MTG Salvation

Hello,
I was wondering if anyone can point me to a list of cards that have been unique to Commander decks (the "Tempt with..." series for example) as well as cards that have been reprinted from them (ie. Scavenging Ooze). I'm trying to collect them all, and would like to know if I'm missing any.

Short of going through every card in each set and cross referencing them with what is already out there, I can't seem to find a list of these cards.

If anyone can help me out, that would be great!

Can't you do a Gatherer search for Legacy-only legal cards that are from Commander sets? It won't be perfect, as cards like Brainstorm will pop up, but it should narrow it down.

Hmm, apparently not, since selecting Format: NOT Modern doesn't remove Modern cards from the search.

Honestly, the easiest way to do it is look up each set on Gatherer. It shows you each set each card is printed in just by scrolling through. It's long, but gatherer's advanced search still isn't perfect.

Unless someone knows of another site with better functioning advanced searches. I never try elsewhere.

You can narrow the gatherer search down a bit by selecting the four Commander sets in "Set" using the "or" operator. This gives you a list of the about 900 cards printed in those sets (so 9 pages of 100 cards to look through). The set symbols will then tell you if a card has been printed in other products. (Mind the reprints of other Commander sets!)

Gotcha. Thanks

http://www.lyradf.com/CommanderOnlyCardsAug2016.html

Feel free to leave corrections if any are found. I'm sure it needs some. I wish I could do mouseover image fetches for the cards but my web design skills are WAY out of practice and I'm just not interested enough to dedicate any more time to this list. It serves my needs.

mythicspoilers does a good job at showing a visual for the 2013, 2014 & 2015 exclusive cards, but I don't think they have a page for the original set. I always hope that the ppl that maintain that site continue going further back to complete every set ever, since their quality of formatting is pretty good.

Thanks a lot, both of you! Those both helped immensely. Do you know off-hand if other supplementary products had unique cards? I know about the Portal trilogy, as well as Conspiracy, obviously. But do things like Planechase have unique cards (other than the planes and such), or Archenemy?

There were many exclusive cards that came out in the planechase set, but most of the cards of relivance have already been reprinted in newer sets (baleful strix/shardless agent being the most common in eternal formats, maelstrom wanderer in commander).

Even some random ones like dragonlair spider originated in planechase and has already been reprinted for whomever actually deemed that worthy.

There are a few planechase cards that have never been reprinted; sai of the shinobi, fractured powerstone, krond the dawn-clad, thromok the insatiable, edlerwood scion, indrik umbra + felidar umbra, and preyseizer dragon. There isn't much demand for these. Sakashima's Student although absolutely needs a reprint, and silent-blade oni, while seeing very little play, is really cool and his price is creeping slightly.


Archenemy has zero exclusive cards.

Thanks very much for the information!