MTG Salvation

Quote from claytonthegreat

sorry gentleman, I've had some personal problems that almost wanted me to replace out but things seem to be working out first let me start with my claim.

Homunculus the Alchemic Being, vanilla.

my fluff indicated that during the early days of the game I was played manly because of the fact that I was a decent sized creature, but as the game evolved I fell behind the pack and that my ability is/was almost usless. hence the lack of an ability. I continue to be played by the casual group were I find a place in the game.

so first off, I had not expected zindabad to come up scum. really none of his play came off scummy but looking back he did have a level of confidence as if he knew more than the rest of us. I'm more suprised by the fact that their was a daykill and that it hit zindabad head on. as for the lack of kills at night, I'm going to say that I currently put blame on the SK for the day kill and can't begin to speculate why the scum didn't kill, hell they might have not submitted a kill for all I know.

as for likely candidates for the scum, I will also agree that zindabad had a level of town read amonst a few of us and make's the cover on R_O look really suspicious. I would like to look further on this before I continue with a vote. Also I also would like to point out that AK has down nothing in regards to my assumtions of him being the SK. In fact he does seem to care very little on what accusations are made to him. I would like anyone who feels that I'm scum to come out and say why, it's about time I address this.

Quote from Anaklusmos761

My nomination for SK: AK. He hasn't been on any lynch wagon, which does a lot for not drawing attention to him. And while he has claimed redirector, I don't recall if he ever proved it. If I am wrong about that last part, please yell at me or something. But, if he never confirms his ability, I definitely think he is the SK.

Quote from red_0mega

Maybe he had one of his buddies do it for him. Maybe the mod is not revealing everything upon death. These are just the first two possibilities that come to mind. NK immunity also works against vigilantes (that kill at night).
For the record I am not saying that he was telling the truth about anything or everything, I am just saying that there is simply no way we can know.

I agree. If people want me to, I have no problem starting.

I disagree here, however, everyone (or almost everyone) should give their opinion first.

Quote from Pale Mage

There's extraneous and irrelevant details in the above (rhyming Cyan...what does that matter?), but the argument would be fine if you believed she was scum. But you don't. The snark is hate, plain and simple.


The game has been fairly slow moving overall, and it had been less than a day between her comment and your vote. The game hadn't stalled. The wagon hadn't stalled, either. Manders was at a virtual L-2 given AKid's comment.

Not relevant to your vote (the issue on the table) since this took place afterwards. Not a terrible argument for her being scum, but (again) you don't think she is. Why is this in here?


Nobody's perfect.

This goes without saying, anyway.


You're playing both sides of the fence in your post (continuing a theme with you re: MH). If you were truly voting out of a desire to keep the game going, I would've expected to see an indication of that with the vote, not the snark.


If you really thought she was town, and you were town, you wouldn't be voting her. You'd be finding the scum on her wagon and putting them on the radar.



You are obviously not reading the thread...or is this meant to be a counterclaim? Please advise.

*eyebrow*

...if there is, we need to know this?

Is the movie on a loop?

Quote from DYH

Unvote

Solid claim and the bit about Stormblind editting the original post is not something I think anyone would be willing to risk lying about.

Infinis' explanation for the claim vote on Manders is good. I'm not suspicious of his actions there.

Vote: Apokalypse Kid

Upgrade from the FoS for his scum behavior pattern post.



Until? Why would you say you chose that word?

Quote from Alpha Werewolf

Okay, couple of points.

First, Bunari is lying scum. That's settled. Let's try not to rush this day though!

I've looked at the cards in the graveyard, here's what I gleaned:

1. iPot was killed by the mafia. Dark World Lightning corresponds to Reign-Beaux, Ruler of Dark World. Therefore, all (or at least most) of the mafia are Dark World monsters.

2. joboman was killed by TACKY, clearly. But note that there's nothing showing for AK's ability. So far, every ability but one (Zindabad's) is a card. Zindabad explains this by saying he is a spirit monster. How do you, AK, explain this?

3. AI was killed by the SK. Since we take Fuhma Shurikens to be TACKY, and Dark World Lightnings to be scum, it follows that Bark of Dark Ruler is the SK kill. This pretty much confirms the SK, As it rules out any and all one-shot kills.

Opinions? Additions?