MTG Salvation

sounds like a bad beat to me.
cause planeswalker deck has problem against mono red

Is there any viable Planeswalker Control at the moment?
It almost felt like there are not enough synergy between the current Planeswalkers

agreed that GW is needed just question is wut to splash

Quote from UberGoose

Call me crazy, but Naya planeswalkers seems really good right now.

• Chandra, the Firebrand
  
• Gideon Jura
  
• Elspeth Tirel
  
• Garruk Relentless
  
• Karn Liberated

So many good choices, and green has Beast Within and Acidic Slime while Red has burn spells and sweepers (and inferno titan) and white is just white.

I dont know..the planeswalkers' ult are subpar...
Chandra, the Firebrand not as good as the previous chandra..imo...and the ult is not devastating...just a 6 dmg mini board wipe..unless u can target the same player for 6 dmg six times....which I dont think that's the case...
Elspeth Tirel kills itself...and fellow planeswalkers...
Garruk, the Veil-Cursed ult is also subpar..because planeswalker control deck..wouldnt run much creature..
Karn Liberated is just really expensive...

I was playing 5CC Planeswalker Control back in Cryptic command
then moved into tri-colour Planeswalker Control (Bant, Esper, ...etc) then unorthodox RWB Planeswalker Control. And been away from magic for quiet a while after the core planeswalker rotated out.

With the new planeswalker in the scope do you guys think the archetype is viable again?

Hi all,

I've been away since the introduction of competitive artifact decks along with the death of the major planeswalker.

I'm wondering how's the meta at the moment.
and how is control decks doing?

Im thinking planeswalker control deck with proliferate engine...
not necessary to have all the pieces..just wondering if that's viable...

When proliferate was introduce in Scars of Mirrodin...
some proliferate deck poped up...however I don't think it had any decent results..
example was like Proliferate Planeswalker Deck...

now that Besieged is in...is the deck getting the stuff it needs?
I've been a big fan of Planeswalker Control..
now that some decent Planeswalker has rotated out..I've stray away from Magic for a while @@

I've been away from magic for a while now.
there used to be a thread dedicated to show the block that's in and that's rotating out
since I dont see it no more..would anyone kindly tell me what is in and what is not?

Quote from Vegetto91

This really isnt the way i wanted to see w/r/b vengeant control coming to its end.

we lose path's, terminate's, blightnings, elspeth and ajani vengeant.

What do we get instead of it some weird artifacts that has nothing to do with our original idea....

honestly I really don't mind loosing blightning and terminate..
while those being good other approach are available (it doesn't have to be discard based..and we have other destruction spells)
The only thing I'm really missing are the planeswalkers.
I think Proliferate is fairly good

Quote from onslaught71

so it's basically a w/r/b plainswalker control?

Personally i think that the deck went out with the rotation which is sad because it was a great deck.

ya...it is a shame that both elspeth and vegeant are out
or they will be very awesome
but then again..since when a well rounded planeswalker is not awesome XD?

I've revisited the deck and attempted to bring this archetype back.
this is the current attempt

now that the scars of mirrodin is fully spoiled...
other than proliferate I don't see how we benefit from the set at all....
not to mention we lost a bunch of cards

Quote from Divisionbyzer0

Dark vengeant splash blue. It needs some tuning, but it's really fun to play.

I feel sun titan would work well with the creature package.

I love nyxathid so much.

WaterBleu's DeckMagic OnlineOCTGN2ApprenticeBuy These Cards
Land 1 Celestial Colonnade 2 Lavaclaw Reaches 2 Creeping Tarpit 4 Terramorphic Expanse 2 Arid Mesa 2 Scalding Tarn 2 Marsh Flats 3 Swamp 3 Island 2 Mountain 3 Plains Creatures 4 Nyxathid 3 Wall of Omens 2 Tidehollow Sculler 2 Sedraxis Specter	Spells 4 Esper Charm 4 Blightning 1 Jace, The Mindsculptor 2 Day of Judgement 2 Slave of Bolas 2 Ajani Vengeant 4 Terminate 2 Bituminous Blast 3 Inquisition of Kozilek	Sideboard 4 Leyline of the Void 4 Spreading Seas 3 Oblivion Ring 3 Path to Exile 1 Day of Judgment

no offense..but we probably should be playing 5CC Planeswalker Control at that point...

I understand the player is not a "permanent"
but is it possible to remove the poison counter from player using hexmage?