Friday night I was playing against G/B devotion I had an Exava,Rakdos Blood Witch with a madcap skills they were at 7 life. He left back a Polukranos and a Sylvan Caryatid for blocking it. Then right in time Gnarled Scarhide rolled off the top, I bestowed it on Polukranos and swung for lethal. What are your thoughts on my new favorite card?
I'm a big fan of the card, but it is so far from OP. Take a look at the biggest decks in standard and you'll see that none of them run it. In fact, the only deck that uses it are black based aggressive ones. The card's strong in its own right and has a lot of utility in bestowing on your creatures and on your opponent's in corner cases, but other than that it's another 'dumb beater'. I like the card a lot, but in order to be on the list of OP it would need a hell of a lot more going for it.
Good job on evaluating a tricky situation and realizing an out. Oh also, nice topdeck.