Regurgitate is broken on so many levels that I don't even know where to begin. Look at Dragon Appeasement for comparison. That's a 6-mana tri-colored card with a worse effect than what you're proposing. The drawbacks on your card won't do anything to stop people from comboing out.
Woeful Summoning suddenly enables an Affinity like effect for all creatures...with the current state of graveyard fillers I don't think this will see print unless at a really prohibitive mana cost.
At first, it was only "Whenever a creature dies, draw a card.", which would still have been broken compared to Dragon Appeasement, as you said. But now, I just realized with the current wording, if I have more then two cards in hand by the time I played the card, I would just mill myself to death, LOL.
The concept for Woeful Summoning is really graveyard affinity. I think a bit of a drawback could fix this card.
Don't understand why impaler shrike is on so many lists. If it isn't connecting with my opponent I'd rather have a serum raker, and if it is then most of the time I'd want to keep my 3 power flier that has demonstrated the ability to connect - i.e. I'd rather have a serum raker. And I know that serum raker isn't a card that would make most peoples' top 10 lists in its set.
The sacrifice clause for Impaler Shrike isn't mandatory.
Hmm, Reaper of Sheoldred is an uncommon in the [NPH] Entire Set Spoiled thread but common in the main spoiler page. Blinding Souleater is common in the thread but uncommon in the spoiler. Which ones are correct?
Oops, Intimidate in an artifact block is a dud.
Morbid Dogs can 3-for-1 if chump blocked on the 1st attack, kills on the next and dies. Granted, any bomb can be N-for-1 if chump blocked repeatedly. OK, 2-for-1 then.
I know this is still too early, but what do you think will be the top 10 commons in New Phyrexia?
Here's mine:
Remember the Fallen - White's version of Morbid Plunder Impaler Shrike - Thieving Magpie on steroids Blind Zealot - Power creeped Severed Legion Geth's Verdict - Edict w/ a ping Mortis Dogs - Possible 3-for-1 is possibly good Artillerize - Wellsprings et al.'s bestfriend, albeit overcosted Volt Charge - Staple burn Parasitic Implant - Removal is removal, although most of the time this will just be a 2-for-2. You place it on their bomb, it attacks, you chump block, your turn you have a shiny new chump blocker. Blighted Agent - Blue's Plague Stinger Reaper of Sheoldred - Should have been named Blightwidower
It would also be nice to have some healthy card discussions, since the Rumor Mill and New Card Discussion pages are now just a hodge-podge of crazy deck ideas and unorganized single card discussions, ever since the Godbook leak.
MODs kindly lock if NPH discussions are not yet allowed.
I was playing proliferate Tezz against Caw-Blade at Game Day. In the first game, he's got me down to 1 life and milled me 3 times with a Hawk carrying a Sword of Body and Mind. To this point I had hit him a couple of times with Inkmoth Nexus and proliferated with my 1 Throne of Geth on the table. So he's sitting at 6 poison counters when I check my graveyard to see what's been milled, I realize that both of my Contagion Clasps and 1 other Throne of Geth are gone. I knew the only way I was going to win was by top decking the other Throne of Geth in the deck, hitting him for 2 with my Nexus, and then proliferating twice to put him at 10. Sure enough, Throne of Geth off the top. My opponent wasn't happy.
[snip]
One thing that you guys need to be aware of!!! Precursor Golem IS REALLY REALLY BAD MAINDECK!!!!! Because almost everyone is running arc trails and thats the worst thing ever!!! I actually lost a game cause of this -.-[/snip]
Read Precursor Golem again. It will only copy a spell with a single target. Now read Arc Trail. Yup, that won't work.
Yup, I missed Kuldotha Flamefiend. It should be on the list, probably replacing Relic-Warder. I remember playing it in the Pre-Release dealing 4 damage (divided) everywhere without even sacrificing an artifact. Oops. Honest mistake. My opponent didn't even call me out on it.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
At first, it was only "Whenever a creature dies, draw a card.", which would still have been broken compared to Dragon Appeasement, as you said. But now, I just realized with the current wording, if I have more then two cards in hand by the time I played the card, I would just mill myself to death, LOL.
The concept for Woeful Summoning is really graveyard affinity. I think a bit of a drawback could fix this card.
Regurgitate
Skip your draw step.
Whenever a card is put into your graveyard from anywhere, draw a card.
Your maximum hand size is two.
Woeful Summoning
Creature spells you cast cost 1 less to cast for each creature card in your graveyard.
The sacrifice clause for Impaler Shrike isn't mandatory.
Oops, Intimidate in an artifact block is a dud.
Morbid Dogs can 3-for-1 if chump blocked on the 1st attack, kills on the next and dies. Granted, any bomb can be N-for-1 if chump blocked repeatedly. OK, 2-for-1 then.
Here's mine:
Remember the Fallen - White's version of Morbid Plunder
Impaler Shrike - Thieving Magpie on steroids
Blind Zealot - Power creeped Severed Legion
Geth's Verdict - Edict w/ a ping
Mortis Dogs - Possible 3-for-1 is possibly good
Artillerize - Wellsprings et al.'s bestfriend, albeit overcosted
Volt Charge - Staple burn
Parasitic Implant - Removal is removal, although most of the time this will just be a 2-for-2. You place it on their bomb, it attacks, you chump block, your turn you have a shiny new chump blocker.
Blighted Agent - Blue's Plague Stinger
Reaper of Sheoldred - Should have been named Blightwidower
It would also be nice to have some healthy card discussions, since the Rumor Mill and New Card Discussion pages are now just a hodge-podge of crazy deck ideas and unorganized single card discussions, ever since the Godbook leak.
MODs kindly lock if NPH discussions are not yet allowed.
How do you hit for 2 with Nexus?
Read Precursor Golem again. It will only copy a spell with a single target. Now read Arc Trail. Yup, that won't work.