I recently had a great experience selling cards from Magic online. I posted on Sunday, they responded Monday. I sent them the CSV of my collection. By the end of the day Monday I had store credit. Two days later just as expected I had my cash direct deposited. It was such a pain free process and they were incredibly timely. I highly recommend to anyone who wants to sell cards on MTGO.
I recently sold my MTGO collection to MTGOTraders. Highly professional and courteous, Gustavo had their bots clear my account in less 24 hours and a check was in the mail and sent my way the same day (received on time as described in the communication). A great way to unload the full collection, thank you!
It can be very challenging trusting someone to take care with your property, especially when it has value. MTGOTraders/Capefeargames.com was not only accommodating to me, they were prompt and helpful to process the transaction and I can say I am %100 satisfied with the trade they administered. I was quite nervous at first, however their friendly demeanor and clear instructions resulted in precisely the outcome they promised. I am grateful for their service and highly recommend to anyone looking to get out of MTGO and into Paper Magic, or visa versa to go to them for a smooth transition. Thanks.
I sold my collection with MTGO Traders and they were responsive with the quote and only a 1-2 day turnaround with the transfer and the payment. Definitely would recommend!
Gustavo with MTGOTraders completed my collection sale with the quickness! It took ZERO business days. I sent my CSV file on a Sunday, and had money in PayPal on Monday. Amazing.
Hi, I got two questions about selling to MtGOTraders;
1. I see the reviews, but is this legit? I thought it would be more like a trade, and not giving them access to my mtgo account.
2. Does anybody know, when I want to sell my collection but I want to keep two EDH decks, if there's and easy way to do this?
I recently decided to quit Online Magic, and I sold my collection to MTGO Traders.
I did not feel ripped off, I think they gave me a fair amount for the cards I was selling.
About what I would estimate the collection to be worth, and it was a pretty big chunk of money,
I got some cool stuff with it. Quite happy with that interaction.
I just sold all my mtgo collection to mtgo traders and I am amazed at how quick this entire process have been.
I was in contact with Gustavo from mtgo for his trade and he handled the trade really professionally and i was payed through my pay-pal
even a bit more then the sum we agreed on.
I sold (part) of my MTGO collection a few days ago and I was pleasantly surprised about the whole process:
- At around 5PM (CET) I followed their steps (explained very well) and I placed a request to sell part of my collection;
- The following morning (around 9AM CET) I received an email from Gustavo with an offer and the next steps to take if I were to accept the offer. No pressure at all from their side, only that the offer was valid for three days (fair). The "scary" part is to give up your accountID and password (which you can change afterwards), as well as banking info, if you choose for this option. I felt that I could trust this website, as they sponsor a number of my favorite MTG players (like Jeff Hoogland). The follow up steps were easy to follow;
- I accepted their offer, which doesn't allow you to use your account until they're done with the transfer of cards.
A few hours later I received an email back that the cards were taken off my account and money was on its way;
- Money came in exactly as expected (1-2 business days);
- Finally, they asked for a review on MTGSalvation after the money had come in.
Overall experience: 10/10
Service: 10/10
Ease of use: 8/10
Likely to recommend: 10/10
@Overcast Mage
A bit late but:
1. I couldn't find my old account so I had to make another one, just for the reply.
Yes it is legit (they sponsor some twitch streamers as well, which made me feel more comfortable)
2. You create a binder with the cards you want to sell, they will only take what you want to sell to them.
Divide & Conquer Card Shuffler
Divide & Conquer is an Android app that completely shuffles your real deck of cards. It's great for unwieldy decks (Battle of Wits, Commander, etc.) and the paranoid thorough 40/60-card player. Check it out!
Sold my collection to MTGO, 10/10 double thumbs up , trustworthy nothing to say about it , will definitely use again and recommend to friends who want to use it and it was done fast!
I just sold my mtg online collection to MTGO traders for credit on their paper magic website cape fear games. After sending them my .csv file yesterday evening I got an offer early this morning. I thought about it and accepted and within a couple hours I got my credit on cape fear games. Excellent service, would recommend working with mtgo traders if you want a quick easy transaction.
Sold everything on my MTGO account to MTGOtraders over the weekend. It was fast and easy. They offered me a very reasonable amount for everything. Would highly recommend.
I have bought from MTGOtraders many times and have never once had an issue. I decided to sell my whole collection and had an offer in a couple of hours (on a weekend at that). Once I accepted, the process went off exactly how it was explained, the turnaround time was also extremely fast.
If (when let's be honest) I get back into MTGO I will be buying most of my cards from here and if I sell again I will be selling exclusively with MTGOtraders.
The process was super easy, very fast, and the quote was the best one I got. 10/10 no complaints.
Just sent in my collection, was a total of 6100 USD. i was nervous giving my account info but after doing business with them over and over i was put to ease. after sending the info within 15 minutes i got an email saying everything was completed and payment sent. i check my paypal and there it was.
this company is a no bull company and top tier quality. i will always recommend them and will always choose to do business solely with mtgotraders
Recently decided to move on from MTGO and decided to check out MTGOTraders/Cape Fear Games because they sponsor Kenji "NumottheNummy" Egashira. Incredibly quick and satisfying experience. Would use again.
Just here to give my feedback on my recent (10 minutes ago) transaction with mtgotraders. I just sold/traded roughly 200 dollars worth of cards for credit at the store - the transaction went incredibly smooth and communication was excellent. Once the cards were removed from my account and store credit applied - I was notified within minutes by Gustavo (Thanks!!) that this was done and I could change my password back. I'm using MTGO to practice my paper decks, and will stick with mtgotraders when dealing with digital cards. Cheers.
Recently sold my collection and as always, MTGO Traders were excellent to work with! Gustavo is always quick and easy to work with. I will be using MTGO Traders in the future when I (inevitably) come back to the cardboard crack.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Well done MTGOTraders
Currently Playing:
Modern Grixis Shadow, Storm
Legacy: Grixis Delver, Sneak and Show
Duel Commander: Kess High Tide
Vintage Big blue(MTGO)
Easy peasy
Highly reccomendwd to buy from and sell too
1. I see the reviews, but is this legit? I thought it would be more like a trade, and not giving them access to my mtgo account.
2. Does anybody know, when I want to sell my collection but I want to keep two EDH decks, if there's and easy way to do this?
I did not feel ripped off, I think they gave me a fair amount for the cards I was selling.
About what I would estimate the collection to be worth, and it was a pretty big chunk of money,
I got some cool stuff with it. Quite happy with that interaction.
I was in contact with Gustavo from mtgo for his trade and he handled the trade really professionally and i was payed through my pay-pal
even a bit more then the sum we agreed on.
- At around 5PM (CET) I followed their steps (explained very well) and I placed a request to sell part of my collection;
- The following morning (around 9AM CET) I received an email from Gustavo with an offer and the next steps to take if I were to accept the offer. No pressure at all from their side, only that the offer was valid for three days (fair). The "scary" part is to give up your accountID and password (which you can change afterwards), as well as banking info, if you choose for this option. I felt that I could trust this website, as they sponsor a number of my favorite MTG players (like Jeff Hoogland). The follow up steps were easy to follow;
- I accepted their offer, which doesn't allow you to use your account until they're done with the transfer of cards.
A few hours later I received an email back that the cards were taken off my account and money was on its way;
- Money came in exactly as expected (1-2 business days);
- Finally, they asked for a review on MTGSalvation after the money had come in.
Overall experience: 10/10
Service: 10/10
Ease of use: 8/10
Likely to recommend: 10/10
A bit late but:
1. I couldn't find my old account so I had to make another one, just for the reply.
Yes it is legit (they sponsor some twitch streamers as well, which made me feel more comfortable)
2. You create a binder with the cards you want to sell, they will only take what you want to sell to them.
Divide & Conquer is an Android app that completely shuffles your real deck of cards. It's great for unwieldy decks (Battle of Wits, Commander, etc.) and the
paranoidthorough 40/60-card player. Check it out!Painless, fast (less than 24 hours turn around) and I could not be happier with the process.
Spirits
If (when let's be honest) I get back into MTGO I will be buying most of my cards from here and if I sell again I will be selling exclusively with MTGOtraders.
The process was super easy, very fast, and the quote was the best one I got. 10/10 no complaints.
this company is a no bull company and top tier quality. i will always recommend them and will always choose to do business solely with mtgotraders
if you're a little concerned about them... trust and you'll be surprised that are still honored people in this earth.
tnks.