Like most, I started my Magic career in green. Crashing big honkin' fatties into your opponent's face is one of the most cathartic experiences in the game! I decided that a decent Nylea deck could help recapture those halcyon days.
This is my oldest EDH deck, and sadly my least-updated. The removal and protection is lacking, and I think I need more threats. Here's the list!
I think you need a lot more ramp because your average cmc is 4.11 which is really high and you don't really have that many good ramp options. I simulated bunch of starting hands and often I only had one ramp spell and bunch of cards that cost +5 mana. If that one ramp spell gets countered it's basically game over. Your deck has basically no interaction and can barely cast one spell a turn when it has 8 mana. Other issue your deck has is that you have bunch creatures with trample which makes your commander's ability a bit redundant.
I would cut most big dump beaters and add more ramp in form of mana dorks (don't go all in dork plan to avoid getting wrathed too hard).
This is my oldest EDH deck, and sadly my least-updated. The removal and protection is lacking, and I think I need more threats. Here's the list!
01 Nylea, God of the Hunt
Creature (37)
02 Acidic Slime
03 Arbor Colossus
04 Archetype of Endurance
05 Conclave Naturalists
06 Courser of Kruphix
07 Dosan the Falling Leaf
08 Garruk's Packleader
09 Genesis Hydra
10 Giant Adephage
11 Gilt-Leaf Seer
12 Heartwood Storyteller
13 Heroes' Bane
14 Kalonian Twingrove
15 Karametra's Acolyte
16 Leatherback Baloth
17 Mistcutter Hydra
18 Nacatl War-Pride
19 Nylea's Disciple
20 Plated Slagwurm
21 Polukranos, World Eater
22 Predator Ooze
23 Primalcrux
24 Primordial Sage
25 Reverent Hunter
26 Sakura-Tribe Elder
27 Scryb Ranger
28 Scute Mob
29 Terastodon
30 Terra Stomper
31 Thunderfoot Baloth
32 Ulvenwald Tracker
33 Vinelasher Kudzu
34 Whisperer of the Wilds
35 Whisperwood Elemental
36 Wolfbriar Elemental
37 Woodland Bellower
38 Worldspine Wurm
39 Artisan's Sorrow
40 Aspect of Hydra
41 Momentous Fall
42 Return to the Earth
Sorcery (7)
43 Cultivate
44 Kodama's Reach
45 Life's Legacy
46 Overrun
47 Primal Command
48 Savage Punch
49 Skyshroud Claim
Artifact (3)
50 Bow of Nylea
51 Expedition Map
52 Sol Ring
Enchantment (8)
53 Death's Presence
54 Elemental Bond
55 Frontier Siege
56 Gravity Well
57 Lurking Predators
58 Primeval Bounty
59 Retreat to Kazandu
60 Zendikar Resurgent
Planeswalker (1)
61 Garruk Wildspeaker
62 Blighted Woodland
63 Dryad Arbor
64 Havenwood Battleground
65 Mosswort Bridge
66 Myriad Landscape
67 Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx
68 Slippery Karst
69 Tectonic Edge
70 Tranquil Thicket
30 Forest
That sure is a big wall of cards! Here are the components loosely broken down:
01 Nylea, God of the Hunt
Romper Stompers (17)
02 Arbor Colossus
03 Genesis Hydra
04 Giant Adephage
05 Kalonian Twingrove
06 Leatherback Baloth
07 Mistcutter Hydra
08 Nacatl War-Pride
09 Plated Slagwurm
10 Polukranos, World Eater
11 Predator Ooze
12 Primalcrux
13 Scute Mob
14 Terastodon
15 Terra Stomper
16 Vinelasher Kudzu
17 Woodland Bellower
18 Worldspine Wurm
Stomp Abusers (14)
19 Garruk's Packleader
20 Primordial Sage
21 Reverent Hunter
22 Scryb Ranger
23 Thunderfoot Baloth
24 Ulvenwald Tracker
25 Aspect of Hydra
26 Momentous Fall
27 Life's Legacy
28 Overrun
29 Savage Punch
30 Elemental Bond
31 Lurking Predators
32 Mosswort Bridge
33 Courser of Kruphix
34 Karametra's Acolyte
35 Sakura-Tribe Elder
36 Whisperer of the Wilds
37 Cultivate
38 Kodama's Reach
39 Skyshroud Claim
40 Frontier Siege
41 Zendikar Resurgent
42 Blighted Woodland
43 Havenwood Battleground
44 Myriad Landscape
Removal/Protection (7)
45 Acidic Slime
46 Archetype of Endurance
47 Conclave Naturalists
48 Heroes' Bane
49 Artisan's Sorrow
50 Return to the Earth
51 Death's Presence
Good EDH Cards (7)
52 Heartwood Storyteller
53 Expedition Map
54 Sol Ring
55 Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx
56 Slippery Karst
57 Tectonic Edge
58 Tranquil Thicket
59 Dosan the Falling Leaf
60 Gilt-Leaf Seer
61 Nylea's Disciple
62 Whisperwood Elemental
63 Wolfbriar Elemental
64 Primal Command
65 Bow of Nylea
66 Gravity Well
67 Primeval Bounty
68 Retreat to Kazandu
69 Garruk Wildspeaker
70 Dryad Arbor
30 Forest
I'm hoping to toss some Good Green Cards and maybe a few Stomp Enablers for more fatties.
I mostly need feedback on what can be cut, though suggestions for new cards are also welcome! Let me know what you think.
Mook's Cube!
Mook's Frontier Atarka Red Primer!
For more of my projects and brews, check out Clutch City Cardboard on Facebook, or at our domain.
I would cut most big dump beaters and add more ramp in form of mana dorks (don't go all in dork plan to avoid getting wrathed too hard).