Why the **** are people posting full reads list on day 1? Stop. All of you. Now.
Jesus christ.
~~~~
EL still way scum. Folza scummy for starting the really awful reads list train
Bloodmoon, what did I overlook from you?
Also I know someone asked me If I was reading the thread. I'm not. I'm lightly skimming cause I already caught a scum, so like...get bent person asking me if I read.
Re: Lurker - If he were a power role, I could see him sparking discussion specifically to try and get reads to narrow down possible targets for whatever he would be able to do.
EternalLurker I really think he's Town Vanilla. I think if he had a role he would be a lot quieter, he is throwing out lots of accusations trying to get people to talk which I think is a good thing. Tho he is also a loose cannon so my read could be way off. I tenitively trust him.
Regarding this speculation on my role...I'm not claiming anything, but since this is a newbie game I guess I'll offer some input on what -- from an outsider's perspective -- I would consider my actions to imply. Yes, it's true that a noisy person attracts attention, but the sort of attention varies depending on a few factors. Here's the basic breakdown.
1) I'm Town and my noisiness is scaring the Mafia. In this case, they'll possibly want to kill me, so it's true that an investigative Townie role wouldn't want to be in this position on day one, before having a chance to use investigative abilities.
2) I'm Town but my noisiness is all on the wrong targets, so the Mafia doesn't care. In this case, there's actually a chance that I'll get lynched for noisy misreads, in which case a Vanilla Townie wouldn't act like this cuz there's nothing he can role-claim to save himself from a mislynch.
3) I'm Mafia. Then I know I won't die at night, and, though I still have to worry about mislynches, the chance is a lil' lower cuz of the fact that my scum-buddy's not gonna be bussing me on day one.
So, if you're reading me as Town like you say, then it's option 1 or 2, in which case the most likely read on me would be as a non-investigative non-vanilla role who's not particularly worried about being night-killed.
Like, say, a Town Bulletproof.
just food for thought
Also I just want to dig into this post a little more for those who aren't understanding why this post is scummy.
Paraphrased this post read:
I haven't claimed a role(foreshadowing)but because I'm more experienced than most the people here I'll explain to you guys what you guys should think about MY posting.
1.I'm town and drawing attention to myself and the mafia is scared that I'm drawing attention to myself(why? that's silly). Mafia is gonna want to kill me, so a power role doesn't want to act like me(wifom - at best)
2. I'm completely full of ***** and the mafia isn't gonna kill me because I'm wrong about everything even though it's only page 2 and you guys are gonna mislynch me cause i'm town guys. guys. I'm town. But i'm not vanilla town. But remember in 1) i'm not a power role...woooo spoooky
3. i wouldn't be loud as scum cause I don't want me lynched. Guy remember 1 and 2, i'm totes town
MAYBE I REALLY WANT THE ATTENTION BECAUSE I'M AN INCREDIBLY NICHE TOWN ROLE! GUYS I'M BULLETPROOF
just food for thought nbd bros.
but really i just claimed bulletproof
~~~~~~
Do you know who else is bulletproof? Godfather.
AutoTsunami I read back through EL's posts 56 and 61. Am I missing a link here? I'm not sure what you meant when you tied the two together. Just looking for some clarity on it.
Both are responses to the same exact post. He first fired off a joke, then felt nervous/wasn't satisfied so he revisited it unsolicited to try to appear more town. The only reason to revisit something you blew off with a joke is to supersede any suspicion.
Now with 214, he refuses to address my point at all and simply writes me of as scum or tunneling, which is laziness if we're being generous.
Hey EL, can I get another flowchart of what town and scum would do in this situation, cause it was oh so helpful in 61.
Also it's silly how many people are voting a lurker on day 1. Y'all need to look at the people in plain sight
56 is a joke, but 56 in combination with 61 changes the context of both posts. He initially and immediately blows it off with the joke then comes back 3 hours later to give a detailed and logically flawed statement on the possible alignments he could be. It's silly and awful. And his now the second time he's said something along the lines of "if I were x alignment, i'd do y and it'd be so easy to get a win if I did y". In conjunction with him being the "content police" several times at this point while his post have been more white noise then actual content is really just icing.
I'm not changing my vote for the rest of the day. EL is confscum in my mind.
@AudioTsunami: Since you've shown that you are present, what are your thoughts on things at the moment? (Just a general idea will suffice, I'm not looking for a detailed analysis of the entire thread from you yet.)
I'm pretty positive EL is scum. I want more analysis from you and less coaching and I don't understand your post about nago being unwilling to pressure a slot that is being replaced at the top of 4. I like Nago. Fugging has still only talked about himself.
@mograppler, where do you normally play at? I'm curious where you picked up the no lynch thing at and whether it has a meta of night role focused games vs games with lots of vanilla town.
Okay, back on MTGS. Wanted to share that if you haven't seen it yet, Vivid Strike delivers. Specially that episode 4... Asside from that Izetta the last Witch is also a really good anime if you want to watch.
I haven't seen vivid strike. I really hate izetta.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
cause it didn't work and I was supposed to try to re-vote or something cause algorithms
Jesus christ.
~~~~
EL still way scum. Folza scummy for starting the really awful reads list train
Bloodmoon, what did I overlook from you?
Also I know someone asked me If I was reading the thread. I'm not. I'm lightly skimming cause I already caught a scum, so like...get bent person asking me if I read.
The only reason to address ANYTHING twice unsolicited is because you were unhappy with what your initial response sounded/looked like.
Also I just want to dig into this post a little more for those who aren't understanding why this post is scummy.
Paraphrased this post read:
I haven't claimed a role(foreshadowing)but because I'm more experienced than most the people here I'll explain to you guys what you guys should think about MY posting.
1.I'm town and drawing attention to myself and the mafia is scared that I'm drawing attention to myself(why? that's silly). Mafia is gonna want to kill me, so a power role doesn't want to act like me(wifom - at best)
2. I'm completely full of ***** and the mafia isn't gonna kill me because I'm wrong about everything even though it's only page 2 and you guys are gonna mislynch me cause i'm town guys. guys. I'm town. But i'm not vanilla town. But remember in 1) i'm not a power role...woooo spoooky
3. i wouldn't be loud as scum cause I don't want me lynched. Guy remember 1 and 2, i'm totes town
MAYBE I REALLY WANT THE ATTENTION BECAUSE I'M AN INCREDIBLY NICHE TOWN ROLE! GUYS I'M BULLETPROOF
just food for thought nbd bros.
but really i just claimed bulletproof
~~~~~~
Do you know who else is bulletproof? Godfather.
lynch when you guys are ready.
Both are responses to the same exact post. He first fired off a joke, then felt nervous/wasn't satisfied so he revisited it unsolicited to try to appear more town. The only reason to revisit something you blew off with a joke is to supersede any suspicion.
Now with 214, he refuses to address my point at all and simply writes me of as scum or tunneling, which is laziness if we're being generous.
Hey EL, can I get another flowchart of what town and scum would do in this situation, cause it was oh so helpful in 61.
Also it's silly how many people are voting a lurker on day 1. Y'all need to look at the people in plain sight
I'm voting EternalLurker
I'm not changing my vote for the rest of the day. EL is confscum in my mind.
56 61 105
Yeah i only read the first page when I posted, that's all I had, I'm now starting page 4
I'm pretty positive EL is scum. I want more analysis from you and less coaching and I don't understand your post about nago being unwilling to pressure a slot that is being replaced at the top of 4. I like Nago. Fugging has still only talked about himself.
could also /mentor if there isn't room to play
I haven't seen vivid strike. I really hate izetta.