So now that what appears to be the only Mafia is dead I will admit my abilities have drawbacks, as I am sure you all have guessed. For my vig I have to target two people and call higher or lower, and my vig will hit what I call between the two card values. I was seriously worried Iso was not the queen like he said he was, so I picked the lowest card number possible, Emo, since Seppel is untargetable, and hoped Iso wasn't the Ace. Glad it worked out! The night I tried to roleblock Iso my ability actually failed. I have to target a person and then send a dice roll calling even or odds to get that one to work. I didn't call it correctly. All of my drawbacks rely on chance in order to hit, which is very frustrating. However I have gotten lucky and only failed the once.
Why didn't you tell us about this when we were massclaiming?
I can confirm that BE took no action last Night, since he hasn't been on the site for 5 days.
Not sure if I agree with Seppel's plan, here. If the last neutral or something isn't a threat then the game would have already ended. Like I said, there has to be something to balance out all of this town power + the fact that the scum this game don't appear to be working with each other.
I did not divulge all of the drawbacks because there was ABSOLUTELY no need to let scum know everything about my role. What if they had a way to control the chance aspects of my drawbacks? I wasn't confident in letting everyone in on them until they needed to be stated. Not sure why this would be an issue for you Proph.
B_E has not posted in nine days. @Mod, can we get a prod check? We need that spot to contribute something. I feel strongly that either B_E or Seppel is our "scum" used loosely to mean anti-town.
Seppel I still feel convinced could be some kind of cult leader. His untargetability mechanic and the fact that he "passes it on" seem to be in line with all I know of cults.
Behaviorally, I have disliked B_E.
Day one, Smoke_K was not far behind. Then he got confirmed and turned into a lazy townie.
I have no concept of a warlock.
The lyncher role I know wins if the person they are given is lynched. Never heard of a version that chooses targets and wins after multiple right guesses.
I am fine with the No Lynch plan. It will seemingly take forever depending on how trumps work out.
You really should have told us about this before now. What is the drawback to your investigation?
No reason not to continue testing Prophylaxis, but you are the only person that I am very interested in lynching.
VOTE: Prophylaxis
The cop shot relies on me targeting a player, calling whether they are higher or lower than myself. If I guess correctly, than I get the result in "guilty" or "not guilty" terms. This is what makes me believe there is another non-killing neutral that is a threat to the town, such as a cult. With GJ able to cop "gun" or "no gun" and my ability able to cop "guilty" or "not guilty" they would make sense to exist together. He could cop the non-killing neutral and find "no gun" and I could cop them and get "guilty." Similarly, he could cop me and get "gun" to give a false positive and even that stuff out.
Because if you come around and we're the only two people who aren't found to be town, well, then there's still time for three lynches -- him, myself, and you.
Can we at least wait a few more days and see if we can get a replacement in here? Would prefer to have that player clear a few things up before we commit to anything.
guess red or black for suit of target player... if I guess correctly it will be successful... not sure how the multiples work, though my guess would be it would go through as successful for them all the time.
Not happy Emo died but glad we still can have smoke... now if more people could target him that would be great.
I targeted Proph for protection, since he was the unlynchable and I couldn't target smoke because of Seppel making him untargetable. However, it came back saying it failed. I chose spades, as that what Proph and KCC had claimed they were, 5 of Spades...
I would like Smoke to confirm for me as well.
I am also interested by what you mean some stuff went down, Proph?
As illogical his play has been Today he's still lying scum who needs to die.
He claimed to have targeted me, but Smoke says that he's targeted two people. In addition to that EP and I got a mason chat last Night which corroborate's Smoke's claim.
My guess is that he gets to see the mason chat and picks either one of us to die but this is all speculation.
The only one that could be lying is Smoke here...
I think it's an unfortunate coincidence that I targeted you last night. It makes sense that my ability would fail in that case. I came in thinking that you were possibly lying about your suit, which would have made equally the same amount of sense. I really don't see you as the scum in this case Proph, simply due to the unlynchable aspect, and because of your play. I am not sure I would have felt the same about KCC at this point.
I feel like I am being set up by smoke right now, because I know that I targeted only Proph last night and for him to say otherwise is super scummy. What makes it more frustrating for me right now is the fact that I have a freaking PM with him being cleared...
I guess he is investigation immune?
Did you actually do nothing last night Seppel? Is that an accurate report?
Is there a role that can sway what watchers see at night?
Either way, I have to vote for him until I get some more concrete answers. Vote smoke
I did not divulge all of the drawbacks because there was ABSOLUTELY no need to let scum know everything about my role. What if they had a way to control the chance aspects of my drawbacks? I wasn't confident in letting everyone in on them until they needed to be stated. Not sure why this would be an issue for you Proph.
B_E has not posted in nine days. @Mod, can we get a prod check? We need that spot to contribute something. I feel strongly that either B_E or Seppel is our "scum" used loosely to mean anti-town.
Seppel I still feel convinced could be some kind of cult leader. His untargetability mechanic and the fact that he "passes it on" seem to be in line with all I know of cults.
Behaviorally, I have disliked B_E.
Day one, Smoke_K was not far behind. Then he got confirmed and turned into a lazy townie.
I have no concept of a warlock.
The lyncher role I know wins if the person they are given is lynched. Never heard of a version that chooses targets and wins after multiple right guesses.
I am fine with the No Lynch plan. It will seemingly take forever depending on how trumps work out.
Any other ideas or suggestions?
The cop shot relies on me targeting a player, calling whether they are higher or lower than myself. If I guess correctly, than I get the result in "guilty" or "not guilty" terms. This is what makes me believe there is another non-killing neutral that is a threat to the town, such as a cult. With GJ able to cop "gun" or "no gun" and my ability able to cop "guilty" or "not guilty" they would make sense to exist together. He could cop the non-killing neutral and find "no gun" and I could cop them and get "guilty." Similarly, he could cop me and get "gun" to give a false positive and even that stuff out.
Why the hell did you give smoke untargetability if you thought he was scummy?
So you think that the two confirmed townies this game are the most behaviorally scummy?
The GJ way path to no lynching:
IMO it is Hunt BE2 or Seppel that even have a short at it and Hunt tops the list as most scummy.
Ok. I'll buy that.
I'm ready to go to night since this game pretty much hinges on Hunt's abilities now.
I'm actually think lynching Hunt is the best option over a no lynch.
Either he finds the last anti-town player, or he lies and we lynch him. There is no bad part about this plan.
Hopefully BE2 gets swapped or mod killed soon.
The GJ way path to no lynching:
smoke_Killah
I like the probability of the impossible. ~Nicolas Roeg
Prophylaxis (2): Prophylaxis, Huntzilla
No lynch (3): Seppel, emo_pinata, Gentleman Johnny
Not Voting: smoke_Killah, Burning_Earth2
V/LA: Prophylxis (~6.6.)
With 7 alive, it's 4 to lynch!
Huntzilla has been prodded.
Unvote
Vote No Lynch
Most gods throw dice, but Fate plays chess, and you don't find out til too late that he's been playing with two queens all along. ~Terry Pratchett
Prophylaxis (1): Prophylaxis
No lynch (4): Seppel, emo_pinata, Gentleman Johnny, Huntzilla
Not Voting: smoke_Killah, Burning_Earth2
V/LA: Prophylxis (~6.6.)
That's the no lynch! It's twilight now.
Protection... Single target...
----------------------------------------------------------
Day 4 has ended in a no lynch.
Burning_Earth2 has been modkilled due to inactivity; he was Ace Hardware, Town Dollamancer.
It is now Night 4, which will last until Tuesday, June 9th, at 9am, EDT. Please place all Night actions by that time.
emo_pinata has been smothered; he was Three-Card Monte, Town Racketeer.
The Day 5 deadline is set for 8 days hence, at 11:00am EDT on Thursday, June 18th.
Diamonds are trump for Day 5!
With 5 alive, it's 3 to lynch!
Would especially like to hear what Hunt did and what Smoke saw.
Smoke can clear me and clear/damn Hunt. Proph is literally unlynchable, so if he's evil, then the game is already lost.
I targeted Proph for protection, since he was the unlynchable and I couldn't target smoke because of Seppel making him untargetable. However, it came back saying it failed. I chose spades, as that what Proph and KCC had claimed they were, 5 of Spades...
I would like Smoke to confirm for me as well.
I am also interested by what you mean some stuff went down, Proph?
Seppel targeted no one, as far as I can tell.
smoke_Killah
Okay, so I got a mason chat with EP last Night. It was the reason for the deadline extension:
Cantrip gave EP and I 24 hours to talk and stuff. Given that Hunt targeted both of us that means that he's lying about his abilities.
Uh. I didn't target Emo though. Not lying about anything...
I am not sure why smoke would see me target both.
What exactly did you guys talk about? And why is Emo dead and you are not?
This is really weird. Why would scum!Hunt contradict someone he's towncleared?
This literally gives him zero outs if he's scum.
As illogical his play has been Today he's still lying scum who needs to die.
He claimed to have targeted me, but Smoke says that he's targeted two people. In addition to that EP and I got a mason chat last Night which corroborate's Smoke's claim.
My guess is that he gets to see the mason chat and picks either one of us to die but this is all speculation.
I think it's an unfortunate coincidence that I targeted you last night. It makes sense that my ability would fail in that case. I came in thinking that you were possibly lying about your suit, which would have made equally the same amount of sense. I really don't see you as the scum in this case Proph, simply due to the unlynchable aspect, and because of your play. I am not sure I would have felt the same about KCC at this point.
I feel like I am being set up by smoke right now, because I know that I targeted only Proph last night and for him to say otherwise is super scummy. What makes it more frustrating for me right now is the fact that I have a freaking PM with him being cleared...
I guess he is investigation immune?
Did you actually do nothing last night Seppel? Is that an accurate report?
Is there a role that can sway what watchers see at night?
Either way, I have to vote for him until I get some more concrete answers.
Vote smoke