Lore Seeker, Agent of Acquisitions and other cards from Conspiracy which are not actual conspiracies should be voted on in their respective cmc sections. (I.E. if you play with Lore Seeker, include him in your vote here).
Voters do not need to vote for 10 total cards for each category.
If you can't think of enough blue creatures (for example), you don't have to add more cards to your list you're not sure of.
You may choose to opt out of voting for 10 total cards for whatever reason.
Functionally identical cards do not take up multiple spots on the Top 10.
I'll accept differences between anything where it could matter. Elite Vanguard works with Champion of the Parish, Xanthrid Necromancer, etc -- so ranking Savannah Lions lower than the human 2/1 is acceptable. Elvish Mystic and Llanowar Elves, however, should be combined into one vote, as they are functionally identical.
Votes are done from a CUBE MANAGEMENT perspective.
Order cards based on their importance to your cube environment.
You may include cards that are not currently in your cube. It shouldn't make much of a difference one way or the other.
You can edit your list as many times as you like until tallies are taken.
PLEASE NOTE THE TEMPLATE HAS SLIGHTLY CHANGED. Please write the card name to the left of = # points (this speeds up compiling data by over 100%, since I'll be able to alphabetically sort cards together).
This thread will be tallied on MONDAY, Jan 19th.
You can edit or submit your list any time before Monday @ 7pm EST (UTC-5). Originally I was going to have the voting blocked up into two votes per week.
I think voting on both creatures and spells on a single thread once a week works a bit better.
It still feels a bit weird to have Porcelain Legionnaire as colorless but Spellskite as blue, but as you wish
Hey willdice! Yeah, I think most people were really set on having Spellskite as a blue card, which I can understand. I think Legionnaire is definitely a colorless card, but hey, a few things that someone somewhere is gonna disagree with no matter what.
Thanks for your votes, everything looks great! Except for one thing: I actually changed the template in the "information for voters section." It will help me speed up vote counting if the names of the cards are first instead of the numbers.
(I put the new template back in the OP.)
It'd really help me out if you could adjust your post to the new template. Thanks in advance if you help make my life a little easier.
---------
Also, everyone else: Lore Seeker and other draft-altering constructs are fine to vote on in this poll. The actual conspiracies and silver boardered cards will be voted on much later. I'll put this in the OP.
Also, everyone else: Lore Seeker and other draft-alteringconspiracies are fine to vote on in this poll. The actual conspiracies and silver boardered cards will be voted on much later. I'll put this in the OP.
Just to clarify, you mean "draft-altering constructs", right?
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
465 card Unpowered cube thread. Draft it here and I'll be happy to return the favor.
450 card Peasant cube thread. Draft it here.
Also, everyone else: Lore Seeker and other draft-alteringconspiracies are fine to vote on in this poll. The actual conspiracies and silver boardered cards will be voted on much later. I'll put this in the OP.
Just to clarify, you mean "draft-altering constructs", right?
Oops. Yeah. Constructs.
I'm gonna start a discussion on Cogwork Librarian and any other issues we might have soon.
My list. I've been putting it off because I haven't wanted to influence voting too much since it's my project. Maybe I'll vote first next time and see if it encourages more people to vote. Maybe everyone is saving up for a flurry of posts on Monday.
WHITE
Stoneforge Mystic = 10 points.
Thalia, Guardian of Thraben = 9 points.
Imposing Sovereign = 8 points.
Wall of Omens= 7 points.
Kor Skyfisher= 6 points.
Soltari Trooper= 5 points.
Seeker of the Way = 4 points.
Accorder Paladin = 3 points.
Cloistered Youth = 2 points.
Lone Missionary = 1 point.
I didn't realize Unexpectedly Absent was being voted on in this section. The same for Everflowing Chalice. Also, wtwlf, you didn't rank Shrine of Burning Rage at all. Is that a miss or do you really just not think it's that good?
I didn't realize Unexpectedly Absent was being voted on in this section. The same for Everflowing Chalice.
Both are classed as Xcmc spells according to the rules, so they should be voted on a later thread. But there's also this: "If you want to vote on a card in multiple places, you can. That means if you think Capsize is a 3cmc card as opposed to a 6cmc card, you may vote for it in the 3cmc section. You can also vote for it in both places." So, if people want to vote on them as 2cmc spells, they can.
I didn't realize Unexpectedly Absent was being voted on in this section. The same for Everflowing Chalice. Also, wtwlf, you didn't rank Shrine of Burning Rage at all. Is that a miss or do you really just not think it's that good?
If he wants to ignore the votes he can. I just voted on the best cards for the slots.
And I only included cards I cube with, so the answer to Shrine is ...both, I guess.
Yeah, I think classification is a tricky issue, and that little sentence about being able to vote for whatever you want solves a lot of problems, since if we miss something and a ton of people want to vote for a card a certain way, they can.
Ah, ok. Well that clears it up, then. I guess I missed that bit in the rules. Thanks again for running this thing, Colby. I know it has to be a ton of work.
It's not that bad, haha. I'm actually going to allow voting to continue until tomorrow at 7pm, just so if anyone wants to get in some extra votes, they can. I'm actually swamped at the moment too.
I'll make an exception for LucidVision and get his votes in here, it's gonna take me a bit to recalc things. No more submissions after this point though.
Spellskite (counts as a BLUE creature)
Ninja of the Deep Hours
Riftwing Cloudskate
Porcelain Legionnaire (counts as a COLORLESS creature)
Mortarpod (counts as a colorless CREATURE)
Lore Seeker, Agent of Acquisitions and other cards from Conspiracy which are not actual conspiracies should be voted on in their respective cmc sections. (I.E. if you play with Lore Seeker, include him in your vote here).
Notable cards which are classified as 2 cmc SPELLS:
Eternal Dragon
Bitterblossom
Shrine of Burning Rage (counts as a RED spell)
Pyrewild Shaman
Fire//Ice (counts as a MULTICOLORED spell)
Signets (such as Azorius Signet) (count as a COLORLESS spell, please only use one spot for signets)
If you can't think of enough blue creatures (for example), you don't have to add more cards to your list you're not sure of.
You may choose to opt out of voting for 10 total cards for whatever reason.
Functionally identical cards do not take up multiple spots on the Top 10.
I'll accept differences between anything where it could matter.
Elite Vanguard works with Champion of the Parish, Xanthrid Necromancer, etc -- so ranking Savannah Lions lower than the human 2/1 is acceptable.
Elvish Mystic and Llanowar Elves, however, should be combined into one vote, as they are functionally identical.
Votes are done from a CUBE MANAGEMENT perspective.
Order cards based on their importance to your cube environment.
You may include cards that are not currently in your cube. It shouldn't make much of a difference one way or the other.
You can edit your list as many times as you like until tallies are taken.
PLEASE NOTE THE TEMPLATE HAS SLIGHTLY CHANGED.
Please write the card name to the left of = # points (this speeds up compiling data by over 100%, since I'll be able to alphabetically sort cards together).
Ancestral Recall = 10 points.
Mystical Tutor = 9 points.
Ponder = 8 points.
Preordain = 7 points.
Brainstorm = 6 points.
Force Spike = 5 points.
Ancestral Vision = 4 points.
Personal Tutor = 3 points.
Serum Visions = 2 points.
Vapor Snag = 1 point.
White:
= 10 points.
= 9 points.
= 8 points.
= 7 points.
= 6 points.
= 5 points.
= 4 points.
= 3 points.
= 2 points.
= 1 point.
Blue:
= 10 points.
= 9 points.
= 8 points.
= 7 points.
= 6 points.
= 5 points.
= 4 points.
= 3 points.
= 2 points.
= 1 point.
Black:
= 10 points.
= 9 points.
= 8 points.
= 7 points.
= 6 points.
= 5 points.
= 4 points.
= 3 points.
= 2 points.
= 1 point.
Red:
= 10 points.
= 9 points.
= 8 points.
= 7 points.
= 6 points.
= 5 points.
= 4 points.
= 3 points.
= 2 points.
= 1 point.
Green:
= 10 points.
= 9 points.
= 8 points.
= 7 points.
= 6 points.
= 5 points.
= 4 points.
= 3 points.
= 2 points.
= 1 point.
Multicolored:
= 10 points.
= 9 points.
= 8 points.
= 7 points.
= 6 points.
= 5 points.
= 4 points.
= 3 points.
= 2 points.
= 1 point.
Colorless
= 10 points.
= 9 points.
= 8 points.
= 7 points.
= 6 points.
= 5 points.
= 4 points.
= 3 points.
= 2 points.
= 1 point.
White:
= 10 points.
= 9 points.
= 8 points.
= 7 points.
= 6 points.
= 5 points.
= 4 points.
= 3 points.
= 2 points.
= 1 point.
Blue:
= 10 points.
= 9 points.
= 8 points.
= 7 points.
= 6 points.
= 5 points.
= 4 points.
= 3 points.
= 2 points.
= 1 point.
Black:
= 10 points.
= 9 points.
= 8 points.
= 7 points.
= 6 points.
= 5 points.
= 4 points.
= 3 points.
= 2 points.
= 1 point.
Red:
= 10 points.
= 9 points.
= 8 points.
= 7 points.
= 6 points.
= 5 points.
= 4 points.
= 3 points.
= 2 points.
= 1 point.
Green:
= 10 points.
= 9 points.
= 8 points.
= 7 points.
= 6 points.
= 5 points.
= 4 points.
= 3 points.
= 2 points.
= 1 point.
Multicolored:
= 10 points.
= 9 points.
= 8 points.
= 7 points.
= 6 points.
= 5 points.
= 4 points.
= 3 points.
= 2 points.
= 1 point.
Colorless
= 10 points.
= 9 points.
= 8 points.
= 7 points.
= 6 points.
= 5 points.
= 4 points.
= 3 points.
= 2 points.
= 1 point.
You can edit or submit your list any time before Monday @ 7pm EST (UTC-5).
Originally I was going to have the voting blocked up into two votes per week.
I think voting on both creatures and spells on a single thread once a week works a bit better.
CUBE TOP 10 - Help us vote for the best cards in cube
WHITE
Stoneforge Mystic = 10 points.
Thalia, Guardian of Thraben = 9 points.
Wall of Omens = 8 points.
Accorder Paladin = 7 points.
Imposing Sovereign = 6 points.
Soltari Trooper = 5 points.
Kor Skyfisher = 4 points.
Lone Missionary = 3 points.
Precinct Captain = 2 points.
Knight of Meadowgrain = 1 point.
BLUE
Snapcaster Mage = 10 points.
Phantasmal Image = 9 points.
Looter il-Kor = 8 points.
Waterfront Bouncer = 7 points.
Spellskite = 6 points.
Gilded Drake = 5 points.
Omenspeaker = 4 points.
Ninja of the Deep Hours = 3 points.
Mindshrieker = 2 points.
Thought Courier = 1 point.
BLACK
Dark Confidant = 10 points.
Pack Rat = 9 points.
Oona's Prowler = 8 points.
Dauthi Horror = 7 points.
Nezumi Graverobber = 6 points.
Reassembling Skeleton = 5 points.
Bloodghast = 4 points.
Vampire Hexmage = 3 points.
Mardu Skullhunter = 2 points.
Blood Artist = 1 point.
RED
Young Pyromancer = 10 points.
Stormblood Berserker = 9 points.
War-Name Aspirant = 8 points.
Keldon Marauders = 7 points.
Plated Geopede = 6 points.
Borderland Marauder = 5 points.
Hellspark Elemental = 4 points.
Lightning Mauler = 3 points.
Ash Zealot = 2 points.
Torch Fiend/Reckless Reveler = 1 point.
GREEN
Lotus Cobra = 10 points.
Fauna Shaman = 9 points.
Scavenging Ooze = 8 points.
Tarmogoyf = 7 points.
Sakura-Tribe Elder = 6 points.
Sylvan Caryatid = 5 points.
Rofellos, Llanowar Emissary = 4 points.
Wall of Roots = 3 points.
Wall of Blossoms = 2 points.
Wild Mongrel = 1 point.
MULTICOLORED
Baleful Strix = 10 points.
Lotleth Troll = 9 points.
Qasali Pridemage = 8 points.
Spike Jester = 7 points.
Voice of Resurgence = 6 points.
Coiling Oracle = 5 points.
Putrid Leech = 4 points.
Tidehollow Sculler = 3 points.
Fleecemane Lion = 2 points.
Burning-Tree Emissary = 1 point.
COLORLESS
Phyrexian Revoker = 10 points.
Porcelain Legionnaire = 9 points.
Lore Seeker = 8 points.
Perilous Myr = 7 points.
Epochrasite = 6 points.
Agent of Acquisitions = 5 points.
Mortarpod = 4 points.
Arcbound Ravager = 3 points.
Mana Myrs (Silver Myr, etc) = 2 points.
Steel Overseer = 1 point.
WHITE
Balance = 10 points.
Disenchant = 9 points.
Journey to Nowhere = 8 points.
Seal of Cleansing = 7 points.
Temporal Isolation = 6 points.
Eternal Dragon = 5 points.
Revoke Existence = 4 points.
Honor of the Pure = 3 points.
Pacifism = 2 points.
Otherworldly Journey = 1 point.
BLUE
Time Walk = 10 points.
Mana Drain = 9 points.
Remand = 8 points.
Mana Leak = 7 points.
Impulse = 6 points.
Counterspell = 5 points.
Cyclonic Rift = 4 points.
Memory Lapse = 3 points.
Miscalculation = 2 points.
Into the Roil = 1 point.
BLACK
Bitterblossom = 10 points.
Demonic Tutor = 9 points.
Animate Dead = 8 points.
Hymn to Tourach = 7 points.
Chainer's Edict = 6 points.
Smallpox = 5 points.
Diabolic Edict = 4 points.
Go for the Throat = 3 points.
Dance of the Dead = 2 points.
Exhume = 1 point.
RED
Magma Jet = 10 points.
Arc Trail = 9 points.
Incinerate = 8 points.
Shrine of Burning Rage = 7 points.
Smash to Smithereens = 6 points.
Goblin Bombardment = 5 points.
Mizzium Mortars = 4 points.
Lightning Strike/Searing Spear = 3 points.
Pyrewild Shaman = 2 points.
Tormenting Voice = 1 point.
GREEN
Survival of the Fittest = 10 points.
Sylvan Library = 9 points.
Regrowth = 8 points.
Life from the Loam = 7 points.
Channel = 6 points.
Farseek = 5 points.
Explore = 4 points.
Edge of Autumn = 3 points.
Nostalgic Dreams = 2 points.
Deglamer/Unravel the Æther = 1 point.
MULTICOLORED
Dreadbore = 10 points.
Izzet Charm = 9 points.
Boros Charm = 8 points.
Abrupt Decay = 7 points.
Fire // Ice = 6 points.
Lightning Helix = 5 points.
Terminate = 4 points.
Sundering Growth = 3 points.
Simic Charm = 2 points.
Ancient Grudge = 1 point.
COLORLESS
Umezawa's Jitte = 10 points.
Grim Monolith = 9 points.
Mind Stone = 8 points.
Scroll Rack = 7 points.
Winter Orb = 6 points.
Coldsteel Heart = 5 points.
Ankh of Mishra = 4 points.
Signets = 3 points.
Lightning Greaves = 2 points.
Ratchet Bomb = 1 point.
Hey willdice! Yeah, I think most people were really set on having Spellskite as a blue card, which I can understand. I think Legionnaire is definitely a colorless card, but hey, a few things that someone somewhere is gonna disagree with no matter what.
Thanks for your votes, everything looks great! Except for one thing: I actually changed the template in the "information for voters section." It will help me speed up vote counting if the names of the cards are first instead of the numbers.
(I put the new template back in the OP.)
It'd really help me out if you could adjust your post to the new template. Thanks in advance if you help make my life a little easier.
---------
Also, everyone else: Lore Seeker and other draft-altering constructs are fine to vote on in this poll. The actual conspiracies and silver boardered cards will be voted on much later. I'll put this in the OP.
EDIT: Whoops, wrong noun.
CUBE TOP 10 - Help us vote for the best cards in cube
Just to clarify, you mean "draft-altering constructs", right?
450 card Peasant cube thread. Draft it here.
Oops. Yeah. Constructs.
I'm gonna start a discussion on Cogwork Librarian and any other issues we might have soon.
Thank you so much.
CUBE TOP 10 - Help us vote for the best cards in cube
2 CMC CREATURES:
White:
Stoneforge Mystic = 10 points.
Thalia, Guardian of Thraben = 9 points.
Soltari Trooper = 8 points.
Wall of Omens = 7 points.
Accorder paladin = 6 points.
Soltari Priest = 5 points.
Kor Skyfisher = 4 points.
Imposing Sovereign = 3 points.
Knight of Glory = 2 points.
War Priest of Thune = 1 point.
Blue:
Snapcaster Mage = 10 points.
Phantasmal Image = 9 points.
Spellskite = 8 points.
Looter il-Kor = 7 points.
Gilded Drake = 6 points.
Ninja of the Deep Hours = 5 points.
Merfolk Looter = 4 points.
Omenspeaker = 3 points.
Black:
Dark Confidant = 10 points.
Pack Rat = 9 points.
Dauthi Horror= 8 points.
Bloodghast= 7 points.
Nezumi Graverobber = 6 points.
Reassembling Skeleton = 5 points.
Mardu Skullhunter = 4 points.
Vampire Hexmage = 3 points.
Red:
Young Pyromancer = 10 points.
War-Name Aspirant = 9 points.
Stormblood Berserker = 8 points.
Plated Geopede = 7 points.
Ash Zealot = 6 points.
Keldon Marauders = 5 points.
Borderland Marauder = 4 points.
Hellspark Elemental = 3 points.
Torch Fiend = 2 points.
Hellspark Elemental = 1 point.
Green:
Lotus Cobra = 10 points.
Scavenging Ooze = 9 points.
Rofellos, Llanowar Emissary = 8 points.
Tarmogoyf = 7 points.
Fauna Shaman = 6 points.
Sylvan Caryatid = 5 points.
Wall of Blossoms = 4 points.
Wild Mongrel = 3 points.
Sakura-Tribe Elder = 2 points.
Wall of Roots = 1 point.
Multicolored:
Baleful Strix= 10 points.
Qasali Pridemage = 9 points.
Lotleth Troll = 8 points.
Tidehollow Sculler = 7 points.
Spike Jester = 6 points.
Fleecemane Lion = 5 points.
Coiling Oracle = 4 points.
Putrid Leech = 3 points.
Burning-Tree Emissary = 2 points.
Azorius Guildmage = 1 point.
Colorless
Phyrexian Revoker = 10 points.
Porcelain Legionnaire = 9 points.
Lore Seeker = 8 points.
Epochrasite = 7 points.
Agent of Acquisitions = 6 points.
Noncreature Spells:
White:
Balance = 10 points.
Journey to Nowhere = 9 points.
Pacifism = 8 points.
Disenchant = 7 points.
Eternal Dragon = 6 points.
Seal of Cleansing = 5 points.
Temporal Isolation = 4 points.
Bonds of Faith = 3 points.
Honor of the Pure = 2 points.
Otherworldly Journey = 1 point.
Blue:
Time Walk = 10 points.
Mana Drain = 9 points.
Mana Leak = 8 points.
Remand = 7 points.
Counterspell = 6 points.
Cyclonic Rift = 5 points.
Arcane Denial = 4 points.
Miscalculation = 3 points.
Compulsion = 2 points.
Memory Lapse = 1 point.
Black:
Bitteblossom = 10 points.
Demonic Tutor = 9 points.
Hymn to Tourach = 8 points.
Animate Dead = 7 points.
Chainer's Edict = 6 points.
Go For the Throat = 5 points.
Smallpox = 4 points.
Diabolic Edict = 3 points.
Exhume = 2 points.
Night's Whisper = 1 point.
Red:
Incinerate = 10 points.
Magma Jet = 9 points.
Arc Trail = 8 points.
Shrine of Burning Rage = 7 points.
Mizzium Mortars = 6 points.
Lightning Strike/Searing Spear = 5 points.
Searing Blaze = 4 points.
Volcanic Hammer = 3 points.
Green:
Survival of the Fittest= 10 points.
Sylvan Library = 9 points.
Regrowth = 8 points.
Channel = 7 points.
Life from the Loam = 6 points.
[c]Explore[/c = 5 points.
Farseek = 4 points.
Rampant Growth = 3 points.
Seal of Primordium= 2 points.
Multicolored:
Dreadbore = 10 points.
Abrupt Decay = 9 points.
Fire // Ice = 8 points.
Lightning Helix = 7 points.
Boros Charm = 6 points.
Terminate = 5 points.
Izzet Charm = 4 points.
Agony Warp = 3 points.
Colorless
Umezawa's Jitte = 10 points.
Grim Monolith = 9 points.
Defense Grid = 8 points.
Winter Orb = 7 points.
Ankh of Mishra = 6 points.
Mind Stone = 5 points.
Scroll Rack = 4 points.
Ratchet Bomb = 3 points.
Thorn of Amethyst = 2 points.
Lightning Greaves = 1 points
My Eternal Cube on CubeTutor| |My Reject Rare Cube on CubeTutor| |My Peasant Cube on CubeTutor
I used to write for MTGS, including Cranial Insertion and cube articles. Good on you if you can find those after the upgrade.
My 630 Card Powered Cube
My Article - "Cube Design Philosophy"
My Article - "Mana Short: A study in limited resource management."
My 49th Set (P)review - Discusses my top 20 Cube cards from MKM!
My Eternal Cube on CubeTutor| |My Reject Rare Cube on CubeTutor| |My Peasant Cube on CubeTutor
I used to write for MTGS, including Cranial Insertion and cube articles. Good on you if you can find those after the upgrade.
Stoneforge Mystic = 10 points.
Thalia, Guardian of Thraben = 9 points.
Imposing Sovereign = 8 points.
Wall of Omens= 7 points.
Kor Skyfisher= 6 points.
Soltari Trooper= 5 points.
Seeker of the Way = 4 points.
Accorder Paladin = 3 points.
Cloistered Youth = 2 points.
Lone Missionary = 1 point.
BLUE
Snapcaster Mage = 10 points.
Phantasmal Image = 9 points.
Looter il-Kor = 8 points.
Spellskite = 7 points.
Waterfront Bouncer = 6 points.
Gilded Drake = 5 points.
Riftwing Cloudskate = 4 points.
Omenspeaker = 3 points.
Ninja of the Deep Hours = 2 points.
Coralhelm Commander = 1 point.
BLACK
Dark Confidant = 10 points.
Pack Rat = 9 points.
Bloodghast = 8 points.
Reassembling Skeleton = 7 points.
Dauthi Horror = 6 points.
Oona's Prowler = 5 points.
Nezumi Graverobber = 4 points.
Vampire Hexmage = 3 points.
Blood Scrivener = 2 points.
Mardu Skullhunter = 1 point.
RED
Young Pyromancer = 10 points.
Stormblood Berserker = 9 points.
Plated Geopede = 8 points.
Generator Servant = 7 points.
Keldon Marauders = 6 points.
Hellspark Elemental = 5 points.
Ash Zealot = 4 points.
Lightning Mauler = 3 points.
Eidolon of the Great Revel = 2 point.
Kargan Dragonlord = 1 point.
GREEN
Fauna Shaman = 10 points.
Lotus Cobra = 9 points.
Rofellos, Llanowar Emissary = 8 points.
Scavenging Ooze = 7 points.
Wild Mongrel = 6 points.
Wall of Blossoms = 5 points.
Wall of Roots = 4 points.
Sakura-Tribe Elder = 3 points.
Tarmogoyf = 2 points.
Sylvan Caryatid = 1 points.
MULTICOLORED
Nightscape Familiar = 10 points.
Goblin Electromancer = 9 points.
Baleful Strix = 8 points.
Qasali Pridemage = 7 points.
Voice of Resurgence = 6 points.
Lotleth Troll = 5 points.
Tidehollow Sculler = 4 points.
Spike Jester = 3 points.
Putrid Leech = 2 points.
Kiora’s Follower = 1 points.
COLORLESS
Porcelain Legionnaire = 10 points.
Lore Seeker = 9 points.
Phyrexian Revoker = 8 points.
Perilous Myr = 7 points.
Agent of Acquisitions = 6 points.
Epochrasite = 5 points.
Arcbound Ravager = 4 points.
Steel Overseer = 3 point.
Mortarpod = 2 points.
Balance = 10 points.
Disenchant = 9 points.
Journey to Nowhere = 8 points.
Seal of Cleansing = 7 points.
Temporal Isolation = 6 points.
Eternal Dragon = 5 points.
Revoke Existence = 4 points.
Abeyance = 3 point.
Pacifism = 2 points.
Honor of the Pure = 1 points.
BLUE
Time Walk = 10 points.
Mana Drain = 9 points.
Counterspell = 8 points.
Remand = 7 points.
Miscalculation = 6 points.
Mana Leak = 5 points.
Impulse = 4 points.
Brain Freeze = 3 points.
Memory Lapse = 2 points.
Snap = 1 point.
BLACK
Demonic Tutor = 10 points.
Cabal Ritual = 9 points.
Bitterblossom = 8 points.
Animate Dead = 7 points.
Hymn to Tourach = 6 points.
Diabolic Edict = 5 points.
Exhume = 4 points.
Dance of the Dead = 3 points.
Sinkhole = 2 points.
Night’s Whisper – 1 point.
RED
Magma Jet = 10 points.
Arc Trail = 9 points.
Incinerate = 8 points.
Lightning Strike/Searing Spear = 7 points.
Grapeshot = 6 points.
Shrine of Burning Rage = 5 points.
Recoup = 4 points.
Pyroclasm = 3 points.
Desperate Ritual = 2 points.
Mizzium Mortars – 1 point.
GREEN
Survival of the Fittest = 10 points.
Channel = 9 points.
Oath of Druids = 8 points.
Regrowth = 7 points.
Sylvan Library = 6 points.
Farseek = 5 points.
Explore = 4 points.
Life from the Loam = 3 points.
Moment’s Peace = 2 points.
Nostalgic Dreams = 1 point.
MULTICOLORED
Dreadbore = 10 points.
Izzet Charm = 9 points.
Lim-Dul’s Vault = 8 points.
Manamorphose = 7 points.
Fire // Ice = 6 points.
Lightning Helix = 5 points.
Abrupt Decay = 4 points.
Boros Charm = 3 points.
Squandered Resources = 2 points.
Ancient Grudge = 1 point.
COLORLESS
Umezawa’s Jitte = 10 points.
Grim Monolith = 9 points.
Time Vault = 8 points.
Mind Stone = 7 points.
Winter Orb = 6 points.
Ankh of Mishra = 5 points.
Helm of Awakening = 4 points.
Isochron Scepter = 3 points.
Scroll Rack = 2 points.
Ratchet Bomb = 1 point.
CUBE TOP 10 - Help us vote for the best cards in cube
You also got Lore Seeker listed twice.
My Eternal Cube on CubeTutor| |My Reject Rare Cube on CubeTutor| |My Peasant Cube on CubeTutor
I used to write for MTGS, including Cranial Insertion and cube articles. Good on you if you can find those after the upgrade.
Here are my votes.
White:
Stoneforge Mystic = 10 points.
Imposing Sovereign = 9 points.
Thalia, Guardian of Thraben = 8 points.
Kor Skyfisher = 7 points.
Wall of Omens = 6 points.
Accorder Paladin = 5 points.
Soltari Trooper = 4 points.
Leonin Relic-Warder = 3 points.
Precinct Captain = 2 points.
Cloistered Youth = 1 point.
Blue:
Phantasmal Image = 10 points.
Snapcaster Mage = 9 points.
Spellskite = 8 points.
Looter il-Kor = 7 points.
Waterfront Bouncer = 6 points.
Guilded Drake = 5 points.
Riftwing Cloudskate = 4 points.
Omen Speaker = 3 points.
Merfolk Looter = 2 points.
Ninja of the Deep Hours = 1 point.
Black:
Dark Confidant = 10 points.
Pack Rat = 9 points.
Oona's Prowler = 8 points.
Blood Artist = 7 points.
Bloodghast = 6 points.
Pain Seer = 5 points.
Reassembling Skeleton = 4 points.
Nezumi Graverobber = 3 points.
Vampire Hexmage = 2 points.
Dauthi Horror = 1 point.
Red:
Young Pyromancer = 10 points.
Stormblood Berserker = 9 points.
War-Name Aspirant = 8 points.
Borderland Marauder = 7 points.
Gore-House Chain Walker = 6 points.
Hellspark Elemental = 5 points.
Keldon Marauders = 4 points.
Lightning Mauler = 3 points.
Plated Geopede = 2 points.
Torch Fiend / Reckless Reveler = 1 point.
Green:
Rofellos, Llanowar Emissary = 10 points.
Lotus Cobra = 9 points.
Scavenging Ooze = 8 points.
Tarmogoyf = 7 points.
Wall of Roots = 6 points.
Fauna Shaman = 5 points.
Sylvan Caryatid = 4 points.
Sakura-Tribe Elder = 3 points.
Wall of Blossoms = 2 points.
Wild Mongrel = 1 point.
Colorless
Porcelain Legionnaire = 10 points.
Phyrexian Revoker = 9 points.
Perilous Myr = 8 points.
Epochrasite = 7 points.
White:
Balance = 10 points.
Journey to Nowhere = 9 points.
Disenchant = 8 points.
Eternal Dragon = 7 points.
Shrine of Loyal Legions = 6 points.
Temporal Isolation = 5 points.
Blue:
Time Walk = 10 points.
Mana Drain = 9 points.
Counter Spell = 8 points.
Mana Leak = 7 points.
Miscalculation = 6 points.
Remand = 5 points.
Into the Roil = 4 points.
Arcane Denial = 3 points.
Impulse = 2 points.
Standstill = 1 point.
Black:
Demonic Tutor = 10 points.
Bitterblossom = 9 points.
Hymn to Tourach = 8 points.
Go For the Throat = 7 points.
Animate Dead = 6 points.
Sinkhole = 5 points.
Chainer's Edict = 4 points.
Malicious Affliction = 3 points.
Dance of the Dead = 2 points.
Diabolic Edict = 1 point.
Red:
Shrine of Burning Rage = 10 points.
Arc Trail = 9 points.
Magma Jet = 8 points.
Incinerate = 7 points.
Searing Spear / Lightning Strike = 6 points.
Smash to Smithereens = 5 points.
Searing Blaze = 4 points.
Goblin Bombardment = 3 points.
Madcap Skills = 2 points.
Pyroclasm = 1 points.
Green:
Sylvan Library = 10 points.
Survival of the Fittest = 9 points.
Regrowth = 8 points.
Life From the Loam = 7 points.
Explore = 6 points.
Naturalize = 5 points.
Farseek = 4 points.
Rampant Growth = 3 points.
Seal of Primordium = 2 points.
Colorless
Umezawa's Jitte = 10 points.
Grim Monolith = 9 points.
Winter Orb = 8 points.
Mind Stone = 7 points.
Coldsteel Heart = 6 points.
Ratchet Bomb = 5 points.
Lightning Greaves = 4 points.
Ankh of Mishra = 3 points.
Scroll Rack = 2 points.
Guardian Idol = 1 point.
MTGS Average Peasant Cube 2023 Edition
Follow me. I tweet.
White:
Stoneforge Mystic = 10 points.
Imposing Sovereign = 9 points.
Thalia, Guardian of Thraben = 8 points.
Wall of Omens = 7 points.
Accorder Paladin = 6 points.
Kor Skyfisher = 5 points.
Soltari Trooper = 4 points.
Lone Missionary = 3 points.
Blue:
Snapcaster Mage = 10 points.
Phantasmal Image = 9 points.
Waterfront Bouncer = 8 points.
Looter il-Kor = 7 points.
Spellskite = 6 points.
Black:
Dark Confidant = 10 points.
Pack Rat = 9 points.
Bloodghast = 8 points.
Oona's Prowler = 7 points.
Nezumi Graverobber = 6 points.
Reassembling Skeleton = 5 points.
Red:
Stormblood Berserker = 10 points.
Young Pyromancer = 9 points.
Plated Geopede = 8 points.
Hallspark Elemental = 7 points.
Keldon Marauders = 6 points.
Lightning Mauler = 5 points.
War-Name Aspirant = 4 points.
Borderland Marauder = 3 points.
Green:
Lotus Cobra = 10 points.
Rofellos, Llanowar Emissary = 9 points.
Tarmogoyf = 8 points.
Fauna Shaman = 7 points.
Scavenging Ooze = 6 points.
Sakura-Tribe Elder = 5 points.
Wall of Roots = 4 points.
Wild Mongrel = 3 points.
Sylvan Caryatid = 2 points.
Vinelasher Kudzu = 1 point.
Multicolored:
Baleful Strix = 10 points.
Lotleth Troll = 9 points.
Grenzo, Dungeon Warden = 8 points.
Colorless
Phyrexian Revoker = 10 points.
Porcelain Legionnaire = 9 points.
White:
Balance = 10 points.
Unexpectedly Absent = 9 points.
Disenchant = 8 points.
Eternal Dragon = 7 points.
Seal of Cleansing = 6 points.
Blue:
Time Walk = 10 points.
Mana Drain = 9 points.
Mana Leak = 8 points.
Miscalculation = 7 points.
Counterspell = 6 points.
Remand = 5 points.
Memory Lapse = 4 points.
Arcane Denial = 3 points.
Black:
Demonic Tutor = 10 points.
Bitterblossom = 9 points.
Hymn to Tourach = 8 points.
Animate Dead = 7 points.
Diabolic Edict = 6 points.
Chainer's Edict = 5 points.
Exhume = 4 points.
Dance of the Dead = 3 points.
Smallpox = 2 points.
Red:
Arc Trail = 10 points.
Magma Jet = 9 points.
Smash to Smithereens = 8 points.
Incinerate = 7 points.
Lightning Strike = 6 points.
Searing Spear = 6 points.
Green:
Survival of the Fittest = 10 points.
Sylvan Library = 9 points.
Regrowth = 8 points.
Life From the Loam = 7 points.
Channel = 6 points.
Multicolored:
Boros Charm = 10 points.
Dreadbore = 9 points.
Izzet Charm = 8 points.
Colorless
Umezawa's Jitte = 10 points.
Grim Monolith = 9 points.
Winter Orb = 8 points.
Mind Stone = 7 points.
Scroll Rack = 6 points.
Everflowing Chalice = 5 points.
Coldsteel Heart = 4 points.
My 630 Card Powered Cube
My Article - "Cube Design Philosophy"
My Article - "Mana Short: A study in limited resource management."
My 49th Set (P)review - Discusses my top 20 Cube cards from MKM!
White:
Thalia, Guiardian of Thraben = 10 pts
Stoneforge Mystic = 9 pts
Wall of Omens = 8 pts
Soltari Trooper = 7 pts
Nearheath Pilgrim = 6 pts
Seeker of the Way = 5 pts
Lenonin Relic-Warden = 1 pt
Blue
Magical Hacker = 10 pts
Phantasmal Image = 9 pts
Snapcaster Mage = 8 pts
Spellskite = 7 pts
Black
Pack Rat = 10 pts
Bloodghast = 9 pts
Oona's Prowler = 9 pts
Reassembling Skeleton = 7 pts
Dark Confidant = 6 pts
Blood Artist = 5 pts
Red
Young Pyromancer = 10 pts
Stormblood Berserk = 9 pts
Frazzled Editor = 8 pts
Ash Zealot = 7 pts
Generator Servant = 6 pts
Lightning Mauler = 5 pts
War-Name Aspirant = 4 pts
Green
Rofellos, Llanowar Emissary = 10 pts
Scavenging Ooze = 9 pts
Wild Mongrel = 8 pts
Lotus Cobra = 7 pts
Strangleroot Geist = 6 pts
Wall of Roots = 5 pts
Fauna Shaman = 4 pts
Wall of Blossoms = 3 pts
Sylvan Caryatid =2 pts
Old Fogey = 1 pt
Artifact
Loreseeker = 10 pts
Porcelain Legionnaire = 9 pts
Arcbound Ravager = 8 pts
Steel Overseer = 7 pts
Phyrexian Revoker = 6 pts
Multi
Gaddock Teeg = 10 pts
Lotleth Troll = 9 pts
Qasali Pridgemage = 8 pts
Grenzo, Dungeon Warden = 7 pts
Voice of Resurgence = 6 pts
Fleecemane Lion = 5 pts
White
Balance = 10 pts
Unexpectedly Absent = 9 pts
bunch of pacifisms = 8,7,6.. pts
Blue
Time Walk = 10 pts
Mana Drain = 9 pts
Mana Leak = 8 pts
bunch of counterspells = 7,6,5.. pts
Black
Demonic Tutor = 10 pts
Bitterblossom = 9 pts
Animate Dead = 8 pts
Hymn to Tourach = 7 pts
Exhume = 6 pts
Cabal Ritual = 5 pts
Go for the Throat = 4 pts
Smallpox = 3 pts
Enter the Dungeon = 2 pts
Diabolic Edict = 1 pt
Red
Goblin Bombardment = 10 pts
Arc Trail = 9 pts
Pyroclasm = 8 pts
Shrine of Burning Rage = 7 pts
Magma Jet = 6 pts
Smash to Smithereens = 5 pts
burn spells = 4,3,2.. pts
Green
Oath of Druids = 10 pts
Channel = 9 pts
Survival of the Fittest = 8 pts
Sylvan Library = 7 pts
Regrowth = 6 pts
Life from the Loam = 5 pts
Artifact
Time Vault = 10 pts
Umezawa's Jitte = 9 pts
Chaos Orb = 8 pts
Ratchet Bomb = 7 pts
Grim Monolith = 6 pts
MTGS Average Peasant Cube 2023 Edition
Follow me. I tweet.
Both are classed as Xcmc spells according to the rules, so they should be voted on a later thread. But there's also this: "If you want to vote on a card in multiple places, you can. That means if you think Capsize is a 3cmc card as opposed to a 6cmc card, you may vote for it in the 3cmc section. You can also vote for it in both places." So, if people want to vote on them as 2cmc spells, they can.
If he wants to ignore the votes he can. I just voted on the best cards for the slots.
And I only included cards I cube with, so the answer to Shrine is ...both, I guess.
My 630 Card Powered Cube
My Article - "Cube Design Philosophy"
My Article - "Mana Short: A study in limited resource management."
My 49th Set (P)review - Discusses my top 20 Cube cards from MKM!
CUBE TOP 10 - Help us vote for the best cards in cube
MTGS Average Peasant Cube 2023 Edition
Follow me. I tweet.
CUBE TOP 10 - Help us vote for the best cards in cube
CUBE TOP 10 - Help us vote for the best cards in cube
White:
Stoneforge Mystic = 10 points.
Wall of omens = 9 points.
Containment Priest = 8 points.
Thalia, Guardian of Thraben = 7 points.
Accorder Paladin = 6 points.
Soltari trooper= 5 points.
Soltari monk= 4 points.
Soltari Priest= 3 points.
Imposing Soverign = 2 Points.
Kor Skyfisher = 1 Point
Blue:
Snapcaster Mage = 10 points.
Phantasmal Image = 9 points.
Looter il-Kor = 8 points.
Spellskite = 7 points.
Gilded Drake = 6 points.
Waterfront Bouncer = 5 points.
Voidmage Prodigy = 4 points.
Corralhelm Commander = 3 Points
Black:
Dark Confidant = 10 points.
Pack Rat = 9 points.
Bloodghast = 8 points.
Oona's Prowler = 7 points.
Blood Artist = 6 points.
Nazumi graverobber = 5 points.
Spiteful Returned = 4 points.
Blood scrivner = 3 points.
Reassembling skeleton = 2 points.
Red:
Young Pyromancer = 10 points.
Hellspark Elemental = 9 points.
Keldon Marauders = 8 points.
Stormblood Berzerker = 7 points.
Plated Geopede = 6 points.
Lightning Mauler = 5 points.
War-Name Aspirant = 4 points.
Borderland Marauder = 3 points.
Gorehouse Chainwalker = 2 points.
Green:
Lotus Cobra = 10 points.
Rofellos, Llanowar Emissary = 9 points.
Tarmogoyf = 8 points.
Scavenging Ooze = 7 points.
Sylvan Caryatid = 6 points.
Sakura-Tribe Elder = 5 points.
Wall of Roots = 4 points.
Fauna Shaman = 3 points.
Wild Mongrel = 2 points.
Vinelasher Kudzu = 1 point.
Multicolored:
Baleful Strix = 10 points.
Qasali Pridemage = 9 points.
Voice of Resurgence = 8 points
Grenzo, Dungeon Warden = 7 points.
Fleecemane Lion = 6 points.
Lotleth Troll = 5 points.
Coiling Oracle = 4 points.
Spike Jester = 3 points.
Kiora's Follower = 2 points.
Burning-tree Emissary = 1 point.
Colorless
Phyrexian Revoker = 10 points.
Porcelain Legionnaire = 9 points.
White:
Balance = 10 points.
Unexpectedly Absent = 9 points.
Disenchant = 8 points.
Journey to nowhere = 7 points
Eternal Dragon = 6 points.
Seal of Cleansing = 5 points.
Blue:
Time Walk = 10 points.
Mana Drain = 9 points.
Mana Leak = 8 points.
Miscalculation = 7 points.
Counterspell = 6 points.
Remand = 5 points.
Into the Roil = 4 points.
Cyclonic Rift = 3 points.
Negate = 2 points.
Essence scatter = 1 point.
Black:
Demonic Tutor = 10 points.
Animate Dead = 9 points.
Bitterblossom = 8 points.
Hymn to Tourach = 7 points.
Diabolic Edict = 6 points.
Chainer's Edict = 5 points.
Go for the Throat = 4 points.
Dance of the Dead = 3 points.
Exhume = 2 points.
Smallpox = 1 point.
Red:
Arc Trail = 10 points.
Searing Blaze = 9 points
Magma Jet = 8 points.
Smash to Smithereens = 7 points.
Incinerate = 6 points.
Lightning Strike = 5 points.
Searing Blood = 4 points.
Green:
Survival of the Fittest = 10 points.
Sylvan Library = 9 points.
Regrowth = 8 points.
Channel = 7 points.
Life from the loam = 6 points.
Explore = 5 points.
Farseek = 4 points.
Multicolored:
Boros Charm = 10 points.
Izzet Charm = 9 points.
Dreadbore = 8 points.
Selesnya Charm = 7 points.
Lim-Dul's Vault = 6 points.
Colorless
Umezawa's Jitte = 10 points.
Grim Monolith = 9 points.
Signets = 8 points.
Winter Orb = 7 points.
Mind Stone = 6 points.
Scroll Rack = 5 points.
Coldsteel heart = 4
Everflowing Chalice = 3 points.
Last Updated 02/07/24
Streaming Standard/Cube on Twitch https://www.twitch.tv/heisenb3rg96
Strategy Twitter https://www.twitter.com/heisenb3rg
CUBE TOP 10 - Help us vote for the best cards in cube