Generic, I rarely try to be on anyone's good side unless reasons. On the other hand - analysis. Is there an in-thread example of it? I'm not really sure if I really know how to do logical analysis well hence being here to learn. There's also the fact that this game has many lurkers so its harder to figure things out.
Natirasha, that is a good question! Why do you think it may be applicable?
Ika, I'm finding it difficult to which just makes me miss homesite more. Also, is your homesite similar to or a whole ton better than this?
my homesite has died after our big last game. in its prime it was a lot of fun.
this is largly offtopic so can be ignored if liked:
m homestie would use every intresting/wierd/odd mechanic you could think of. The thing that i like about my homesite is that we used elemnt that are considered bastardised (cults, bus drivers, janitors, framer ect) but were actually considered normal.
so for me this game has stagnented to halt of lurk, lurk, lurk. its also a basic so that mean nothing super special is around and its just core scum hunting, we prob have 2-3 prs but that it. i just rapidly grow board of this wait for 1 new post that has nothing of intrest to me. thats why i go to ms and play like 5 games at once. it keeps me busy and i can foucs on them all at once.
Anyone who thinks ika is scum will kindly point out the scum motivation in his belief to have deduced my role from one of my posts and thereby come to conclusion that I'm town.
If he were scum and believed to have discovered a PR tell, wouldn't he just keep this under wraps and possibly kill me?
Otherwise what would be the point in making this up?
Let's lynch Neon. Pretty sure my vote is already there but just in case
My gut is telling me that NeonFrequency is town. I don't think she's the correct lynch for today.
Ultimately, the troubling fact about this game is that so many people are lurking. My townreads are solidified but I have no one that I am convinced is scum.
Iterated, it's funny you assumed my flashback to Avatar was relating to Fonti being scum rather then the alternative. Where are your generally strong leadership skills? If you had to describe the players you know in this game and their meta, can you give us a rundown?
I cannot lead when half of the playerbase is lurking.
"This is the Tournament, not professional wrestling! Terrible call by the officials."
Due to moderator error (induced by Curse's threaded PM system and sleep deprivation), Antny223 has accidentally gained access to Generic's role PM, and has requested to hydra with him. Ordinarily, I would allow them to hydra in this circumstance, but as this is a Basic game and hydras aren't really Basic I will ask for player approval before doing so..
If a majority of (non-Generic) players permit it, Generic and Antny will be permitted to hydra for the remainder of the game. Otherwise, Antny will become Generic's mentor/observer (his choice). Players, please indicate your preference in the thread in bold.
(Also, an error in the previous vote count has been fixed.) - Tar
Does hydra imply same alignment? I'm fine with it, I guess. Can mod kill players\flip them if they are scum and havne't posted like once in 24 hours?
Bolly, why are you interested in lynching me incorrectly? Why are your two scumspects the same as half the player base? Original thoughts?
Iterated, I meant that you might know some of the people on here that we don't so giving a rundown of their meta, such as:
- rogue always has its foot in mouth regardless of alignment
- scarbo is always cranky
- Bolly randomly posts that its going to do such and such and then disappears, not following up with previous claims but doing another post that's similar and promises actual explanation to be forthcoming
- etc etc
Scarbo, ika feel townish to me
Hawk had one post that really read town to me so until he speaks further, lean town
Iterated is playing unlike its former playstyle but idk if its because of new name\style so waiting to see less barning of fulcrum
I want Generic to be town because it seems likely to be more fun but waiting on analysis
Natirasha's posts so far have been brief, random commentary or responding to questions with "NO U explain" so lean scum
AtheistGod, wow I forgot this person was in the game. They add nothing and haven't posted worth memory so most likely they should die. If mods don't kill it then we should.
Oh yeah and my favorite KamikazeArch...I still got my eye on you. Answer my last few questions.
People who I'm okay with lynching:
AtheistGod
Kamikaze*
People who look really scummy but need to be further clarified:
Rogue
Natirasha
Questions for all players, regardless of whether they are an evil little scum with a horrid mustache or a townie with a penchant for chivalry:
- Who do you hope the scum NK's first night? Why?
- If you were a doctor, which player would you protect from scum first night?
- If you were a cop, who would you investigate?
Questions for all players, regardless of whether they are an evil little scum with a horrid mustache or a townie with a penchant for chivalry:
- 1)Who do you hope the scum NK's first night? Why?
- If you were a doctor, which player would you protect from scum first night?
- If you were a cop, who would you investigate?
1) i hoe the first nk is on me. that way i can say "**** ya, died n1" i ussaly get endgamed and it bugs me
2) ... dont even get me started. i refuse to heal anyone on n1
3) prob fulcrum just to rid paranoia. but there are others i would check (hawk, proph are also strong contendors)
have we played before? i feel like i know who you are or you at least remind me of another perosn i ahve played with
I've had a bit of time to look back over the thread and will spend today doing more of the same. I re-iterate my earlier position that it is better to lynch incorrectly than no-lynch. I also think that it's a waste to use one of our extensions toDay. My preliminary thoughts are that one of Neon or Rogue is the best lynch for toDay and will clarify this later.
I strongly dislike this post.
The first three statements are self-evident and are mostly fluff. NeonFrequency and rogueofoz are also the town's main lynch suspects at this point. What happened to your scumread on ika?
The ika wagon could have been a goo thing for analysis, if you had let it go. Your reasoning for not letting that happen makes no sense, because ika was in no real danger of being lynched in the short term (with the size of the game and the site culture of stopping at l-2). He was also in no danger in the long term, as you know I would have stepped in to back up your town read. Why did you cut off the wagon immediately?
Because I place more value in restraining attacks on town rather than building up a wagon for analysis.
I don't hide my townreads until one of them gets pressured. I defend that person immediately as soon as they get run up.
Why not?
Really, man? What part of this question wasn't clear?
Something feels off with Iterated. I don't really know how to describe it. The way he acknowledged my point against hawk and then just moved on was part of it.
So proph as town is pretty effective at reading me, as scum he already knows my alignment. I think if you are reading his alignment off of his read on me, you should go check out some of the league games like star wars.
Who if anyone is opposed to a rogue lynch? Also where has AG been?
So proph as town is pretty effective at reading me, as scum he already knows my alignment. I think if you are reading his alignment off of his read on me, you should go check out some of the league games like star wars.
Who if anyone is opposed to a rogue lynch? Also where has AG been?
Nice, asking permission to lynch someone? thats like scum posting 101
how about you tell us why we should not read him based off you. how about a read list?
I haven't been cryptic with my reads. I don't like rogue, neon, fulcrum. Wingz and AG were scummy question marks. I think proph and you are town. Bolly slight lean town after looking over his last game as scum. Kami is probably town but hates being wrong/emotional. Everyone else is null.
I wanna know who is actually opposing the rogue lynch because I feel like scum are delaying the lynch without actively trying to stop it.
I haven't been cryptic with my reads. I don't like rogue, neon, fulcrum. Wingz and AG were scummy question marks. I think proph and you are town. Bolly slight lean town after looking over his last game as scum. Kami is probably town but hates being wrong/emotional. Everyone else is null.
I wanna know who is actually opposing the rogue lynch because I feel like scum are delaying the lynch without actively trying to stop it.
a lot of your reads look like fence sitting on people and going "heres read leave me"
Wut, I've explicitly stated everything that is in the above post with reasons. I was just recapping for you since you weren't paying attention. The only read that I didn't explain is why rogue is scum, which no one even asked me about. Scum are scared because then it looks like defending a buddy. Most town either understand it or are busy in the mines. Hence I wanted to prod further about getting him lynched.
1)Wut, I've explicitly stated everything that is in the above post with reasons.
2)I was just recapping for you since you weren't paying attention. The only read that I didn't explain is why rogue is scum, which no one even asked me about.
3)Scum are scared because then it looks like defending a buddy. Most town either understand it or are busy in the mines. Hence I wanted to prod further about getting him lynched.
1) now do it in the format i asked, is that too much to ask? a lot of it to me looks like null, null, null, null, ect i dont give *****s about reaosn a good chunck of the time when i ask for somethign simple
2) im always paying attention, never assume that i dont. nobody needs to ask you why you think they are scum, you can openly explian it.
no here let me help you instead: why is rouge scum?
3) now you want to talke mafia theiroy? isnt that what you were scum readinf fulcrum for?
It was bolly and it wasn't because of mafia theory, the topic was brought up and a strange time which was designed to make bolly look town for doing nothing.
Also, I generally phone posT so if you want me to format anything, it will have to wait.
Also, it's a pretty nice spectrum from scum, lean scum, null, lean town and town already. If you can't understand the context within that post without me formatting it, how will you ever catch scum trying to hide information from you?
Also, it's a pretty nice spectrum from scum, lean scum, null, lean town and town already. If you can't understand the context within that post without me formatting it, how will you ever catch scum trying to hide information from you?
the diffrence is i see small context things. how else do you think i figures most peoples roles? if it blindly obvious i tend to miss it, but stuble small thing that little to none pick up on is what i find
Well you are worried about the syntax of my posts instead of the semantics. Context is important so if you disregard my content and argue syntax, it's not very productive when we have bigger fish to fry.
I'll talk about rogue when others start talking about him. I can't find motive if I ask a question and immediately give the answer.
Kamekaze: The level of aggression in Neon's wording is how I usually figure out her alignment. I keep expecting her to get adapt to that but she ... hasn't.
Generic: I had some question for you yesterday. Could you answer them?
Bolly: Chill a bit. There's a lot of room baked into the game for being wrong. Just try to figure it out as best you can. And don't forget to vote for hawk.
Natirasha, that is a good question! Why do you think it may be applicable?
i could be right i could be wrong. but come post-game i will show you what made me figure your role or at least assume it
my homesite has died after our big last game. in its prime it was a lot of fun.
this is largly offtopic so can be ignored if liked:
m homestie would use every intresting/wierd/odd mechanic you could think of. The thing that i like about my homesite is that we used elemnt that are considered bastardised (cults, bus drivers, janitors, framer ect) but were actually considered normal.
so for me this game has stagnented to halt of lurk, lurk, lurk. its also a basic so that mean nothing super special is around and its just core scum hunting, we prob have 2-3 prs but that it. i just rapidly grow board of this wait for 1 new post that has nothing of intrest to me. thats why i go to ms and play like 5 games at once. it keeps me busy and i can foucs on them all at once.
If he were scum and believed to have discovered a PR tell, wouldn't he just keep this under wraps and possibly kill me?
Otherwise what would be the point in making this up?
Let's lynch Neon. Pretty sure my vote is already there but just in case
Unvote
Vote: NeonFrequency
kthnx
Either way, we're all gonna burn
Ultimately, the troubling fact about this game is that so many people are lurking. My townreads are solidified but I have no one that I am convinced is scum.
I want fulcrum in here.
I cannot lead when half of the playerbase is lurking.
What does your second question accomplish?
Uh.
I want hawk dead. I don't want ika, neon, bolly, kamekaze or scarbo dead, in that order.
Unvote
Vote hawk
Do you have reasoning for your NeonFrequency townread?
2) Iterated
4) AtheistGod
5) rogueofoz
6) W1ngz/Generic
12) WillTheBee/Hookerpunch
Nah, I really just want to lynch hawk.
Neon is town.
"This is the Tournament, not professional wrestling! Terrible call by the officials."
Due to moderator error (induced by Curse's threaded PM system and sleep deprivation), Antny223 has accidentally gained access to Generic's role PM, and has requested to hydra with him. Ordinarily, I would allow them to hydra in this circumstance, but as this is a Basic game and hydras aren't really Basic I will ask for player approval before doing so..
If a majority of (non-Generic) players permit it, Generic and Antny will be permitted to hydra for the remainder of the game. Otherwise, Antny will become Generic's mentor/observer (his choice). Players, please indicate your preference in the thread in bold.
(Also, an error in the previous vote count has been fixed.) - Tar
The Fourth Vote Count (aka the "Rule -1: Don't Mod While Low On Sleep?" Vote Count)
1) KamikazeArchon (2) - NeonFrequency, rogueofoz
2) Iterated (0) -
3) NeonFrequency (2) - HookerPunch, scarbo
4) AtheistGod (0) -
5) rogueofoz (2) - Iterated, 7hawk77
6) HookerPunch (replacing W1ngz) (0) -
7) scarbo (0) -
8) 7hawk77 (2) - KamikazeArchon, fulcrum
9) fulcrum (1) - ika42
10) ika42 (2) - Bolly, Generic
11) Bolly (0) -
12) Generic (replacing WillTheBee) (0) -
Not Voting (1): AtheistGod
With 12 votes in play it takes 7 votes to lynch.
Deadline: September 10, 2014 at ~6:00 P.M. GMT -6)
Remaining Extensions: Option 1 (3 days), Option 2 (number of days equal to lynch threshold)
It is too late for the pebbles to vote."
Bolly, why are you interested in lynching me incorrectly? Why are your two scumspects the same as half the player base? Original thoughts?
Iterated, I meant that you might know some of the people on here that we don't so giving a rundown of their meta, such as:
- rogue always has its foot in mouth regardless of alignment
- scarbo is always cranky
- Bolly randomly posts that its going to do such and such and then disappears, not following up with previous claims but doing another post that's similar and promises actual explanation to be forthcoming
- etc etc
Scarbo, ika feel townish to me
Hawk had one post that really read town to me so until he speaks further, lean town
Iterated is playing unlike its former playstyle but idk if its because of new name\style so waiting to see less barning of fulcrum
I want Generic to be town because it seems likely to be more fun but waiting on analysis
Natirasha's posts so far have been brief, random commentary or responding to questions with "NO U explain" so lean scum
AtheistGod, wow I forgot this person was in the game. They add nothing and haven't posted worth memory so most likely they should die. If mods don't kill it then we should.
Oh yeah and my favorite KamikazeArch...I still got my eye on you. Answer my last few questions.
People who I'm okay with lynching:
AtheistGod
Kamikaze*
People who look really scummy but need to be further clarified:
Rogue
Natirasha
Questions for all players, regardless of whether they are an evil little scum with a horrid mustache or a townie with a penchant for chivalry:
- Who do you hope the scum NK's first night? Why?
- If you were a doctor, which player would you protect from scum first night?
- If you were a cop, who would you investigate?
and neon, it was presidential mafia, my other game here
****, I have it right in my notes.
In my defense, I was posting at 2am. In my not defense, I could have posted earlier but didn't.
I've got zero ****s to give about the hydra.
Neon: Think about your questions before you ask them.
Outdated Mafia Stats
1) i hoe the first nk is on me. that way i can say "**** ya, died n1" i ussaly get endgamed and it bugs me
2) ... dont even get me started. i refuse to heal anyone on n1
3) prob fulcrum just to rid paranoia. but there are others i would check (hawk, proph are also strong contendors)
have we played before? i feel like i know who you are or you at least remind me of another perosn i ahve played with
"Why not" what?
This is true. I admit that one of my worries is hawk improving his scum-game under Rhand's mentoring.
I strongly dislike this post.
The first three statements are self-evident and are mostly fluff. NeonFrequency and rogueofoz are also the town's main lynch suspects at this point. What happened to your scumread on ika?
Unvote; Vote: Bolly
Really, man? What part of this question wasn't clear?
Spot what, exactly?
I'm not seeing exactly why you think ika and Bolly are scum. Care to elaborate?
well sorry that i have grown disintrested in this game and dont pay attention to who is alts of what.
anyway. bollys prob town, i can see proph/hawk team atm but unsure of 3rd
Neon, why should I answer your questions when you refuse to answer mine?
fulcrum, is your townread on Neon solely due to meta?
you don't have to
bulleted list of reads
every post
Also I don't care about hydras.
Either way, we're all gonna burn
I still voted for them though! That's cool.
And I mean if we're just going to be softclaiming that's cool too I guess.
Either way, we're all gonna burn
Either way, we're all gonna burn
Who if anyone is opposed to a rogue lynch? Also where has AG been?
Outdated Mafia Stats
Outdated Mafia Stats
Nice, asking permission to lynch someone? thats like scum posting 101
how about you tell us why we should not read him based off you. how about a read list?
I wanna know who is actually opposing the rogue lynch because I feel like scum are delaying the lynch without actively trying to stop it.
Outdated Mafia Stats
a lot of your reads look like fence sitting on people and going "heres read leave me"
how about be more clear by doing it like this
town:
null:
scum:
neon is town though.
Outdated Mafia Stats
1) now do it in the format i asked, is that too much to ask? a lot of it to me looks like null, null, null, null, ect i dont give *****s about reaosn a good chunck of the time when i ask for somethign simple
2) im always paying attention, never assume that i dont. nobody needs to ask you why you think they are scum, you can openly explian it.
no here let me help you instead: why is rouge scum?
3) now you want to talke mafia theiroy? isnt that what you were scum readinf fulcrum for?
Also, I generally phone posT so if you want me to format anything, it will have to wait.
Outdated Mafia Stats
Outdated Mafia Stats
the diffrence is i see small context things. how else do you think i figures most peoples roles? if it blindly obvious i tend to miss it, but stuble small thing that little to none pick up on is what i find
I'll talk about rogue when others start talking about him. I can't find motive if I ask a question and immediately give the answer.
Outdated Mafia Stats
I just got back in town, the first thing I do is answer direct questions and then follow up if I have my own.
Outdated Mafia Stats
Outdated Mafia Stats
Generic: I had some question for you yesterday. Could you answer them?
Bolly: Chill a bit. There's a lot of room baked into the game for being wrong. Just try to figure it out as best you can. And don't forget to vote for hawk.
hawk: all your doing is theory crafting at me now so ya i will lynch you but i want the hammer.
bolly: neon is town, just trust me on that it her meta. lets get hawk today and then we can sort them out
proph: wheres your famous reead lists?
mod vote count?
also hawk fliping scum will rpob clear rouge.....
i want to troll it over