) Horizon Lands
11) Grand Coliseum
12) Mishra's Factory
13) Mutavault
14) Manlands
15) Rishadan Port
16) Shocklands
17) Ash Barrens
18) Maze of Ith
19) Gemstone Mine
20) Painlands
Voting is now closed!